journal article·2011-11-08Open access

Is Macroporosity Absolutely Required for Preliminary in Vitro Bone Biomaterial Study? A Comparison Between Porous Materials and Flat Materials

Juliana T. Y. Lee, King L. Chow, Kefeng Wang, Wai-Hung Tsang

Abstract

Porous materials are highly preferred for bone tissue engineering due to space for blood vessel ingrowth, but this may introduce extra experimental variations because of the difficulty in precise control of porosity. In order to decide whether it is absolutely necessary to use porous materials in in vitro comparative osteogenesis study of materials with different chemistries, we carried out osteoinductivity study using C3H/10T1/2 cells, pluripotent mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs), on seven material types: hydroxyapatite (HA), α-tricalcium phosphate (α-TCP) and b-tricalcium phosphate (β-TCP) in both porous and dense forms and tissue culture plastic. For all materials under test, dense materials give higher alkaline phosphatase gene (Alp) expression compared with porous materials. In addition, the cell density effects on the 10T1/2 cells were assessed through alkaline phosphatase protein (ALP) enzymatic assay. The ALP expression was higher for higher initial cell plating density and this explains the greater osteoinductivity of dense materials compared with porous materials for in vitro study as porous materials would have higher surface area. On the other hand, the same trend of Alp mRNA level (HA > β-TCP > α-TCP) was observed for both porous and dense materials, validating the use of dense flat materials for comparative study of materials with different chemistries for more reliable comparison when well-defined porous materials are not available. The avoidance of porosity variation would probably facilitate more reproducible results. This study does not suggest porosity is not required for experiments related to bone regeneration application, but emphasizes that there is often a tradeoff between higher clinical relevance, and less variation in a less complex set up, which facilitates a statistically significant conclusion. Technically, we also show that the base of normalization for ALP activity may influence the conclusion and there may be ALP activity from serum, necessitating the inclusion of “no cell” control in ALP activity assay with materials. These explain the opposite conclusions drawn by different groups on the effect of porosity.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Bone Tissue Engineering Materials · Orthopaedic implants and arthroplasty · Dental Implant Techniques and Outcomes

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

Affiliations

Bioengineering Graduate Program, The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, Clear Water Bay, Kowloon 2327 0271, Hong Kong, China

Division of Life Science, The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, Clear Water Bay, Kowloon 2327 0271, Hong Kong, China

Department of Mechanical Engineering, The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, Clear Water Bay, Kowloon 2327 0271, Hong Kong, China

National Engineering Research Center for Biomaterials, Sichuan University, 29 Wangjiang Road, Chengdu 610064, China

References (100+)

Show source-provided references
1. Porosity of 3D biomaterial scaffolds and osteogenesis10.1016/j.biomaterials.2005.02.002 ↗
2. A novel porous bioceramics scaffold by accumulating hydroxyapatite spherules for large bone tissue engineering in vivo. I. Preparation and characterization of scaffold10.1002/jbm.a.32408 ↗
3. Bioactive glass-poly (ε-caprolactone) composite scaffolds with 3 dimensionally hierarchical pore networks10.1016/j.msec.2010.08.020 ↗
4. Cell infiltration and growth in a low density, uncompressed three-dimensional electrospun nanofibrous scaffold10.1016/j.biomaterials.2010.10.056 ↗
5. Development, characterization, and validation of porous carbonated hydroxyapatite bone cement10.1002/jbm.b.31360 ↗
6. Development of macroporous calcium phosphate scaffold processed via microwave rapid drying10.1016/j.msec.2009.01.022 ↗
7. Differentiation of mesenchymal stem cells in chitosan scaffolds with double micro and macroporosity10.1002/jbm.a.32906 ↗
8. Effects of structural property and surface modification of Ti6Ta4Sn scaffolds on the response of SaOS2 cells for bone tissue engineering10.1016/j.jallcom.2010.01.026 ↗
9. High surface area nanomacroporous bioactive glass scaffold for hard tissue engineering10.1111/j.1551-2916.2010.03970.x ↗
10. Macroporous hydroxyapatite scaffolds for bone tissue engineering applications: Physicochemical characterization and assessment of rat bone marrow stromal cell viability10.1002/jbm.a.32213 ↗
11. Physical characterization of hydroxyapatite porous scaffolds for tissue engineering10.1016/j.msec.2008.09.052 ↗
12. Pre-osteoblast infiltration and differentiation in highly porous apatite-coated PLLA electrospun scaffolds10.1016/j.biomaterials.2010.12.003 ↗
13. Primary human osteoblast culture on 3D porous collagen-hydroxyapatite scaffolds10.1002/jbm.a.32805 ↗
14. Bone formation and degradation of a highly porous biphasic calcium phosphate ceramic in presence of BMP-7, VEGF and mesenchymal stem cells in an ectopic mouse model10.1016/j.jcms.2010.01.003 ↗
15. Bioceramic bone graft substitutes: Influence of porosity and chemistry10.1111/j.1744-7402.2005.02020.x ↗
16. A review on stereolithography and its applications in biomedical engineering10.1016/j.biomaterials.2010.04.050 ↗
17. Ceramic scaffolds produced by computer-assisted 3D printing and sintering: Characterization and biocompatibility investigations10.1002/jbm.b.31577 ↗
18. Chitosan-based inverse opals: Three-dimensional scaffolds with uniform pore structures for cell culture10.1002/adma.200803504 ↗
19. Engineered tissue scaffolds with variational porous architecture
20. Scaffolds with a standardized macro-architecture fabricated from several calcium phosphate ceramics using an indirect rapid prototyping technique10.1007/s10856-010-4183-5 ↗
21. Mathematically defined tissue engineering scaffold architectures prepared by stereolithography10.1016/j.biomaterials.2010.05.068 ↗
22. Biphasic calcium phosphate bioceramics: Preparation, properties and applications10.1023/A:1022872421333 ↗
23. Bronner, F., Farach-Carson, M.C., and Mikos, A.G. (2007). Engineering of Functional Skeletal Tissues, SpringerLink.10.1007/978-1-84628-366-6 ↗
24. Multilineage potential of adult human mesenchymal stem cells10.1126/science.284.5411.143 ↗
25. The profile of gene expression of human marrow mesenchymal stem cells10.1634/stemcells.21-6-661 ↗
26. Osteogenic differentiation of purified, culture-expanded human mesenchymal stem cells in vitro10.1002/(SICI)1097-4644(199702)64:2<295::AID-JCB12>3.0.CO;2-I ↗
27. Material-dependent bone induction by calcium phosphate ceramics: A 2.5-year study in dog10.1016/S0142-9612(00)00450-6 ↗
28. Simple modifications to standard TRIzol® protocol allow high-yield RNA extraction from cells on resorbable materials10.4236/jbnb.2011.21006 ↗
29. Lee, J.T.Y., and Chow, K.L. (2011). SEM sample preparation for cells on 3D scaffolds by freezing drying and HMDS. Scanning.10.1002/sca.20271 ↗
30. Molecular mechanisms mediating proliferation/differentiation interrelationships during progressive development of the osteoblast phenotype10.1210/edrv-14-4-424 ↗
31. Molecular structure of osteocalcin and the role as an essential marker in the osteogenic differentiation cascade
32. Comparative in vitro osteoinductivity study of CaP ceramics (HA, α-TCP, β-TCP) using 10T1/2 cells with different controls and possible correlations with other systems10.4236/jbnb.2011.22021 ↗
33. Effect of the fiber diameter and porosity of non-woven PET fabrics on the osteogenic differentiation of mesenchymal stem cells10.1163/156856204322752228 ↗
34. Influence of the porosity of hydroxyapatite ceramics on in vitro and in vivo bone formation by cultured rat bone marrow stromal cells10.1007/s10856-006-8232-z ↗
35. McCullough, K.C., and Spier, R.E. (1990). Monoclonal Antibodies in Biology and Biotechnology: Theoretical and Practical Aspects, Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9780511565137 ↗
36. Crowther, J.R. (1995). ELISA: Theory and Practice, Humana Press.10.1385/0896032795 ↗
37. Catecholamines stimulate the proliferation and alkaline phosphatase activity of MC3T3-E1 osteoblast-like cells10.1016/S8756-3282(98)00099-4 ↗
38. Effects of hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) on alkaline phosphatase activity and matrix mineralization of odontoblast and osteoblast cell lines10.1007/s10565-006-0018-z ↗
39. Vitamin K induces osteoblast differentiation through pregnane X receptor-mediated transcriptional control of the Msx2 gene10.1128/MCB.00813-07 ↗
40. In vitro characterization of trimegestone: A new potent and selective progestin10.1016/S0039-128X(00)00120-3 ↗
41. Stimulation of osteoblastic differentiation and inhibition of interleukin-6 and nitric oxide in MC3T3-E1 cells by pomegranate ethanol extract10.1002/ptr.2587 ↗
42. The effects of calcium phosphate particles on the growth of osteoblasts10.1002/(SICI)1097-4636(19971205)37:3<324::AID-JBM3>3.0.CO;2-N ↗
43. Extracellular matrix formation and mineralization on a phosphate-free porous bioactive glass scaffold using primary human osteoblast (HOB) cells10.1016/j.biomaterials.2006.11.022 ↗
44. Ectopic bone formation associated with mesenchymal stem cells in a resorbable calcium deficient hydroxyapatite carrier10.1016/j.biomaterials.2005.03.001 ↗
45. Effect of fluoridation of hydroxyapatite in hydroxyapatite-polycaprolactone composites on osteoblast activity10.1016/j.biomaterials.2004.11.008 ↗
46. Improvement in biocompatibility of ZrO2-Al2O3 nano-composite by addition of HA10.1016/j.biomaterials.2004.02.061 ↗
47. Synthetic peptide-coated bone mineral for enhanced osteoblastic activation in vitro and in vivo10.1002/jbm.a.31721 ↗
48. Osteoblastic cell behaviour on different titanium implant surfaces10.1016/j.actbio.2007.12.002 ↗
49. High surface energy enhances cell response to titanium substrate microstructure10.1002/jbm.a.30320 ↗
50. Control of in vitro tissue-engineered bone-like structures using human mesenchymal stem cells and porous silk scaffolds10.1016/j.biomaterials.2006.10.019 ↗
51. Bone morphogenetic protein-2 decorated silk fibroin films induce osteogenic differentiation of human bone marrow stromal cells10.1002/jbm.a.30186 ↗
52. Porous silk fibroin 3-D scaffolds for delivery of bone morphogenetic protein-2 in vitro and in vivo10.1002/jbm.a.30728 ↗
53. Mesenchymal stem cell ingrowth and differentiation on coralline hydroxyapatite scaffolds10.1016/j.biomaterials.2006.10.003 ↗
54. In vitro evaluation of chitosan/poly (lactic acid-glycolic acid) sintered microsphere scaffolds for bone tissue engineering10.1016/j.biomaterials.2006.05.025 ↗
55. In vitro and in vivo evaluation of differentially demineralized cancellous bone scaffolds combined with human bone marrow stromal cells for tissue engineering10.1016/j.biomaterials.2004.08.020 ↗
56. Osteogenic differentiation of mesenchymal stem cells in biodegradable sponges composed of gelatin and β-tricalcium phosphate10.1016/j.biomaterials.2004.09.046 ↗
57. In vitro cytocompatibility of MG63 cells on chitosan-organosiloxane hybrid membranes10.1016/j.biomaterials.2004.02.056 ↗
58. Novel hydroxyapatite/chitosan bilayered scaffold for osteochondral tissue-engineering applications: Scaffold design and its performance when seeded with goat bone marrow stromal cells10.1016/j.biomaterials.2006.07.034 ↗
59. Human osteoblast response to pulsed laser deposited calcium phosphate coatings10.1016/j.biomaterials.2004.07.057 ↗
60. Poly-ε-caprolactone/hydroxyapatite composites for bone regeneration: In vitro characterization and human osteoblast response10.1002/jbm.a.30528 ↗
61. Enhanced osteoinduction by controlled release of bone morphogenetic protein-2 from biodegradable sponge composed of gelatin and β-tricalcium phosphate10.1016/j.biomaterials.2005.01.012 ↗
62. Macroporous biphasic calcium phosphate ceramics: Influence of macropore diameter and macroporosity percentage on bone ingrowth10.1016/S0142-9612(97)00180-4 ↗
63. Osteoinduction by biomaterials—Physicochemical and structural influences10.1002/jbm.a.30712 ↗
64. Comparative in vivo study of six hydroxyapatite-based bone graft substitutes10.1002/jor.20648 ↗
65. In vivo behavior of calcium phosphate scaffolds with four different pore sizes10.1016/j.biomaterials.2006.05.051 ↗
66. Porosity and pore size of β-tricalcium phosphate scaffold can influence protein production and osteogenic differentiation of human mesenchymal stem cells: An in vitro and in vivo study10.1016/j.actbio.2008.05.017 ↗
67. Viable osteogenic cells are obligatory for tissue-engineered ectopic bone formation in goats10.1089/107632703764664792 ↗
68. Role of scaffold internal structure on in vivo bone formation in macroporous calcium phosphate bioceramics10.1016/j.biomaterials.2006.01.031 ↗
69. Pore size of porous hydroxyapatite as the cell-substratum controls BMP-induced osteogenesis10.1093/oxfordjournals.jbchem.a021589 ↗
70. Geometry of artificial ECM: Sizes of pores controlling phenotype expression in BMP-induced osteogenesis and chondrogenesis10.1080/03008200290001104 ↗
71. 3D microenvironment as essential element for osteoinduction by biomaterials10.1016/j.biomaterials.2004.09.056 ↗
72. Eggli, P.S., Muller, W., and Schenk, R.K. (1988). Porous hydroxyapatite and tricalcium phosphate cylinders with two different pore size ranges implanted in the cancellous bone of rabbits. A comparative histomorphometric and histologic study of bone ingrowth and implant substitution. Clin. Orthop. Relat. Res., 127–138.10.1097/00003086-198807000-00017 ↗
73. Effect of porosity on the osteointegration and bone ingrowth of a weight-bearing nickel-titanium bone graft substitute10.1016/S0142-9612(03)00359-4 ↗
74. The pore size of polycaprolactone scaffolds has limited influence on bone regeneration in an in vivo model
75. Soft and hard tissue response to photocrosslinked poly(propylene fumarate) scaffolds in a rabbit model10.1002/jbm.1268 ↗
76. Effect of surface finish on the osseointegration of laser-treated titanium alloy implants10.1016/j.biomaterials.2003.11.002 ↗
77. Influence of porosity on mechanical properties and in vivo response of Ti6Al4V implants10.1016/j.actbio.2009.11.011 ↗
78. Characterization of CO3Ap-collagen sponges using X-ray high-resolution microtomography10.1016/j.biomaterials.2003.09.071 ↗
79. The effect of mean pore size on cell attachment, proliferation and migration in collagen-glycosaminoglycan scaffolds for bone tissue engineering10.1016/j.biomaterials.2009.09.063 ↗
80. Porosity variation in hydroxyapatite and osteoblast morphology: A scanning electron microscopy study10.1111/j.0022-2720.2004.01354.x ↗
81. Osteoblastic differentiation of cultured rat bone marrow cells on hydroxyapatite with different surface topography10.1016/S0109-5641(03)00024-1 ↗
82. Biological and physico-chemical assessment of hydroxyapatite (HA) with different porosity10.1016/j.bioeng.2007.08.015 ↗
83. Electrospun poly (ε-caprolactone) microfiber and multilayer nanofiber/microfiber scaffolds: Characterization of scaffolds and measurement of cellular infiltration10.1021/bm060680j ↗
84. Preparation and analysis of macroporous TiO2 films on Ti surfaces for bone-tissue implants10.1002/1097-4636(20011215)57:4<588::AID-JBM1206>3.0.CO;2-Y ↗
85. Microfabricated electrospun collagen membranes for 3-D cancer models and drug screening applications10.1021/bm8012764 ↗
86. Effect of a three-dimensional chitosan porous scaffold on the differentiation of mesenchymal stem cells into chondrocytes10.1159/000231472 ↗
87. Effect of three-dimensional expansion and cell seeding density on the cartilage-forming capacity of human articular chondrocytes in type II collagen sponges10.1002/jbm.a.32917 ↗
88. Influence of platelet-rich plasma on chondrogenic differentiation and proliferation of chondrocytes and mesenchymal stem cells10.1159/000151290 ↗
89. Gelatin-based haemostyptic Spongostan as a possible three-dimensional scaffold for a chondrocyte matrix? An experimental study with bovine chondrocytes10.1302/0301-620X.91B3.20869 ↗
90. A novel concept for scaffold-free vessel tissue engineering: Self-assembly of microtissue building blocks10.1016/j.jbiotec.2010.03.002 ↗
91. Alterations in the content and physiological role of sphingomyelin in plasma membranes of cells cultured in three-dimensional matrix10.1007/s11010-010-0420-y ↗
92. Taking cell-matrix adhesions to the third dimension10.1126/science.1064829 ↗
93. Effects of biomimetic surfaces and oxygen tension on redifferentiation of passaged human fibrochondrocytes in 2D and 3D cultures10.1016/j.biomaterials.2011.04.033 ↗
94. Three-dimensional microstructured tissue scaffolds fabricated by two-photon laser scanning photolithography10.1016/j.biomaterials.2010.06.029 ↗
95. Agar-gelatin hybrid sponge-induced three-dimensional in vitro ‘liver-like’ HepG2 spheroids for the evaluation of drug cytotoxicity10.1002/term.172 ↗
96. Tensile strain induces integrin β1 and ILK expression higher and faster in 3D cultured rat skeletal myoblasts than in 2D cultures10.1016/j.tice.2008.12.007 ↗
97. A scaffold-free multicellular three-dimensional in vitro model of osteogenesis10.1007/s00223-011-9467-3 ↗
98. Effect of biomimetic 3D environment of an injectable polymeric scaffold on MG-63 osteoblastic-cell response10.1016/j.msec.2010.06.005 ↗
99. Extracellular matrix expression of human tenocytes in three-dimensional air-liquid and PLGA cultures compared with tendon tissue: Implications for tendon tissue engineering10.1002/jor.21109 ↗
100. Fetal dermal fibroblasts exhibit enhanced growth and collagen production in two- and three-dimensional culture in comparison to adult fibroblasts10.1002/term.204 ↗