journal article·2026-01-16Open access

Efficacy of Etidronic Acid for Smear Layer Removal: A Systematic Review of In Vitro Studies

María-Inmaculada Vidal-Montolío, José Luis Sanz, James Ghilotti, Sofía Folguera, Carmen Llena

Abstract

Irrigation plays a crucial role in the success of root canal treatment; however, currently, no standardized irrigation protocols exist, particularly regarding the optimal sequence for smear layer removal. This systematic review aimed to determine which irrigation protocol achieves superior smear layer removal: traditional sequential irrigation with sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl) followed by ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA), or irrigation with etidronic acid, either combined with NaOCl in continuous chelation or used as a final irrigant. Continuous chelation with etidronic acid may be clinically advantageous in daily practice, as it would facilitate workflow by using a single irrigating solution without compromising the efficacy of the irrigation process. A comprehensive electronic search was conducted in Medline, Embase, Cochrane, Scopus, and Web of Science, last updated in August 2025. In vitro studies were selected according to predefined PICO-based criteria. Two reviewers independently screened the studies and extracted data, with an inter-rater agreement of 0.92 using the Kappa index. Risk of bias was evaluated using a modified CONSORT checklist for in vitro studies on dental materials. The average item compliance of the included studies was 58%. The maximum score was 73% and the minimum was 47%. Twenty studies met the inclusion criteria. Etidronic acid used in continuous chelation showed equal or superior smear layer removal compared with sequential irrigation in nine of ten studies. Conversely, when used as a final irrigant, etidronic acid demonstrated inferior performance in more than half of the studies, particularly in the apical third. Based on the available evidence, etidronic acid in continuous chelation appears as effective as, or more effective than, traditional NaOCl–EDTA sequential irrigation.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Endodontics and Root Canal Treatments · Dental Trauma and Treatments · Dental materials and restorations

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

Affiliations

Department of Stomatology, Faculty of Medicine and Dentistry, Universitat de València, 46010 Valencia, Spain

References (92)

Show source-provided references
1. Biofilms and Apical Periodontitis: Study of Prevalence and Association with Clinical and Histopathologic Findings10.1016/j.joen.2010.04.007 ↗
2. Clinical Implications of the Smear Layer in Endodontics: A Review10.1067/moe.2002.128962 ↗
3. A Preliminary Scanning Electron Microscopic Study of Root Canals after Endodontic Procedures10.1016/S0099-2399(75)80226-3 ↗
4. Effect of pH Modified EDTA Solution to the Properties of Dentin10.1097/01.DON.0000134205.05404.8E ↗
5. The Smear Layer in Endodontic: To Keep or Remove—An Updated Overview10.4103/sej.sej_95_18 ↗
6. Effects of Changes in Surface Area, Thickness, Temperature and Post-Extraction Time on Human Dentine Permeability10.1016/0003-9969(76)90029-7 ↗
7. The Influence of the Smear Layer on Dentinal Tubule Penetration Depth by Three Different Root Canal Sealers: An In Vitro Study10.1097/00004770-200402000-00009 ↗
8. A Scanning Electron Microscopic Evaluation of In Vitro Dentinal Tubules Penetration by Selected Anaerobic Bacteria10.1016/S0099-2399(96)80265-2 ↗
9. Effect of Smear Layer on Sealing Ability of Canal Obturation: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis10.1016/j.joen.2006.10.007 ↗
10. Chelating Agents in Root Canal Treatment: Mode of Action and Indications for Their Use10.1111/j.1365-2591.2003.00754.x ↗
11. Mikheikina, A., Novozhilova, N., Polyakova, M., Sokhova, I., Mun, A., Zaytsev, A., Babina, K., and Makeeva, I. (2023). Knowledge, Attitude, and Practice towards Chelating Agents in Endodontic Treatment among Dental Practitioners. Dent. J., 11.10.3390/dj11070156 ↗
12. Current Trends in Irrigation Solution and Adjunct Use During Endodontic Therapy Among Dental Professionals in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia: A Cross-Sectional Study
13. Current Trends in the Use of Irrigant Activation Techniques among Endodontist & Post Graduates in India—A Knowledge, Attitude and Practice Based Survey
14. Treatment of Pulpal and Apical Disease: The European Society of Endodontology (ESE) S3-level Clinical Practice Guideline10.1111/iej.13974 ↗
15. A Review on Root Canal Irrigation Solutions in Endodontics
16. Interactions of Ethylenediamine Tetraacetic Acid with Sodium Hypochlorite in Aqueous Solutions10.1046/j.1365-2591.2003.00670.x ↗
17. Final Irrigation Protocols May Affect Intraradicular Dentin Ultrastructure10.1007/s00784-016-2006-x ↗
18. Effect of Chelating Solutions on the Microhardness of Root Canal Lumen Dentin10.1016/j.joen.2010.12.001 ↗
19. The Effect of Different Concentrations of EDTA on Instrumented Root Canal Walls10.1016/j.tripleo.2009.04.042 ↗
20. Time-Dependent Effects of EDTA on Dentin Structures10.1097/00004770-200201000-00004 ↗
21. Comparative Evaluation of the Effect of EDTA, Chitosan, Etidronic Acid, and Silver Citrate on the Mineral Content of Root Canal Dentine Using Energy Dispersive X-Ray Spectroscopy: An In-Vitro Study10.14744/eej.2024.30092 ↗
22. Interactions between Irrigants Commonly Used in Endodontic Practice: A Chemical Analysis10.1016/j.joen.2012.11.050 ↗
23. Chelation in Root Canal Therapy Reconsidered10.1097/01.don.0000158233.59316.fe ↗
24. Bisphosphonates: From the Laboratory to the Clinic and Back Again10.1016/S8756-3282(99)00116-7 ↗
25. Falbe, J. (1987). Performance in Detergents, Cleaning Agents and Personal Care Products. Surfactants in Consumer Products, Springer.10.1007/978-3-642-71545-7 ↗
26. Reduction of Hard-Tissue Debris Accumulation during Rotary Root Canal Instrumentation by Etidronic Acid in a Sodium Hypochlorite Irrigant10.1016/j.joen.2011.12.019 ↗
27. Influence of Smear Layer on the Antimicrobial Activity of a Sodium Hypochlorite/Etidronic Acid Irrigating Solution in Infected Dentin10.1016/j.joen.2016.07.023 ↗
28. Efficacy of Etidronic Acid, BioPure MTAD and SmearClear in Removing Calcium Ions from the Root Canal: An In Vitro Study10.4103/1305-7456.172613 ↗
29. Effects of Chelating Agents on the Mineral Content of Root Canal Dentin10.1016/j.tripleo.2011.06.037 ↗
30. Novozhilova, N., Babina, K., Polyakova, M., Sokhova, I., Sherstneva, V., Zaytsev, A., Makeeva, I., and Mikheikina, A. (2024). The Effect of Different Compositions and Concentrations of Etidronate-Containing Irrigants on the Antibacterial Activity of Sodium Hypochlorite against Enterococcus faecalis and Candida albicans. Dent. J., 12.10.3390/dj12030046 ↗
31. Etidronate Causes Minimal Changes in the Ability of Sodium Hypochlorite to Dissolve Organic Matter10.1111/iej.12329 ↗
32. Enhancing the Intracanal Antibacterial Effects of Sodium Hypochlorite with Etidronic Acid or Citric Acid10.1016/j.joen.2022.06.006 ↗
33. Safety Assessment of an Etidronate in a Sodium Hypochlorite Solution: Randomized Double-blind Trial10.1111/iej.13129 ↗
34. Antimicrobial Activity of Chlorhexidine, Peracetic Acid and Sodium Hypochlorite/Etidronate Irrigant Solutions against Enterococcus faecalis Biofilms10.1111/iej.12424 ↗
35. Flexural Strength and Microhardness of Human Radicular Dentin Sticks after Conditioning with Different Endodontic Chelating Agents10.4103/jcd.jcd_173_23 ↗
36. Longitudinal Co-Site Optical Microscopy Study on the Chelating Ability of Etidronate and EDTA Using a Comparative Single-Tooth Model10.1016/j.joen.2007.09.020 ↗
37. Declaración PRISMA 2020: Una guía actualizada para la publicación de revisiones sistemáticas10.1016/j.recesp.2021.06.016 ↗
38. Guidelines for Reporting Pre-Clinical In Vitro Studies on Dental Materials10.1016/j.jebdp.2012.10.001 ↗
39. Effectiveness of XP-Endo Finisher and Passive Ultrasonic Irrigation in the Removal of the Smear Layer Using Two Different Chelating Agents
40. In Vitro Evaluation of Smear Layer and Debris Removal and Antimicrobial Activity of Different Irrigating Solutions10.14744/eej.2023.19042 ↗
41. Effects of Ethylenediaminetetraacetic, Etidronic and Peracetic Acid Irrigation on Human Root Dentine and the Smear Layer10.1111/j.1365-2591.2008.01514.x ↗
42. Cleanliness and Erosion of Root Canal Walls after Irrigation with a New HEDP-Based Solution vs. Traditional Sodium Hypochlorite Followed by EDTA. A Scanning Electron Microscope Study10.1007/s00784-020-03249-w ↗
43. Kamil, A.A., Ali, A.H., Foschi, F., and Mannocci, F. (2025). Effectiveness of Continuous and Sequential Chelation and Different Agitation Techniques on Smear Layer Removal and Microhardness of Root Canal Dentin (An In Vitro Study). Dent. J., 13.10.20944/preprints202504.2154.v1 ↗
44. The Effectiveness of Continuous versus Sequential Chelation in the Removal of Smear Layer and Their Influence on Push-out Bond Strength of Bio-C Sealer (An In Vitro Study)10.7126/cumudj.1231568 ↗
45. Razumova, S., Brago, A., Kryuchkova, A., Troitskiy, V., Bragunova, R., and Barakat, H. (2025). Evaluation of the Efficiency of Smear Layer Removal during Endodontic Treatment Using Scanning Electron Microscopy: An In Vitro Study. BMC Oral Health, 25.10.1186/s12903-025-05510-8 ↗
46. Effect of Continuous Soft Chelating Irrigation Protocol on Removal of Smear Layer10.4103/endo.endo_58_18 ↗
47. Effect of Continuous Chelation Irrigation Using DualRinse HEDP + 3% NaOCL with or without High-Power Sonic Activation on Debris and Smear Layer Removal
48. Hazar, E., and Hazar, A. (2025). Effects of Phytic Acid and Etidronic Acid Using Continuous and Sequential Chelation on the Removal of Smear Layer, Dentin Microhardness, and Push-out Bond Strength of Calcium Silicate-Based Cement. BMC Oral Health, 25.10.1186/s12903-025-06010-5 ↗
49. A Comparative Evaluation of Smear Layer Removal by Using Four Different Irrigation Solutions like Root Canal Irrigants: An In Vitro SEM Study10.5005/jp-journals-10024-3064 ↗
50. Comparative Evaluation of Three Different Irrigants on Smear Layer Removal in Instrumented Root Canals: An In-Vitro Scanning Electron Microscopic Study
51. Efficacy of New Irrigating Solution on Smear Layer Removal in Apical Third of Root Canal: A Scanning Electron Microscope Study10.4103/JCD.JCD_155_17 ↗
52. A Scanning Electron Microscopic Evaluation of the Effectiveness of Etidronic Acid, SmearClear and MTAD in Removing the Intracanal Smear Layer
53. Effect of Final Irrigating Solutions on Smear Layer Removal and Penetrability of an Epoxy Resin Based Sealer into Dentinal Tubules
54. Smear Layer Removal Efficacy of Different Types of Irrigation Solutions with Single File System: An In Vitro SEM Study10.52711/0974-360X.2023.00307 ↗
55. Scanning Electron Microscopy Evaluation of Smear Layer Removal Using Ethylenediaminetetraacetic Acid, Etidronic Acid, and Chitosan Nanoparticle Solution as Root Canal Irrigants10.4103/endo.endo_126_22 ↗
56. A Comparative Evaluation of Smear Layer Removal by Using Edta, Etidronic Acid, and Maleic Acid as Root Canal Irrigants: An In Vitro Scanning Electron Microscopic Study10.4103/0972-0707.157266 ↗
57. Evaluation of Smear Layer Removal and Marginal Adaptation of Root Canal Sealer after Final Irrigation Using Ethylenediaminetetraacetic, Peracetic, and Etidronic Acids with Different Concentrations10.1002/jemt.22851 ↗
58. Qualitative Analysis of Smear Layer Treated with Different Etidronate Concentrations: A Scanning Electron Microscopy Study10.1002/jemt.23318 ↗
59. Root Canal Cleanliness after Preparation with Different Endodontic Handpieces and Hand Instruments: A Comparative SEM Investigation10.1016/S0099-2399(97)80410-4 ↗
60. A New Solution for the Removal of the Smear Layer10.1097/00004770-200303000-00002 ↗
61. The Effectiveness of Syringe Irrigation and Ultrasonics to Remove Debris from Simulated Irregularities within Prepared Root Canal Walls10.1111/j.1365-2591.2004.00848.x ↗
62. Ultrasonic Root-end Preparation Part 1. SEM Analysis10.1111/j.1365-2591.1994.tb00276.x ↗
63. Habshi, A.Y., Aga, N., Habshi, K.Y., Hassan, M.E.M., Choudhry, Z., Ahmed, M.A., Syed, A.U.Y., and Jouhar, R. (2023). Efficacy of Smear Layer Removal at the Apical One-Third of the Root Using Different Protocols of Erbium-Doped Yttrium Aluminium Garnet (Er:YAG) Laser. Medicina, 59.10.3390/medicina59030433 ↗
64. Atomic Absorption Spectrometry and Scanning Electron Microscopy Evaluation of Concentration of Calcium Ions and Smear Layer Removal with Root Canal Chelators10.1016/j.joen.2009.02.008 ↗
65. A Scanning Electron Microscopic Study of Debris and Smear Layer Remaining Following Use of GT Rotary Instruments10.1046/j.1365-2591.2002.00495.x ↗
66. Investigation of the Efficacy of Passive Ultrasonic Irrigation Versus Irrigation with Reciprocating Activation: An Environmental Scanning Electron Microscopic Study10.1016/j.joen.2016.01.016 ↗
67. Present Status and Future Directions—Irrigants and Irrigation Methods10.1111/iej.13739 ↗
68. Short-term Storage Stability of NaOCl Solutions When Combined with Dual Rinse HEDP10.1111/iej.12875 ↗
69. Organic Tissue Dissolution in Clodronate and Etidronate Mixtures with Sodium Hypochlorite10.1016/j.joen.2019.10.020 ↗
70. Effect of Continuous Chelation on Physicochemical Properties of Dentin: A Systematic Review10.5005/jp-journals-10024-3839 ↗
71. Comparative Evaluation of Continuous and Sequential Chelation on the Dentinal Tubule Penetration of Bioceramic-Based Sealer—A Confocal Laser Scanning Microscopic Study10.4103/JCDE.JCDE_288_24 ↗
72. Influence of Dual Rinse Irrigation on Dentinal Penetration of a Bioceramic Root Canal Sealer: A Confocal Microscopic Analysis10.1111/aej.12599 ↗
73. Continuous Chelation Irrigation Improves the Adhesion of Epoxy Resin-based Root Canal Sealer to Root Dentine10.1111/j.1365-2591.2012.02073.x ↗
74. Update on Chelating Agents in Endodontic Treatment: A Systematic Review10.4317/jced.60989 ↗
75. A Scoping Review of New Technologies for Dental Plaque Quantitation: Benefits and Limitations10.1016/j.jdent.2023.104772 ↗
76. Expert Consensus on Irrigation and Intracanal Medication in Root Canal Therapy10.1038/s41368-024-00280-5 ↗
77. Comparison of the Effect of Four Decalcifying Agents Combined with 60 °C 3% Sodium Hypochlorite on Smear Layer Removal10.1016/j.joen.2011.11.013 ↗
78. De Deus, G., Silva, E.J.N.L., Souza, E., Versiani, M.A., and Zuolo, M. (2022). Managing Canal Anatomies in the Context of Shaping for Cleaning Proposal. Shaping for Cleaning the Root Canals, Springer International Publishing.10.1007/978-3-030-84617-6 ↗
79. Positive and Negative Pressure Irrigation in Oval Root Canals with Apical Ramifications: A Computational Fluid Dynamics Evaluation in micro-CT Scanned Real Teeth10.1111/iej.13260 ↗
80. Apical Vapour Lock Effect in Endodontics—A Review
81. A Critical Analysis of Research Methods and Experimental Models to Study Irrigants and Irrigation Systems10.1111/iej.13710 ↗
82. Critical Appraisal of Published Smear Layer-Removal Studies: Methodological Issues10.1016/j.tripleo.2011.01.046 ↗
83. Mechanical Preparation of Root Canals: Shaping Goals, Techniques and Means10.1111/j.1601-1546.2005.00152.x ↗
84. Effects of Mechanical and Chemical Procedures on Root Canal Surfaces10.1111/j.1601-1546.2005.00133.x ↗
85. Accumulated Hard Tissue Debris Levels in Mesial Roots of Mandibular Molars after Sequential Irrigation Steps: Debris Reduction10.1111/j.1365-2591.2010.01823.x ↗
86. Co-site Digital Optical Microscopy and Image Analysis: An Approach to Evaluate the Process of Dentine Demineralization10.1111/j.1365-2591.2007.01235.x ↗
87. Root Canal Debridement Using Manual Dynamic Agitation or the EndoVac for Final Irrigation in a Closed System and an Open System10.1111/j.1365-2591.2010.01755.x ↗
88. Effect of Vapor Lock on Root Canal Debridement by Using a Side-Vented Needle for Positive-Pressure Irrigant Delivery10.1016/j.joen.2009.11.022 ↗
89. A Comparative SEM Investigation of Smear Layer Remaining on Dentinal Walls by Three Rotary NiTi Files with Different Cross Sectional Designs in Moderately Curved Canals
90. Comparison of Cleaning Efficiency of Root Canal Using Different Rotary NiTi Instrumentation System: A Scanning Electron Microscopic Study
91. Concentration and Time-Dependent Effect of Initial Sodium Hypochlorite on the Ability of QMix and Ethylenediaminetetraacetic Acid to Remove Smear Layer10.4103/0972-0707.218314 ↗
92. Time-Dependent Effect of Various Irrigants for Root Canal on Smear Layer Removal10.4103/JPBS.JPBS_195_18 ↗