journal article·2022-04-20Open access

Is There a Better Biomaterial for Dental Implants than Titanium?—A Review and Meta-Study Analysis

Håvard J. Haugen, Hongyu Chen

Abstract

This article focuses on preclinical studies and reviews the available evidence from the literature on dental implant and abutment materials in the last decade. Specifically, different peri-implantitis materials and how surface modifications may affect the peri-implant soft-tissue seal and subsequently delay or hinder peri-implantitis are examined. This review analyzed more than 30 studies that were Randomized Controlled Trials (RCTs), Controlled Clinical Trials (CCTs), or prospective case series (CS) with at least six months of follow-up. Meta-analyses were performed to make a comparison between different implant materials (titanium vs. zirconia), including impact on bone changes, probing depth, plaque levels, and peri-implant mucosal inflammation, as well as how the properties of the implant material and surface modifications would affect the peri-implant soft-tissue seal and peri-implant health conditions. However, there was no clear evidence regarding whether titanium is better than other implant materials. Clinical evidence suggests no difference between different implant materials in peri-implant bone stability. The metal analysis offered a statistically significant advantage of zirconia implants over titanium regarding developing a favorable response to the alveolar bone.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Dental Implant Techniques and Outcomes · Bone Tissue Engineering Materials · Dental materials and restorations

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

Affiliations

Department of Biomaterials, Institute of Clinical Dentistry, University of Oslo, 0318 Oslo, Norway

Department of Biomedical Engineering, Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, Troy, NY 12180, USA

Funding

The Research Council of Norway

References (100+)

Show source-provided references
1. Correlation of bone resorption and formation with the physical behavior of loaded bone10.1177/00220345650440012801 ↗
2. A systematic review of the incidence of biological and technical complications in implant dentistry reported in prospective longitudinal studies of at least 5 years10.1034/j.1600-051X.29.s3.12.x ↗
3. Hussain, B., Haugen, H.J., Aass, A.M., Sanz, M., Antonoglou, G.N., Bouchard, P., Bozic, D., Eickholz, P., Jepsen, K., and Jepsen, S. (2021). Peri-Implant Health and the Knowing-Doing Gap—A Digital Survey on Procedures and Therapies. Front. Dent. Med., 2.10.3389/fdmed.2021.726607 ↗
4. The diagnosis and treatment of peri-implantitis10.1111/j.1600-0757.1998.tb00124.x ↗
5. Oral health-related quality of life and esthetic outcome in single anterior maxillary implants10.1111/clr.12922 ↗
6. On implant surfaces: A review of current knowledge and opinions
7. Hussain, B., Karaca, E.O., Kuru, B.E., Gursoy, H., Haugen, H.J., and Wohlfahrt, J.C. (J. Periodontol., 2021). Treatment of residual pockets using an oscillating chitosan device versus regular curettes alone-A randomized, feasibility parallel-arm clinical trial, J. Periodontol., Online ahead of print.10.1002/JPER.21-0496 ↗
8. The microbiota of osseointegrated implants in patients with a history of periodontal disease10.1111/j.1600-051X.1995.tb00123.x ↗
9. Experimentally induced peri-implant mucositis. A clinical study in humans10.1034/j.1600-0501.1994.050409.x ↗
10. Peri-implant diseases and conditions: Consensus report of workgroup 4 of the 2017 World Workshop on the Classification of Periodontal and Peri-Implant Diseases and Conditions
11. Management of peri-implant mucositis and peri-implantitis10.1111/prd.12049 ↗
12. Chala, M., Anagnostaki, E., Mylona, V., Chalas, A., Parker, S., and Lynch, E. (2020). Adjunctive Use of Lasers in Peri-Implant Mucositis and Peri-Implantitis Treatment: A Systematic Review. Dent. J., 8.10.3390/dj8030068 ↗
13. Recent advances in dental implants10.1186/s40902-017-0132-2 ↗
14. Titanium, a metal for surgery10.2106/00004623-195133020-00021 ↗
15. Interface analysis of titanium and zirconium bone implants10.1016/0142-9612(85)90070-5 ↗
16. Osseointegrated titanium implants: Requirements for ensuring a long-lasting, direct bone-to-implant anchorage in man10.3109/17453678108991776 ↗
17. Wintermantel, E., and Ha, S. (2009). Medizintechnik Life Science Engineering, Springer.10.1007/978-3-540-93936-8 ↗
18. Titanium-the material of choice?10.1111/j.1600-0757.1998.tb00119.x ↗
19. Biocompatibility of titanium implants: Surface science aspects10.1016/0022-3913(83)90359-1 ↗
20. Material-tissue interfaces: The role of surface properties and processes
21. Integrated experimental and theoretical approach for corrosion and wear evaluation of laser surface nitrided, Ti-6Al-4V biomaterial in physiological solution10.1016/j.jmbbm.2014.05.017 ↗
22. Nicholson, J.W. (2002). The Chemistry of Medical and Dental Materials (RSC Materials Monographs), Royal Society of Chemistry.10.1039/9781847552051 ↗
23. Systemic drugs that influence titanium implant osseointegration10.1080/03602532.2016.1277737 ↗
24. Biology of implant osseointegration
25. Advances in dental implant materials and tissue regeneration10.1111/j.1600-0757.2006.00175.x ↗
26. Titanium implant surface modification by cathodic reduction in hydrofluoric acid: Surface characterization and in vivo performance10.1002/jbm.a.31898 ↗
27. The effect of hydrofluoric acid treatment of titanium surface on nanostructural and chemical changes and the growth of MC3T3-E1 cells10.1016/j.biomaterials.2008.10.052 ↗
28. Tensile force testing of optimized coin-shaped titanium implant attachment kinetics in the rabbit tibiae10.1023/A:1025622407727 ↗
29. Analysing the optimal value for titanium implant roughness in bone attachment using a tensile test10.1016/S0142-9612(03)00256-4 ↗
30. Bone bonding assessed by tensile testing of osseointegrating coin-shaped titanium implants
31. Comparison between bioactive fluoride modified and bioinert anodically oxidized implant surfaces in early bone response using rabbit tibia model10.1097/ID.0b013e318249f283 ↗
32. Reliability of circumferential bone level assessment around single implants in healed ridges and extraction sockets using cone beam CT10.1111/j.1708-8208.2011.00393.x ↗
33. A 2-year prospective study on immediate loading with fluoride-modified implants in the edentulous mandible10.1111/j.1600-0501.2010.02077.x ↗
34. Bone apposition to a titanium-zirconium alloy implant, as compared to two other titanium-containing implants10.22203/eCM.v023a21 ↗
35. Soft tissue considerations in implant site development10.1016/j.coms.2010.04.001 ↗
36. A Review of Titanium Zirconium (TiZr) Alloys for Use in Endosseous Dental Implants10.3390/ma5081348 ↗
37. Concerning the role of aluminum in causing dementia10.1016/0531-5565(94)00050-D ↗
38. Vanadium and tungsten derivatives as antidiabetic agents10.1385/BTER:88:2:097 ↗
39. Histological and electron microprobe studies of mineralisation in aluminium-related osteomalacia10.1136/jcp.45.6.502 ↗
40. Effect of friction on anodic polarization properties of metallic biomaterials10.1016/S0142-9612(01)00337-4 ↗
41. Development of low rigidity beta-type titanium alloy for biomedical applications10.2320/matertrans.43.2970 ↗
42. Martensitic transformation of Ti-18Nb (at.%) alloy with zirconium10.1007/s12598-012-0496-5 ↗
43. Interdiffusion in β-Ti–Zr binary alloys10.1016/j.jallcom.2008.02.082 ↗
44. Conjoint corrosion and wear in titanium alloys10.1016/S0142-9612(98)00229-4 ↗
45. Structure, mechanical properties, and grindability of dental Ti-Zr alloys10.1007/s10856-008-3454-x ↗
46. Mechanical properties of the binary titanium-zirconium alloys and their potential for biomedical materials10.1002/jbm.820290805 ↗
47. Attachment and growth behaviour of human gingival fibroblasts on titanium and zirconia ceramic surfaces10.1088/1748-6041/4/2/025005 ↗
48. Influence of abutment material on stability of peri-implant tissues: A systematic review
49. The binary TiZr Alloy—A newly developed Ti alloy for use in dental implants
50. Evaluation of a New Titanium-Zirconium Dental Implant: A Biomechanical and Histological Comparative Study in the Mini Pig10.1111/j.1708-8208.2010.00289.x ↗
51. Corrosion resistance of the Ti–50Zr at.% alloy after anodization in different acidic electrolytes10.1016/j.corsci.2010.08.021 ↗
52. Fabrication of novel TiZr alloy foams for biomedical applications10.1016/j.msec.2005.08.006 ↗
53. Hydrogen content in titanium and a titanium-zirconium alloy after acid etching10.1016/j.msec.2012.12.027 ↗
54. Differential response of human gingival fibroblasts to titanium- and titanium-zirconium-modified surfaces10.1111/jre.12121 ↗
55. Surface hydride on titanium by cathodic polarization promotes human gingival fibroblast growth10.1002/jbm.a.34819 ↗
56. The influence of surface nanoroughness, texture and chemistry of TiZr implant abutment on oral biofilm accumulation10.1111/clr.12354 ↗
57. A Double-Blind Randomized Controlled Trial (RCT) of Titanium-13Zirconium versus Titanium Grade IV Small-Diameter Bone Level Implants in Edentulous Mandibles—Results from a 1-Year Observation Period
58. Bone response to a novel Ti-Ta-Nb-Zr alloy10.1016/j.actbio.2015.03.038 ↗
59. Newly developed Ti-Nb-Zr-Ta-Si-Fe biomedical beta titanium alloys with increased strength and enhanced biocompatibility10.1016/j.msec.2015.11.043 ↗
60. Influence of alloying elements on cellular response and in-vitro corrosion behavior of titanium-molybdenum-chromium alloys for implant materials10.1016/j.jpor.2020.01.004 ↗
61. Titanium alloys: In vitro biological analyzes on biofilm formation, biocompatibility, cell differentiation to induce bone formation, and immunological response10.1007/s10856-019-6310-2 ↗
62. Binary titanium alloys as dental implant materials-a review10.1093/rb/rbx027 ↗
63. Ionescu, R.N., Totan, A.R., Imre, M.M., Tancu, A.M.C., Pantea, M., Butucescu, M., and Farcasiu, A.T. (2022). Prosthetic Materials Used for Implant-Supported Restorations and Their Biochemical Oral Interactions: A Narrative Review. Materials, 15.10.3390/ma15031016 ↗
64. Zirconia based dental ceramics: Structure, mechanical properties, biocompatibility and applications10.1039/C6DT03484E ↗
65. Zirconia in dental prosthetics: A literature review10.1016/j.jmrt.2019.06.043 ↗
66. Lorusso, F., Noumbissi, S., Francesco, I., Rapone, B., Khater, A.G.A., and Scarano, A. (2020). Scientific Trends in Clinical Research on Zirconia Dental Implants: A Bibliometric Review. Materials, 13.10.3390/ma13235534 ↗
67. Crystal structure of zirconia affects osteoblast behavior10.1016/j.dental.2020.04.017 ↗
68. Zirconia implants restored with single crowns or fixed dental prostheses: 5-year results of a prospective cohort investigation10.1111/clr.13581 ↗
69. Hydride formation on titanium surfaces by cathodic polarization10.1016/j.apsusc.2008.08.090 ↗
70. Surface nano-functionalization of biomaterials10.1016/j.mser.2010.06.013 ↗
71. Determining optimal surface roughness of TiO2 blasted titanium implant material for attachment, proliferation and differentiation of cells derived from human mandibular alveolar bone10.1034/j.1600-0501.2001.120513.x ↗
72. Influence of surface characteristics on bone integration of titanium implants. A histomorphometric study in miniature pigs10.1002/jbm.820250708 ↗
73. Rough surfaces of titanium and titanium alloys for implants and prostheses10.1016/j.msec.2004.08.004 ↗
74. Implant surface roughness and patient factors on long-term peri-implant bone loss10.1111/prd.12177 ↗
75. Oral implant surfaces: Part 1--review focusing on topographic and chemical properties of different surfaces and in vivo responses to them
76. Effect of micro-roughness produced by TiO2 blasting. Tensile testing of bone attachment by using coin-shaped implants10.1016/S0142-9612(02)00167-9 ↗
77. A study on the effect of dual blasting with TiO2 on titanium implant surfaces on functional attachment in bone10.1002/jbm.a.10580 ↗
78. Preparation of bioactive microporous titanium surface by a new two-step chemical treatment10.1023/A:1008859417664 ↗
79. Fast precipitation of calcium phosphate layers on titanium induced by simple chemical treatments10.1016/S0142-9612(97)82297-1 ↗
80. The influence of titanium abutment surface roughness on plaque accumulation and gingivitis: Short-term observations
81. The influence of abutment surface roughness on plaque accumulation and peri-implant mucositis10.1034/j.1600-0501.1996.070302.x ↗
82. Hydrogen desorption from sand-blasted and acid-etched titanium surfaces after glow-discharge treatment10.1002/1097-4636(200101)54:1<20::AID-JBM3>3.0.CO;2-Z ↗
83. Influence of surface treatments developed for oral implants on the physical and biological properties of titanium.(I) Surface characterization10.1034/j.1600-0501.1997.080307.x ↗
84. Ellingsen, J.E., Videm, K., Opsahl, L., and Rønold, H.J. (2000). Implants with Modified Surfaces for Increased Biocompatibility and Method for Production Thereof. (WO/2000/038753).
85. Biological responses of anodized titanium implants under different current voltages10.1111/j.1365-2842.2006.01669.x ↗
86. Osseointegration of anodized titanium implants under different current voltages: A rabbit study10.1111/j.1365-2842.2006.01688.x ↗
87. The preliminary study on the oxide film of pure titanium treated by anodic oxidation
88. Characteristics of the surface oxides on turned and electrochemically oxidized pure titanium implants up to dielectric breakdown: The oxide thickness, micropore configurations, surface roughness, crystal structure and chemical composition10.1016/S0142-9612(01)00131-4 ↗
89. Preparation of bioactive titanium metal via anodic oxidation treatment10.1016/S0142-9612(03)00626-4 ↗
90. Influence of abutment material and modifications on peri-implant soft-tissue attachment: A systematic review and meta-analysis of histological animal studies10.1016/j.prosdent.2020.01.025 ↗
91. Crystal structure of the surface oxide layer on titanium and its changes arising from immersion10.1002/jbm.820290111 ↗
92. Surface characterization of implant materials c.p. Ti, Ti-6Al-7Nb and Ti-6Al-4V with different pretreatments10.1023/A:1008840026907 ↗
93. Cell adhesion and in vivo osseointegration of sandblasted/acid etched/anodized dental implants10.3390/ijms160510324 ↗
94. Ellingsen, J.E., and Lyngstadaas, S.P. (2008). Medical Prosthetic Devices Having Improved Biocompatibility. (7410502B2), U.S. Patent.
95. Understanding and controlling the bone–implant interface10.1016/S0142-9612(99)00160-X ↗
96. Surface modification of titanium, titanium alloys, and related materials for biomedical applications10.1016/j.mser.2004.11.001 ↗
97. Effect of cathodic polarization on coating doxycycline on titanium surfaces10.1016/j.msec.2016.03.012 ↗
98. Corrigendum to “Bioactive implant surface with electrochemically bound doxycycline promotes bone formation markers in vitro and in vivo” [Dental 30 (2) (2014) 200–214]10.1016/j.dental.2014.01.015 ↗
99. Coating doxycycline on titanium-based implants: Two in vivo studies
100. Simvastatin-activated implant surface promotes osteoblast differentiation in vitro10.1177/0885328213486364 ↗