Comparative life cycle assessment of chip seal preventive maintenance techniques: Cost and environmental implications
Source abstract
Abstract
This study presents a comparative life cycle assessment and lifecycle cost analysis of seven chip-seal preventive maintenance treatments (Single, Double, and Triple chip seals; Scrub seal; Cape seal; Fiber-modified chip seal; and Rubberized chip seal) using a cradle-to-construction system boundary. Environmental impacts were quantified with SimaPro v9 (Ecoinvent) using the ReCiPe 2016 Endpoint (H) method for a functional unit of 1 m² of treated pavement and for the economic analysis, documented U.S. project costs and the Iranian price list were used and annualized with a 10 % discount rate. Results indicate that, under a cradle-to-construction boundary, Single Chip Seal and Scrub Seal have the lowest total normalized costs (1.88 and 2.6 USD/ m 2 ), while Rubberized and Triple Chip Seals show the highest total costs (7.06 and 6.28 USD/ m 2 ). When costs are annualized by service life, Single chip seal and Scrub seal remain the least costly (0.5 and 0.69 USD/ m 2 ), whereas Fiber chip seal, Cape seal and Triple chip seal are the most expensive ones (1.03, 1.05, and 1.05, respectively). From an environmental standpoint, Scrub Seal has the lowest total GHG emissions (≈1545 g CO₂e) and the lowest weighted endpoint scores across Human Health, Ecosystems and Resources, whereas Cape Seal and Triple Chip Seal are the worst performers (Cape seal total GHG ≈ 5301 g CO₂e; Triple chip seal frequently attains the maximum normalized score across midpoint categories). However, when these values normalized per service year, Rubberized Chip Seal yields one of the lowest annual GHG burdens (≈177.5 g CO₂e/year), illustrating the trade-off between higher upfront material and installation impacts and longer service life. Monte Carlo uncertainty analysis (1000 runs, 95 % CI) confirms that the relative ranking of alternatives is robust. The results highlight clear cost–environment tradeoffs and the importance of life-span weighting in selecting preservation strategies.
Source: openalex_inverted_index · Quality: baseline
Research context
OpenAlex topics: Asphalt Pavement Performance Evaluation · Infrastructure Maintenance and Monitoring · Microplastics and Plastic Pollution
SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.
References (56)
Show source-provided references
1. ADI Analytics. (2021). Asphalt Binder Market Assessment. Available at:[〈https://albertainnovates.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/2020-ADI-AI-Asphalt-Binder-Market-Report-FINAL-Public.pdf〉]. Accessed: Aug 2025.
2. Freedonia Group. Global Asphalt (Bitumen). 2022 June 2025]; Available from: 〈https://www.freedoniagroup.com/industry-study/global-asphalt-bitumen〉.
3. Reducing the environmental impact of concrete and asphalt: a scenario approach10.1016/j.jclepro.2013.10.012 ↗
4. Evaluation of lab performance of stamp sand and acrylonitrile styrene acrylate waste composites without asphalt as road surface materials10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2022.127569 ↗
5. Exploring the long-term impact of preventive road treatments on municipal highways
6. Life-cycle cost analysis of optimal timing of pavement preservation10.1007/s11709-016-0369-3 ↗
7. Pavement preservation: the preventive maintenance concept
8. Pavement preventive maintenance decision-making for high antiwear and optimized skid resistance performance10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2023.132757 ↗
9. Sustainable pavement management: Integrating economic, technical, and environmental aspects in decision making10.3141/2523-07 ↗
10. Cost effectiveness of chip seal and hot mix asphalt pavements10.3390/geotechnics4040058 ↗
11. Gransberg · 2005 · 342
12. Performance evaluation of emulsion and hot asphalt cement chip seal pavements10.1061/(ASCE)MT.1943-5533.0002057 ↗
13. A review on adhesion behavior of chip seal pavement and aggregate
14. Life-extending benefit of chip sealing for pavement preservation10.1177/0361198121989721 ↗
15. Effect of simultaneous application of glass fiber reinforcement and polymer-modified asphalt emulsion on DBST’s resistance to aggregate loss using laboratory investigation10.3390/coatings14060702 ↗
16. Role of fiber-reinforced chip seal interlayers in asphalt pavement bonding strength10.1080/09276440.2024.2330787 ↗
17. Comparison of asphalt emulsion-based chip seal and hot rubber asphalt-based chip seal
18. Adhesion performance of rubber modified asphalt in chip seal: a molecular dynamic study10.3390/ma16186324 ↗
19. Bertsch · 2025
20. Life cycle assessment of pervious pavements: integrative review and novel ideas of analysis10.3390/w16101403 ↗
21. Greenhouse gas emissions from asphalt pavement construction: a case study in China10.3390/ijerph13030351 ↗
22. Lessons learned from the construction and initial performance of a double chip seal over a paving mat pilot project10.3390/infrastructures8090134 ↗
23. Gregory M. Duncan, Luis V. Sibaja, Stephen B. Seeds, and David G. Peshkin. (2020). Using Reclaimed Asphalt Pavement in Pavement-Preservation Treatments. Available at:[〈https://rosap.ntl.bts.gov/view/dot/54776〉]. Accessed: Aug 2025.
24. Adriana Vargas-Nordcbeck, Jerry Geib, Benjamin Worel, Buzz Powell, and Joel D. Ulring. (2024). Findings from the Pavement Preservation Group (PG) Study. Available at:[〈https://rosap.ntl.bts.gov/view/dot/77733〉]. Accessed: Aug 2025.
25. John P. Zaniewski and Michael S. Mamlouk, Chip & Seal Techniques, Chapter 5" Pavement Maintenance Effectiveness, Preventive Maintenance Treatment, Participants Handbook". 1997. Available at:[〈https://docs.lib.purdue.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3843&context=roadschool〉]. Accessed: Aug 2025.
26. Gransberg · 2005
27. Gary Hicks Scott Shuler, Larry Tomkins, Rod Birdsall, Andy Clayton, Mark Ishee, Stormy Brewster, Amy Epps Martin, Jon A. Epps, Bobby Betsold Best Practices for Emulsified Asphalt Chip Seals 2021. American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASHTO). Available at:[〈https://www.pavementpreservation.org/wp-content/uploads/ETF/Best%20Practices/Best%20Practices%20-%20Chip%20Seals%20[2021-02-08].pdf〉]. Accessed: Aug 2025.
28. Gheni · 2025
29. Cold in-place recycling asphalt mixtures: Laboratory performance and preliminary ME design analysis10.3390/ma14082036 ↗
30. Asphalt mixture with scrap tire rubber and nylon fiber from waste tires: laboratory performance and preliminary ME design analysis10.3390/buildings12020160 ↗
31. Waste cathode-ray-tube glass powder modified asphalt materials: preparation and characterization10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.127949 ↗
32. Development of loaded wheel test for evaluating bleeding in chip seals10.3141/2481-07 ↗
33. Performance Evaluation Test for Fiber Asphalt Chip Seal
34. The Kentucky Transportation Center. Chip Seal. 2023 Nov 2025 Nov 2025]; Available from: 〈https://kp.uky.edu/knowledge-portal/articles/chip-seal/〉.
35. Inc Applied Pavement Technology. Chip Seal Performance Measures―Best Practices. 2015. Available at:[〈https://www.wsdot.wa.gov/research/reports/fullreports/841.1.pdf〉]. Accessed: Nov 2025.
36. The Kentucky Transportation Center. Scrub Seal. 2023 Nov 2025]; Available from: 〈https://kp.uky.edu/knowledge-portal/articles/scrub-seal/〉.
37. The Kentucky Transportation Center. Cape Seal. 2023 2025 Nov 2025]; Available from: 〈https://kp.uky.edu/knowledge-portal/articles/cape-seal/〉.
38. Inc American Pavement Systems. Asphalt‑Rubber Chip and Cape Seal. 2022 June 2025]; Available from: 〈https://www.americanpavementsystems.com/asphalt-rubber-chip-and-cape-seal/〉.
39. John Harvey, Joep Meijer, Hasan Ozer, Imad L. Al-Qadi, Arash Saboori and Alissa Kendall. (2016). Pavement life cycle assessment framework. Available at:[〈https://rosap.ntl.bts.gov/view/dot/38470/dot_38470_DS1.pdf〉]. Accessed: May 2025.
40. Valorization of recycled wastes in pavement preventive maintenance: a review on reclaimed asphalt pavement and recycled waste tire10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e27776 ↗
41. Comparative analysis of rubberized asphalt and traditional asphalt: performance, economic, and environmental impacts in life cycle10.3390/infrastructures10020034 ↗
42. "PRé Sustainability". SimaPro 9.0: Life Cycle Assessment Software. 2019. Available at: 〈https://simapro.com/〉. [Accessed: May 2025].
43. Granulator Machine. Nov 2025]; Available from: 〈https://dmabna.com/product/%d8%af%d8%b3%d8%aa%da%af%d8%a7%d9%87-%da%af%d8%b1%d8%a7%d9%86%d9%88%d9%84-%d8%b3%d8%a7%d8%b2/〉.
44. Gary Hicks, DingXin Cheng, and Lerose Lane. (2019). Manual for Chip Seals. Available at:[〈https://transweb.sjsu.edu/sites/default/files/1845A-Chip-Seal-Manual.pdf〉]. Accessed: June 2025.
45. Plan and Budget Organization of Iran. Unit Price List for Road Maintenance. 2023. Iran. Available at:[〈https://download.acco.ir/PDF/FehrestBaha/1402/22-Rahdari1402@ISCCchannel.pdf〉]. Accessed: Aug 2025.
46. Athanassios Nikolaides, Highway engineering: Pavements, materials and control of quality. 2014: CRC Press. Available [〈https://doi.org/10.1680/jtran.15.00036〉]. Accessed: Aug 2025.10.1680/jtran.15.00036 ↗
47. Akzo Nobel. Production of Emulsions - Overview of Manufacture. 2003. Available at:[〈https://e-asphalt.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/overview-1.pdf〉]. Accessed: Aug 2025.
48. Assessment of eco-friendly pavement construction and maintenance using multi-recycled rap mixtures10.3390/recycling5030017 ↗
49. All States Materials Group (ASMG). (2020). Double Chip Seal Technical Specifications. Available at:[〈https://asmg.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/Double-Chip-Seal.pdf〉]. Accessed: June 2025.
50. M. AASHTO. (2017). Sizes of Aggregate for Road and Bridge Construction. Available at:[〈https://www.gov.bm/sites/default/files/2018-004P-Supply%20and%20Delivery%20of%20Aggregates_AnnexC-ASTM%20D448-12.pdf〉]. Accessed: Aug 2025.
51. Asphalt Emulsion Manufacturers Association (AEMA). (2020). Section 6: Scrub Seals Using Asphalt Emulsions. Available at:[〈https://www.mdt.mt.gov/publications/docs/brochures/research/toolbox/aema/docs/s6scrub.pdf〉]. Accessed: June 2025.
52. AAshto Emulsion Task Force (ETF). (2020). Section 407 - Hot Applied Asphalt-Rubber Chip Seal. P.P. Center. Available at:[〈https://www.pavementpreservation.org/wp-content/uploads/ETF/Specifications/Finals/407_Hot%20Applied%20Chip%20Seal%209-4-20%20(V-3).pdf〉]. Accessed: Aug 2025.
53. American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASHTO). Chip Seal. Available at:[〈https://tsp2pavement.pavementpreservation.org/technical/surveys/mppp-agency-preservation-treatment-survey/chip-seal/〉]. Accessed: Nov 2025.
54. American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASHTO). Scrub Seal. Available at:[〈https://tsp2pavement.pavementpreservation.org/technical/surveys/mppp-agency-preservation-treatment-survey/scrub-seal/〉]. Accessed: Nov 2025.
55. City of Patterson. 2025 Slurry Seal Project. 2025. Available at:[〈http://pattersonca.gov/DocumentCenter/View/12454/Bid-Tabulation-Matrix---04-02-25---Slurry-Seal-Project?bidId=#:∼:text=7%20Slurry%20Seal%20,25〉]. Accessed: Nov 2025.
56. Connecticut Department Of Transportation. ASPHALT RUBBER CHIP SEAL. Available at:[〈https://portal.ct.gov/dot/-/media/dot/contracts/0000---2023-bid-tabs/0172-0520.pdf?rev=38ac94548b4b467fb33aa8b5bc69391b&hash=0FBAAB84FEFFD164FC8D96529C0303CF#:∼:text=0060%200406132%20ASPHALT%20RUBBER%20CHIP,00〉]. Accessed: Nov 2025.