journal article·2025-04-07Open access

Insights into Sinus-Lift Bone Grafting Materials: What’s Changed?

Anida-Maria Băbțan, Claudia N. Feurdean, Anca Ionel, Willi A. Uriciuc, Radu Chifor, Chambon Antoine Bernard Jaques, Bianca A. Boșca, Aranka Ilea

Abstract

Background: Sinus-lift (SL) is a pre-prosthetic procedure with the objective of increasing bone height to achieve implant insertion primary stability in implant-supported prostheses. The biomechanical properties of SL augmentation materials are influenced by their origin, manufacture, bioactive substances addition, receiver, and surgical procedure. This systematic review provides insights into state-of-the-art SL biomaterials, focusing on autologous bone grafting as the gold standard. Methods: The study followed the PRISMA flow diagram, searching WoS (Web of Science), Embase, Cochrane, and PubMed databases using the search terms «sinus lift» OR «sinus augmentation» OR «bone graft» OR «bovine» OR «porcine» OR «autologous» OR «allogenic» OR «xenogeneic» OR «alloplastic» OR «hydroxyapatite» OR «β-tricalcium phosphate (β-TCP)» OR «equine» OR «PRF». Results: The highest bone gain was provided by Bioglass at 42%. Articles written between 2014 and 2024 in English or French, containing human studies and with full text available, were included. Participants were required to be in good general health, without acute, chronic, or congenital diseases, or substance abuse (drugs, alcohol, or nicotine). SL surgery was performed using the lateral approach, with no Schneiderian membrane perforation or postoperative complications. The network meta-analysis was conducted using the R statistical computing environment. To assess the inconsistency between direct and indirect evidence, we used a net heat plot. To evaluate heterogeneity across studies, we used the chi-squared-based Q-test and I2 statistic. A significance level of 0.05 was applied throughout all analyses. Results: Allogeneic bovine bone and hydrox yapatite demonstrated the lowest resorption rates. Significant differences were found for residual graft and connective tissue between allogenous bovine bone (ABB) + AlB vs. β-TCP + PRF (p = 0.028); ABB + AlB vs. β-TCP (p = 0.034); ABB + AlB vs. BCP (p = 0.037). Meta-analysis showed that the overall heterogeneity was 51.8% (6.9–75%; p = 0.019), with significant heterogeneity within designs (p = 0.007) and no significant heterogeneity between designs (p = 0.39). AB had a better bone regeneration ratio compared to many of the other interventions, but only two passed the threshold of significance: A1B and B-TCP + AB. Conclusions: A grafting material’s superiority is determined by its new bone formation ratio, connective tissue integration, residual graft content, and bone resorptionratio. Although autologous bone grafting has exhibited superior bone regeneration compared to other biomaterials, it was not favored due to its unpredictable connective tissue concentration and bone resorption ratio. Additionally, autologous bone exhibited the fastest metabolic turnover among all grafting materials.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Dental Implant Techniques and Outcomes · Bone Tissue Engineering Materials · Periodontal Regeneration and Treatments

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

Affiliations

IIIrd Department-Oral Rehabilitation, Faculty of Dentistry, “Iuliu Haţieganu” University of Medicine and Pharmacy, 400347 Cluj-Napoca, Romania

Faculty Nursing and Science for Health, “Iuliu Hațieganu” University of Medicine and Pharmacy, 400012 Cluj-Napoca, Romania

Faculty of Dentistry, “Iuliu Haţieganu” University of Medicine and Pharmacy, 400347 Cluj-Napoca, Romania

Ist Department-Histology, Faculty of Medicine, “Iuliu Haţieganu” University of Medicine and Pharmacy, 400347 Cluj-Napoca, Romania

References (64)

Show source-provided references
1. The maxillary sinus membrane elevation procedure: Augmentation of bone around dental implants without grafts—A review of a surgical technique10.1155/2012/105483 ↗
2. (2023, July 08). Healthjade.net. Available online: https://healthjade.net/sinus-lift/.
3. Themes, U.F.O. (2023, July 08). The Maxillary Sinus Lift. Pocket Dentistry. Available online: https://pocketdentistry.com/the-maxillary-sinus-lift/.
4. (2023, July 08). Elévation Sinusienne par Voie Latérale ou Crestale: Quel Choix Thérapeutique? Le Courrier du Dentiste. Available online: https://www.lecourrierdudentiste.com/dossiers-du-mois/elevation-sinusienne-par-voie-laterale-ou-crestale-quel-choix-therapeutique.html.
5. Maxillary sinus augmentation10.4103/jisp.jisp_236_18 ↗
6. Maxillary sinus membrane repair: Report of a technique for large perforations10.1097/00008505-199901000-00003 ↗
7. Sinus membrane perforations and the incidence of complications: A retrospective study from a residency program10.1016/j.oooo.2015.02.477 ↗
8. Maarek, H. (2023, July 08). Les Complications Sinusiennes post Implantaires. LEFILDENTAIRE Magazine Dentaire, Available online: https://www.lefildentaire.com/articles/clinique/implantologie/les-complications-sinusiennes-post-implantaires/.
9. Disappearance of a dental implant after migration into the maxillary sinus: An unusual case10.5125/jkaoms.2015.41.5.278 ↗
10. Maxillary Sinus Lift Procedures: An Overview of Current Techniques, Presurgical Evaluation, and Complications
11. (2023, July 08). Journal LS—Implantologie Dentaire Greffe Osseuse Autologue: Les Sites de Prélèvement. Available online: https://journal-stomato-implanto.com/content/greffe-osseuse-autologue%C2%A0-les-sites-de-pr%C3%A9l%C3%A8vement.
12. Olivier, S.A.A.D. (2018). Les substituts Osseux Allogénique et Xénogénique: Utilisation en Chirurgie pré Implantaire. [Postgraduate Ph.D. Thesis, Université de Lorraine]. Available online: https://hal.univ-lorraine.fr/hal-01739102/document.
13. (2023, July 08). Utilisation de Greffes Allogéniques Selon un Protocole Spécifique: Rapport de cas Cliniques. Biobank.fr. Available online: https://www.biobank.fr/Medias/Fichier/utilisation-de-greffes-allogeniques-selon-un-protocole-specifique-dr-mailhes.pdf.
14. Bone substitutes
15. (2023, July 08). Augmentation des Tissus Durs—Un Aperçu des Techniques de Régénération en Dentisterie. Straumann.com. Available online: https://www.straumann.com/be/fr/shared/news/bone-substitutes/augmentation-of-hard-tissue-regenerative-techniques-in-dentistry.html.
16. Deborah, P. (2020). Alternatives aux Sinus Lifts: Comblements Sous Sinusiens par Biomatériaux Collagéniques. [Ph.D. Thesis, Université de Paris].
17. Verrier, P. (2008). Utilisation des Verres Bioactifs dans les Dispositifs Médicaux Implantables. [Postgraduate Thesis, Université Nancy]. Available online: http://www.idverre.net/veille/dostec/coll06-verre-bioactif/verre-bioactif.pdf.
18. Gallego, T. (2019). Utilisation du PRF en implantologie en 2018. Chirurgie, dumas-02102939.
19. (2023, July 08). The Use of Barrier Membranes in Implant Dentistry. Glidewell. Available online: https://glidewelldental.com/education/chairside-magazine/volume-13-issue-1/barrier-membranes-implant-dentistry.
20. (2023, July 08). La Regeneration Osseuse Guide. 3Dcelo. Available online: https://www.3dcelo.com/blog/la-regeneration-osseuse-guidee.
21. Antoun, H., and Eid, J. (2023, July 08). Résultats Cliniques, Histologiques et Histomorphométriques des Greffes D’hydroxyapatite Bovine dans les Comblements Sinusiens. Chirurgiens-dentistes.fr. Available online: https://dr-joseph-eid.chirurgiens-dentistes.fr/wp-content/uploads/Resultats-cliniques.pdf.
22. Levaudi, A.-L. (2017). Évaluation du volume osseux après implantation: Une revue systématique de la littérature. Chirurgie, dumas-01620355.
23. Khayat, P.G., and Peuch-Lestrade, G.R. (2023, July 08). Conical Implants by Means of Resonance Frequency Analysis. Asso.fr. Available online: https://www.sop.asso.fr/admin/documents/ros/ROS0000166/2010.pdf.
24. The Correlation Between Immediate Implant Insertion Torque and Implant Stability Quotient10.11607/prd.2865 ↗
25. Guthmann, M. (2020). Évaluation des taux de survie et des taux de succès implantaires chez des patients atteints de maladies rares traités dans le centre de références “O-rares” de l’hôpital Rothschild Marion Guthmann. Sciences du Vivant, dumas-03420590.
26. Use of autogenous bone and beta-tricalcium phosphate in maxillary sinus lifting: Histomorphometric study and immunohistochemical assessment of RUNX2 and VEGF10.1016/j.ijom.2017.01.002 ↗
27. Regeneration of human bone using different bone substitute biomaterials10.1111/cid.12089 ↗
28. Platelet-rich plasma and deproteinized bovine bone matrix in maxillary sinus lift surgery: A split-mouth histomorphometric evaluation10.1097/ID.0000000000000293 ↗
29. Maxillary sinus floor elevation using platelet-rich plasma combined with either biphasic calcium phosphate or deproteinized bovine bone10.1097/SCS.0000000000002522 ↗
30. Maxillary Sinus Elevation Surgery with ChronOS and Autogenous Bone Graft: Immunohistochemical Assessment of RUNX2, VEGF, TRAP, and Osteocalcin10.11607/prd.2606 ↗
31. Maxillary sinus augmentation with three different biomaterials: Histological, histomorphometric, clinical, and patient-reported outcomes from a randomized controlled trial10.1111/cid.12964 ↗
32. Maxillary sinus augmentation with leukocyte and platelet-rich fibrin and deproteinized bovine bone mineral: A split-mouth histological and histomorphometric study10.1111/clr.13044 ↗
33. Histopathological comparison of healing after maxillary sinus augmentation using xenograft mixed with autogenous bone versus allograft mixed with autogenous bone10.1111/clr.13098 ↗
34. Histomorphometric and immunohistochemical assessment of RUNX2 and VEGF of BiogranTM and autogenous bone graft in human maxillary sinus bone augmentation: A prospective and randomized study10.1111/cid.12507 ↗
35. Annibali, S., Iezzi, G., Sfasciotti, G.L., Cristalli, M.P., Vozza, I., Mangano, C., la Monaca, G., and Polimeni, A. (2015). Histological and histomorphometric human results of HA-Beta-TCP 30/70 compared to three different biomaterials in maxillary sinus augmentation at 6 months: A preliminary report. BioMed Res. Int., 2015.10.1155/2015/156850 ↗
36. Fresh-frozen allografts combined with bovine bone mineral enhance bone formation in sinus augmentation10.1177/0885328214552709 ↗
37. la Monaca, G., Iezzi, G., Cristalli, M.P., Pranno, N., Sfasciotti, G.L., and Vozza, I. (2018). Comparative Histological and Histomorphometric Results of Six Biomaterials Used in Two-Stage Maxillary Sinus Augmentation Model after 6-Month Healing. BioMed Res. Int., 2018.10.1155/2018/9430989 ↗
38. Stacchi, C., Lombardi, T., Oreglia, F., Maltoni, A.A., and Traini, T. (2017). Histologic and Histomorphometric Comparison between Sintered Nanohydroxyapatite and Anorganic Bovine Xenograft in Maxillary Sinus Grafting: A Split-Mouth Randomized Controlled Clinical Trial. BioMed Res. Int., 2017.10.1155/2017/9489825 ↗
39. Double Centrifugation Versus Single Centrifugation of Bone Marrow Aspirate Concentrate in Sinus Floor Elevation: A Pilot Study10.11607/jomi.4170 ↗
40. Pasquali, P.J., Teixeira, M.L., de Oliveira, T.A., de Macedo, L.G.S., Aloise, A.C., and Pelegrine, A.A. (2015). Maxillary Sinus Augmentation Combining Bio-Oss with the Bone Marrow Aspirate Concentrate: A Histomorphometric Study in Humans. Int. J. Biomater., 2015.10.1155/2015/121286 ↗
41. Impact of autogenous concentrated bone marrow aspirate on bone regeneration after sinus floor augmentation with a bovine bone substitute—A split-mouth pilot study10.1111/clr.12228 ↗
42. PRGF as adjunct to DBB in maxillary sinus floor augmentation: Histological results of a pilot split-mouth study10.1186/s40729-019-0166-6 ↗
43. A Comparative Study with Biphasic Calcium Phosphate to Deproteinized Bovine Bone in Maxillary Sinus Augmentation: A Prospective Randomized and Controlled Clinical Trial10.11607/jomi.7116 ↗
44. Kivovics, M., Szabó, B.T., Németh, O., Czinkóczky, B., Dőri, F., Nagy, P., and Szabo, G. (2018). Microarchitecture of the Augmented Bone Following Sinus Elevation with an Albumin Impregnated Demineralized Freeze-Dried Bone Allograft (BoneAlbumin) versus Anorganic Bovine Bone Mineral: A Randomized Prospective Clinical, Histomorphometric, and Micro-Computed Tomography Study. Materials, 11.10.3390/ma11020202 ↗
45. Bioactive glass added to autogenous bone graft in maxillary sinus augmentation: A prospective histomorphometric, immunohistochemical, and bone graft resorption assessment
46. Effects of directly autotransplanted tibial bone marrow aspirates on bone regeneration and osseointegration of dental implants10.1111/clr.12172 ↗
47. Monophasic ß-TCP vs. biphasic HA/ß-TCP in two-stage sinus floor augmentation procedures—A prospective randomized clinical trial10.1111/clr.12983 ↗
48. Histomorphometric and Histologic Evaluation of Nano-HA with and without PRGF in Bilateral Sinus Lift Augmentation: A Randomized Clinical Trial
49. Histologic and histomorphometric assessment of sinus-floor augmentation with beta-tricalcium phosphate alone or in combination with pure-platelet-rich plasma or platelet-rich fibrin: A randomized clinical trial10.1111/cid.12522 ↗
50. A randomized and controlled clinical trial of two different compositions of deproteinized bovine bone and autogenous bone used for lateral ridge augmentation10.1111/clr.12143 ↗
51. Correia, F., Pozza, D.H., Gouveia, S., Felino, A.C., and Faria-Almeida, R. (2021). Advantages of porcine xenograft over autograft in sinus lift: A randomised clinical trial. Materials, 14.10.3390/ma14123439 ↗
52. Maxillary sinus floor augmentation with synthetic bone substitutes compared with other grafting materials: A systematic review and meta-analysis10.1097/ID.0000000000000768 ↗
53. Histomorphometric results of different grafting materials and effect of healing time on bone maturation after sinus floor augmentation: A systematic review and meta-analysis10.1111/jre.12402 ↗
54. Comparative study of volumetric changes and trabecular microarchitecture in human maxillary sinus bone augmentation with bioactive glass and autogenous bone graft: A prospective and randomized assessment10.1016/j.ijom.2017.11.016 ↗
55. Maxillary sinus grafting with fresh frozen allograft versus bovine bone mineral: A tomographic and histological study10.1016/j.jcms.2016.03.005 ↗
56. Relative performance of various biomaterials used for maxillary sinus augmentation: A Bayesian network meta-analysis10.1111/clr.13690 ↗
57. Comparative effectiveness of natural and synthetic bone grafts in oral and maxillofacial surgery prior to insertion of dental implants: Systematic review and network meta-analysis of parallel and cluster randomized controlled trials10.1016/j.jdent.2016.03.010 ↗
58. Effects of platelet-rich plasma in association with bone grafts in maxillary sinus augmentation: A systematic review and meta-analysis10.1016/j.ijom.2015.07.012 ↗
59. Ortega-Mejia, H., Estrugo-Devesa, A., Saka-Herrán, C., Ayuso- Montero, R., López-López, J., and Velasco-Ortega, E. (2020). Platelet-rich plasma in maxillary sinus augmentation: Systematic review. Materials, 13.10.3390/ma13030622 ↗
60. Lateral ridge augmentation with Bio-Oss alone or Bio-Oss mixed with particulate autogenous bone graft: A systematic review10.1016/j.ijom.2017.03.008 ↗
61. Bouwman, W.F., Bravenboer, N., ten Bruggenkate, C.M., Eijsackers, F.A., Stringa, N., and Schulten, E.A.J.M. (2021). Tissue level changes after maxillary sinus floor elevation with three types of calcium phosphate ceramics: A radiological study with a 5-year follow-up. Materials, 14.10.3390/ma14061471 ↗
62. Long-term stability of autologous bone graft of intraoral origin after lateral sinus floor elevation with simultaneous implant placement10.1111/cid.12649 ↗
63. Longterm results of new deproteinized bovine bone material in a maxillary sinus graft procedure10.5051/jpis.2014.44.5.259 ↗
64. Twenty Years-Passed Case of Demineralized Dentin Matrix Autograft for Sinus Bone Augmentation—A First Case of Dentin Graft in Human10.4317/jced.60912 ↗