Standardized Photobiomodulation Dosimetry Targeting the Base of Calvarial Critical-Sized Defects for Bone Regeneration: A Preclinical RCT Comparing Flattop vs. Gaussian Beam Profiles, with or Without Bio-Oss®

Photobiomodulation (PBM) has shown promising potential to enhance bone regeneration; however, its optimal delivery parameters and interactions with osteoconductive scaffolds remain insufficiently defined. This preclinical study is the first to incorporate a pilot dosimetry evaluation to standardize 980-nm PBM delivery and ensure that effective irradiance reached the target surface of critical-size calvarial defects in mice. The primary aim was to evaluate the effectiveness of this novel 980-nm PBM protocol delivered using either flat-top (FT) or standard Gaussian (ST) handpieces in enhancing bone regeneration in critical-size defects (CSDs), both with and without Bio-Oss® grafting. A total of 120 adult mice were allocated into twelve experimental groups (n = 10 per group): untreated (control), Bio-Oss® alone, PBM alone, and PBM combined with Bio-Oss®, using either FT or ST handpieces, and evaluated at 30 and 60 days. Animals received 980 nm irradiation at 0.6 W (nominal power output–set on laser interface) in continuous-wave mode for 60 s, three times per week, for two consecutive weeks. Pilot dosimetry included power meter measurements to determine the therapeutic power reaching the defect surface area and temperature monitoring to ensure safe energy delivery. The dosimetry study demonstrated that, after accounting for the optical properties of mouse shaved skin and the Bio-Oss® graft covered with Bio-Gide® membrane, the effective irradiance reaching the base of the defect surface area was 1.131 W/cm2 for the FT handpiece and 0.413 W/cm2 for the ST handpiece. This dose was sufficient to induce significant regenerative effects. Histological, Masson’s trichrome, and immunohistochemical analyses for Runx2, OCN, GLI1, CD34, and CTSK were performed to characterize early and late osteogenic events. The combination of PBM and Bio-Oss® significantly accelerated bone regeneration compared with PBM alone, with the FT handpiece producing the most uniform and advanced osteogenesis. PBM enhanced progenitor activation, osteoblast differentiation, angiogenesis, matrix deposition, and late-stage remodeling, demonstrating a synergistic effect with the scaffold, whereas Bio-Oss® alone or defect alone showed limited early regenerative potential. These findings highlight the effectiveness of this novel standardized PBM dosimetry and uniform beam profile (FT), supporting their use as a foundation for future randomized controlled trials in craniofacial bone repair.