journal article·2023-01-29Open access

Three-Dimensional Impression of Biomaterials for Alveolar Graft: Scoping Review

Inês Francisco, Ângela Basílio, Madalena Prata Ribeiro, Catarina Nunes, Raquel Travassos, Filipa Marques, Flávia Pereira, Anabela Baptista Paula, Eunice Carrilho, Carlos Miguel Marto, Francisco Vale

Abstract

Craniofacial bone defects are one of the biggest clinical challenges in regenerative medicine, with secondary autologous bone grafting being the gold-standard technique. The development of new three-dimensional matrices intends to overcome the disadvantages of the gold-standard method. The aim of this paper is to put forth an in-depth review regarding the clinical efficiency of available 3D printed biomaterials for the correction of alveolar bone defects. A survey was carried out using the following databases: PubMed via Medline, Cochrane Library, Scopus, Web of Science, EMBASE, and gray literature. The inclusion criteria applied were the following: in vitro, in vivo, ex vivo, and clinical studies; and studies that assessed bone regeneration resorting to 3D printed biomaterials. The risk of bias of the in vitro and in vivo studies was performed using the guidelines for the reporting of pre-clinical studies on dental materials by Faggion Jr and the SYRCLE risk of bias tool, respectively. In total, 92 publications were included in the final sample. The most reported three-dimensional biomaterials were the PCL matrix, β-TCP matrix, and hydroxyapatite matrix. These biomaterials can be combined with different polymers and bioactive molecules such as rBMP-2. Most of the included studies had a high risk of bias. Despite the advances in the research on new three-dimensionally printed biomaterials in bone regeneration, the existing results are not sufficient to justify the application of these biomaterials in routine clinical practice.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Bone Tissue Engineering Materials · Dental Implant Techniques and Outcomes · Periodontal Regeneration and Treatments

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

Affiliations

Institute of Orthodontics, Faculty of Medicine, University of Coimbra, 3000-075 Coimbra, Portugal

Coimbra Institute for Clinical and Biomedical Research (ICBR), Area of Environment Genetics and Oncobiology (CIMAGO), Faculty of Medicine, University of Coimbra, 3000-075 Coimbra, Portugal

Laboratory for Evidence-Based Sciences and Precision Dentistry, University of Coimbra, 3000-075 Coimbra, Portugal

Centre for Innovative Biomedicine and Biotechnology (CIBB), University of Coimbra, 3000-075 Coimbra, Portugal

Clinical Academic Center of Coimbra (CACC), 3030-370 Coimbra, Portugal

Institute of Integrated Clinical Practice, Faculty of Medicine, University of Coimbra, 3004-531 Coimbra, Portugal

Institute of Experimental Pathology, Faculty of Medicine, University of Coimbra, 3004-531 Coimbra, Portugal

References (100+)

Show source-provided references
1. Cell Sources for Bone Regeneration: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly (But Promising)10.1089/ten.teb.2011.0199 ↗
2. Concise Review: Personalized Human Bone Grafts for Reconstructing Head and Face10.5966/sctm.2011-0020 ↗
3. Culture Human Mesenchymal Stem Cells with Calcium Phosphate Cement Scaffolds for Bone Repair10.1002/jbm.b.31563 ↗
4. Concise Review: Induced Pluripotent Stem Cells and Lineage Reprogramming: Prospects for Bone Regeneration10.1002/stem.611 ↗
5. Bone Repair Cells for Craniofacial Regeneration10.1016/j.addr.2012.03.005 ↗
6. Integration of a Novel Injectable Nano Calcium Sulfate/Alginate Scaffold and BMP2 Gene-Modified Mesenchymal Stem Cells for Bone Regeneration10.1089/ten.tea.2012.0244 ↗
7. Alveolar Osseous Defect in Rat for Cell Therapy: Preliminary Report10.1590/S0102-86502010000400002 ↗
8. Bone Regeneration in Artificial Jaw Cleft by Use of Carbonated Hydroxyapatite Particles and Mesenchymal Stem Cells Derived from Iliac Bone10.1155/2012/352510 ↗
9. Environmental Mechanisms of Orofacial Clefts10.1002/bdr2.1830 ↗
10. Epidemiology of Cleft Palate in Europe: Implications for Genetic Research10.1597/02-074.1 ↗
11. Cleft Lip and Palate: Diagnosis and Management10.12968/hmed.2015.76.10.584 ↗
12. The Team Approach in the Management of Congenital and Acquired Deformities10.1016/S0094-1298(20)32442-1 ↗
13. Francisco, I.N. (2021). Overview of Care in Cleft Lip and Palate for Orthodontic Treatment. [Ph.D. Thesis, Universidade do Porto].
14. Graber, L., Vanarsdall, R.L., and Vig, K.W.L. (2005). Orthodontics Current Principles & Techniques, Elsevier Mosby. [4th ed.].
15. Secondary Alveolar Bone Grafting: The Dilemma of Donor Site Selection and Morbidity10.1016/j.bjoms.2008.07.184 ↗
16. Francisco, I., Fernandes, M.H., and Vale, F. (2020). Platelet-Rich Fibrin in Bone Regenerative Strategies in Orthodontics: A Systematic Review. Materials, 13.10.3390/ma13081866 ↗
17. Reconstruction of Craniofacial Bony Defects Using Autogenous Bone Grafts: A Retrospective Study on 233 Patients10.1097/scs.0b013e3180690123 ↗
18. Cleft Alveolus Reconstruction Using a Three-Dimensional Printed Bioresorbable Scaffold with Human Bone Marrow Cells10.1097/SCS.0000000000004747 ↗
19. Tissue-Engineered Bone Grafts for Osteoplasty in Patients with Cleft Alveolus10.1016/j.aanat.2012.06.002 ↗
20. Is PRP Useful in Alveolar Cleft Reconstruction? Platelet-Rich Plasma in Secondary Alveoloplasty
21. Dental Pulp Stem Cells for in Vivo Bone Regeneration: A Systematic Review of Literature10.1016/j.archoralbio.2013.08.011 ↗
22. Zumarán, C., Parra, M., Olate, S., Fernández, E., Muñoz, F., and Haidar, Z. (2018). The 3 R’s for Platelet-Rich Fibrin: A “Super” Tri-Dimensional Biomaterial for Contemporary Naturally-Guided Oro-Maxillo-Facial Soft and Hard Tissue Repair, Reconstruction and Regeneration. Materials, 11.10.3390/ma11081293 ↗
23. Fresh-Frozen Homologous Bone in Sinus Lifting: Histological and Radiological Analysis10.23736/S0026-4970.19.04192-X ↗
24. Chisci, G., and Fredianelli, L. (2022). Therapeutic Efficacy of Bromelain in Alveolar Ridge Preservation. Antibiotics, 11.10.3390/antibiotics11111542 ↗
25. Grafting Materials for Alveolar Cleft Reconstruction: A Systematic Review and Best-Evidence Synthesis10.1016/j.ijom.2017.08.003 ↗
26. Francisco, I., Paula, A.B., Oliveiros, B., Fernandes, M.H., Carrilho, E., Marto, C.M., and Vale, F. (2021). Regenerative Strategies in Cleft Palate: An Umbrella Review. Bioengineering, 8.10.3390/bioengineering8060076 ↗
27. Biomaterials for Craniofacial Bone Regeneration10.1016/j.cden.2017.06.003 ↗
28. Three-Dimensional (3D) Printed Scaffold and Material Selection for Bone Repair10.1016/j.actbio.2018.11.039 ↗
29. Three-Dimensional Printing of Porous Ceramic Scaffolds for Bone Tissue Engineering10.1002/jbm.b.30291 ↗
30. Guidelines for Reporting Pre-Clinical In Vitro Studies on Dental Materials10.1016/j.jebdp.2012.10.001 ↗
31. Hydrogel-β-TCP Scaffolds and Stem Cells for Tissue Engineering Bone10.1016/j.bone.2005.10.016 ↗
32. 3D Printing Technology to Control BMP-2 and VEGF Delivery Spatially and Temporally to Promote Large-Volume Bone Regeneration10.1039/C5TB00637F ↗
33. Nanotube-Decorated Hierarchical Tantalum Scaffold Promoted Early Osseointegration10.1016/j.nano.2021.102390 ↗
34. In Vitro Comparison of 3D Printed Polylactic Acid/Hydroxyapatite and Polylactic Acid/Bioglass Composite Scaffolds: Insights into Materials for Bone Regeneration10.1016/j.jmbbm.2020.103641 ↗
35. Efficacy of RhBMP-2 Loaded PCL/β -TCP/BdECM Scaffold Fabricated by 3D Printing Technology on Bone Regeneration10.1155/2018/2876135 ↗
36. 3D Printed β-TCP Scaffold with Sphingosine 1-Phosphate Coating Promotes Osteogenesis and Inhibits Inflammation10.1016/j.bbrc.2019.03.132 ↗
37. Osteogenic and Angiogenic Potentials of the Cell-Laden Hydrogel/Mussel-Inspired Calcium Silicate Complex Hierarchical Porous Scaffold Fabricated by 3D Bioprinting10.1016/j.msec.2018.06.005 ↗
38. Chiu, Y.-C., Shie, M.-Y., Lin, Y.-H., Lee, A.K.-X., and Chen, Y.-W. (2019). Effect of Strontium Substitution on the Physicochemical Properties and Bone Regeneration Potential of 3D Printed Calcium Silicate Scaffolds. IJMS, 20.10.3390/ijms20112729 ↗
39. 3D Printed Polyurethane Scaffolds for the Repair of Bone Defects10.3389/fbioe.2020.557215 ↗
40. 3D Printing of Cu-Doped Bioactive Glass Composite Scaffolds Promotes Bone Regeneration through Activating the HIF-1α and TNF-α Pathway of HUVECs10.1039/D1BM00870F ↗
41. Extracellular Matrix/Amorphous Magnesium Phosphate Bioink for 3D Bioprinting of Craniomaxillofacial Bone Tissue10.1021/acsami.0c05311 ↗
42. Enhancing Cell Seeding and Osteogenesis of MSCs on 3D Printed Scaffolds through Injectable BMP2 Immobilized ECM-Mimetic Gel10.1016/j.dental.2019.04.004 ↗
43. The Effect of Biomimetic Mineralization of 3D-Printed Mesoporous Bioglass Scaffolds on Physical Properties and in Vitro Osteogenicity10.1016/j.msec.2019.110572 ↗
44. 3D Magnetic Nanocomposite Scaffolds Enhanced the Osteogenic Capacities of Rat Bone Mesenchymal Stem Cells in Vitro and in a Rat Calvarial Bone Defect Model by Promoting Cell Adhesion10.1002/jbm.a.37162 ↗
45. Huang, K.-H., Wang, C.-Y., Chen, C.-Y., Hsu, T.-T., and Lin, C.-P. (2021). Incorporation of Calcium Sulfate Dihydrate into a Mesoporous Calcium Silicate/Poly-ε-Caprolactone Scaffold to Regulate the Release of Bone Morphogenetic Protein-2 and Accelerate Bone Regeneration. Biomedicines, 9.10.3390/biomedicines9020128 ↗
46. 3D Printing of Bone-Mimetic Scaffold Composed of Gelatin/Β-Tri-Calcium Phosphate for Bone Tissue Engineering10.1002/mabi.202000256 ↗
47. Poly(Dopamine) Coating of 3D Printed Poly(Lactic Acid) Scaffolds for Bone Tissue Engineering10.1016/j.msec.2015.06.028 ↗
48. Effects of MgO, ZnO, SrO, and SiO2 in Tricalcium Phosphate Scaffolds on in Vitro Gene Expression and in Vivo Osteogenesis10.1016/j.msec.2018.10.073 ↗
49. Incorporation of BMP-2 Nanoparticles on the Surface of a 3D-Printed Hydroxyapatite Scaffold Using an ε-Polycaprolactone Polymer Emulsion Coating Method for Bone Tissue Engineering10.1016/j.colsurfb.2018.06.043 ↗
50. Magnesium Phosphate Ceramics Incorporating a Novel Indene Compound Promote Osteoblast Differentiation in Vitro and Bone Regeneration in Vivo10.1016/j.biomaterials.2017.11.032 ↗
51. Development of a Three-Dimensionally Printed Scaffold Grafted with Bone Forming Peptide-1 for Enhanced Bone Regeneration with in Vitro and in Vivo Evaluations10.1016/j.jcis.2018.12.097 ↗
52. Li, J., Chen, M., Wei, X., Hao, Y., and Wang, J. (2017). Evaluation of 3D-Printed Polycaprolactone Scaffolds Coated with Freeze-Dried Platelet-Rich Plasma for Bone Regeneration. Materials, 10.10.3390/ma10070831 ↗
53. An Effective Dual-factor Modified 3D-printed PCL Scaffold for Bone Defect Repair10.1002/jbm.b.34555 ↗
54. Combination of Polyetherketoneketone Scaffold and Human Mesenchymal Stem Cells from Temporomandibular Joint Synovial Fluid Enhances Bone Regeneration10.1038/s41598-018-36778-2 ↗
55. Bioactive Calcium Silicate/Poly-ε-Caprolactone Composite Scaffolds 3D Printed under Mild Conditions for Bone Tissue Engineering10.1007/s10856-017-6020-6 ↗
56. The Synergistic Effects of Graphene-Contained 3D-Printed Calcium Silicate/Poly-ε-Caprolactone Scaffolds Promote FGFR-Induced Osteogenic/Angiogenic Differentiation of Mesenchymal Stem Cells10.1016/j.msec.2019.109887 ↗
57. Engineering a Multifunctional 3D-Printed PLA-Collagen-Minocycline-NanoHydroxyapatite Scaffold with Combined Antimicrobial and Osteogenic Effects for Bone Regeneration10.1016/j.msec.2019.03.056 ↗
58. 3D Printing of Ti3C2-MXene-Incorporated Composite Scaffolds for Accelerated Bone Regeneration10.1088/1748-605X/ac5ffe ↗
59. Engineering Natural Matrices with Black Phosphorus Nanosheets to Generate Multi-Functional Therapeutic Nanocomposite Hydrogels10.1039/C9BM01072F ↗
60. Silk Fibroin-Bioactive Glass Based Advanced Biomaterials: Towards Patient-Specific Bone Grafts10.1088/1748-605X/aad2a9 ↗
61. MicroRNA-Activated Hydrogel Scaffold Generated by 3D Printing Accelerates Bone Regeneration10.1016/j.bioactmat.2021.08.034 ↗
62. Three-dimensionally Printed Polycaprolactone/Beta-tricalcium Phosphate Scaffold Was More Effective as an rhBMP-2 Carrier for New Bone Formation than Polycaprolactone Alone10.1002/jbm.a.37075 ↗
63. Effect of Dual Pore Size Architecture on In Vitro Osteogenic Differentiation in Additively Manufactured Hierarchical Scaffolds10.1021/acsbiomaterials.0c01719 ↗
64. Rat Calvarial Bone Regeneration by 3D-Printed β-Tricalcium Phosphate Incorporating MicroRNA-200c10.1021/acsbiomaterials.0c01756 ↗
65. Addition of MgO Nanoparticles and Plasma Surface Treatment of Three-Dimensional Printed Polycaprolactone/Hydroxyapatite Scaffolds for Improving Bone Regeneration10.1016/j.msec.2016.12.054 ↗
66. Shim, J.-H., Won, J.-Y., Park, J.-H., Bae, J.-H., Ahn, G., Kim, C.-H., Lim, D.-H., Cho, D.-W., Yun, W.-S., and Bae, E.-B. (2017). Effects of 3D-Printed Polycaprolactone/β-Tricalcium Phosphate Membranes on Guided Bone Regeneration. IJMS, 18.10.3390/ijms18050899 ↗
67. Accelerated Degradation of HAP/PLLA Bone Scaffold by PGA Blending Facilitates Bioactivity and Osteoconductivity10.1016/j.bioactmat.2020.09.001 ↗
68. Osseointegration of Porous Apatite-Wollastonite and Poly(Lactic Acid) Composite Structures Created Using 3D Printing Techniques10.1016/j.msec.2018.04.022 ↗
69. Tsai, C.-H., Hung, C.-H., Kuo, C.-N., Chen, C.-Y., Peng, Y.-N., and Shie, M.-Y. (2019). Improved Bioactivity of 3D Printed Porous Titanium Alloy Scaffold with Chitosan/Magnesium-Calcium Silicate Composite for Orthopaedic Applications. Materials, 12.10.3390/ma12020203 ↗
70. Optimization of Culture Duration of Bone Marrow Cells before Transplantation with a β-Tricalcium Phosphate/Recombinant Collagen Peptide Hybrid Scaffold10.1016/j.reth.2020.04.005 ↗
71. Simultaneously Constructing Nanotopographical and Chemical Cues in 3D-Printed Polylactic Acid Scaffolds to Promote Bone Regeneration10.1016/j.msec.2020.111457 ↗
72. Fabrication and Application of a 3D-Printed Poly-ε-Caprolactone Cage Scaffold for Bone Tissue Engineering
73. Wu, Y.-H., Chiu, Y.-C., Lin, Y.-H., Ho, C.-C., Shie, M.-Y., and Chen, Y.-W. (2019). 3D-Printed Bioactive Calcium Silicate/Poly-ε-Caprolactone Bioscaffolds Modified with Biomimetic Extracellular Matrices for Bone Regeneration. IJMS, 20.10.3390/ijms20040942 ↗
74. Additively Manufactured Pure Zinc Porous Scaffolds for Critical-Sized Bone Defects of Rabbit Femur10.1016/j.bioactmat.2022.03.010 ↗
75. Xu, Z., Wang, N., Liu, P., Sun, Y., Wang, Y., Fei, F., Zhang, S., Zheng, J., and Han, B. (2019). Poly(Dopamine) Coating on 3D-Printed Poly-Lactic-Co-Glycolic Acid/β-Tricalcium Phosphate Scaffolds for Bone Tissue Engineering. Molecules, 24.10.3390/molecules24234397 ↗
76. Preparation and Study of 3D Printed Dipyridamole/β-Tricalcium Phosphate/ Polyvinyl Alcohol Composite Scaffolds in Bone Tissue Engineering10.1016/j.jddst.2021.103053 ↗
77. Yun, S., Choi, D., Choi, D.-J., Jin, S., Yun, W.-S., Huh, J.-B., and Shim, J.-H. (2021). Bone Fracture-Treatment Method: Fixing 3D-Printed Polycaprolactone Scaffolds with Hydrogel Type Bone-Derived Extracellular Matrix and β-Tricalcium Phosphate as an Osteogenic Promoter. IJMS, 22.10.3390/ijms22169084 ↗
78. Increased Osteogenic Potential of Pre-Osteoblasts on Three-Dimensional Printed Scaffolds Compared to Porous Scaffolds for Bone Regeneration10.29252/ibj.25.2.78 ↗
79. Zhang, Y., Wang, C., Fu, L., Ye, S., Wang, M., and Zhou, Y. (2019). Fabrication and Application of Novel Porous Scaffold in Situ-Loaded Graphene Oxide and Osteogenic Peptide by Cryogenic 3D Printing for Repairing Critical-Sized Bone Defect. Molecules, 24.10.3390/molecules24091669 ↗
80. Effect of Composition and Macropore Percentage on Mechanical and in Vitro Cell Proliferation and Differentiation Properties of 3D Printed HA/β-TCP Scaffolds10.1039/C7RA07204J ↗
81. 3D Printing of Metal–Organic Framework Incorporated Porous Scaffolds to Promote Osteogenic Differentiation and Bone Regeneration10.1039/D0NR06297A ↗
82. Reconstruction of the Alveolar Cleft: Can Growth Factor-Aided Tissue Engineering Replace Autologous Bone Grafting? A Literature Review and Systematic Review of Results Obtained with Bone Morphogenetic Protein-210.1007/s00784-011-0547-6 ↗
83. Regenerative Medicine in the Treatment of Alveolar Cleft Defect: A Systematic Review of the Literature10.1016/j.jcms.2015.06.041 ↗
84. Volumetric Comparison of Autogenous Bone and Tissue-Engineered Bone Replacement Materials in Alveolar Cleft Repair: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis10.1016/j.bjoms.2018.05.007 ↗
85. Effects of PCL, PEG and PLGA Polymers on Curcumin Release from Calcium Phosphate Matrix for in Vitro and in Vivo Bone Regeneration10.1016/j.mtchem.2018.03.005 ↗
86. Lee, J.S., Park, T.H., Ryu, J.Y., Kim, D.K., Oh, E.J., Kim, H.M., Shim, J.-H., Yun, W.-S., Huh, J.B., and Moon, S.H. (2021). Osteogenesis of 3D-Printed PCL/TCP/BdECM Scaffold Using Adipose-Derived Stem Cells Aggregates; An Experimental Study in the Canine Mandible. IJMS, 22.10.3390/ijms22115409 ↗
87. Evaluation of Mechanical Strength and Bone Regeneration Ability of 3D Printed Kagome-Structure Scaffold Using Rabbit Calvarial Defect Model10.1016/j.msec.2019.01.050 ↗
88. Bone Regeneration in Critical Bone Defects Using Three-Dimensionally Printed β-Tricalcium Phosphate/Hydroxyapatite Scaffolds Is Enhanced by Coating Scaffolds with Either Dipyridamole or BMP-2: AGENTS THAT STIMULATE A2A RECEPTORS FURTHER ENHANCE HA/Β-TCP SCAFFOLDS BONE REGENERATION10.1002/jbm.b.33561 ↗
89. Evaluation of a Poly(Lactic-Acid) Scaffold Filled with Poly(Lactide-Co-Glycolide)/Hydroxyapatite Nanofibres for Reconstruction of a Segmental Bone Defect in a Canine Model10.17221/80/2019-VETMED ↗
90. In Vitro and in Vivo Biocompatibility of Calcium-phosphate Scaffolds Three-dimensional Printed by Stereolithography for Bone Regeneration10.1002/jbm.a.36823 ↗
91. Ryu, J.-I., Yang, B.-E., Yi, S.-M., Choi, H.-G., On, S.-W., Hong, S.-J., Lim, H.-K., and Byun, S.-H. (2021). Bone Regeneration of a 3D-Printed Alloplastic and Particulate Xenogenic Graft with RhBMP-2. IJMS, 22.10.3390/ijms222212518 ↗
92. Evaluation of 3D Printed PCL/PLGA/ β -TCP versus Collagen Membranes for Guided Bone Regeneration in a Beagle Implant Model10.1088/1748-6041/11/5/055013 ↗
93. Dipyridamole Enhances Osteogenesis of Three-Dimensionally Printed Bioactive Ceramic Scaffolds in Calvarial Defects10.1016/j.jcms.2017.11.011 ↗
94. Degradable RGD-Functionalized 3D-Printed Scaffold Promotes Osteogenesis10.1177/00220345211024634 ↗
95. Bone Formation with Functionalized 3D Printed Poly-ε-Caprolactone Scaffold with Plasma-Rich-Fibrin Implanted in Critical-Sized Calvaria Defect of Rat10.1016/j.jds.2021.01.015 ↗
96. Three-Dimensional Printed PLA Scaffold and Human Gingival Stem Cell-Derived Extracellular Vesicles: A New Tool for Bone Defect Repair10.1186/s13287-018-0850-0 ↗
97. Engineering 3D-Printed Core–Shell Hydrogel Scaffolds Reinforced with Hybrid Hydroxyapatite/Polycaprolactone Nanoparticles for in Vivo Bone Regeneration10.1039/D1BM00062D ↗
98. Three-Dimensionally-Printed Bioactive Ceramic Scaffolds: Construct Effects on Bone Regeneration10.1097/SCS.0000000000007146 ↗
99. 3D-Printing Biodegradable PU/PAAM/Gel Hydrogel Scaffold with High Flexibility and Self-Adaptibility to Irregular Defects for Nonload-Bearing Bone Regeneration10.1021/acs.bioconjchem.1c00322 ↗
100. A Three-Dimensional-Printed SPION/PLGA Scaffold for Enhanced Palate-Bone Regeneration and Concurrent Alteration of the Oral Microbiota in Rats10.1016/j.msec.2021.112173 ↗