A Finite Element Investigation into the Effect of Slope of Grain on Wood Baseball Bat Durability
Source abstract
Abstract
Bat durability is defined as the relative bat/ball speed that results in bat breakage, i.e., the higher the speed required to initiate bat cracking, the better the durability. In 2008, Major League Baseball added a regulation to the Wooden Baseball Bat Standards concerning Slope-of-Grain (SoG), defined to be the angle of the grain of the wood in the bat with respect to a line parallel to the longitudinal axis of the bat, as part of an overall strategy to reverse what was perceived to be an increasing rate of wood bats breaking into multiple pieces during games. The combination of a set of regulations concerning wood density, prescribed hitting surface, and SoG led to a 30% reduction in the rate of multi-piece failures. In an effort to develop a fundamental understanding of how changes in the SoG impact the resulting bat durability, a popular professional bat profile was examined using the finite element method in a parametric study to quantify the relationship between SoG and bat durability. The parametric study was completed for a span of combinations of wood SoGs, wood species (ash, maple, and yellow birch), inside-pitch and outside-pitch impact locations, and bat/ball impact speeds ranging from 90 to 180 mph (145 to 290 kph). The *MAT_WOOD (MAT_143) material model in LS-DYNA was used for implementing the wood material behavior in the finite element models. A strain-to-failure criterion was also used in the *MAT_ADD_EROSION option to capture the initiation point and subsequent crack propagation as the wood breaks. Differences among the durability responses of the three wood species are presented and discussed. Maple is concluded to be the most likely of the three wood species to result in a Multi-Piece Failure. The finite element models show that while a 0°-SoG bat is not necessarily the most durable configuration, it is the most versatile with respect to bat durability. This study is the first comprehensive numerical investigation as to the relationship between SoG and bat durability. Before this numerical study, only limited empirical data from bats broken during games were available to imply a qualitative relationship between SoG and bat durability. This novel study can serve as the basis for developing future parametric studies using finite element modeling to explore a large set of bat profiles and thereby to develop a deeper fundamental understanding of the relationship among bat profile, wood species, wood SoG, wood density, and on-field durability.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline
Research context
OpenAlex topics: Sports Dynamics and Biomechanics · Tree Root and Stability Studies · Hydrology and Sediment Transport Processes
SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.
Affiliations
Baseball Research Center, Mechanical Engineering Department, University of Massachusetts Lowell, 1 University Avenue, Lowell, MA 01854, USA
U.S. Forest Products Laboratory, US Forest Service, 1 Gifford Pinchot Drive, Madison, WI 53726, USA
Funding
Major League Baseball
References (19)
Show source-provided references
1. Jensen, D. (2009). The Timeline History of Baseball, Thunder Bay Press.
2. Cannella, S. (2002). Against The Grain Carving a New Niche in Maple, A Canadian Woodworker Gave Hitters an Alternative to Ash and Unleashed the Boutique Bat Business, Sports Illustrated.
3. MLB/MLBPA MLB (2008). MLBPA Adopt Recommendations of Safety and Health Advisory Committee December, Major League Baseball.
4. Dvorchak, R. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 2010). Bat Maker a big hit with the pros, SPORTS P. A-1, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.
5. Saraceno, J. (USA TODAY, 2016). Taking swing at safer bats, man says his creation curbs exploding effect, USA TODAY, FA CHASE EDITION P.1C.
6. Fortin-Smith, J., Sherwood, J., Drane, P., and Kretschmann, D. (2018). Characterization of Maple and Ash Material Properties for the Finite Element Modeling of Wood Baseball Bats. Appl. Sci., 8.10.3390/app8112256 ↗
7. Ruggiero, E., Sherwood, J., Drane, P., and Kretschmann, D. (2012, January 9–13). An Investigation of bat durability by wood species. Proceedings of the ISEA 2012, 9th Conference of the International Sports Engineering Association, Lowell, MA, USA.
8. Ruggiero, E., Sherwood, J., and Drane, P. (2014, January 8–10). Breaking Bad(ly)—Investigation of the Durability of Wood Bats in Major League Baseball using LS-DYNA®. Proceedings of the 13th LS-DYNA International Users Conference, Dearborn, MI, USA.
9. Applying Failure Criteria to Shear Strength Evaluation of Bonded Joints According to Grain Slope under Compressive Load
10. Hankinson, R.L. (1921). Investigation of Crushing Strength of Spruce at Varying Angles of Grain, The Chief of Air Service. Air Force Information Circular No. 259.
11. Hernandez, R. (2018, April 08). About RockBats 2012. Available online: http//:www.rockbats.com/company_aboutRockBats.html.
12. Kretschmann, D.E., Bridwell, J.J., and Nelson, T.C. (2010, January 20–24). Effect of changing slope of grain on ash, maple, and yellow birch in bending strength. Proceedings of the WCTE 2010, World Conference on Timber Engineering, Riva del Garda, Trento, Italy.
13. Glier, R. (USA TODAY, 2009). Wood experts will study bats further, USA TODAY, SPORTS P. 5C.
14. Moritz, E.F., and Haake, S. (2006). An Experimental Investigation of Baseball Bat Durability. The Engineering of Sport 6, Springer.
15. Ruggiero, E., Fortin-Smith, J., Sherwood, J., Drane, P., and Kretschmann, D. (2017). Development of a Protocol for Certification of New Wood Species for Making Baseball Bats. J. Sports Eng. Technol., submitted for review.
16. Ruggiero, E. (2011). Investigating Baseball Bat Durability Using Experimental and LS-DYNA Finite Element Modeling Methods. [Master’s Thesis, University of Massachusetts Lowell].
17. Murray, D., Reid, J.D., Faller, R.K., Bielenberg, B.W., and Paulsen, T.J. (2005). Evaluation of LS-DYNA Wood Material Model 143, Federal Highway Administration. PUBLICATION NO. FHWA-HRT-04-096.
18. (2007). Manual for LS-DYNA Wood Material Model 143, U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Highway Administration.
19. Drane, P., Sherwood, J., Colosimo, R., and Kretschmann, D. (2012, January 9–13). A study of wood baseball bat breakage. Proceedings of the ISEA 2012, 9th Conference of the International Sports Engineering Association, Lowell, MA, USA.