Effect of Oblique Impact Angles on Fracture Patterns in Laminated Glass Plates Impacted by a 10 mm Steel Ball

Many studies have examined normal impacts on glass, but data on oblique impacts are limited, and, in particular, there is very limited experimental data on oblique impacts at various angles under consistent experimental conditions. Therefore, this study investigated fracture patterns of 5 mm thick low-emissivity (low-e) glass impacted by a 10 mm steel ball at velocities of 40 to 50 m/s at various oblique impact angles from 0° to 80°. Results showed that fracture patterns varied clearly with impact angle. Truncated cone fractures occurred in all specimens at 0° to 60°, while three of six specimens did not fracture at 80° because the normal energy dropped to below damage limit energy. Damage parameters normalized by kinetic energy showed that Cmax/KE and Cmin/KE remained stable at 5.7–6.4 and 4.9–5.3 mm/J from 0° to 45°, but dropped sharply to 0.7 and 0.6 mm/J at 80°. The aspect ratio of cone cracks remained relatively constant (1.2–1.3) regardless of oblique impact angle, while the aspect ratio of perforated holes increased from 1.0 (0°) to 1.6 (60°) before decreasing at 80°. Steel ball size comparison confirmed that normalized damage patterns are not significantly affected by projectile size variations. Mechanism-based analysis revealed that cone cracks and perforated holes are governed by fundamentally different physical processes. Cone cracks form through axisymmetric stress fields following Hertzian contact theory, showing limited angular sensitivity (15.4% maximum eccentricity change). In contrast, perforated holes result from trajectory-dependent mechanical penetration, exhibiting extreme angular sensitivity with 338.9% eccentricity increase from 0° to 60°. This 22-fold difference demonstrates a dual damage mechanism framework that explains the pronounced angular dependence of hole geometry versus the relative stability of cone crack patterns. These findings provide essential data for forensic glass analysis and impact-resistant glazing design, while the dual mechanism concept offers new insights into angle-dependent fracture behavior of brittle materials.