Efficacy of Endodontic Files in Root Canal Retreatment: A Systematic Review of In Vitro Studies
Source abstract
Abstract
The success rate of root canal treatment is high, but it can fail. In these cases, orthograde root canal retreatment is often the treatment of choice, for which numerous biomaterials are available on the market, including endodontic files. This systematic review aimed to study the endodontic files available on the market and establish their efficacy in root canal retreatment. An electronic search of six different databases was performed, and in vitro experimental studies that studied root canal cleaning, debris extrusion, retreatment time, or dentinal damage produced with any of the comparison methods were selected. The quality of the studies was assessed with the QUIN scale. In total, 78 studies were included for the analysis, of which 9 had a high risk of bias, 53 had a moderate risk, and 16 had a low risk. The methods used to evaluate the efficacy of endodontic files in root canal retreatment are heterogeneous. Manual files produce more apical extrusion than rotary files. PTUR files are the most studied endodontic files. It is the file system that leaves the least residual filling material in the canal, takes the least time during retreatment, and removes the greatest amount of dentine. However, no file system achieved the complete removal of the root canal filling material. No consistent pattern emerged across studies when comparing rotary files with continuous and reciprocating rotation in terms of the removal of the filling material, the time required for de-obturation, dentine damage produced, or apical extrusion.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline
Research context
OpenAlex topics: Endodontics and Root Canal Treatments · Dental materials and restorations · Occupational health in dentistry
SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.
Affiliations
Department of Stomatology, Faculty of Medicine and Dentistry, Universitat de València, Gascó Oliag 1, 46010 Valencia, Spain
Departamento di Medicina e Chirurgia, Università degli Studi di Milano-Bicocca, 20854 Milan, Italy
References (90)
Show source-provided references
1. Effectiveness of Different Rotary Files Systems in Removal of Gutta-percha during Endodontic Retreatment with or without Solvents: A Comparative Study10.5005/jp-journals-10024-3523 ↗
2. A Comparative Evaluation of Gutta Percha Removal and Extrusion of Apical Debris by Rotary and Hand Files
3. The Efficacy of Two Novel Retreatment Systems in the Removal of Root Canal Obturating Materials (An In vitro Study)10.3889/oamjms.2022.8112 ↗
4. Efficacy of ProTaper Universal Retreatment Files in Removing Filling Materials during Root Canal Retreatment10.1016/j.joen.2008.08.002 ↗
5. Evaluation of the efficacy of TruNatomy, ProTaper retreatment, and RaCe file systems in retreatment of moderately curved mandibular molars: An in vitro study
6. Shaheen, N.A., Elhelbawy, N.G., and Sherif, D.A. (2022). Quantitative Assessment of Apically Extruded Debris after Single-Files Supplemental Retreatment considering Apical Patency Influence: In Vitro Study. Int. J. Biomater., 2022.10.1155/2022/7544813 ↗
7. Evaluation of Root Dentin Damage during Retreatment Procedure using Various Engine-Driven Retreatment File Systems—A Micro-CT Study10.4103/jpbs.jpbs_490_22 ↗
8. The effectiveness of manual and mechanical instrumentation for the retreatment of three different root canal filling materials10.1016/j.joen.2008.02.008 ↗
9. Buckling resistance, torque, and force generation during retreatment with D-RaCe, HyFlex Remover, and Mtwo retreatment files10.5395/rde.2023.48.e10 ↗
10. PRISMA 2020 explanation and elaboration: Updated guidance and exemplars for reporting systematic reviews10.1136/bmj.n160 ↗
11. Development and validation of a risk-of-bias tool for assessing in vitro studies conducted in dentistry: The QUIN10.1016/j.prosdent.2022.05.019 ↗
12. A comparison of the efficacy of conventional and new retreatment instruments to remove gutta-percha in curved root canals: An ex vivo study10.1111/j.1365-2591.2008.01518.x ↗
13. Efficacy of three different rotary files to remove gutta-percha and Resilon from root canals10.1111/j.1365-2591.2010.01758.x ↗
14. Comparison of debris extruded apically and working time used by ProTaper Universal rotary and ProTaper retreatment system during gutta-percha removal10.1590/S1678-77572010000600002 ↗
15. Removal of Gutta-Percha/Zinc-Oxide-Eugenol Sealer or Gutta-Percha/Epoxy Resin Sealer from Severely Curved Canals: An In Vitro Study10.1155/2011/541831 ↗
16. Damage to root dentin during retreatment procedures10.1016/j.joen.2010.10.002 ↗
17. Efficacy of ProTaper Retreatment System in Root Canals Obturated with Gutta-Percha Using Two Different Sealers and GuttaFlow10.1155/2011/676128 ↗
18. Efficacy of rotary Ni-Ti retreatment systems in root canals filled with a new warm vertical compaction technique10.4012/dmj.2011-123 ↗
19. Comparing the Efficacy of Mtwo and D-RaCe Retreatment Systems in Removing Residual Gutta-Percha and Sealer in the Root Canal
20. Effectiveness of ProTaper, D-RaCe, and Mtwo retreatment files with and without supplementary instruments in the removal of root canal filling material10.1111/j.1365-2591.2012.02051.x ↗
21. Efficacy of two Ni-Ti systems and hand files for removing gutta-percha from root canals10.1111/j.1365-2591.2011.01932.x ↗
22. Self-Adjusting Files in Retreatment: A High-resolution Micro–Computed Tomography Study10.1016/j.joen.2012.06.019 ↗
23. Removal of gutta-percha from root canals using the self-adjusting file10.1016/j.joen.2012.03.003 ↗
24. Comparative Analysis of Efficacy and Cleaning Ability of Hand and Rotary Devices for Gutta-Percha Removal in Root Canal Retreatment: An in vitro Study10.5005/jp-journals-10024-1377 ↗
25. To Evaluate and Compare the Efficacy, Cleaning Ability of Hand and Two Rotary Systems in Root Canal Retreatment10.5005/jp-journals-10024-1341 ↗
26. An in vitro CT comparison of gutta-percha removal with two rotary systems and hedstrom files
27. Comparison of ProTaper and Mtwo retreatment systems in the removal of resin-based root canal obturation materials during retreatment10.1111/aej.12011 ↗
28. Oval-shaped canal retreatment with self-adjusting file: A micro-computed tomography study10.1007/s00784-013-1086-0 ↗
29. Retreatment of flat-oval root canals with a self-adjusting file: An SEM study10.4012/dmj.2014-054 ↗
30. Incidence of apical crack initiation and propagation during the removal of root canal filling material with ProTaper and Mtwo rotary nickel-titanium retreatment instruments and hand files10.1016/j.joen.2013.12.020 ↗
31. The Effects of Mtwo, R-Endo, and D-RaCe Retreatment Instruments on the Incidence of Dentinal Defects during the Removal of Root Canal Filling Material10.1016/j.joen.2013.07.024 ↗
32. The effect of reciprocation versus rotational movement on the incidence of root defects during retreatment procedures10.1111/iej.12387 ↗
33. Comparison of the amount of apical debris extrusion associated with different retreatment systems and supplementary file application during retreatment process10.4103/0972-0707.186456 ↗
34. In vitro evaluation of efficacy of different rotary instrument systems for gutta percha removal during root canal retreatment
35. The Comparative Efficacy of Different Files in The Removal of Different Sealers in Simulated Root Canal Retreatment- An In-vitro Study
36. Efficacy of Different Methods for Removing Root Canal Filling Material in Retreatment—An In-vitro Study
37. Apical extrusion of debris by supplementary files used for retreatment: An ex vivo comparative study10.4103/0972-0707.178686 ↗
38. A comparative evaluation of two rotary Ni-Ti instruments in the removal of gutta-percha during retreatment10.4103/2231-0762.189740 ↗
39. Efficiency of Three Different Techniques in the Removal of Gutta-percha10.4067/S0718-381X2016000200023 ↗
40. Comparative evaluation of three different rotary instrumentation systems for removal of gutta-percha from root canal during endodontic retreatment: An in vitro study10.4103/JCD.JCD_132_17 ↗
41. Comparison of the amount of apically extruded debris during retreatment using different nickel-titanium systems and hand instruments in teeth with wide apices
42. Efficacy of manual and mechanical instrumentation techniques for removal of overextended root canal filling material10.4103/1119-3077.180069 ↗
43. Incidence of apical crack formation and propagation during removal of root canal filling materials with different engine driven nickel-titanium instruments10.5395/rde.2017.42.4.332 ↗
44. Effect of root canal preparation, obturation, and retreatment on the induction of dentinal microcracks: A microcomputed tomography study10.4103/JCD.JCD_184_18 ↗
45. Comparison of apically extruded debris after retreatment procedure with protaper and endostar retreatment file systems
46. Retreatability of root canals filled with Gutta percha and a novel bioceramic sealer: A scanning electron microscopy study10.4103/JCD.JCD_228_18 ↗
47. Evaluation of Effectiveness of Two Different Endodontic Retreatment Systems in Removal of Gutta-percha: An in vitro Study10.5005/jp-journals-10024-2326 ↗
48. Efficacy of the ProTaper retreatment system in removing Thermafil, GuttaCore or vertically compacted gutta-percha from curved root canals assessed by micro-CT10.1111/iej.12893 ↗
49. Evaluation of Efficacy of Different Instrumentation for Removal of Gutta-percha and Sealers in Endodontic Retreatment: An In Vitro Study10.5005/jp-journals-10024-2670 ↗
50. Comparative assessment of manual, rotary and reciprocating instruments for removal of root fillings, using stereomicroscope: An in vitro study10.3329/bmrcb.v45i1.41809 ↗
51. Evaluation of remaining dentin thickness following use of three different rotary nickel–titanium retreatment files: A cone-beam computed tomography study10.4103/JCD.JCD_269_19 ↗
52. Evaluation of gutta-percha removal from the dentinal tubules using different instrumentation techniques with or without solvent: An In vitro study10.4103/jicdro.jicdro_46_19 ↗
53. The Efficacy of WaveOne Gold and Mtwo retreatment files in the Removal of Carrier-based Gutta-percha obturators
54. The efficacy of d-race and different niti rotary instruments in the removal of root canal filling materials
55. Comparative evaluation of retreatment techniques by using different file systems from oval-shaped canals10.4103/JCD.JCD_167_20 ↗
56. Evaluation of apically extruded debris during the removal of canal filling material using three different Ni-Ti systems and hand files in teeth with simulated apical root resorption10.1111/iej.13234 ↗
57. A Digital Microscopic Inspection of Dentinal Defects after Using Endodontic Retreatment Files10.1155/2021/6661387 ↗
58. Comparative assessment of canal transportation, dentin loss, and remaining root filling material by different retreatment files An In vitro cross-sectional study10.4103/ccd.ccd_31_20 ↗
59. Micro CT pilot evaluation of removability of two endodontic sealers10.2334/josnusd.21-0196 ↗
60. Efficacy of XP-endo Finisher-R in enhancing removal of bioceramic sealer from oval root canal: A micro CT study
61. Comparative Evaluation of Efficacy of Three Different Rotary Retreatment Systems with Manual Instrumentation in Removing Gutta-Percha from Root Canals—An In Vitro Study10.14260/jemds/2021/219 ↗
62. Effectiveness of different rotary file systems in removing the root canal filling material: A micro-computed tomography study10.34172/joddd.2021.045 ↗
63. Comparative Evaluation of the Remaining Dentin Thickness Using Different Root Canal Retreatment Techniques: A Cone-Beam Computed Tomography Study
64. Assessment of root dentin defect during retreatment procedure using various NiTi hand and rotary retreatment files: An In vitro study10.4103/jpbs.jpbs_743_21 ↗
65. Efficacy of retreatment NiTi files for root canals filled with calcium silicate-based sealer10.14368/jdras.2022.38.4.213 ↗
66. Evaluation of dentinal crack propagation, amount of gutta percha remaining and time required during removal of gutta percha using two different rotary instruments and hand instruments—An In vitro study10.4103/njcp.njcp_1838_21 ↗
67. Abdelnaby, P., Ibrahim, M., and ElBackly, R. (2023). In vitro evaluation of filling material removal and apical debris extrusion after retreatment using Reciproc blue, Hyflex EDM and ProTaper retreatment files. BMC Oral Health, 23.10.1186/s12903-023-03579-7 ↗
68. Influence of heat treated files on conserving the remaining dentin thickness during endodontic retreatment—An invitro CBCT study10.1016/j.jksus.2023.102969 ↗
69. Micro-CT Study on the Supplementary Effect of XP-Endo Finisher R after Endodontic Retreatment with Mtwo-R10.4103/njcp.njcp_360_23 ↗
70. Comparative evaluation of incidence of dentinal defects after root canal preparation using three different endodontic retreatment systems—An in vitro study10.4103/JCDE.JCDE_266_23 ↗
71. Time Required for Root Canal Retreatment Using Continuous Rotation, Reciprocation, and Optimum Torque Reverse Motions: An In-Vitro Study
72. Micro-Computed Tomography Analysis of Resin and Calcium Silicate Based Sealers Removal in Mandibular Molars Curved Canals10.15644/asc58/2/3 ↗
73. Evaluation of the Efficacy of Neo-endo, Hyflex Re-treatment File Systems and H-Files for Removing Gutta-Percha From Root Canal Treated Tooth by Using Stereomicroscope—An In Vitro Study10.4103/jpbs.jpbs_970_23 ↗
74. Debris extrusion during retreatment using continuous rotation motion of canal obturated with gutta-percha and bioceramic sealer using three different obturation techniques (an in vitro study)
75. Comparative evaluation of the remaining dentin thickness using Solite RS3 and ProTaper Universal retreatment files: A nanocomputed tomography study10.4103/endo.endo_6_24 ↗
76. Comparative evaluation of the canal transportation after retreatment with Solite RS3 and Protaper Universal retreatment files: A nano computed tomography study10.4322/bds.2024.e4369 ↗
77. Comparative Evaluation of Solite RS3 and HyFlex Remover Retreatment Files in Conserving Remaining Dentin Thickness During Endodontic Retreatment Using Cone Beam Computed Tomography: An In Vitro Analysis
78. Comparative Analysis of the Efficacy of Various Retreatment File Systems in the Removal of Gutta-Percha in Retreatment Cases and Time Taken During the Procedure: An In Vitro Cone Beam CT Study
79. Efficacy of Various Heat-treated Retreatment File Systems on Dentin Removal and Crack Analysis: An in vitro Study10.1590/pboci.2024.093 ↗
80. Retreatability of Bonded and Nonbonded Root Canals Obturation Materials Using D-RaCe Retreatment Files10.5005/jp-journals-10015-2338 ↗
81. Efficacy, cleaning ability and safety of different rotary NiTi instruments in root canal retreatment10.1111/j.1365-2591.2004.00823.x ↗
82. Root canal cleanliness after preparation with different endodontic handpieces and hand instruments: A comparative SEM investigation10.1016/S0099-2399(97)80410-4 ↗
83. The effects of canal preparation and filling on the incidence of dentinal defects10.1111/j.1365-2591.2008.01502.x ↗
84. Retreatability of root canals obturated using gutta-percha with bioceramic, MTA and resin-based sealers
85. Efficacy of retreatment techniques for a resin-based root canal obturation material10.1016/j.joen.2005.09.010 ↗
86. Vertical root fractures and dentin defects: Effects of root canal preparation, filling, and mechanical cycling10.1016/j.joen.2012.05.002 ↗
87. The efficacy of gutta-percha removal using ProFiles10.1046/j.1365-2591.2001.00379.x ↗
88. A comparison of weights of debris extruded apically by conventional filing and Canal Master techniques10.1016/S0099-2399(06)81866-2 ↗
89. Dixit, K.Z. (2019). Evaluation of the Amount of Apically Extruded Debris During Retreatment of Root Canals Filled by Single Cone Obturation on Using Different Retreatment Files With or Without Using Solvent—An In Vitro Study. [Doctoral Thesis, Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences Bangalore].
90. Prince, E. (2019). Comparative Evaluation of Apical Debris Extrusion Associated with Different Retreatment Rotary Systems—An Invitro Study. [Doctoral Thesis, Rajiv Gandhi Unversity of Health Sciences Bengalore].