Comparing Several P300-Based Visuo-Auditory Brain-Computer Interfaces for a Completely Locked-in ALS Patient: A Longitudinal Case Study

In a completely locked-in state (CLIS), often resulting from traumatic brain injury or neurodegenerative diseases like amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), patients lose voluntary muscle control, including eye movement, making communication impossible. Brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) offer hope for restoring communication, but achieving reliable communication with these patients remains a challenge. This study details the design, testing, and comparison of nine visuo-auditory P300-based BCIs (combining different visual and auditory stimuli and different visual layouts) with a CLIS patient over ten months. The aim was to evaluate the impact of these stimuli in achieving effective communication. While some interfaces showed promising progress, achieving up to 90% online accuracy in one session, replicating this success in subsequent sessions proved challenging, with the average online accuracy across all sessions being 56.4 ± 15.2%. The intertrial variability in EEG signals and the low discrimination between target and non-target events were the main challenge. Moreover, the lack of communication with the patient made BCI design a challenging blind trial-and-error process. Despite the inconsistency of the results, it was possible to infer that the combination of visual and auditory stimuli had a positive impact, and that there was an improvement over time.