journal article·2025-01-30Open access

Root Cause Analysis of a Collapse in a Hydropower Tunnel

Paul Schlotfeldt, Joe Carvalho, Brad Panton

Applied Sciences· Volume 15· Issue 3

Abstract

This paper describes the investigation and findings from the root cause analysis (RCA) of a significant collapse that occurred in a hydropower tunnel at a confidential location. This collapse involved about 12,000 m3 of material being deposited in the tunnel from a narrow 20 m width failure zone encountered in the haunch and crown area of the main power tunnel. This paper describes contributing factors which include the following: (1) degradation of a highly zeolitized (laumontite-rich) zone of rock within a bedding concordant fault zone, termed the fault-damaged zone or FDZ; (2) relatively high in situ rock stresses concentrated in the haunch and crown area of the collapse zone in the tunnel; (3) large transient water pressure differences in the rock above the collapse zone and upstream and downstream of the collapse zone; (4) cyclical repetition of the above-described factors resulted in the propagation of crown and sidewall collapse in and around the FDZ. Lessons learnt on this project and other projects with similar durability problems in volcanic rock are distilled in this paper. It is hoped that advances made in the understanding of the failure mechanism at the unnamed tunnel can be included in future tunnel investigations and design in volcanic rocks.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Rock Mechanics and Modeling · Geotechnical Engineering and Underground Structures · Tunneling and Rock Mechanics

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

Affiliations

WSP Canada Inc., 590 McKay Avenaute, Suite 300, Kelowna, BC V1Y 5A8, Canada

WSP Canada Inc., 6925 Century Avenue, Floor 6, Mississauga, ON L5N 7K2, Canada

WSP Canada Inc., 201 Columbia Ave, Castlegar, BC V1N 1A8, Canada

References (50)

Show source-provided references
1. Swelling rock in tunnels: Rock characterization, effect of horizontal stresses and construction procedures10.1016/0148-9062(93)91720-4 ↗
2. Stability problems in water tunnels caused by expandable minerals. Swelling pressure measurements and mineralogical analysis10.1016/0013-7952(95)00009-5 ↗
3. Tunnelling in difficult ground—Swelling behaviour and identification of swelling rocks10.1007/BF01032649 ↗
4. Cause of swelling phenomena in tunnelling and a proposal for a design procedure for a swelling tunnel10.3208/sandf.36.4_101 ↗
5. Castro, S., Van Sint Jan, M., Gonzalez, R., Lois, P., and Velasco, L.E. (2003, January 8–12). Dealing with expansive rocks in the Los Quilos and Chacabuquito water tunnels-Andes mountains of central Chile. Proceedings of the 10th ISRM Congress, Sandton, South Africa.
6. Galera, J., Paredes, M., Menchero, C., and Pozo, V. (2014, January 26–28). Risk Associated with Swelling Rocks in Volcanic Formations in the Design of Hydro-Tunnels. Proceedings of the ISRM Regional Symposium-EUROCK 2014, Vigo, Spain.10.1201/b16955-144 ↗
7. Existing methods for swelling tests—A critical review10.1016/j.egypro.2015.07.857 ↗
8. Squeezing failure of tunnels: A case study10.1016/j.tust.2018.04.007 ↗
9. Brox, D. (2019). Hydropower tunnel failures: Risks and causes. Tunnels and Underground Cities: Engineering and Innovation Meet Archaeology, Architecture and Art, CRC Press.10.1201/9780429424441-464 ↗
10. Investigation on the effect of cyclic moisture change on rock swelling in hydropower water tunnels10.1007/s00603-020-02266-1 ↗
11. Designing tunnel lining in anhydritic claystones. Intensity and distribution of swelling forces10.1007/s00603-022-03107-z ↗
12. Engineering classification of rock masses for the design of tunnel support10.1007/BF01239496 ↗
13. Some new Q-value correlations to assist in site characterization and tunnel design10.1016/S1365-1609(02)00011-4 ↗
14. Use and misuse of rock mass classification systems with particular reference to the Q-system10.1016/j.tust.2005.10.005 ↗
15. Support Decision Critieria for Tunnels in Fault Zones
16. Tunnelling in fault zones—State of the art10.1016/j.tust.2005.12.191 ↗
17. Anagnostou, G., and Kovári, K. (2005, January 7–10). Tunnelling through geological fault zones. In Proceedings of International Symposium on Design, Construction and Operation of Long Tunnels, Taipei, Taiwan.
18. Groundwater effect on faulted rock mass: An evaluation of Modi Khola pressure tunnel in the Nepal Himalaya10.1007/s00603-013-0467-7 ↗
19. Anagnostou, G., and Kovari, K. (2005). Tunnelling Through Geological Fault Zones, ETH. Zurich Research Collection.
20. Vrkljan, I. (2009). Tunnelling in Overstressed Rock. Rock Engineering in Difficult Ground Conditions—Soft Rocks and Karst, Taylor and Francis Group.10.1201/9781482288841 ↗
21. Dehydration-hydration reactivity of laumontite: Analyses and tests for easy detection10.1180/claymin.2017.052.3.03 ↗
22. Ghimire, S., Panthi, K.K., and Vereide, K. (2023). Hydraulic Transient Impact on Surrounding Rock Mass of Unlined Pressure Tunnels. Water, 15.10.3390/w15223894 ↗
23. Twiss, R.J., and Moore, E.M. (1992). Structural Geology, W.H. Freeman.
24. Bish, D.L., and Post, J.E. (1989). Modern Powder Diffraction, De Gruyter. Reviews in Mineralogy & Geochemistry.10.1515/9781501509018 ↗
25. Schlotfeldt, P.J.E. (1995). Assessment of Basalt Durability. Unpublished Report No. 1009/24/00. Lesotho Highlands Tunnel Partnership (Mohale), Lesotho Highlands Development Authority.
26. A geotechnical overview of Katse dam and transfer tunnel, Lesotho, with a note on basalt durability10.1016/S0013-7952(96)00110-X ↗
27. Schlotfeldt, P. (1999). The Engineering Geology of the Katse Arch Dam, Lesotho Highlands. [Ph.D. Thesis, University of Cape Town].
28. Bell, F.G., Haskins, D.R., and Jermy, C.A. (2000, January 19–24). Basalt Durability and the Transfer Tunnel: Lesotho Highlands Water Project. Proceedings of the Conference Proceedings—GeoEng 2000, Melbourne, Australia.
29. Schlotfeldt, P. (2014, January 26–28). Assessment of basalt durability in tunnels—The Lesotho Highlands water scheme experience (Southern Africa). Proceedings of the Conference Proceedings—Vancouver TAC 2014—Tunneling in a Resource Diven World, Vancouver, BC, Canada.
30. Burial metamorphism
31. Low grade regional metamorphism: Phase equilibrium relations10.1146/annurev.ea.02.050174.001143 ↗
32. Sand, L.B., and Mumpton, F.A. (1978). Zeolite zones in geothermal areas in Iceland. Natural Zeolites, Occurrence, Properties, Use, Springer.
33. A chlorite solid solution geothermometer the Los Azufres (Mexico) geothermal system10.1007/BF00413350 ↗
34. Phase equilibria and mineral parageneses of metabasites in low-grade metamorphism10.1180/minmag.1985.049.352.03 ↗
35. Secondary mineralization and hydrothermal alteration in the Reydarfjordur drill core, eastern Iceland10.1029/JB087iB08p06511 ↗
36. Dehydration veins in diagenetic and very-low-grade metamorphic rocks: Features of the crustal seismogenic zone and their significance to mineral facies10.1111/j.1525-1314.1993.tb00156.x ↗
37. The smectite-chlorite transition in drillhole NJ-15, Nesjavellier geothermal field, Iceland: XRD, BSE and electron microprobe investigations10.1111/j.1525-1314.1991.tb00558.x ↗
38. Regional and local patterns of low-grade metamorphism in the North Shore Volcanic Group, Minnesota, USA10.1111/j.1525-1314.1993.tb00157.x ↗
39. Geothermal-type alteration in a burial metamorphosed volcanic pile, central Chile10.1111/j.1525-1314.1993.tb00161.x ↗
40. Secondary mineral zonation in the Drakensberg Basalt Formation, South Africa
41. MacKellar, D.C.R., and Reid, J.A.F. Mineralogical Aspects of the Durability of Basalt in the Lesotho Highlands. Tuncon ’94: Advances in Underground Construction with Special Reference to Tunnelling in Basalt.
42. The chemistry and petrogenesis of igneous rocks of the Karoo central area, Southern Africa
43. Some technical lessons learnt from construction of the Lesotho Highlands Water Project transfer tunnel10.1016/S0886-7798(99)00011-5 ↗
44. ISRM (1979). Suggested methods for determining water content, porosity, density, absorption and related properties and swelling and slake-durability index properties. Int. J. Rock Mech. Min. Sci. Geomech. Abstr., 16, 141–156.10.1016/0148-9062(79)91453-0 ↗
45. ISRM (1989). Suggested methods for laboratory testing of argillaceous swelling rocks. Int. J. Rock Mech. Min. Sci. Geomech. Abstr., 26, 415–426.
46. ISRM (1999). Suggested methods for laboratory testing of swelling rocks. Int. J. Rock Mech. Min. Sci., 36, 291–306.
47. (2008). Standard Test Methods for One-Dimensional Swell or Collapse of Cohesive Soils (Standard No. ASTM D4546-08).
48. Chaudhary, B., Panthi, K.K., and Trinh, N.Q. (2023, January 9–14). Assessment on the in-situ rock stress condition along an unlined pressure tunnel/shaft of a Norwegian Hydropower Project using numerical modeling. Proceedings of the ISRM Congress ISRM–15CONGRESS, Salzburg, Austria.
49. Hoek, E., Carranza-Torres, C., Diederichs, M., and Corkum, B. (2008, January 29). The 2008 Kersten Lecture Integration of geotechnical and structural design in tunneling. Proceedings of the 56th Annual Geotechnical Engineering Conference, Minneapolis, MN, USA.
50. (2024, December 24). Phase2-2D Finite Element Program for Calculating Stresses and Estimating Support around Underground Excavations. Available online: https://www.rocscience.com/downloads/phase2/Phase2_ModelReference.pdf.