Coherent surface structure induces unique epitaxial overgrowth of metastable octacalcium phosphate on stable hydroxyapatite at critical fluoride concentration

The phase transformation from soluble calcium phosphates to less-soluble hydroxyapatite (HAP) is a thermodynamically natural route. This process is irreversible, and effective use of poorly reactive HAP to repair teeth that have no cellular metabolism remains challenging. However, this thermodynamically controlled transformation may apparently be reversed through the fast nucleation and growth of metastable phases, leading to a reactive HAP surface. Here, the assembled HAP-nanorod phase is demonstrated to change into the metastable octacalcium phosphate (OCP) phase in a calcium phosphate solution containing 0.8 ppm fluoride. Grown OCPs display parallel surface streaks and their 11¯0 and 00l (l: odd) electron-diffraction spots are often not visible. The streaked, elongated OCP gradually grows into large plates with flat surfaces that exhibit an intense11¯0 spot. Crystal-structure models reveal that the unique epitaxial overgrowth of OCP on HAP occurs since both materials share coherent {100} faces, resulting in the distinctive disappearance of 11¯0 and 00l OCP spots. A polysynthetic twin model that reliably explains this disappearance is proposed for the growth of OCP. This apparent reverse phase transformation produces hybrid calcium phosphates consisting of HAP cores and highly reactive outer OCP layers that are promising for the repair of dentin caries. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: This paper demonstrates important and interesting finding regarding formation of calcium phosphates in relation to their crystal structures. We first show that hydroxyapatite (HAP), the major constituent of human teeth and bone, can reversely change to its precursor, octacalcium phosphate (OCP), contrary to thermodynamic-stability rule. This apparent reverse phase transformation occurs through sharing the coherent {100} faces of both materials under controlled fluoride concentration. Nanoscale similarity of two crystal surfaces enables structurally shared epitaxial overgrowth of OCP on HAP aided by faster growth rate of OCP than that of HAP. This reaction produces hybrid crystal consisting of outer OCP and core HAP, that has not been known before and is able to be applied to dentin caries repair.