journal article·2025-07-29Open access

On the Interplay Between Roughness and Elastic Modulus at the Nanoscale: A Methodology Study with Bone as Model Material

Alessandro Gambardella, Gregorio Marchiori, Melania Maglio, Marco Boi, Matteo Montesissa, Jessika Bertacchini, Stefano Biressi, Nicola Baldini, Gianluca Giavaresi, Marco Bontempi

Abstract

Atomic force microscopy (AFM)-based nanoindentation enables investigation of the mechanical response of biological materials at a subcellular scale. However, quantitative estimates of mechanical parameters such as the elastic modulus (E) remain unreliable because the influence of sample roughness on E measurements at the nanoscale is still poorly understood. This study re-examines the interpretation of roughness from a more rigorous perspective and validates an experimental methodology to extract roughness at each nanoindentation site—i.e., the local roughness γs—with which the corresponding E value can be accurately correlated. Cortical regions of a murine tibia cross-section, characterized by complex nanoscale morphology, were selected as a testbed. Eighty non-overlapping nanoindentations were performed using two different AFM tips, maintaining a maximum penetration depth of 10 nm for each measurement. Our results show a slight decreasing trend of E versus γs (Spearman’s rank correlation coefficient ρ = −0.27187). A total of 90% of the E values are reliable when γs < 10 nm (coefficient of determination R2 > 0.90), although low γs values are associated with significant dispersion around E (γs = 0) = E0 = 1.18 GPa, with variations exceeding 50%. These findings are consistent with a qualitative tip-to-sample contact model that accounts for the pronounced roughness heterogeneity typical of bone topography at the nanoscale.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Force Microscopy Techniques and Applications · Calcium Carbonate Crystallization and Inhibition · Advanced Materials Characterization Techniques

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

Affiliations

Scienze e Tecnologie Chirurgiche, IRCCS Istituto Ortopedico Rizzoli, 40136 Bologna, Italy

Scienze e Tecnologie Biomediche e Nanobiotecnologie, IRCCS Istituto Ortopedico Rizzoli, 40136 Bologna, Italy

Department of Surgery, Medicine, Dentistry and Morphological Sciences with Interest in Transplant, Oncology and Regenerative Medicine, University of Modena and Reggio Emilia, 41125 Modena, Italy

Department of Cellular, Computational and Integrative Biology, University of Trento, 38123 Trento, Italy

Department of Biomedical and Neuromotor Sciences, University of Bologna, 40100 Bologna, Italy

Funding

Ministry of Health · Istituto Ortopedico Rizzoli · Telethon Foundation

References (41)

Show source-provided references
1. Nanomechanics of biomaterials—From cells to shells10.1002/ijch.202000079 ↗
2. Native extracellular matrix probes to target patient- and tissue-specific cell–microenvironment interactions by force spectroscopy10.1039/D3NR01568H ↗
3. All the small things: Nanoscale matrix alterations in aging tissues10.1016/j.ceb.2024.102322 ↗
4. An overview of substrate stiffness guided cellular response and its applications in tissue regeneration
5. Trends in mechanobiology guided tissue engineering and tools to study cell-substrate interactions: A brief review10.1186/s40824-023-00393-8 ↗
6. Wang, L., Tian, L., Zhang, W., Wang, Z., and Liu, X. (2020). Effect of AFM Nanoindentation Loading Rate on the Characterization of Mechanical Properties of Vascular Endothelial Cell. Micromachines, 11.10.3390/mi11060562 ↗
7. Nanoindentation Characteristics of Stem Cells Towards Osteogenic Differentiation in a Nanoscale Vibratory Bioreactor
8. “May the Force Be with You!” Force–Volume Mapping with Atomic Force Microscopy10.1021/acsomega.1c03829 ↗
9. Modeling the influence of roughness on nanoindentation data using finite element analysis
10. Del Alamo, J.C., Meili, R., Alvarez-Gonzalez, B., Alonso-Latorre, B., Bastounis, E., Firtel, R., and Lasheras, J.C. (2013). Three-Dimensional Quantification of Cellular Traction Forces and Mechanosensing of Thin Substrata by Fourier Traction Force Microscopy. PLoS ONE, 8.10.1371/journal.pone.0069850 ↗
11. Mineral and Cross-Linking in Collagen Fibrils: The Mechanical Behavior of Bone Tissue at the Nano-Scale
12. Recent Advances of Nanoparticles on Bone Tissue Engineering and Bone Cells10.1039/D3NA00851G ↗
13. Wan, T., Zhang, M., Jiang, H.-R., Zhang, Y.-C., Zhang, X.-M., Wang, Y.-L., and Zhang, P.-X. (2023). Tissue-Engineered Nanomaterials Play Diverse Roles in Bone Injury Repair. Nanomaterials, 13.10.3390/nano13091449 ↗
14. Bauso, L.V., La Fauci, V., Longo, C., and Calabrese, G. (2024). Bone Tissue Engineering and Nanotechnology: A Promising Combination for Bone Regeneration. Biology, 13.10.3390/biology13040237 ↗
15. Nanofibril-Mediated Fracture Resistance of Bone10.1088/1748-3190/abdd9d ↗
16. Bioinspired Approaches to Toughen Calcium Phosphate-Based Ceramics for Bone Repair10.1016/j.jmbbm.2020.104078 ↗
17. On the Influence of Structural and Chemical Properties on the Elastic Modulus of Woven Bone Under Healing10.3389/fbioe.2024.1476473 ↗
18. Computational Study of Bone Tissue Mechanical Properties Dependence on Nanoscale Morphological Characteristics10.4028/www.scientific.net/AMM.752-753.103 ↗
19. Bone Tissue Response to the Bone-Like Tissue Coating on Titanium10.1007/s11595-015-1126-5 ↗
20. Histological, Histomorphometrical, and Biomechanical Studies of Bone-Implanted Medical Devices: Hard Resin Embedding10.1155/2020/1804630 ↗
21. Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy of Bone Tissue: Bone Quality Assessment in Preclinical and Clinical Applications of Osteoporosis and Fragility Fracture10.1007/s12018-018-9255-y ↗
22. Imaging Fossil Bone Alterations at the Microscale by SR-FTIR Microspectroscopy10.1039/c0ja00250j ↗
23. Bontempi, M., Salamanna, F., Capozza, R., Visani, A., Fini, M., and Gambardella, A. (2022). Nanomechanical Mapping of Hard Tissues by Atomic Force Microscopy: An Application to Cortical Bone. Materials, 15.10.3390/ma15217512 ↗
24. Force Measurements with the Atomic Force Microscope: Technique, Interpretation and Applications10.1016/j.surfrep.2005.08.003 ↗
25. Hertz model or Oliver & Pharr analysis? Tutorial regarding AFM nanoindentation experiments on biological samples10.1088/2053-1591/ab79ce ↗
26. Material anisotropy and elasticity of cortical and trabecular bone in the adult mouse femur via AFM indentation10.1016/j.jmbbm.2019.01.024 ↗
27. Role of Mechanical and Thermal Nonlinearities in Imaging by Atomic Force Microscope10.1016/j.ijmecsci.2017.01.021 ↗
28. Thermal Induced Deflection in Atomic Force Microscopy Cantilevers: Analysis & Solution10.1088/1361-6501/acf061 ↗
29. An Effective Correction Method for AFM Image Distortion due to Hysteresis and Thermal Drift
30. The influence of polymer scaffolds on cellular behaviour of bone marrow derived human mesenchymal stem cells10.3233/CH-2012-1611 ↗
31. Cultivation and spontaneous differentiation of rat bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells on polymeric surfaces10.3233/CH-131698 ↗
32. Toughness and damage susceptibility in human cortical bone is proportional to mechanical inhomogeneity at the osteonal-level10.1016/j.bone.2015.03.020 ↗
33. Alternate soaking enables easy control of mineralized collagen scaffold mechanics from nano- to macro-scale10.1016/j.jmbbm.2020.103863 ↗
34. Osteocytic Osteolysis in PTH-Treated Wild-Type and Rankl−/− Mice Examined by Transmission Electron Microscopy, Atomic Force Microscopy, and Isotope Microscopy10.1369/0022155420961375 ↗
35. Elasticity and Material Anisotropy of Lamellar Cortical Bone in Adult Bovine Tibia Characterized via AFM Nanoindentation10.1016/j.jmbbm.2023.105992 ↗
36. Finite element simulation of the effect of surface roughness on nanoindentation of thin films with spherical indenters10.1016/j.surfcoat.2007.07.038 ↗
37. Modeling Effect of Surface Roughness on Nanoindentation Tests10.1016/j.procir.2013.06.112 ↗
38. Nanoscale Heterogeneity Promotes Energy Dissipation in Bone10.1038/nmat1911 ↗
39. Anisotropy and Inhomogeneity of Permeability and Fibrous Network Response in the Pars Intermedia of the Human Lateral Meniscus10.1016/j.actbio.2021.08.020 ↗
40. Nanoindentation analysis of the micromechanical anisotropy in mouse cortical bone10.1098/rsos.160971 ↗
41. Gregorio, M., Alessandro, G., Melania, M., Marco, B., Marco, B., Matteo, M., Jessika, B., Stefano, B., Nicola, B., and Gianluca, G. (2025, January 6–9). Targeting the Micrometers Scale on The Relation of Bone Crystallinity, Elastic Modulus and Mineral Density. Proceedings of the 30th Congress of the European Society of Biomechanics, Zürich, Switzerland. Available online: https://www.conftool.com/esb2025/index.php/ESB2025_D2_10_Marchiori.pdf?page=downloadPaper&filename=ESB2025_D2_10_Marchiori.pdf&form_id=840.