Ethical issues in research and publication of illicit cultural property
Source abstract
Abstract
Abstract There is much discussion in conservation, if it is ethical for conservators to ‘touch’ illicit antiquities. One of the problems in studying unprovenanced archaeological objects is their publication. Many archaeologists believe that they should never publish or cite in print unprovenanced antiquities, because it indirectly supports illicit trafficking of antiquity. Some museum professionals believe that conservators’ technical and/or scientific study of such material helps to fight against criminal activity by identifying fakes and forgers. Whatever the belief, research and publication in conservation currently do not provide ethical reviews when studies involve such problematic material in order to ensure scientific integrity of the results. The paper presents case studies where ethical standards may have needed to be considered and discusses the complexity involved in authentication studies of such antiquities. The paper concludes that a standard should be drafted on ethics in research and scientific publication of cultural property similar to the biomedical field, which warns when papers deal with human and animals testing.
Source: openaire · Quality: candidate unverified · Source record ↗
Research context
OpenAlex topics: Conservation Techniques and Studies · Archaeological Research and Protection · Image Processing and 3D Reconstruction
SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.
References (61)
Show source-provided references
1. 1954 UNESCO First protocol to the Convention for the Protection of Cultural Property in the Event of Armed conflict, Hague, 1954.
2. 1954 UNESCO protocol Convention on the Means of Prohibiting and Preventing the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of Ownership of Cultural Property, Records of the General Conference 16th Session, Resolutions, vol. 1, Paris, 12 October to 14 November, 1970 pp. 135–141.
3. 1999 UNESCO Second Protocol to the Hague Convention, 1954.
4. Conservation and the antiquities trade
5. Renfrew · 2000
6. Waxman · 2008
7. Watson · 2006
8. Mackenzie · 2005
9. Atwood · 2004
10. History Lost was created with the support of the Culture 2000 Programme of the European Union with coordinator Anemon Productions.
11. Beyond Bamiyan: will the world be ready next time?
12. Material and intellectual consequences of esteem for Cycladic figures
13. Recovering stolen art
14. International antiquities trafficking: theft by another name
15. R.E. Stone, Defining Authenticity, Met Objectives 4(1) (2002) 4.
16. Rorimer · 1931
17. Craddock · 2009
18. Hoving · 1997
19. Looting: an international view
20. The forgery indictments and biblical archaeology review: learning from hindsight
21. Conservators and unprovenanced objects: preserving the cultural heritage or servicing the antiquities trade
22. The antiquities trade: an archaeological conservators perspective
23. UK Goverment-Department of Culture, Media and Sport-Cultural Property Unit. Combating illicit trade: due diligence guidelines for museums, libraries, and archives on collecting and borrowing cultural material, UK, 2005.
24. The international illicit trade in cultural heritage: can museum professionals help stop it?
25. ICOM code of ethics for museums, 2006, Section 4.5: Display of unprovenanced material and Section 5.2: Authentication and valuation (Appraisal).
26. An archaeologist's view of the trade in unprovenanced antiquities
27. Editorial policy, Information for authors and style guide, American antiquity and Latin American antiquity. http://saa.org/Portals/0/SAA/Publications/StyleGuide/styleguide.pdf, 2003 (accessed 30.09.09).
28. Editorial policy on the publication recently acquired antiquities10.3764/aja.109.2.135 ↗
29. Raman analysis of ninth-century Iraqi stuccoes from Samarra10.1016/j.jas.2006.08.002 ↗
30. Neutron resonance capture analysis of some genuine and fake Etruscan copper alloy statuettes10.1111/j.1475-4754.2004.00179.x ↗
31. Technical study of a ceremonial Sican Tumi figurine10.1111/j.1475-4754.1996.tb00778.x ↗
32. A technical examination of an ancient Egyptian painting on canvas10.1179/sic.1981.26.1.15 ↗
33. The reconstruction of a Greek vase: the Kyknos Krater10.1179/sic.1988.33.4.165 ↗
34. Technical and aesthetic considerations in the conservation of ancient ceramic and terracotta objects in the J. Paul Getty Museum: five case studies10.1179/sic.1990.35.2.69 ↗
35. Unusual pigments on a Greek marble basin10.1179/sic.1995.40.3.177 ↗
36. Texture analysis of ancient coins with TOF neutron diffraction10.1023/B:JMSC.0000026933.28906.19 ↗
37. Studies on the composition of ancient Indian punch-marked silver coins10.1002/xrs.776 ↗
38. Ancient Arabian silver coins – surface analysis by SNMS10.1007/BF00321873 ↗
39. Non-destructive analysis and identification of jade by PIXE10.1016/j.nimb.2004.01.023 ↗
40. Archaeologists, collectors, museums and John Boardman
41. Emerging ethical issues in instructions to authors of high-impact biomedical journals
42. Muscarella · 2000
43. Luminescence dating of the Tanagra terracottas of the Louvre collections
44. The Egyptian blue glass head: revealing a forgery
45. Examination of a Spanish medieval processional crucifix substantially reworked in the 20th century10.1002/jrs.1188 ↗
46. Pyrolysis gas chromatographic studies on Egyptian archaeological specimens: organic patinas on the “Three Princesses” gold vessels10.1016/0165-2370(91)80074-I ↗
47. Böttger stoneware from North America and Europe; are they authentic?10.1016/S0168-583X(99)00703-X ↗
48. K.W. Tubb, Point, counterpoint, in: N. Brondie, K.W. Tubb (Eds.), Illicit antiquities: the theft of culture, extinction of archaeology, Routledge, London, 2002 280–301.10.4324/9780203165461_chapter_16 ↗
49. Ethics for researchers, facilitating research excellence
50. Interpretation of ancient artistry: conservation of a gold wreath from the fourth century BC
51. J. Paul Getty Museum, 2007. Italian Ministry of Culture and the J. Paul Getty Museum sign agreement in Rome, Press Release, August 1.
52. Lydian bed of iron, bronze and copper: technical examination of a metallurgical masterpiece10.1179/sic.2010.55.1.3 ↗
53. Technical Examination of two ancient Greek copper plaques
54. A new data for improving authentication of bronze artefacts
55. The Shroud of Turin: blood or artists pigment?10.1021/ar00171a004 ↗
56. The double superficiality of the frontal image of the Turin Shroud10.1088/1464-4258/6/6/001 ↗
57. Radiocarbon dating of the Shroud of Turin10.1038/337611a0 ↗
58. Studies on the radiocarbon sample from the Shroud of Turin10.1016/j.tca.2004.09.029 ↗
59. Archaeometric analysis of the “Jehoash Inscription” tablet10.1016/j.jas.2008.06.019 ↗
60. Israel Antiquities Authority (IAA), Final reports on the Jehoash Inscription and James Ossuary. http://www.bibleinterp.com/articles/Final_committees_reports.shtml, 2003 (accessed 30.09.09)
61. S.V. Margolis, Authenticating ancient marble sculpture, Sci Am 260(6) (1989) 104–110.10.1038/scientificamerican0689-104 ↗