journal article·2024-03-10Open access

Surface Treatment of Dental Mini-Sized Implants and Screws: A Systematic Review with Meta-Analysis

Ana Luísa Figueiredo, Raquel Travassos, Catarina Nunes, Madalena Prata Ribeiro, Mariana Santos, Flavia Iaculli, Anabela Baptista Paula, Carlos Miguel Marto, Francisco Caramelo, Inês Francisco, Francisco Vale

Abstract

Miniscrews are devices that allow for absolute skeletal anchorage. However, their use has a higher failure rate (10–30%) than dental implants (10%). To overcome these flaws, chemical and/or mechanical treatment of the surface of miniscrews has been suggested. There is no consensus in the current literature about which of these methods is the gold standard; thus, our objective was to carry out a systematic review and meta-analysis of the literature on surface treatments of miniscrews. The review protocol was registered (PROSPERO CRD42023408011) and is in accordance with the PRISMA guidelines. A bibliographic search was carried out on PubMed via MEDLINE, Cochrane Library, Embase and Web of Science. The initial search of the databases yielded 1684 results, with 98 studies included in the review, with one article originating from the search in the bibliographic references of the included studies. The results of this systematic review show that the protocols of miniscrew surface treatments, such as acid-etching; sandblasting, large-grit and acid-etching; photofunctionalization with ultraviolet light; and photobiomodulation, can increase stability and the success of orthodontic treatment. The meta-analysis revealed that the treatment with the highest removal torque is SLA, followed by acid-etching. On the other hand, techniques such as oxidative anodization, anodization with pre-calcification and heat treatment, as well as deposition of chemical compounds, require further investigation to confirm their effectiveness.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics · Dental Implant Techniques and Outcomes · Dental materials and restorations

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

Affiliations

Institute of Orthodontics, Faculty of Medicine, University of Coimbra, 3000-354 Coimbra, Portugal

Laboratory for Evidence-Based Sciences and Precision Dentistry (LACBE–MDP), Faculty of Medicine, University of Coimbra, 3000-354 Coimbra, Portugal

Institute for Clinical and Biomedical Research (iCBR), Area of Environment Genetics and Oncobiology (CIMAGO), Faculty of Medicine, University of Coimbra, 3000-354 Coimbra, Portugal

Clinical Academic Center of Coimbra (CACC), 3000-354 Coimbra, Portugal

Department of Neurosciences, Reproductive and Odontostomatological Sciences, University of Naples “Federico II”, 80138 Naples, Italy

Institute of Integrated Clinical Practice, Faculty of Medicine, University of Coimbra, 3000-354 Coimbra, Portugal

Institute of Experimental Pathology, Faculty of Medicine, University of Coimbra, 3000-354 Coimbra, Portugal

References (100+)

Show source-provided references
1. Dental Implant Length and Diameter: A Proposed Classification Scheme10.1111/jopr.12517 ↗
2. Implants for Orthodontic Anchorage: Success Rates and Reasons of Failures10.1097/ID.0000000000000048 ↗
3. Upendran, A., Gupta, N., and Salisbury, H.G. (2023). StatPearls, StatPearls Publishing.
4. The Use of Miniscrew Implants for Temporary Skeletal Anchorage in Orthodontics: A Comprehensive Review10.1016/j.tripleo.2006.11.022 ↗
5. Proffit, R.F., Larson, E., and Sarver, M.D. (2018). Contemporary Orthodontics, Elsevier. [6th ed.].
6. Mechanical Stability of Orthodontic Miniscrew Depends on a Thread Shape10.1016/j.jds.2021.11.010 ↗
7. Miniscrew Implants as Temporary Anchorage Devices in Orthodontics: A Comprehensive Review10.5005/jp-journals-10024-1439 ↗
8. Clinical Effectiveness of Orthodontic Miniscrew Implants: A Meta-Analysis10.1177/0022034511409236 ↗
9. Torque Ratio as a Predictable Factor on Primary Stability of Orthodontic Miniscrew Implants
10. Failure Rates and Associated Risk Factors of Orthodontic Miniscrew Implants: A Meta-Analysis10.1016/j.ajodo.2012.05.016 ↗
11. Complications Reported with the Use of Orthodontic Miniscrews: A Systematic Review10.4041/kjod.2021.51.3.199 ↗
12. Effect of Surface Treatment on the Mechanical Stability of Orthodontic Miniscrews10.2319/020721-111.1 ↗
13. Rotational Resistance of Surface-Treated Mini-Implants10.2319/090608-466.1 ↗
14. Bone-Miniscrew Contact and Surface Element Deposition on Orthodontic Miniscrews After Ultraviolet Photofunctionalization10.11607/jomi.8391 ↗
15. Influence of Chemically-Modified Implant Surfaces on the Stability of Orthodontic Mini-Implants
16. Influence of Surface Characteristics on Survival Rates of Mini-Implants10.2319/100206-401.1 ↗
17. Success Rate of Surface-Treated and Non-Treated Orthodontic Miniscrews as Anchorage Reinforcement in the Lower Arch for the Herbst Appliance: A Single-Centre, Randomised Split-Mouth Clinical Trial10.1093/ejo/cjab081 ↗
18. Light Emitting Diode Mediated Photobiomodulation Therapy Improves Orthodontic Tooth Movement and Miniscrew Stability: A Randomized Controlled Clinical Trial10.1002/lsm.22516 ↗
19. Benalcázar Jalkh, E.B., Parra, M., Torroni, A., Nayak, V.V., Tovar, N., Castellano, A., Badalov, R.M., Bonfante, E.A., Coelho, P.G., and Witek, L. (2021). Effect of Supplemental Acid-Etching on the Early Stages of Osseointegration: A Preclinical Model. J. Mech. Behav. Biomed. Mater., 122.10.1016/j.jmbbm.2021.104682 ↗
20. Influence of Acid Treatment on Surface Properties and in Vivo Performance of Ti6Al4V Alloy for Biomedical Applications10.1007/s10856-017-5977-5 ↗
21. The Effect of Sandblasting and Acid Etching on Survival Rate of Orthodontic Miniscrews: A Split-Mouth Randomized Controlled Trial10.1186/s40510-020-00347-z ↗
22. Cervino, G., Fiorillo, L., Iannello, G., Santonocito, D., Risitano, G., and Cicciù, M. (2019). Sandblasted and Acid Etched Titanium Dental Implant Surfaces Systematic Review and Confocal Microscopy Evaluation. Materials, 12.10.3390/ma12111763 ↗
23. The PRISMA 2020 Statement: An Updated Guideline for Reporting Systematic Reviews10.1136/bmj.n71 ↗
24. Guidelines for Reporting Pre-Clinical In Vitro Studies on Dental Materials10.1016/j.jebdp.2012.10.001 ↗
25. Hooijmans, C.R., Rovers, M.M., De Vries, R.B., Leenaars, M., Ritskes-Hoitinga, M., and Langendam, M.W. (2014). SYRCLE’s Risk of Bias Tool for Animal Studies. BMC Med. Res. Methodol., 14.10.1186/1471-2288-14-43 ↗
26. RoB 2: A Revised Tool for Assessing Risk of Bias in Randomised Trials10.1136/bmj.l4898 ↗
27. ROBINS-I: A Tool for Assessing Risk of Bias in Non-Randomised Studies of Interventions10.1136/bmj.i4919 ↗
28. Roughness and Wettability Effect on Histological and Mechanical Response of Self-Drilling Orthodontic Mini-Implants10.1007/s00784-016-1770-y ↗
29. Is It Possible to Re-Use Mini-Implants for Orthodontic Anchorage? Results of an in Vitro Study10.1590/S1516-14392010000400015 ↗
30. Improvement of Osseointegration of Ti–6Al–4V ELI Alloy Orthodontic Mini-Screws through Anodization, Cyclic Pre-Calcification, and Heat Treatments10.1186/s40510-022-00405-8 ↗
31. Evaluation of Osseointegration of Ti-6Al-4V Alloy Orthodontic Mini-Screws with Ibandronate-Loaded TiO2 Nanotube Layer10.4012/dmj.2023-021 ↗
32. Comparison of Mechanical Stability of Mini-Screws with Resorbable Blasting Media and Micro-Arc Oxidation Surface Treatments under Orthodontic Forces: An in Vitro Biomechanical Study10.1016/j.ortho.2023.100775 ↗
33. Biomimetic Calcium Phosphate Coating on Medical Grade Stainless Steel Improves Surface Properties and Serves as a Drug Carrier for Orthodontic Applications10.1016/j.dental.2022.12.009 ↗
34. Baser, B., and Ozel, M.B. (2023). Comparison of Primary Stability of Used and Unused Self-Tapping and Self-Drilling Orthodontic Mini-Implants. Adv. Clin. Exp. Med., 33.10.17219/acem/169511 ↗
35. Effect of Autoclaving on the Fracture Torque of Mini-implants Used for Orthodontic Anchorage10.1179/14653121141200 ↗
36. Effects of Sodium Fluoride Mouth Rinses on the Torsional Properties of Miniscrew Implants10.1016/j.ajodo.2009.05.042 ↗
37. In Vitro and in Vivo Mechanical Stability of Orthodontic Mini-Implants: Effect of Sandblasted, Large-Grit, and Anodic-Oxidation vs. Sandblasted, Large-Grit, and Acid-Etching10.2319/071311-447.1 ↗
38. Effect of Surface Treatment on Cell Responses to Grades 4 and 5 Titanium for Orthodontic Mini-Implants10.1016/j.ajodo.2011.12.022 ↗
39. A Processing Method for Orthodontic Mini-Screws Reuse
40. Effects of Repeated Sterilization Cycles on Primary Stability of Orthodontic Mini-Screws10.2319/082612-685.1 ↗
41. Nanostructured Severe Plastic Deformation Processed Titanium for Orthodontic Mini-Implants10.1016/j.msec.2013.06.012 ↗
42. Effects of a Newly Designed Apparatus on Orthodontic Skeletal Anchorage10.4103/1305-7456.119082 ↗
43. Effect of Recycling Protocol on Mechanical Strength of Used Mini-Implants10.1155/2014/424923 ↗
44. Enhanced Compatibility and Initial Stability of Ti6Al4V Alloy Orthodontic Miniscrews Subjected to Anodization, Cyclic Precalcification, and Heat Treatment10.4041/kjod.2014.44.5.246 ↗
45. Development of a Novel Spike-like Auxiliary Skeletal Anchorage Device to Enhance Miniscrew Stability10.1016/j.ajodo.2015.02.030 ↗
46. Behavior of Osteoblasts on TI Surface with Two Different Coating Designed for Orthodontic Devices10.1007/s10856-014-5335-9 ↗
47. Low-Intensity Pulsed Ultrasound Enhances Bone Formation around Miniscrew Implants10.1016/j.archoralbio.2015.02.014 ↗
48. Strontium Coating by Electrochemical Deposition Improves Implant Osseointegration in Osteopenic Models10.3892/etm.2014.2038 ↗
49. Effect of UV Photofunctionalization on Biologic and Anchoring Capability of Orthodontic Miniscrews10.11607/jomi.3994 ↗
50. Biomechanical and Histomorphometric Properties of Four Different Mini-Implant Surfaces10.1093/ejo/cju097 ↗
51. Laser-Treated Stainless Steel Mini-Screw Implants: 3D Surface Roughness, Bone-Implant Contact, and Fracture Resistance Analysis10.1093/ejo/cjv017 ↗
52. Bone Cutting Capacity and Osseointegration of Surface-Treated Orthodontic Mini-Implants10.4041/kjod.2016.46.6.386 ↗
53. Biochemical Characteristics of Mini-Implants Sterilised by Different Chemical and Physical Procedures10.37358/MP.17.2.4827 ↗
54. Effects of UV Treatment on Orthodontic Microimplant Surface after Autoclaving10.14815/kjdm.2017.44.2.119 ↗
55. Micrographic Study and Torsional Strength of Grade 23 Titanium Mini-Implants Recycled for Orthodontic Purposes
56. Surface Properties and Maximum Insertion Energy of Sterilized Orthodontic Mini-Implants with Different Chemical Materials10.37358/RC.18.11.6716 ↗
57. In-Vitro Evaluation of the Effects of Insertion and Sterilization Procedures on the Mechanical and Surface Characteristics of Mini Screws10.26650/eor.20197993 ↗
58. Iodice, G., Perinetti, G., Ludwig, B., Polishchuk, E.V., and Polishchuk, R.S. (2019). Biological Effects of Anodic Oxidation on Titanium Miniscrews: An In Vitro Study on Human Cells. Dent. J., 7.10.3390/dj7040107 ↗
59. Preliminary Testing for Reduction of Insertion Torque of Orthodontic Mini-Screw Implant Using Diamond-like Carbon Films10.1088/1742-6596/1380/1/012062 ↗
60. Bioactive Antibacterial Modification of Orthodontic Microimplants Using Chitosan Biopolymer10.1007/s13233-019-7069-5 ↗
61. Evaluation of Miniscrew Stability Using an Automatic Embedding Auxiliary Skeletal Anchorage Device10.2319/121117-857.1 ↗
62. Do Chlorhexidine and Probiotics Solutions Provoke Corrosion of Orthodontic Mini-Implants? An In Vitro Study10.11607/jomi.7392 ↗
63. Effect of Steam and Dry Heat Sterilization on the Insertion and Fracture Torque of Orthodontic Miniscrews10.4103/1735-3327.284729 ↗
64. Evaluation of Insertion Torque and Surface Integrity of Zirconia-Coated Titanium Mini Screw Implants10.1016/j.ejwf.2020.01.002 ↗
65. Development of Novel Bone-like Nanocomposite Coating of Hydroxyapatite/Collagen on Titanium by Modified Electrophoretic Deposition10.1002/jbm.a.37182 ↗
66. Zogheib, T., Walter-Solana, A., De La Iglesia, F., Espinar, E., Gil, J., and Puigdollers, A. (2021). Do Titanium Mini-Implants Have the Same Quality of Finishing and Degree of Contamination before and after Different Manipulations? An In Vitro Study. Metals, 11.10.3390/met11020245 ↗
67. Li, M., Wu, G., Wang, M., Hunziker, E.B., and Liu, Y. (2022). Crystalline Biomimetic Calcium Phosphate Coating on Mini-Pin Implants to Accelerate Osseointegration and Extend Drug Release Duration for an Orthodontic Application. Nanomaterials, 12.10.3390/nano12142439 ↗
68. Use of Bone Morphogenetic Protein-2 and Dentin Matrix Protein-1 to Enhance the Osteointegration of the Onplant System10.1080/03008200390151927 ↗
69. Fixation of an Orthodontic Anchor Screw Using Beta-Tricalcium Phosphate in a Screw-Loosening Model in Rats10.2319/080822-558.1 ↗
70. Okawa, K., Matsunaga, S., Kasahara, N., Kasahara, M., Tachiki, C., Nakano, T., Abe, S., and Nishii, Y. (2023). Alveolar Bone Microstructure Surrounding Orthodontic Anchor Screws with Plasma Surface Treatment in Rats. J. Funct. Biomater., 14.10.3390/jfb14070356 ↗
71. A Novel Auxiliary Device Enhances Miniscrew Stability under Immediate Heavy Loading Simulating Orthopedic Treatment10.2319/022222-163.1 ↗
72. The Use of Bioabsorbable Implants as Orthodontic Anchorage in Dogs10.4012/dmj.24.628 ↗
73. Removal Torque Values of Surface-Treated Mini-Implants after Loading10.1016/j.ajodo.2006.07.038 ↗
74. Effects of Microgrooves on the Success Rate and Soft Tissue Adaptation of Orthodontic Miniscrews10.2319/101707-496.1 ↗
75. The Effect of Microrough Surface Treatment on Miniscrews Used as Orthodontic Anchors10.1111/j.1600-0501.2009.01728.x ↗
76. Application of α-Tricalcium Phosphate Coatings on Titanium Subperiosteal Orthodontic Implants Reduces the Time for Absolute Anchorage: A Study Using Rabbit Femora10.4012/dmj.28.477 ↗
77. Resistance to Immediate Orthodontic Loading of Surface-Treated Mini-Implants10.2319/030309-123.1 ↗
78. Effects of Insertion Angle and Implant Thread Type on the Fracture Properties of Orthodontic Mini-Implants during Insertion10.2319/082812-689.1 ↗
79. Surface Changes of Anodic Oxidized Orthodontic Titanium Miniscrew10.2319/071311-448.1 ↗
80. Effect of Surface Anodization on Stability of Orthodontic Microimplant10.4041/kjod.2012.42.1.4 ↗
81. Low-Level Laser Therapy Enhances the Stability of Orthodontic Mini-Implants via Bone Formation Related to BMP-2 Expression in a Rat Model10.1089/pho.2011.3157 ↗
82. Resonance Frequency Analysis of Orthodontic Miniscrews Subjected to Light-Emitting Diode Photobiomodulation Therapy10.1093/ejo/cjq166 ↗
83. Biologic Stability of Plasma Ion-Implanted Miniscrews10.4041/kjod.2013.43.3.120 ↗
84. Influence of Low-Intensity Laser Therapy on the Stability of Orthodontic Mini-Implants: A Study in Rabbits10.1016/j.oooo.2011.09.036 ↗
85. Local Application of Zoledronate Enhances Miniscrew Implant Stability in Dogs10.1016/j.ajodo.2014.01.020 ↗
86. A Preliminary Study of the Effects of Low-Intensity Pulsed Ultrasound Exposure on the Stability of Orthodontic Miniscrews in Growing Rats10.1093/ejo/cjt066 ↗
87. Evaluation of Stability of Surface-Treated Mini-Implants in Diabetic Rabbits10.1155/2014/838356 ↗
88. Effect of Different Sterilization Modes on the Surface Morphology, Ion Release, and Bone Reaction of Retrieved Micro-Implants10.2319/012014-56.1 ↗
89. Histomorphometric Evaluation of the Effects of Various Diode Lasers and Force Levels on Orthodontic Mini Screw Stability10.1089/pho.2014.3833 ↗
90. Jang, I., Shim, S.-C., Choi, D.-S., Cha, B.-K., Lee, J.-K., Choe, B.-H., and Choi, W.-Y. (2015). Effect of TiO2 Nanotubes Arrays on Osseointegration of Orthodontic Miniscrew. Biomed. Microdevices, 17.10.1007/s10544-015-9986-1 ↗
91. Histomorphological and Torque Removal Comparison of 6 Mm Orthodontic Miniscrews with and without Surface Treatment in New Zealand Rabbits10.1093/ejo/cju077 ↗
92. Ultraviolet Photofunctionalization Increases Removal Torque Values and Horizontal Stability of Orthodontic Miniscrews10.1016/j.ajodo.2015.03.022 ↗
93. Stability of Smooth and Rough Mini-Implants: Clinical and Biomechanical Evaluation—An in Vivostudy10.1590/2177-6709.20.5.035-042.oar ↗
94. Evaluation of the Effect of Platelet-Released Growth Factor and Immediate Orthodontic Loading on the Removal Torque of Miniscrews10.11607/jomi.4288 ↗
95. Orthodontic Tunnel Miniscrews with and without TiO2 Nanotube Arrays as a Drug-Delivery System: In Vivo Study10.3233/BME-161597 ↗
96. Stress Distributions in Peri-Miniscrew Areas from Cylindrical and Tapered Miniscrews Inserted at Different Angles10.4041/kjod.2016.46.4.189 ↗
97. Gansukh, O., Jeong, J.-W., Kim, J.-W., Lee, J.-H., and Kim, T.-W. (2016). Mechanical and Histological Effects of Resorbable Blasting Media Surface Treatment on the Initial Stability of Orthodontic Mini-Implants. BioMed Res. Int., 2016.10.1155/2016/7520959 ↗
98. Enhancement of Orthodontic Anchor Screw Stability Under Immediate Loading by Ultraviolet Photofunctionalization Technology10.11607/jomi.4706 ↗
99. Jang, I., Choi, D.-S., Lee, J.-K., Kim, W.-T., Cha, B.-K., and Choi, W.-Y. (2017). Effect of Drug-Loaded TiO2 Nanotube Arrays on Osseointegration in an Orthodontic Miniscrew: An in-Vivo Pilot Study. Biomed. Microdevices, 19.10.1007/s10544-017-0237-5 ↗
100. The Integration of Orthodontic Miniscrews under Mechanical Loading: A Pre-Clinical Study in Rabbit10.1093/ejo/cjw069 ↗