Study on the difference of composition between traditional and modern lime used in the restoration of Qufu San Kong Ancient Architectural

In recent years, a decline in the binding strength and frost resistance of lime binder used in the restoration of the Qufu San Kong ancient architectural complex in Shandong Province has been observed, which has significantly affected the quality of restoration. In this study, lime binder samples were collected from the Kuiwen Pavilion roof, limestone samples in the vicinity of the Confucius Temple, and modern industrial quicklime from various provinces in China. Analytical methods including X-ray diffraction (XRD) and Fourier-transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy were employed. Results indicate that the local limestone in Qufu contains impurities such as Si or Mg. XRD patterns reveal that the main phase of the Kuiwen Pavilion roof lime binder samples is calcite. Using FTIR and Scanning Electron Microscope- Energy Dispersive Spectrometer (SEM-EDS), the presence of hydrated calcium silicate (C-S-H) gel is identified in the samples. This suggests that the traditional quicklime-production process in Qufu yields a multiphase composite system. Modern industrial quicklime, aged for two months, showed no presence of C-S-H gel in the FTIR spectra and SEM-EDS results, indicating that it is a comparatively pure system primarily comprising CaO. The study suggests that traditional quicklime-production processes typically involve burning limestone with higher Si content, leading to the generation of a significant amount of dicalcium silicate. Additionally, the use of high-ash coal as fuel introduces reactive silicon dioxide into the quicklime product. These factors contribute to the formation of C-S-H gel in hydrated lime. The presence of C-S-H gel enhances lime binder properties such as binding strength and frost resistance. Modern quicklime production, which selects limestone with lower Si content and employs low-ash coal as fuel, aims to minimize or avoid the formation of C-S-H gel in hydrated lime. High-purity CaO quicklime products align with the principles of modern fine processing; however, they compromise the binding strength and durability of lime binder required for traditional architectural restoration. • Calcium silicate hydrate was found in lime samples collected from the Kuiwen Pavilion roof. • Modern quicklime products try to avoid the formation of hydraulic components in China. • Calcium silicate hydrate is beneficial for lime binder used in the restoration of architectural heritage.