Effect of Rubber Cup Rotational Speeds during Tooth Polishing on Sound, Early Caries, and Cracked Tooth Surfaces

High-speed rubber cup polishing can exacerbate tooth surface damage, especially when preexisting conditions such as early caries or cracks exist. This study aimed to quantify the extent of damage to sound teeth based on rotating rubber cup speed and assess the damage in relation to the tooth surface condition. Using a rubber cup, 36 sound teeth were polished at 100, 3000, and 10,000 rpm, and 24 teeth with early carious lesions and 24 cracked teeth were polished at 3000 and 10,000 rpm. Polishing was performed using a rubber cup and prophylaxis paste, applying an on–off method (3.0 N force for 3 s). Damage depth was quantified using a surface profilometer and examined using scanning electron microscopy. Polishing at 10,000 rpm caused significantly more damage to sound teeth than polishing at lower speeds (depth increase: 71.45 ± 15.12 µm at 100 rpm; 61.91 ± 17.82 µm at 3000 rpm; p < 0.001). Teeth with early carious lesions or cracks demonstrated more damage after polishing than sound teeth (p < 0.05). Therefore, the rotational speed of the rubber cup has a critical impact on the extent of enamel damage. Higher speeds can increase the damage depth in both sound and damaged tooth surfaces.