journal article·2024-01Open access

Revealing the iron skeleton of Notre-Dame de Paris. Methodologies and issues of archaeological and analytical investigations following the blaze

Maxime L'Héritier, Aurélia Azéma, Delphine Syvilay, Delphine Neff, Ivan Guillot, Emmanuelle Delqué-Kolic, Thibault Creacheadec, Philippe Dillmann

Abstract

The fire at Notre-Dame de Paris led to the discovery of several series of previously unknown iron armatures, which were systematically recorded. Amongst them, several iron staples from the top of the eaves walls, lead crest reinforcements and a sample of the tie rods used in the choir in the 19th century were analysed by metallography and tensile tests in order to determine their nature and mechanical characteristics. These results can be put into perspective with previous studies on such monuments. The chemical analysis with SEM-EDS of the slag inclusions contained in the matrix of these ferrous alloys makes it possible to determine the technical processes used for their production throughout the construction and restoration of the building, highlighting several differences depending on the typologies of the iron armatures. This information is complemented by a series of radiocarbon dates currently being carried out to better understand the periods of use of these ferrous reinforcements. When compared with those of other materials, these dates could be used to recalibrate the phasing of the building.
Source: openaire · Quality: candidate unverified · Source record ↗

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Metallurgy and Cultural Artifacts · Cultural Heritage Materials Analysis · Archaeology and ancient environmental studies

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

References (49)

Show source-provided references
1. M. L'Héritier, Le fer et le plomb dans la construction monumentale au Moyen Âge, de l’étude des sources écrites à l'analyse de la matière. Bilan de 20 ans de recherches et perspectives, Ædificare. Revue Internationale d'histoire de La Construction. (2019) 79–121.
2. Timbert · 2006 · 16
3. E. Lefebvre, M. L'Héritier, De l'emploi du fer dans la structure de la cathédrale de Chartres. Approche qualitative et quantitative, in: Chartres. Construire et Restaurer La Cathédrale (XIe-XXIe s.), Presses Universitaires Du Septentrion, Villeneuve-d'Ascq, 2014: pp. 287–306.10.4000/books.septentrion.31457 ↗
4. Les armatures de fer de la cathédrale de Bourges : nouvelles données, nouvelles lectures10.3406/bulmo.2016.12893 ↗
5. La cathédrale de Bourges et l'utilisation du fer dans l'architecture10.3406/bulmo.1996.4550 ↗
6. Iron in the building of gothic churches: its role, origins and production using evidence from Rouen and Troyes
7. Réflexion sur les usages du fer à la cathédrale de Coutances et dans l'architecture gothique normande
8. De Soissons à Beauvais : le fer des cathédrales de Picardie, une approche archéométrique
9. Taupin · 1996 · 18
10. Fer et plomb sur le chantier, in: saint-Denis
11. L'architecture rayonnante et le métal
12. Les matériaux mis en œuvre
13. Viollet-le-Duc · 1854
14. Leniaud · 1980
15. From debris to remains, an experimental protocol under emergency conditions
16. Notre-Dame de Paris: the first iron lady? Archaeometallurgical study and dating of the Parisian cathedral iron reinforcements
17. La technologie 3D au service de Notre-Dame
18. Microstructure of ferrous alloys
19. Iron–phosphorus–carbon system: part 2–metallographic behaviour of Oberhoffer's reagent10.1179/026708300101507848 ↗
20. Microstructural characterization and mechanical properties of iron reinforcements in buildings from the medieval and modern periods in France10.1080/15583058.2018.1563229 ↗
21. M. L'Héritier, P. Dillmann, S. Aumard, P. Fluzin, Iron? Which iron? Methodologies for metallographic and slag inclusion studies applied to ferrous reinforcements from Auxerre Cathedral, in: J. Humphris, T. Rehren (Eds.), The World of Iron, 2013: pp. 409–420.
22. Iron-phosphorus-carbon system. Part 3 - metallography of low carbon iron-phosphorus alloys10.1179/026708300101507857 ↗
23. Iron-phosphorus-carbon system part 1 - mechanical properties of low carboniron-phosphorus alloys10.1179/026708300101507839 ↗
24. Bénard · 1984
25. Experimental characterization of ancient metal tie-rods in historic masonry buildings10.1080/15583058.2018.1563230 ↗
26. Metallurgical characterisation of a historical metal tie-rod from Milan cathedral10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2019.07.272 ↗
27. Mechanical performance of historical wrought iron rods10.1111/arcm.12470 ↗
28. Ashby · 2016
29. Dillmann · 2016 · 63
30. M. Mollat, R.-.H. Bautier, Le trafic fluvial sur la Seine au pont de Meulan au milieu du XVe siècle, Bulletin Philologique et Historique Du Comité Des Travaux Historiques et Scientifiques. (1959) 251–296.
31. Slag inclusion analyses for studying ferrous alloys employed in French medieval buildings: supply of materials and diffusion of smelting processes10.1016/j.jas.2006.12.022 ↗
32. Iron reinforcements in Beauvais and Metz Cathedrals: from bloomery or finery? The use of logistic regression for differentiating smelting processes10.1016/j.jas.2013.10.034 ↗
33. Iron supply for the building of Metz cathedral: new methodological development for provenance studies and historical considerations10.1111/arcm.12265 ↗
34. The medieval iron market in Ariège (France). Multidisciplinary analytical approach and multivariate analyses10.1016/j.jas.2011.11.025 ↗
35. Deciphering the iron provenance on a medieval building yard: the case of Bourges Cathedral10.3390/min10121131 ↗
36. Characterisation of slag inclusion in iron objects
37. The Construction of Notre-Dame in Paris10.1080/00043079.1987.10788458 ↗
38. Notre-Dame de Paris, Histoire et archéologie d'une cathédrale (XIIe-XIVe siècle)
39. Verna · 2001
40. Autour de la « minette » : la perduration de la production de fer en bas fourneau en Lorraine à la fin du Moyen Age
41. F. Epaud, Etude archéologique de la charpente de Notre-Dame de Paris, 2020.
42. D. Syvilay, A. Azéma, Cathédrale Notre-Dame –75, Paris. Crêtes Et épis de Faîtage. Armatures en fer – Etude, inventaire et typologie, 2020.
43. 2012
44. L. Delisle, Chronique De Robert de Torigni, Abbé Du Mont-Saint-Michel, 1872. https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/bpt6k36182g (accessed November 25, 2021).
45. The fallen arch of Notre-Dame. A reassessment of its chronology in light of new archaeological data
46. Epaud · 2019
47. Consolidation or initial design? Radiocarbon dating of ancient iron alloys sheds light on the reinforcements of French Gothic Cathedrals10.1016/j.jas.2014.10.016 ↗
48. Bayesian analysis of radiocarbon dates10.1017/S0033822200033865 ↗
49. The IntCal20 Northern Hemisphere radiocarbon age calibration curve (0–55cal kBP)10.1017/RDC.2020.41 ↗