journal article·2024-06-19Open access

Validity and Reliability of New Three-Dimensional Reference Systems for Soft Tissue Analysis Using Non-Ionizing Three-Dimensional Imaging

Roberto Rongo, Vincenzo D’Antò, Ambrosina Michelotti, Marie A. Cornelis, Paolo M. Cattaneo

Applied Sciences· Volume 14· Issue 12

Abstract

Background: The aim of this study was to evaluate the accuracy and the repeatability of two reference systems for three-dimensional facial scans (FSs) compared with a reference system based on cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT). Subjects and methods: A total of sixty subjects, thirty growing participants (8–17 years old) and thirty non-growing participants (older than 21 years old), with FSs and full-field-of-view CBCT were included. Two different reference systems on the same FS were constructed. To assess validity, the two reference systems based on FSs were compared with the reference systems built using the CBCT scans. After two weeks, all of the FSs were reassessed to evaluate intra-operator repeatability. Reliability and repeatability were evaluated by means of parametric and non-parametric tests, intra-class correlation, the Dahlberg formula, and Bland–Altman plots (p < 0.05). Results: Both reference systems presented good reliability and showed a small difference with respect to the CBCT-based sagittal plane (Sagittal FS1 = 1.90 ± 0.98°; Sagittal FS2 = 1.80 ± 1.13°; p = 0.232). Between them, the two reference systems showed a small difference in the position of the sagittal plane (Sagittal FS1^Sagittal FS2 = 1.39 ± 1.13°). Conclusions: Both reference systems assessed in this study showed good intra-operator repeatability and their use may be suggested as reliable reference systems for FSs.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Nuclear Physics and Applications · Body Composition Measurement Techniques

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

Affiliations

School of Orthodontics, Department of Neurosciences, Reproductive Sciences and Oral Sciences, University of Naples Federico II, Via Pansini, 5, 80131 Naples, Italy

Melbourne Dental School, Faculty of Medicine, Dentistry, and Health Sciences, University of Melbourne, Melbourne, VIC 3010, Australia

References (49)

Show source-provided references
1. Use of 3-dimensional surface acquisition to study facial morphology in 5 populations10.1016/j.ajodo.2009.04.022 ↗
2. Assessment of motivation and psychological characteristics of adult orthodontic patients10.1016/j.ajodo.2011.06.022 ↗
3. Oral health-related quality of life after orthodontic treatment for anterior tooth alignment: Association with emotional state and sociodemographic factors10.1007/s00056-016-0018-4 ↗
4. The emerging soft tissue paradigm in orthodontic diagnosis and treatment planning10.1111/ocr.1999.2.2.49 ↗
5. Anthropometric determination of craniofacial morphology10.1002/ajmg.1320650102 ↗
6. Facial growth in man, studied with the AID of metallic implants10.3109/00016355509028170 ↗
7. Growth changes in the soft tissue facial profile
8. Facial growth: Separating shape from size10.1093/ejo/23.3.275 ↗
9. Appropriate use of ionizing radiation in orthodontic practice and research10.1016/j.ajodo.2014.11.010 ↗
10. Evaluation of accuracy of photogrammetry with 3D scanning and conventional impression method for craniomaxillofacial defects using a software analysis10.1186/s13063-022-07005-1 ↗
11. Kluge, J., Bruggink, R., Pandis, N., Unkovskiy, A., Jost-Brinkmann, P.-G., Kuijpers-Jagtman, A.M., and Bartzela, T. (2023). Longitudinal Three-Dimensional Stereophotogrammetric Growth Analysis in Infants with Unilateral Cleft Lip and Palate from 3 to 12 Months of Age. J. Clin. Med., 12.10.3390/jcm12206432 ↗
12. Cascos, R., del Amo, L.O., Álvarez-Guzmán, F., Antonaya-Martín, J.L., Celemín-Viñuela, A., Gómez-Costa, D., Zafra-Vallejo, M., Agustín-Panadero, R., and Gómez-Polo, M. (2023). Accuracy between 2D Photography and Dual-Structured Light 3D Facial Scanner for Facial Anthropometry: A Clinical Study. J. Clin. Med., 12.10.3390/jcm12093090 ↗
13. Facial surface morphology predicts variation in internal skeletal shape10.1016/j.ajodo.2015.09.028 ↗
14. Three-dimensional analysis of facial morphology surface changes in untreated children from 12 to 14 years of age10.1016/j.ajodo.2007.01.037 ↗
15. Three-dimensional evaluation of the relationship between jaw divergence and facial soft tissue dimensions10.2319/092313-699.1 ↗
16. Two-dimensional versus three-dimensional Fränkel Manoeuvre: A reproducibility study10.1093/ejo/cjz081 ↗
17. Long-Term Stability of Condylectomy and Costochondral Graft Reconstruction for Treatment of Idiopathic Condylar Resorption10.1016/j.joms.2018.10.007 ↗
18. Comparison of the effects on facial soft tissues produced by rapid and slow maxillary expansion using stereophotogrammetry: A randomized clinical trial10.1186/s40510-023-00498-9 ↗
19. Three-dimensional analysis of hard and soft tissue changes in skeletal class II patients with high mandibular plane angle undergoing surgery10.1038/s41598-024-51322-1 ↗
20. Treatment and posttreatment changes in patients with Class II, Division 1 malocclusion after extraction and nonextraction treatment10.1016/S0889-5406(97)70297-X ↗
21. A three-dimensional evaluation of Māori and New Zealand European faces10.2478/aoj-2014-0014 ↗
22. The 3D Facial Norms Database: Part 1. A Web-Based Craniofacial Anthropometric and Image Repository for the Clinical and Research Community10.1597/15-199 ↗
23. Immediate effect of clear aligners and fixed appliances on perioral soft tissues and speech10.1111/ocr.12625 ↗
24. Validity and reliability of craniofacial anthropometric measurement of 3D digital photogrammetric images10.1597/06-175 ↗
25. Jayaratne, Y.S.N., McGrath, C.P.J., and Zwahlen, R.A. (2012). How accurate are the fusion of cone-beam CT and 3-D stereophotographic images?. PLoS ONE, 7.10.1371/journal.pone.0049585 ↗
26. Development and reproducibility of a 3D stereophotogrammetric reference frame for facial soft tissue growth of babies and young children with and without orofacial clefts10.1016/j.ijom.2012.07.006 ↗
27. A simple and accurate craniofacial midsagittal plane definition10.1016/j.ajodo.2016.12.025 ↗
28. Effects of different rapid maxillary expansion appliances on facial soft tissues using three-dimensional imaging10.2319/051115-319.1 ↗
29. Dahlberg, G. (1940). Statistical methods for medical and biological students. Statistical Methods for Medical and Biological Students, George Allen & Unwin.
30. Exploring the midline soft tissue surface changes from 12 to 15 years of age in three distinct country population cohorts10.1093/ejo/cjz080 ↗
31. Evaluation of reproducibility and reliability of 3D soft tissue analysis using 3D stereophotogrammetry10.1016/j.ijom.2008.12.009 ↗
32. Orthodontic soft-tissue parameters: A comparison of cone-beam computed tomography and the 3dMD imaging system10.1016/j.ajodo.2013.07.007 ↗
33. Accuracy and reliability of 3D stereophotogrammetry: A comparison to direct anthropometry and 2D photogrammetry10.2319/041415-244.1 ↗
34. Superimposition of serial 3-dimensional facial photographs to assess changes over time: A systematic review10.1016/j.ajodo.2021.06.017 ↗
35. Reproducibility of soft tissue landmarks on three-dimensional facial scans10.1093/ejo/cjl024 ↗
36. Three-dimensional imaging in orthognathic surgery: The clinical application of a new method
37. Reproducibility of facial soft tissue landmarks on 3D laser-scanned facial images10.1111/j.1601-6343.2008.01435.x ↗
38. Facial soft tissue changes during the pre-pubertal and pubertal growth phase: A mixed longitudinal laser-scanning study10.1093/ejo/cjw008 ↗
39. Facial keys to orthodontic diagnosis and treatment planning. Part I10.1016/0889-5406(93)70010-L ↗
40. Three-dimensional surface imaging: Limitations and considerations from the anthropometric perspective10.1097/01.SCS.0000164330.96675.0C ↗
41. Validation and reproducibility of a high-resolution three-dimensional facial imaging system10.1016/j.bjoms.2007.04.017 ↗
42. Facial soft-tissue changes after rapid maxillary expansion analyzed with 3-dimensional stereophotogrammetry: A randomized, controlled clinical trial10.2319/111315-766.1 ↗
43. Validation of a three-dimensional facial scanning system based on structured light techniques10.1016/j.cmpb.2009.01.010 ↗
44. Metric precision via soft-tissue landmarks in three-dimensional structured-light scans of human faces10.1007/s00056-013-0201-9 ↗
45. Soft tissue effects of twin block and herbst appliances in patients with class ii division 1 mandibular retrognathy10.1093/ejo/cjq187 ↗
46. Long-term soft-tissue response to orthodontic treatment with early cervical headgear—A randomized study10.1016/j.ajodo.2007.05.024 ↗
47. Martina, S., Di Stefano, M.L., Paduano, F.P., Aiello, D., Valletta, R., and Paduano, S. (2020). Evaluation of profile changes in class II individuals treated by means of herbst miniscope appliance. Dent. J., 8.10.3390/dj8010027 ↗
48. Three-dimensional soft tissue changes in orthodontic extraction and non-extraction patients: A prospective study10.1111/ocr.12506 ↗
49. Brons, S., van Beusichem, M.E., Bronkhorst, E.M., Draaisma, J.M., Bergé, S.J., Schols, J.G., and Kuijpers-Jagtman, A.M. (2014). Methods to quantify soft tissue-based cranial growth and treatment outcomes in children: A systematic review. PLoS ONE, 9.10.1371/journal.pone.0089602 ↗