journal article·2023-08-24Open access

A Comparative Study of HA/DBM Compounds Derived from Bovine and Porcine for Bone Regeneration

Lina Roldan, Catalina Isaza, Juan Ospina, Carolina Montoya, José Domínguez, Santiago Orrego, Santiago Correa

Abstract

This comparative study investigated the tissue regeneration and inflammatory response induced by xenografts comprised of hydroxyapatite (HA) and demineralized bone matrix (DBM) extracted from porcine (P) and bovine (B) sources. First, extraction of HA and DBM was independently conducted, followed by chemical and morphological characterization. Second, mixtures of HA/DBM were prepared in 50/50 and 60/40 concentrations, and the chemical, morphological, and mechanical properties were evaluated. A rat calvarial defect model was used to evaluate the tissue regeneration and inflammatory responses at 3 and 6 months. The commercial allograft DBM Puros® was used as a clinical reference. Different variables related to tissue regeneration were evaluated, including tissue thickness regeneration (%), amount of regenerated bone area (%), and amount of regenerated collagen area (%). The inflammatory response was evaluated by quantifying the blood vessel area. Overall, tissue regeneration from porcine grafts was superior to bovine. After 3 months of implantation, the tissue thickness regeneration in the 50/50P compound and the commercial DBM was significantly higher (~99%) than in the bovine materials (~23%). The 50/50P and DBM produced higher tissue regeneration than the naturally healed controls. Similar trends were observed for the regenerated bone and collagen areas. The blood vessel area was correlated with tissue regeneration in the first 3 months of evaluation. After 6 months of implantation, HA/DBM compounds showed less regenerated collagen than the DBM-only xenografts. In addition, all animal-derived xenografts improved tissue regeneration compared with the naturally healed defects. No clinical complications associated with any implanted compound were noted.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Bone Tissue Engineering Materials · Dental Implant Techniques and Outcomes · Periodontal Regeneration and Treatments

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

Affiliations

Grupo de Investigación en Bioingeniería (GIB), Universidad EAFIT, Medellín 050022, Colombia

Department of Oral Health Sciences, Kornberg School of Dentistry, Temple University, Philadelphia, PA 19122, USA

Centro de Investigación y Desarrollo Cárnico, Industrias de Alimentos Zenú S.A.S., Grupo Nutresa, Medellín 050044, Colombia

Bioengineering Department, College of Engineering, Temple University, Philadelphia, PA 191122, USA

Escuela de Ciencias Aplicadas e Ingeniería, Universidad EAFIT, Medellín 050022, Colombia

Funding

Ministerio de Ciencia, Tecnología e Innovación de Colombia (Minciencias) · Temple University Maurice Kornberg School of Dentistry Start-up · Office of Provost at the Temple University Strategic · Universidad EAFIT

References (78)

Show source-provided references
1. Dimitriou, R., Jones, E., McGonagle, D., and Giannoudis, P.V. (2011). Bone regeneration: Current concepts and future directions. BMC Med., 9.10.1186/1741-7015-9-66 ↗
2. The clinical use of bone graft substitutes in orthopedic surgery in Germany-A 10-years survey from 2008 to 2018 of 1,090,167 surgical interventions10.1002/jbm.b.34911 ↗
3. Methods of reconstruction for bone defect after tumor excision: A review of alternatives
4. Bone Grafts in Trauma and Orthopaedics
5. Management of segmental bone defects
6. An overview of translational research in bone graft biomaterials10.1080/09205063.2022.2127143 ↗
7. Biomineralization of bone tissue: Calcium phosphate-based inorganics in collagen fibrillar organic matrices10.1186/s40824-022-00288-0 ↗
8. Ielo, I., Calabrese, G., De Luca, G., and Conoci, S. (2022). Recent advances in hydroxyapatite-based biocomposites for bone tissue regeneration in orthopedics. Int. J. Mol. Sci., 23.10.3390/ijms23179721 ↗
9. Ochoa, S.L., Lara, W.O., and Beltrán, C.G. (2021). Hydroxyapatite nanoparticles in drug delivery: Physicochemistry and applications. Pharmaceutics, 13.10.3390/pharmaceutics13101642 ↗
10. New bone formation around porous hydroxyapatite wedge implanted in opening wedge high tibial osteotomy in patients with osteoarthritis10.1016/S0142-9612(00)00318-5 ↗
11. Osseous tissue reaction around hydroxyapatite block implanted into proximal metaphysis of tibia of rat with collagen-induced arthritis10.1016/S0142-9612(99)00198-2 ↗
12. Demineralized bone matrix carriers and their clinical applications: An overview10.1111/os.12509 ↗
13. Demineralized bone matrix in bone repair: History and use10.1016/j.addr.2012.06.008 ↗
14. A novel gelatin/chitooligosaccharide/demineralized bone matrix composite scaffold and periosteum-derived mesenchymal stem cells for bone tissue engineering10.1186/s40824-021-00220-y ↗
15. Comparison of the osteogenic potential of osteoselect demineralized bone matrix putty to novabone calcium-phosphosilicate synthetic putty in a cranial defect model10.1097/SCS.0000000000000610 ↗
16. Bone grafts and biomaterials substitutes for bone defect repair: A review10.1016/j.bioactmat.2017.05.007 ↗
17. Comparison of osteogenesis of bovine bone xenografts between true bone ceramics and decalcified bone matrix10.1007/s10856-022-06696-x ↗
18. Demineralized bone matrix and hydroxyapatite/tri-calcium phosphate mixture for bone healing in rats10.1007/s00264-006-0079-x ↗
19. Remineralization of demineralized bone matrix in critical-size cranial defects in rats: A 6-month follow-up study10.1002/jbm.b.33446 ↗
20. A study of the mechanical strength of long bone defects treated with various bone autograft substitutes: An experimental investigation in the rabbit10.1002/jor.1100070416 ↗
21. Guided bone regeneration with collagen membranes and particulate graft materials: A systematic review and meta-analysis10.11607/jomi.5461 ↗
22. Valencia-Llano, C.H., López-Tenorio, D., Saavedra, M., Zapata, P.A., and Grande-Tovar, C.D. (2022). Comparison of two bovine commercial xenografts in the regeneration of critical cranial defects. Molecules, 27.10.3390/molecules27185745 ↗
23. Development of a decellularized porcine bone matrix for potential applications in bone tissue regeneration10.2217/rme-2019-0125 ↗
24. Physicochemical characterization of porcine bone-derived grafting material and comparison with bovine xenografts for dental applications10.5051/jpis.2017.47.6.388 ↗
25. Osteogenesis in Bone Defects in Rats: The Effects of Hydroxyapatite and Demineralized Bone Matrix10.1097/00000441-198912000-00003 ↗
26. Comparative assessment of bovine versus porcine xenograft for augmentation: A randomized prospective cohort study10.11607/prd.6025 ↗
27. Bae, E.B., Kim, H.J., Ahn, J.J., Bae, H.Y., Kim, H.J., and Huh, J.B. (2019). Comparison of Bone Regeneration between Porcine-Derived and Bovine-Derived Xenografts in Rat Calvarial Defects: A Non-Inferiority Study. Materials, 18.10.3390/ma12203412 ↗
28. The Effects of Soft Tissue Removal Methods on Porcine Skeletal Remains
29. A review on bovine hydroxyapatite; Extraction and characterization10.1088/2057-1976/ac414e ↗
30. Characterization and elemental quantification of natural hydroxyapatite produced from cow bone10.1002/ceat.201800636 ↗
31. Flexural and morphological properties of Poly(Methyl Methacrylate)/ hydroxyapatite composites: Effects of planetary ball mill grinding time10.1177/0731684409344899 ↗
32. Comparison of different protocols for demineralization of cortical bone10.1038/s41598-021-86257-4 ↗
33. Assess shear-thinning hydrogels for application as injectable biomaterials10.1021/acsbiomaterials.7b00734 ↗
34. ASTM International (2008). Standard Practice for In-Vitro Environmental Conditioning of Polymer Matrix Composite Materials and Implant Devices, ASTM International.
35. Anesthesia protocol for ear surgery in Wistar rats (animal research)10.1002/ame2.12198 ↗
36. Evaluation of bone regenerative capacity in rats claverial bone defect using platelet rich fibrin with and without beta tri calcium phosphate bone graft material10.1016/j.sdentj.2015.09.003 ↗
37. Alendronate associated with bovine bone graft in bone defect repair: A histomorphometric study
38. Detecting behavioral deficits in rats after traumatic brain injury
39. Biomechanical evaluation of rat skull defects, 1, 3, and 6 months after implantation with osteopromotive substances10.1016/j.jcms.2007.06.004 ↗
40. Tissue preparation and immunostaining of mouse craniofacial tissues and undecalcified bone
41. Comparison of routine decalcification methods with microwave decalcification of bone and teeth10.4103/0973-029X.125204 ↗
42. Bone regeneration potential of stem cells derived from periodontal ligament or gingival tissue sources encapsulated in RGD-modified alginate scaffold
43. Hydroxyapatite calvaria graft repair in experimental diabetes mellitus in rats10.1016/j.jcms.2018.04.016 ↗
44. Autologous micrografts from the palatal mucosa for bone regeneration in calvarial defects in rats: A radiological and histological analysis10.1186/s40729-020-00288-6 ↗
45. Kojima, S., Nakamura, H., Lee, S., Nagata, F., and Kato, K. (2019). Hydroxyapatite formation on self-assembling peptides with differing secondary structures and their selective adsorption for proteins. Int. J. Mol. Sci., 20.10.3390/ijms20184650 ↗
46. Microstructural parameters from X-ray diffraction peak broadening10.1016/j.scriptamat.2004.05.007 ↗
47. X-ray diffraction and infrared spectroscopy analyses on the crystallinity of engineered biological hydroxyapatite for medical application10.1088/1757-899X/79/1/012028 ↗
48. Demineralized bone matrix and calcium-phosphate cement in bone regeneration in rats10.1590/s0102-865020180040000007 ↗
49. Longitudinal in vivo evaluation of bone regeneration by combined measurement of multi-pinhole SPECT and micro-CT for tissue engineering10.1038/srep10238 ↗
50. Regeneration of human bone using different bone substitute biomaterials10.1111/cid.12089 ↗
51. Synthesis and Characterization of Sintered Sr/Fe-Modified Hydroxyapatite Bioceramics for Bone Tissue Engineering Applications10.1021/acsbiomaterials.9b01666 ↗
52. Tihăuan, B.M., Pircalabioru, G.G., Axinie, M., Marina, I.C., Nicoară, A.C., Măru, L., Oprea, O., Matei, E., and Maier, S.S. (2022). Crosslinked collagenic scaffold behavior evaluation by physico-chemical, mechanical and biological assessments in an in vitro microenvironment. Polymers, 14.10.3390/polym14122430 ↗
53. A novel porcine graft for regeneration of bone defects10.3390/ma8052523 ↗
54. Osteogenic effect of low-temperature-heated porcine bone particles in a rat calvarial defect model10.1002/jbm.a.35022 ↗
55. What can infrared spectra tell us about the crystallinity of nanosized interstellar silicate dust grains?10.1021/acsearthspacechem.9b00157 ↗
56. Bioresorbability, porosity and mechanical strength of bone substitutes: What is optimal for bone regeneration?10.1016/j.injury.2011.06.008 ↗
57. Elastic proteins and elastomeric protein alloys10.1016/j.copbio.2015.12.020 ↗
58. Yang, B.-C., Lee, J.-W., Ju, C.-P., and Lin, J.-H.C. (2020). Physical/chemical properties and resorption substitute material. Materials, 13.10.3390/ma13163458 ↗
59. Fernandez de Grado, G., Keller, L., Idoux-Gillet, Y., Wagner, Q., Musset, A.M., Benkirane-Jessel, N., Bornert, F., and Offner, D. (2018). Bone substitutes: A review of their characteristics, clinical use, and perspectives for large bone defects management. J. Tissue Eng., 9.10.1177/2041731418776819 ↗
60. Walsh, W.R., Oliver, R.A., Christou, C., Lovric, V., Walsh, E.R., Prado, G.R., and Haider, T. (2017). Critical size bone defect healing using collagen-calcium phosphate bone graft materials. PLoS ONE, 12.10.1371/journal.pone.0168883 ↗
61. DFT calculated IR spectrum amide I, II, and III band contributions of N-methylacetamide fine components10.1021/acsomega.9b04421 ↗
62. A novel lamellar structural biomaterial and its effect on bone regeneration10.1039/D0RA05760F ↗
63. Bone vascularization in normal and disease conditions10.3389/fendo.2013.00106 ↗
64. Vascular consequences of inflammation: A position statement from the ESH working group on vascular structure and function and the artery society10.1097/HJH.0000000000002508 ↗
65. Spatiotemporal blood vessel specification at the osteogenesis and angiogenesis interface of biomimetic nanofiber-enabled bone tissue engineering10.1016/j.biomaterials.2021.121041 ↗
66. Prevention of fracture healing in rats by an inhibitor of angiogenesis10.1016/S8756-3282(01)00608-1 ↗
67. Histomorphometric study ischemia leads to delayed union during fracture healing: A mouse model10.1002/jor.20264 ↗
68. Dual delivery of an angiogenic and an osteogenic growth factor for bone regeneration in a critical size defect model10.1016/j.bone.2008.06.019 ↗
69. A systems biology view of blood vessel growth and remodelling10.1111/jcmm.12164 ↗
70. Macrophage polarization plays roles in bone formation instructed by calcium phosphate ceramics10.1039/C9TB02932J ↗
71. The available evidence on demineralised bone matrix in trauma and orthopaedic surgery: A systematic review10.1302/2046-3758.67.BJR-2017-0027.R1 ↗
72. Injectable demineralized bone matrix particles and their hydrogel bone grafts loaded with β-tricalcium phosphate powder and granules: A comparative study10.1016/j.mtbio.2022.100422 ↗
73. Unique coexpression in osteoblasts of broadly expressed genes accounts for the spatial restriction of ECM mineralization to bone10.1101/gad.1276205 ↗
74. Marger, L., Liaudet, N., Scherrer, S.S., Brembilla, N.C., Preynat-Seauve, O., Manoil, D., Mekki, M., and Durual, S. (2022). Identification of type-h-like blood vessels in a dynamic and controlled model of osteogenesis in rabbit calvarium. Materials, 15.10.3390/ma15134703 ↗
75. The biology of fracture healing10.1016/j.injury.2011.03.031 ↗
76. Biological perspectives of delayed fracture healing10.1016/j.injury.2014.04.003 ↗
77. Methods for bone quality assessment in human bone tissue: A systematic review10.1186/s13018-022-03041-4 ↗
78. Bilateral double site (calvarial and mandibular) critical-size bone defect model in rabbits for evaluation of a craniofacial tissue engineering constructs10.1016/j.mtbio.2022.100267 ↗