journal article·2025-07-15Open access

Reassessing the Use of Membranes in Peri-Implantitis Surgery: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of In Vivo Studies

Young Joon Cho, Yong Tak Jeong, Hyun Nyun Woo, Hyun Woo Cho, Min Gu Kang, Sung-Min Hwang, Jae-Mok Lee

Abstract

Peri-implantitis (PI) presents a growing challenge in implant dentistry, with regenerative surgical approaches often incorporating barrier membranes despite the uncertainty of their clinical value. This systematic review and meta-analysis of in vivo studies aimed to evaluate the efficacy of barrier membranes in the reconstructive surgical treatment of PI. A comprehensive electronic search was performed in PubMed, Scopus, Google Scholar, and the Cochrane Library, covering studies published from 1990 to 2024. The protocol followed PRISMA guidelines and was registered in PROSPERO (CRD42025625417). Eligible studies included in vivo investigations comparing regenerative procedures with and without membrane use, with a minimum follow-up of 6 months and at least 10 implants per study. Risk of bias (RoB) was assessed using the Cochrane RoB tool. The meta-analysis was conducted using a random-effects model and included 15 studies comprising 560 patients. Although not consistently statistically significant, the findings suggested that membrane use may offer enhanced outcomes in terms of probing pocket depth (PPD) reduction and marginal bone level (MLB) gain. The evidence was limited by high clinical heterogeneity, variability in outcome definitions, and short follow-up durations. While membranes are commonly utilized, current evidence does not justify their routine use. Further well-designed, long-term clinical trials are needed to establish specific indications and optimize treatment strategies.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Dental Implant Techniques and Outcomes · Periodontal Regeneration and Treatments · Dental Radiography and Imaging

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

Affiliations

Mac Dental Clinic, Daegu 42117, Republic of Korea

Department of Periodontology, School of Dentistry, Kyungpook National University, Daegu 41940, Republic of Korea

Private Practice, New York, NY 10075, USA

Department of Oral & Maxillofacial Surgery, Boston University Henry M. Goldman School of Dental Medicine, Boston, MA 02118, USA

Private Practice, Gumi-si 39236, Kyeongsangbuk-do, Republic of Korea

References (52)

Show source-provided references
1. Periodontitis: Consensus Report of Workgroup 2 of the 2017 World Workshop on the Classification of Periodontal and Peri-Implant Diseases and Conditions10.1002/JPER.17-0721 ↗
2. Peri-Implantitis10.1111/jcpe.12954 ↗
3. Supportive Therapy Following Peri-Implantitis Treatment10.1111/clr.14257 ↗
4. Supportive Peri-Implant Therapy Following Anti-Infective Surgical Peri-Implantitis Treatment: 5-Year Survival and Success10.1111/clr.12910 ↗
5. Surgical Therapy for the Control of Peri-Implantitis10.1111/j.1600-0501.2012.02554.x ↗
6. The Recent Advances in Scaffolds for Integrated Periodontal Regeneration
7. Clinical Research on Peri-implant Diseases: Consensus Report of W Orking G Roup 410.1111/j.1600-051X.2011.01837.x ↗
8. The Therapy of Peri-Implantitis: A Systematic Review10.11607/jomi.2014suppl.g5.3 ↗
9. Surgical Treatment of Peri-Implantitis Using a Bone Substitute with or without a Resorbable Membrane: A Prospective Cohort Study10.1111/j.1600-051X.2007.01102.x ↗
10. Significance of Barrier Membrane on the Reconstructive Therapy of Peri-implantitis: A Randomized Controlled Trial10.1002/JPER.22-0511 ↗
11. The Cochrane Collaboration’s Tool for Assessing Risk of Bias in Randomised Trials10.1136/bmj.d5928 ↗
12. Surgical Therapy of Peri-Implant Disease: A 3-Year Follow-Up Study of Cases Treated with 3 Different Techniques of Bone Regeneration10.1902/jop.2001.72.11.1498 ↗
13. Surgical Therapy of Peri-Implantitis Lesions by Means of a Bovine-Derived Xenograft: Comparative Results of a Prospective Study on Two Different Implant Surfaces10.1111/j.1600-051X.2011.01742.x ↗
14. A Single-centre Randomized Controlled Clinical Trial on the Adjunct Treatment of Intra-bony Defects with Autogenous Bone or a Xenograft: Results after 12 Months10.1111/j.1600-051X.2012.01880.x ↗
15. Clinical and Radiographic Outcomes of a Combined Resective and Regenerative Approach in the Treatment of Peri-implantitis: A Prospective Case Series10.1111/clr.12183 ↗
16. Surgical Treatment of Peri-Implantitis Using a Bone Substitute with or without a Resorbable Membrane: A 5-Year Follow-Up10.1111/jcpe.12308 ↗
17. Regenerative Surgical Therapy for Peri-implantitis Using Deproteinized Bovine Bone Mineral with 10% Collagen, Enamel Matrix Derivative and Doxycycline—A Prospective 3-year Cohort Study10.1111/clr.13256 ↗
18. Surgical Treatment of Peri-Implantitis Lesions with or without the Use of a Bone Substitute-a Randomized Clinical Trial10.1111/jcpe.12986 ↗
19. The Adjunctive Effect of a Titanium Brush in Implant Surface Decontamination at Peri-implantitis Surgical Regenerative Interventions: A Randomized Controlled Clinical Trial10.1111/jcpe.13095 ↗
20. Surgical Treatment of Peri-implantitis Defects with Two Different Xenograft Granules: A Randomized Clinical Pilot Study10.1111/clr.13651 ↗
21. Surgical Treatment of Peri-Implantitis with or without a Deproteinized Bovine Bone Mineral and a Native Bilayer Collagen Membrane: A Randomized Clinical Trial10.1111/jcpe.13513 ↗
22. Reconstructive Surgical Therapy of Peri-Implantitis: A Multicenter Randomized Controlled Clinical Trial10.1111/clr.13972 ↗
23. Surgical Peri-Implantitis Treatment with and without Guided Bone Regeneration. A Randomized Controlled Trial10.1111/clr.14116 ↗
24. The Adjunctive Effect of a Resorbable Membrane to a Xenogeneic Bone Replacement Graft in the Reconstructive Surgical Therapy of Peri-implantitis: A Randomized Clinical Trial10.1111/jcpe.13796 ↗
25. Solderer, A., and Schmidlin, P.R. (2020). Regenerative Surgical Therapy of Peri-Implantitis: An Umbrella Review of Answered/Unanswered Questions and Future Perspectives. Front. Dent. Med., 1.10.3389/fdmed.2020.614240 ↗
26. Surgical Treatment of Periimplantitis With Augmentative Techniques10.1097/ID.0000000000000839 ↗
27. Wijesundara, S., Sharma, L.A., Alavi, S.E., and Sharma, A. (2023). Peri-Implantitis Therapy Using Surgical Methods: A Systematic Review. Appl. Sci., 13.10.3390/app13053166 ↗
28. Bone Augmentation at Implant Dehiscences and Fenestrations. A Systematic Review of Randomised Controlled Trials
29. Efficacy of Local Antibiotic Therapy in the Treatment of Peri-Implantitis: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis10.1016/j.jdent.2021.103790 ↗
30. Adjunctive Systemic and Local Antimicrobial Therapy in the Surgical Treatment of Peri-Implantitis: A Randomized Controlled Clinical Trial10.1177/0022034515601961 ↗
31. Toledano-Osorio, M., Vallecillo, C., Toledano, R., Aguilera, F.S., Osorio, M.T., Muñoz-Soto, E., García-Godoy, F., and Vallecillo-Rivas, M. (2022). A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Systemic Antibiotic Therapy in the Treatment of Peri-Implantitis. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public. Health, 19.10.3390/ijerph19116502 ↗
32. Efficacy of Alternative or Adjunctive Measures to Conventional Non-Surgical and Surgical Treatment of Peri-Implant Mucositis and Peri-Implantitis: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis10.1186/s40729-021-00388-x ↗
33. Systemic Antibiotics in the Surgical Treatment of Peri-implantitis: A Randomized Placebo-controlled Trial10.1111/jcpe.13994 ↗
34. Therapy of Peri-Implantitis with Resective Surgery. A 3-Year Clinical Trial on Rough Screw-Shaped Oral Implants. Part I: Clinical Outcome10.1111/j.1600-0501.2004.01084.x ↗
35. Therapy of Peri-Implantitis with Resective Surgery. A 3-Year Clinical Trial on Rough Screw-Shaped Oral Implants. Part II: Radiographic Outcome10.1111/j.1600-0501.2006.01318.x ↗
36. Surgical Regenerative Treatment of Peri-Implantitis Lesions Using a Nanocrystalline Hydroxyapatite or a Natural Bone Mineral in Combination with a Collagen Membrane: A Four-Year Clinical Follow-up Report10.1111/j.1600-051X.2009.01443.x ↗
37. Resective Treatment of Peri-Implantitis: Clinical and Radiographic Outcomes After 2 Years10.11607/prd.3386 ↗
38. Laser-Assisted Regenerative Surgical Therapy for Peri-Implantitis: A Randomized Controlled Clinical Trial10.1002/JPER.20-0040 ↗
39. Antimicrobial Photodynamic Therapy for Managing the Peri-Implant Mucositis and Peri-Implantitis: A Systematic Review of Randomized Clinical Trials10.1016/j.pdpdt.2024.103990 ↗
40. Pisano, M., Amato, A., Sammartino, P., Iandolo, A., Martina, S., and Caggiano, M. (2021). Laser Therapy in the Treatment of Peri-Implantitis: State-of-the-Art, Literature Review and Meta-Analysis. Appl. Sci., 11.10.3390/app11115290 ↗
41. Re-Osseointegration Following Reconstructive Surgical Therapy of Experimental Peri-Implantitis. A Pre-Clinical in Vivo Study10.1111/clr.13430 ↗
42. Long-Term Outcomes and Prognostic Factors of Surgical Treatment of Peri-Implantitis—A Retrospective Study10.1111/clr.14228 ↗
43. A 10-Year Follow-Up of Reconstructive Treatment of Peri-Implantitis Using Mineralized Dehydrated Allograft and Resorbable Membrane: A Retrospective Case Series10.1111/clr.14385 ↗
44. Mordini, L., Sun, N., Chang, N., De Guzman, J.-P., Generali, L., and Consolo, U. (2021). Peri-Implantitis Regenerative Therapy: A Review. Biology, 10.10.3390/biology10080773 ↗
45. Mechanical and Repeated Antimicrobial Therapy Using a Local Drug Delivery System in the Treatment of Peri-Implantitis: A Randomized Clinical Trial10.1902/jop.2008.070347 ↗
46. Immediate Transmucosal Implants Using the Principle of Guided Tissue Regeneration. I. Rationale, Clinical Procedures and 30-month Results10.1034/j.1600-0501.1994.050306.x ↗
47. Bone Formation Utilizing Titanium Reinforced Barrier Membranes10.1097/00008505-199500440-00029 ↗
48. Use of a New Cross-Linked Collagen Membrane for the Treatment of Peri-Implant Dehiscence Defects: A Randomised Controlled Double-Blinded Clinical Trial
49. Treatment of Stage I–III Periodontitis—The EFP S3 Level Clinical Practice Guideline10.1111/jcpe.13290 ↗
50. Efficacy of Growth Factors for the Treatment of Peri-Implant Diseases: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis10.1007/s00784-020-03240-5 ↗
51. Defect Angle as Prognostic Indicator in the Reconstructive Therapy of Peri-Implantitis10.1111/cid.13244 ↗
52. The Influence of Implantoplasty on the Diameter, Chemical Surface Composition, and Biocompatibility of Titanium Implants10.1007/s00784-016-2030-x ↗