Considerations for the modeling of the laser ablation region of ICF targets with Lagrangian simulations

Recently, much effort has been dedicated to the improvement of models and modeling choices utilized in radiation hydrodynamic simulations of direct drive inertial confinement fusion experiments in an effort to improve their predictive capability. In this paper, we consider the choice in mesh for the simulation of the laser ablation of a direct-drive-like target and compare Lagrangian simulations with various mesh zoning choices with Eulerian simulations with fixed resolution in the laser energy deposition region. Using these simulations, we demonstrate how errors in ablation pressure, laser deposition rate, shock speed, and density profile arise from insufficient zoning following from the conservation of mass of Lagrangian zones. These considerations place stringent requirements on the initial t = 0 zoning in the solid density shell for simulations aiming at resolving the ablation and laser absorption region. However, with sufficiently fine zoning in the t = 0 shell, agreement with Eulerian simulations and analytic scaling laws can be recovered.