Application of plasma arc melting technology to processing of reactive metals
Source abstract
Abstract
The requirements and limitations of furnaces and plasma torches for cold hearth remelting processes are discussed and existing transferred arc plasma technology critically reviewed, placing particular emphasis on identifying which commercial systems are applicable to these processes. Areas requiring further research are identified. Titanium, Ti alloys, and superalloys are used extensively in the aerospace industry. Waste material must be recycled, owing to its high value, and refined to remove impurities. Compositional specifications must also be maintained. Plasma melting processes have been demonstrated to be a viable alternative to electron beam remelting and offer certain metallurgical advantages. An introduction to plasma melting technology is given in which the underlying concepts of cold hearth melting — electric arcs, plasma torches, and power supplies — are described; followed by a detailed review of the current state of the art of commercial plasma arc technology and processes; discussions of the process and plasma torch criteria pertinent to the development of plasma cold hearth melting processes; and conclusions and recommendations. It is concluded that while plasma cold hearth melting processes have been developed these are currently confined to the recycling of materials for the aerospace industry before vacuum arc remelting. Only hollow electrode type torches are acceptable in this application. The use of Ti and superalloy materials will expand into other, less critical, areas in the future and more and/or larger furnaces will be required. Further work is required in the areas of process, furnace, and torch design and development, specifically the influence of process conditions on product quality, and studies of torch performance – electrode erosion, operating power, and arc-melt interactions.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline
Research context
OpenAlex topics: Welding Techniques and Residual Stresses · Advanced materials and composites · Metal and Thin Film Mechanics
SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.
References (100+)
Show source-provided references
1. DAVY H.: ‘Elements of chemical philosophy’ I; 1812 London Smith and Elder.10.5479/sil.328466.39088000955757 ↗
2. SCHWABE W. E.: in Proc. 8th Int. Cong. on Electroheat Liege 1976 UIE Section Ia (8).
3. GAGE R. M.: Weld. J., 1959, 38, (10), 959–962.
4. GAGE R. M.: US Pat. 2 806 124 1957.10.1136/bmj.2.5048.806 ↗
5. GAGE R. M.: US Pat. 3 130 292 1964.10.2307/1794613 ↗
6. ‘Industry standards subject index’ 479-481; 1988 Engle-wood CO VSMF Data Control Services.10.1016/0166-1280(88)80407-X ↗
7. National Materials Advisory Board: ‘Plasma processing of materials’ Publication NMAB- 415; 1985 Washington DC National Academy Press.
8. CHOUDHURY A. WEING E. ÄRTNER: 111 ‘Metals handbook’ 9 edn Vol. 15 406–408; 1988 Materials Park OH ASM International.
9. BARBER G. F. and it. BAKISH: in ‘Introduction to electron beam technology’ (ed. Bakish R.); 1962 New York Wiley.
10. 10.1179/imtr.1986.31.1.7710.1179/imtr.1986.31.1.77 ↗
11. National Materials Advisory Board: `Electroslag remelting and plasma arc melting' Publication NMAB- 324; 1976 Washington DC National Academy of Sciences.
12. CHOUDHURY A. ICEMMER H.: in ‘Metals handbook’ 9 edn Vol. 15 393–399; 1988 Materials Park OH ASM International.
13. comvroN K. T.: Trans. AIEE, 1927, 46, 868–883.
14. FINKELNBURG W. MAECKER H.: in ‘Handbuch der Physik’ Band 22 (ed. Fliigge E.) 254-449; 1956 Berlin Springer.10.1007/978-3-642-45847-7_4 ↗
15. GUILE A. E.: Proc. IEE IEE Rev. 1971 118 (9R) 1131-1154.10.1049/piee.1971.0246 ↗
16. COBINE J. D.: ‘Gaseous conductors. Theory and engineering applications’; 1958 New York Dover.
17. ECKER G.: Ergeb. exakt. Naturwissen., 1961, 33, 1–104.
18. ENGEL A. VON: ‘Ionized gases’; 1965 London New York Oxford University Press (Clarendon).
19. HOYAUX M. F.: ‘Arc physics’; 1968 New York Springer-Verlag.10.1007/978-3-642-85652-5 ↗
20. GROSSE B. GRYCZ B. MIKLOSSY K.: ‘Plasma technology’ (English edn. ed. R. C. G. Leckey); 1968 London Iliffe.
21. PFENDER E.: in ‘Gaseous electronics. Vol. I Electrical discharges’ (ed. Hirsh M. N. Oskam H. J.) 291-398; 1978 London Academic Press.10.1016/B978-0-12-349701-7.50010-9 ↗
22. DEMBOVSKY v.: ‘Plasma metallurgy — the principles’: 1985 New York Elsevier.
23. LANGMUIR I.: Gen. Elect. Re v., 26, 731–735.
24. 10.1103/PhysRev.21.62310.1103/PhysRev.21.623 ↗
25. ZHUKOV M. F. BORTNITCHOUK N. I. KROUTIANSKY M. I.: in Proc. 8th Int. Cong. on Electroheat Liege 1976 U1E Section IIc (7).
26. USHIO M.: in Proc. 8th Int. Symp. on Plasma Chemistry Toyko 1987 IUPAC Paper S1-02.
27. 10.1103/PhysRev.34.61110.1103/PhysRev.34.611 ↗
28. 10.1063/1.173611210.1063/1.1736112 ↗
29. 10.1103/PhysRev.74.147510.1103/PhysRev.74.1475 ↗
30. 10.1007/BF0132964210.1007/BF01329642 ↗
31. SCHOUMAKER H. R. P.: in Proc. 8th Int. Cong. on Electro-heat Liege 1976 UIE Section lb. (1).
32. THORPE M. C.: in ‘Advances in extractive metallurgy and refining’ 275-288; 1972 London Institution of Mining and Metallurgy.
33. ZHUHOV M. F., PUSTOGAROV A. V., Ya. R. KUCHEROV, and V. I-ZAVIDEI: Contrib. Plasma Phys., 1986, 26, (5), 321–334.
34. WEATHERLY M. H., ANDERSON J. E.: Electrochem. Technol., 1965, 3, (3-4), 80–84.
35. FRIDYLAND M. G. et al.: Weld. Prod., 1985, 49-5 2.
36. ESCHENBACH R. C. BARCZA N. A. REID K. S.: in ‘Plasma technology in metallurgical processing’ (ed. Feinman J.) 77-87; 1987 Warrendale PA Iron and Steel Society of AIME.
37. HOWATSON A. M.: ‘An introduction to gas discharges’ 2 edn 93; 1976 Oxford Pergamon.
38. ZHUKOV M. F. (ed.): ‘Near-electrode processes and elec-trode erosion in plasmatrons’ Academy of Sciences of the USSR Siberian Dept Institute of Thermophysics Novosi-birsk 1977 (in Russian).
39. FEY M. G., McDONALD J.: in AIChE Symp. Ser. 186, 75, 31–37.
40. 10.1049/ip-d.1981.002110.1049/ip-d.1981.0021 ↗
41. RAHAL A. M.: J. Phys. D, App!. Phys., 1986, 19, L33—L36.
42. DONALDSON A. L. KRISTIANSEN M. WATSON A. ZINS-MEYER K. KRISTIANSEN E.: IEEE Trans. Magnetics 1986 MAG- 22 (6) 1441–1447.10.1109/TMAG.1986.1064638 ↗
43. 10.1007/BF0101583010.1007/BF01015830 ↗
44. DAVIS R. M.: ‘Power diode and thyristor circuits’; 1971 London Cambridge University Press and Institution of Electrical Engineers.
45. ‘Silicon rectifier handbook’ 2 edn; 1973 Motorola Semi-conductor Products.
46. ESSMANN H., GRUNBERG D.: Stahl Eisen, 1983, 103, (3), 133–137.
47. MEREDITH D., STENKVIST S. E.: Iron Steelmaker, 1987, 14, (5), 53–56.
48. SPIVEY P. B., MUELLER E. G.-: Elect. Furn. Conf. Proc. AIME, 1985, 43, 93–100.
49. FINNEY D.: ‘The power thyristor and its applications’; 1980 McGraw-Hill Book Co. (UK) Ltd.
50. RICE J. B.: in ‘Power semiconductor applications Vol. 1: General considerations’ 485-489; 1969 New York Insti-tution of Electrical and Electronic Engineers.
51. BRowNsEy C. M. CSUROS L.: in ‘Abnormal loads on powers systems’ ed. Robinson J. E. L.) Paper No. 23; 1963 London Institution of Electrical Engineers.
52. SAYCE I. G.: in ‘Advances in extraction metallurgy and refining’ 241-274; 1972 London Institution of Mining and Metallurgy.
53. HAMBLYN S. M. L.: Miner Sci. Eng., 1977, 9, (3), 151–176.
54. 10.1351/pac19805207180110.1351/pac198052071801 ↗
55. BHAT G. K.: ‘Establishment of a plasma melting manufactur-ing process for production of nickel-base alloys’ Tech. Rep. AFML—TR-75-80 Carnegie-Mellon University Pitts-burgh PA and Air Force Materials Laboratories 1975.
56. BHAT G. K.: ‘Plasma technology and its industrial appli-cations’ EPR1 Rep. RP 1275-4-00 Electric Power Research Institute Palo Alto CA 1981.
57. FRUEHAN R. J.: ‘Plasma processes for metals production — a scoping study’ CMP Rep. No. 85-3 Carnegie-Mellon University Pittsburgh PA 1985.
58. EDDY T. L. HEBERLEIN J. V. R. (eds.): NSF ‘Workshop on thermal plasma systems’ New Hampshire Highway Hotel Concord NH 15-18 Aug. 1986 National Science Foun-dation Georgia Institute of Technology and Westinghouse R. & D Center.
59. Workshop EPRI; ‘Research opportunities for plasma pro-cessing’ (organisers P. Estey R. Scott and J. Stringer) Electric Power Research Institute Palo Alto CA 1987.
60. FEINMAN J. (ed.): ‘Plasma technology in metallurgical processing’; 1987 Warrendale PA Iron and Steel Society of AIME.
61. EATON B. E., LAKOMSKII V. I., DUDKO D. A., 0. S. ZABARILO, I. S. PRYANISHNIKOV, and V. V. TOPILIN: Avtom. Svarka, 1966, 19, (8), 1–5.
62. ROMAN W. C.: IEEE Trans. Plasma Sci. 1986 PS- 14 (4) 370–383.10.1109/TPS.1986.4316564 ↗
63. YAJIMA T. TAMARI O. ICAMIYA H. HIRATAKE S. NAKANISHI Y. KATO K. YAMADA H. YOSHIDA K.: in Proc. Int. Conf. on `Ti products and applications' San Francisco CA Oct. 1986 Titanium Development Association et al.
64. 10.1007/BF0265843510.1007/BF02658435 ↗
65. MIMURA K. NANJO M.: in Proc. 8th Int. Symp. on Plasma Chemistry Toyko 1987 IUPAC Paper D11-07.
66. 10.1016/0022-5088(89)90205-110.1016/0022-5088(89)90205-1 ↗
67. FISHER R. W.: ‘A nonconsumable arc-melting furnace’ Rep. SAND81-0810 Sandia National Laboratories Albuquer-que NM 1981.
68. FIEDLER H. LACHNER W. BELICA G. MEULLER F. BORTNICHUK N. L KRUTJANSKY M. M.: in Proc. 5th Int. Symp. on Electroslag Melting Pittsburgh PA 1974 American Society for Metals and Mellon Institute of Carnegie-Mellon University 466-476.
69. KOLZER U.: Voest-Alpine Industrieanlagenbau Linz Austria personal communication 1989.
70. MUELLER H. G.: Voest-Alpine Industrieanlagenbau Linz Austria personal communication 1990.
71. MÜELLER H. G. KOCH E. DOSAJ V. D. WELLBELOVED D.: in Proc. Workshop on ‘Industrial plasma applications’ Pug-nochiuso Italy 1989 IUPAC (ed. Boulos M. I.) Vol. 2 50-59.
72. DOSAJ V. D. MAY J. B. MUELLER H. G. KOCH E.: in Proc. Infacon '89 5th Int. Ferroalloys Cong. New Orleans LA 1989 206-212.
73. DOSAJ V. D. MAY J. B. RAUCHHOLZ A. W. MUELLER H. G. MATZAWRAKOS P.: in Symp. ‘Industrial and environ-mental applications of plasma’ Palo Alto CA 1990 Electric Power Research Institute.
74. TYLKO J. K.: ‘Manufacture of hydraulic cements from waste materials’, ICS Proc., 1978, 62-6 8.
75. COWX P. M. HEANLEY C. P.: in ‘Extraction metallurgy '85’ 593-606; 1985 London Institution of Mining and Metallurgy.
76. PAGE D. G. HEANLEY C. P. at P.. COWX: in Proc. MINTEK 50 Int. Conf. on ‘Mineral science and tech-nology’ Johannesburg Mar. 1984 South African Council for Mineral Technology 1-27.
77. COWX P. M. HEANLEY c. P.: in IEE Colloq. on ‘Thermal plasma industrial processes’ Teesside Polytechnic Mid-dlesbrough UK 4 June 1985.
78. MOORE C., HEANLEY C. P., COWX P. M.: Steel Times Int., 1989, 217.
79. COWX P. M. RODDIS B.: in Proc. Reinhardt Schumann Int. Symp. on ‘Innovative technology and reactor design in extractive metallurgy’ Colorado Springs CO 1986 Metal-lurgical Society of AIME 73-85.
80. COWX P. M.: presentation at Symp. ‘Industrial and environ-mental applications of plasma’ Palo Alto CA 1990 Electric Power Research Institute.
81. MAZANEK M. S. PARGETER J. K. COWX P. M.: presenta-tion at Symp. ‘Industrial and environmental applications of plasma’ Palo Alto CA 1990 Electric Power Research Institute.
82. CHANDRA U., HARTWIG J., ULRICH K. H.: Tech. Mitt. Krupp Forsch. Ber., 1973, 31, (1), 1–9.
83. FEY M. G.: Ind. Heating, 1976, 46.
84. STENKVIST S. E.: in Proc. MINTEK 50 Int. Conf. on ‘Mineral science and technology’ Johannesburg 1984 South African Council for Mineral Technology 769-775.
85. CURR T. R. NICOL K. C. MOONEY J. F. STEWART A. B. BARCZA N. A.: in Proc. MINTEK 50 Int. Conf. on ‘Recent advances in mineral science and technology’ Johannes-burg 1984 South African Council for Mineral Technology 863-872.
86. NADEN D. KERSHAW P. WIGHTMAN G.: in Pyrometal-lurgy ‘87’ 813-835; 1987 London Institution of Mining and Metallurgy.
87. BREITZMANN M.: Mannesmann Demag Hfittentechnik Duis-berg Germany personal communication 1989.
88. BEBBER H. BREITZMANN M. SOEJIMA T. MATSUO K.: in Proc. ‘Workshop on industrial plasma applications’ Pugno-chiuso Italy 1989 IUPAC (ed. Boulos M. I.) Vol. 2 71-79.
89. GAUVIN W. H. KUBANEK G. R. MEHMETOGLU M. T. CHOI H. K.: in Proc. 5th Int. Symp. on Plasma Chemistry Edinburgh 1981 IUPAC Vol. 1 186-196.
90. KERSHAW P. MOSS D. J. GILL M. E. HEGGIE J. G.: in ‘Extraction metallurgy '89’ 197-208; 1989 London Insti-tution of Mining and Metallurgy.
91. MACRAE D. R.: in AIChE Symp. Ser. 186, 75, 25–30.
92. ASADA C., ADACHI T.: Neue HiMe, 1971, 16, (11), 657–660.
93. BARCZA N. A.: in ‘Plasma technology in metallurgical processing’ (ed. Feinman J.) 136; 1987 Warrendale PA Iron and Steel Society of AIME.
94. YAMADA H. YOSHIDA K. SHIMIZU T.: in Proc. 7th Int. Conf. on Vacuum Metallurgy Tokyo 1982 The Iron and Steel Institute of Japan et al. 1086-1093.
95. FUKUMOTO S., NAKAO N., FUJI M., TAKEUCHI H.: ‘Melting and casting of titanium sponge in electron beam cold hearth melting process’, Central R & D Bureau, Nippon Steel Corp. Hikari City, Japan, 1989.
96. KUWABARA T. UMEZAWA K. NUIBE T. FUKUYAMA M.: in Proc. 8th Int. Symp. on Plasma Chemistry Toyko 1987 IUPAC Paper No. 51-05 2247-2252.
97. SHINODA T. HIROTSU N. SHIRAISHI H. MATSUMOTO K. NOMURA I. NOMURA H. TAKEDA K.: in Proc. Workshop on ‘Industrial plasma applications’ Pugnochiuso Italy 1989 IUPAC (ed. Boulos M. I.) Vol. 2 61-70.
98. AMAKAWA T. ADACHI K. YASUI S. SHIBUYA M. INABA T. FUKUGAWA H. HIROTSU N. SHINODA T. TAJIMA N. TAKEDA K. KUSANO K.: presentation at Symp. ‘Industrial and environmental applications of plasma’ Palo Alto CA 1990 Electric Power Research Institute.
99. 10.1116/1.57092010.1116/1.570920 ↗
100. BHAT G. K.: in ‘Plasma technology in metallurgical pro-cessing’ (ed. Feinman J.) 171; 1987 Warrendale PA Iron and Steel Society of AIME.