journal article·2024-07-29Open access

The Evaluation of the Trueness of Dental Mastercasts Obtained through Different 3D Printing Technologies

Lucian Toma Ciocan, Vlad Gabriel Vasilescu, Mihaela Pantea, Silviu Mirel Pițuru, Marina Imre, Alexandra Ripszky Totan, Florin Octavian Froimovici

Abstract

In contemporary dentistry, several 3D printing techniques, including a stereolithography apparatus (SLA), digital light processing (DLP), liquid crystal display (LCD), and PolyJet 3D inkjet printing technology (PolyJet), are employed for model production. Despite their widespread use, there remains a paucity of the literature regarding the trueness and precision of these devices in dental applications. Existing studies comparing the accuracy of dental models manufactured by different printing technologies yield disparate conclusions regarding dental prosthesis manufacturing. This study aimed to test two null hypotheses: first, that the trueness of various new-generation 3D printers is equivalent, and second, that the trueness of printing by these printers is sufficient for achieving high-precision mastercasts in dental prosthodontics manufacturing. The research focuses on evaluating the trueness of five contemporary dental 3D printers: Anycubic Mono X 6Ks (Hongkong Anycubic Technology Co., Hongkong, China), Asiga Max (Asiga, Sydney, Australia), Creo C5 (Planmeca Oy, Helsinki, Finland), Form 3B (Formlabs, Boston, MA, USA), and J5 Dentajet (Stratasys Ltd., Eden Prairie, MN, USA). The methodology employed involved the creation of a digital test object using Blender software, adhering meticulously to the dimensions outlined in ISO standard 20896-1. These dimensions were chosen to be both relevant for this study and representative of clinical scenarios. Subsequently, the test object was printed and precise measurements were conducted utilizing a metrology-type Nikon XTH225 ST Reflection target in conjunction with VGStudio MAX analysis software. The results of our investigation revealed clinically negligible deviations in ball dimensions across all printers, with the maximum observed deviations ranging between 1.17% and 2.03% (notably observed in the Creo C5 printer). Transversal distortion exhibited variance based on the linear accuracy of each printer, with Stratasys21 and Formlabs 3B demonstrating superior accuracy among the evaluated printers. Distortions in the analyzed dimensions (specifically, anterior b–c, posterior a–d, and oblique a–c) were found to be uniform. In conclusion, while the first null hypothesis was rejected, indicating variations in trueness among the 3D printers assessed, our findings affirm the suitability of all five analyzed 3D printers for clinical applications. Consequently, these printers can be utilized for the fabrication of high-precision mastercasts in dental prosthodontics manufacturing.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Dental materials and restorations · Dental Research and COVID-19 · Digital Imaging in Medicine

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

Affiliations

Discipline of Dental Prosthetics Technology, Faculty of Dentistry, “Carol Davila” University of Medicine and Pharmacy, Dionisie Lupu Street, No. 37, District 2, 020021 Bucharest, Romania

Discipline of Prosthodontics, Faculty of Dentistry, “Carol Davila” University of Medicine and Pharmacy, 37 Dionisie Lupu Street, District 2, 020021 Bucharest, Romania

Discipline of Organization, Professional Legislation and Dental Office Management, “Carol Davila” University of Medicine and Pharmacy, Dionisie Lupu Street, No. 37, District 2, 020021 Bucharest, Romania

Department of Biochemistry, Faculty of Dentistry, “Carol Davila” University of Medicine and Pharmacy, Dionisie Lupu Street, No. 37, District 2, 020021 Bucharest, Romania

References (52)

Show source-provided references
1. Kim, J., Pinhata-Baptista, O., Ayres, A., da Silva, R., Lima, J., Urbano, G., No-Cortes, J., Vasques, M., and Cortes, A. (2022). Accuracy Comparison among 3D-Printing Technologies to Produce Dental Models. Appl. Sci., 12.10.3390/app12178425 ↗
2. (2023). Accuracy (Trueness and Precision) of Measurement Methods and Results. Part 1: General Principles and Definitions (Standard No. ISO 5725-1:2023(en)).
3. Masri, R., and Driscoll, C.F. (2023). Clinical Applications of Digital Dental Technology, Wiley. [2nd ed.].10.1002/9781119800613 ↗
4. Accuracy, trueness, and precision—A guideline for the evaluation of these basic values in digital dentistry
5. Al-Hassiny, A. (2024, February 26). iDD Compares: Medit i700 W vs. 3Shape TRIOS 5. Available online: https://instituteofdigitaldentistry.com/idd-compares/idd-compares-medit-i700-w-vs-3shape-trios-5/.
6. Accuracy of 3D Printed Implant Casts Versus Stone Casts: A Comparative Study in the Anterior Maxilla10.1111/jopr.13335 ↗
7. Etemad-Shahidi, Y., Qallandar, O.B., Evenden, J., Alifui-Segbaya, F., and Ahmed, K.E. (2020). Accuracy of 3-Dimensionally Printed Full-Arch Dental Models: A Systematic Review. J. Clin. Med., 9.10.3390/jcm9103357 ↗
8. Three-dimensional printing technology
9. Accuracy of commercial 3D printers for the fabrication of surgical guides in dental implantology10.1016/j.jdent.2021.103909 ↗
10. In vitro accuracies of 3D printed models manufactured by two different printing technologies
11. Moon, W., Kim, S., Lim, B.S., Park, Y.S., Kim, R.J., and Chung, S.H. (2021). Dimensional Accuracy Evaluation of Temporary Dental Restorations with Different 3D Printing Systems. Materials, 14.10.3390/ma14061487 ↗
12. Czajkowska, M., Walejewska, E., Zadrozny, L., Wieczorek, M., Swieszkowski, W., Wagner, L., Mijiritsky, E., and Markowski, J. (2020). Comparison of Dental Stone Models and Their 3D Printed Acrylic Replicas for the Accuracy and Mechanical Properties. Materials, 13.10.3390/ma13184066 ↗
13. Accuracy of five different 3D printing workflows for dental models comparing industrial and dental desktop printers
14. In vivo trueness and precision of full-arch implant scans using intraoral scanners with three different acquisition protocols10.1016/j.jdent.2022.104308 ↗
15. Trueness of full-arch dental models obtained by digital and conventional impression techniques: An in vivo study10.1038/s41598-022-26983-5 ↗
16. Development of 3D Model and Display on Web Using Open-Source Technology10.32628/IJSRST202114 ↗
17. Dentistry, Digital Impression Devices, Part 1: Methods for Assessing Accuracy (Standard No. ISO 20896-1:2019). Available online: https://www.iso.org/standard/69402.html.
18. Hongkong Anycubic Technology Co. (2024, February 28). Anycubic Photon Mono X 6Ks. Available online: https://store.anycubic.com/products/photon-mono-x-6ks.
19. Formlabs Inc. (2024, February 28). User Manual Form 3B. Available online: https://media.formlabs.com/m/1aa00d88fe52d5bc/original/-ENUS-Form-3B-Manual.pdf.
20. Asiga Pty Ltd. (2024, February 28). Max User Guide. Available online: https://myaccount.asiga.com/accounts/resources/MAX/1%20-%20Quick%20Start%20Guide/MAX%20User%20Guide%2020220211.pdf.
21. Planmeca Oy. (2023, July 26). Planmeca Creo C5—The ultimate dental 3D printer. Available online: https://www.planmeca.com/cadcam/3d-printing/3d-printer/.
22. Stratasys (2024, February 28). J5 DentaJet. Available online: https://www.stratasys.com/en/3d-printers/printer-catalog/polyjet/j5-dentajet/.
23. Asiga Pty Ltd. (2024, February 28). Instructions For Use—DentaMODEL, 9 ed. Available online: https://myaccount.asiga.com/media/public/Materials/Asiga-DentaMODEL-IFU-en.pdf.
24. Bártolo, P.J. (2011). Stereolithography, Springer.10.1007/978-0-387-92904-0 ↗
25. 3D printing processes for photocurable polymeric materials: Technologies, materials, and future trends
26. (2015). Additive Manufacturing—General Principles. Part 2: Overview of Process Categories and Feedstock (Standard No. ISO 17296-2:2015(en)).
27. Current status and applications of additive manufacturing in dentistry: A literature-based review10.1016/j.jobcr.2019.04.004 ↗
28. A review on chemical composition, mechanical properties, and manufacturing work flow of additively manufactured current polymers for interim dental restorations10.1111/jerd.12438 ↗
29. Digital tools and 3D printing technologies integrated into the workflow of restorative treatment: A clinical report10.1016/j.prosdent.2018.02.020 ↗
30. Workflow description of additively manufactured clear silicone indexes for injected provisional restorations: A novel technique10.1111/jerd.12464 ↗
31. Rapid Prototyping Technologies and their Applications in Prosthodontics, a Review of Literature
32. A comparison of trueness and precision of 12 3D printers used in dentistry10.1038/s41405-022-00108-6 ↗
33. Effect of print layer height and printer type on the accuracy of 3-dimensional printed orthodontic models10.1016/j.ajodo.2017.06.012 ↗
34. Effect of print layer height on the assessment of 3D-printed models10.1016/j.ajodo.2019.02.013 ↗
35. Digital workflow: In vitro accuracy of 3D printed casts generated from complete-arch digital implant scans10.1016/j.prosdent.2019.10.029 ↗
36. Influence of the three-dimensional printing technique and printing layer thickness on model accuracy10.1007/s00056-019-00180-y ↗
37. Accuracy and reproducibility of dental replica models reconstructed by different rapid prototyping techniques10.1016/j.ajodo.2013.05.011 ↗
38. Comparison of reconstructed rapid prototyping models produced by 3-dimensional printing and conventional stone models with different degrees of crowding10.1016/j.ajodo.2016.08.019 ↗
39. Accuracy of 3D Printed Models Created by Two Technologies of Printers with Different Designs of Model Base10.1111/jopr.13107 ↗
40. Additive Manufacturing Technologies Used for Processing Polymers: Current Status and Potential Application in Prosthetic Dentistry10.1111/jopr.12801 ↗
41. Desimone, J.M., Er-Moshkin, A., and Samulski, E. (2024, February 28). Continuous Liquid Interphase Printing. Available online: https://patents.google.com/patent/WO2014126837A2/en.
42. Influence of the Rinsing Postprocessing Procedures on the Manufacturing Accuracy of Vat-Polymerized Dental Model Material10.1111/jopr.13288 ↗
43. 3D printing of porous structures by UV-curable O/W emulsion for fabrication of conductive objects10.1039/C4TC02215G ↗
44. Phrozen Tech Co. (2024, February 28). Water-Washable Dental Model Resin. Available online: https://dental.phrozen3d.com/pages/dental-resin.
45. Acrylic Nanocomposite Resins for Use in Stereolithography and Structural Light Modulation Based Rapid Prototyping and Rapid Manufacturing Technologies10.1002/adfm.200800344 ↗
46. Nanotailoring photocrosslinkable epoxy resins with multi-walled carbon nanotubes for stereolithography layered manufacturing10.1007/s10853-006-1035-2 ↗
47. 3D printing parameters, supporting structures, slicing, and post-processing procedures of vat-polymerization additive manufacturing technologies: A narrative review10.1016/j.jdent.2021.103630 ↗
48. Influence of postpolymerization methods and artificial aging procedures on the fracture resistance and flexural strength of a vat-polymerized interim dental material10.1016/j.prosdent.2021.02.017 ↗
49. 3D-printed material for temporary restorations: Impact of print layer thickness and post-curing method on degree of conversion
50. Arnold, C., Monsees, D., Hey, J., and Schweyen, R. (2019). Surface Quality of 3D-Printed Models as a Function of Various Printing Parameters. Materials, 12.10.3390/ma12121970 ↗
51. Park, G.S., Kim, S.K., Heo, S.J., Koak, J.Y., and Seo, D.G. (2019). Effects of Printing Parameters on the Fit of Implant-Supported 3D Printing Resin Prosthetics. Materials, 12.10.3390/ma12162533 ↗
52. Influence of layer thickness on mechanical properties in stereolithography10.1108/13552540610652456 ↗