journal article·2018-06Open access

Formulation of optimized excavatable cement treated materials using a new punching test apparatus

E. Gennesseaux, T. Sedran, J. M. Torrenti, M. Hardy

Materials and Structures· Volume 51· Issue 3

Abstract

Classical techniques for backfilling of trenches use unbounded materials. Unfortunately, they have been presenting several drawbacks regarding compaction such as noise disturbance, time of implementation and long-term settlement. In that context, controlled low strength materials could be a good alternative solution thanks to their fluidity and cementitious setting, provided that they remain excavatable, even manually with a pick. In fact, it is essential to ensure a rapid and easy permanent access to the underlying networks, in case of emergency or maintenance. Yet, the excavatability was not well defined, nor well measured so far. A fortiori, no mix design process is available to control the excavatability of these materials. It is the purpose of this article to develop one. Recently, a new approach based on a simple punching test in laboratory was proposed to provide a quantitative characterization of cement treated materials excavatability, accounting for the pick impact energy (Morin in Study of cementitious material excavatability, 2009; Morin et al. in Eur J Environ Civ Eng 17(10):935–955, 2013; Can Geotech J, 2017. https://doi.org/10.1139/cgi-2016-0534 ). The present paper first briefly describes how, in the continuation of this study, the testing set-up was improved, the approach was validated and the underlying theoretical models were calibrated on an important campaign of manual excavation on real scale trenches, in parallel with laboratory punching tests. Once the laboratory method developed, it was possible to proceed a large parametric campaign at the laboratory stage to identify the mix design parameters that influence the excavatability of cementitious materials. The second part of the paper describes the methodology used and the empirical model deduced to link the mix proportions of a cementitious material to its excavatability. Finally, manual excavations were realized on real scale trenches to confirm the relevance of the model. In conclusion, a global mix design method is proposed for excavatable cement treated materials, with a brief economical simulation.
Source: openaire · Quality: candidate unverified · Source record ↗

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Materials Engineering and Processing · Tunneling and Rock Mechanics · Grouting, Rheology, and Soil Mechanics

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

References (20)

Show source-provided references
1. Bonnet G, Gavalda A, Quibel A (1998) Remblayage des tranchées, Utilisation de matériaux autocompactants. Etat des connaissances (Back filling of trenches, the use of self-compacting concrete—state of the art). In Dossier Certu, no. 78 (in French)
2. ACI-229R-99 (1999) Controlled low strength material, Farmington Hills, Michigan: American Concrete Institute 229R-99
3. Pons F, Landwermeyer J, Kerns L (1998) Development of engineering properties for regular and quick-set flowable fill, pp 67–8610.1520/STP13063S ↗
4. Crouch L et al (2003) Long term study of 23 excavatable Tennessee flowable fill mixtures. ASTM-STP 1459, p 89
5. NCHRP (2008) Development of a recommended practice for use of controlled low-strength material in highway construction. TRB: Report 597
6. Morin (2009) Etude de l’excavabilité des matériaux traités aux liants hydrauliques (Study of cementitious material excavatability). Ph.D. thesis, ed. Université Pierre et Marie-Curie de Pari (in French)
7. Morin C et al (2013) Prediction of the volume of concrete backfill materials excavated using a pick. Eur J Environ Civ Eng 17(10):935–95510.1080/19648189.2013.837012 ↗
8. Morin C et al (2017) Development of an excavatability test for backfill materials, numerical and experimental studies. Can Geotech J. https://doi.org/10.1139/cgi-2016-053410.1139/cgi-2016-0534 ↗
9. CERTU (1998) Bonnet, G., Galvada, A., et Quibel, A. Remblayage des tranchées; utilisation de matériaux autocompactants. Etats des connaissances (Trench filling with flowable cementitious material. State of the art) Dossier Certu (in French)
10. Webb M, McGarth T, Selig E (1998) Field test of buried pipe with CLSM backfill. The design and application of controlled low strength materials (flowable fill), ASTM STP 1331. ed. American Society for Testing and Materials, pp 237–25410.1520/STP13077S ↗
11. Hamcin (1996) A performance specification for controlled low strength material controlled density fill (CLSM-CDF), Hamilton County and the City of Cincinnati
12. Crouch L, Gamble R, Brogdon J, Tucker C (1998) Use of high fines limestone screening as aggregate for CLSM. The design and application of CLSM (flowable fill), volume ASTM 1331, pp 45–59
13. Halmen C (2005) Physiochemical characteristics of controlled low strength materials influencing the electrochemical performance and service life of metallic materials (Dissertation). Texas A&M University, College Station
14. Krell W (1989) Flowable fly ash. Concr Int 11(11):54–58
15. Gennesseaux E (2015) Excavabilité et formulation des matériaux traités aux liants hydrauliques pour tranchées (Excavatability and mix design of cementitions materials for trench). Ph.D. thesis, ed. Ecole Centrale de Nantes (in French)
16. Ifsttar et Engie (2016) Evaluation de l’excavabilité à la pioche des matériaux granulaires traités avec un liant hydraulique à l’aide d’un essai de poinçonnement (Evaluation of the excavatability with a pick of granulat matérials treated with hydraulic binder with the help of a punching test), Techniques et méthodes, GTI3, ed Ifsttar, Marne La vallée (in French)
17. BS 1881-103 (1983) British standard. Testing concrete. Method for determination of compacting factor, replaced by BS EN 12350-4:2000
18. de Larrard F (1999) Concrete mixture-proportioning: a scientific approach, modern concrete technology series no. 9, A. Bentur and S. Mindness editors, E & FN SPON10.1201/9781482272055 ↗
19. Fennis S, Walraven J, Uijl J (2013) Compaction-interaction packing model: an extended basis to design concrete mixtures including aggregates and fillers. Mater Struct 46:463–47810.1617/s11527-012-9910-6 ↗
20. Gennesseaux E, Sedran T, Hardy M, Torrenti J-M (2014) How to evaluate the excavability of controlled low-strength materials for trenches: a new approach. In: Proceeding of the conference transport research Arena, Paris