journal article·2020-12-14Open access

Impact of Technical, Human, and Organizational Risks on Reliability of Fire Safety Systems in High-Rise Residential Buildings—Applications of an Integrated Probabilistic Risk Assessment Model

Samson Tan, Darryl Weinert, Paul Joseph, Khalid Moinuddin

Applied Sciences· Volume 10· Issue 24

Abstract

The current paper presents an application of an alternative probabilistic risk assessment methodology that incorporates technical, human, and organizational risks (T-H-O-Risk) using Bayesian network (BN) and system dynamics (SD) modelling. Seven case studies demonstrate the application of this holistic approach to the designs of high-rise residential buildings. An incremental risk approach allows for quantification of the impact of human and organizational errors (HOEs) on different fire safety systems. The active systems considered are sprinklers, building occupant warning systems, smoke detectors, and smoke control systems. The paper presents detailed results from T-H-O-Risk modelling for HOEs and risk variations over time utilizing the SD modelling to compare risk acceptance in the seven case studies located in Australia, New Zealand, Hong Kong, Singapore, and UK. Results indicate that HOEs impact risks in active systems up to ~33%. Large variations are observed in the reliability of active systems due to HOEs over time. SD results indicate that a small behavioral change in ’risk perception’ of a building management team can lead to a very large risk to life variations over time through the self-reinforcing feedback loops. The quantification of difference in expected risk to life due to technical, human, and organizational risks for seven buildings for each of 16 trial designs is a novel aspect of this study. The research is an important contribution to the development of the next generation building codes and risk assessment methods.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Occupational Health and Safety Research · Risk and Safety Analysis · Traffic and Road Safety

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

Affiliations

Centre for Environmental Safety and Risk Engineering, Victoria University, Melbourne, Victoria 3030, Australia

References (49)

Show source-provided references
1. Hackitt, J. (2018). Building a Safer Future—Independent Review of Building Regulations and Fire Safety: Final Report, Cm 9607, APS Group.
2. The Need for Hierarchies of Acceptance Criteria for Probabilistic Risk Assessments in Fire Engineering10.1007/s10694-018-0746-7 ↗
3. Cost-benefit analysis of residential sprinklers—Application of a judgement value method10.1016/j.firesaf.2019.04.003 ↗
4. The J-Value and Its Role in Evaluating Investments in Fire Safety Schemes10.1007/s10694-018-0752-9 ↗
5. Meacham, B.J. (2016). Ultimate Health & Safety (UHS) Quantification: Individual and Societal Risk Quantification for Use in National Construction Code (NCC), ABCB.
6. BSI (2019). PD 7974-7:2019. Application of Fire Safety Engineering Principles to the Design of Buildings—Part 7: Probabilistic Risk Assessment, BSI. British Standards Published Document.
7. Defining ALARP for fire safety engineering design via the Life Quality Index10.1016/j.firesaf.2019.04.015 ↗
8. van Straalen, I.J., and Meacham, B.J. (2018, January 23–27). A quantified risk-based framework for life-safety. Proceedings of the 12th International Conference on Performance-Based Codes and Fire Safety Design Methods, SFPE, Honolulu, HI, USA.
9. Probabilistic Risk Assessment of Life Safety for a Six-Storey Commercial Building with an Open Stair Interconnecting Four Storeys: A Case Study10.1007/s10694-019-00859-z ↗
10. Development of an Integrated Risk Assessment Method to Quantify the Life Safety Risk in Buildings in Case of Fire
11. Literature Review of Fire Risk Assessment Methodologies
12. Tan, S., Weinert, D., Joseph, P., and Moinuddin, K.A.M. (2019, January 1–3). A Dynamic Probabilistic Fire Risk Model Incorporating Technical, Human and Organizational Risks for High-Rise Residential Buildings. Proceedings of the Interflam (2019) Fire Science and Engineering Conference, Royal Holloway College, London, UK.
13. Oldham, K.C.D., Cunningham, C.M.F., Spinetto, J.V., NZ Transport Agency, and Navigatus Consulting (2016). Framework for Review and Prioritisation of Rail Safety Risks in New Zealand.
14. Systematic review of human and organizational risks for probabilistic risk analysis in high-rise buildings10.1016/j.ress.2019.03.012 ↗
15. Enhancing egress drills: Preparation and assessment of evacuee performance10.1002/fam.2448 ↗
16. Heinrich, H.W., Petersen, D., Roos, N.R., Brown, J., and Hazlett, S. (1980). Industrial Accident Prevention: A Safety Management Approach, McGraw-Hill.
17. Tan, S., Weinert, D., Joseph, P., and Moinuddin, K.A.M. (2020). Incorporation of technical, human and organizational risks in a dynamic probabilistic fire risk model for high-rise residential buildings. Fire Mater.10.1002/fam.2872 ↗
18. Material Solutions for Passive Fire Protection of Buildings and Structures and Their Performances Testing10.1016/j.proeng.2016.07.388 ↗
19. Assessing the Reliance of Sprinklers for Active Protection of Structures10.1016/j.proeng.2013.08.107 ↗
20. Spitzenberger, C., Johnson, C., Le, M., Mshelia, A., and Pitblado, R. (2016). Strike the Right Balance between Active and Passive Fire Protection, AIChE. CEP, American Institute of Chemical Engineers.
21. A socio-technical system framework for risk-informed performance-based building regulation10.1080/09613218.2017.1299525 ↗
22. Data-theoretic methodology and computational platform to quantify organizational factors in socio-technical risk analysis10.1016/j.ress.2018.12.020 ↗
23. Incorporating organizational factors into probabilistic risk assessment of complex socio-technical systems: Principles and theoretical foundations10.1016/j.ssci.2008.12.008 ↗
24. Measurement techniques for organizational safety causal models: Characterization and suggestions for enhancements10.1016/j.ssci.2009.04.002 ↗
25. Mohaghegh, Z. (2010, January 23–26). Combining System Dynamics and Bayesian Belief Networks for Socio-Technical Risk Analysis. Proceedings of the 2010 IEEE International Conference on Intelligence and Security Informatics, Vancouver, BC, Canada.10.1109/ISI.2010.5484736 ↗
26. A paired comparison approach to improve the quantification of management influences in air transportation10.1016/j.ress.2012.12.001 ↗
27. A hybrid algorithm for developing third generation HRA methods using simulator data, causal models, and cognitive science10.1016/j.ress.2019.106507 ↗
28. Human Reliability Analysis in Healthcare: A Review of Techniques
29. A Bayesian method for using simulator data to enhance human error probabilities assigned by existing HRA methods10.1016/j.ress.2014.03.010 ↗
30. A comprehensive system for semantic spatiotemporal assessment of risk in urban areas10.1111/1468-5973.12309 ↗
31. Hollnagel, E. (1998). Cognitive Reliability and Error Analysis Method (CREAM), Elsevier.
32. On risk defined as an event where the outcome is uncertain10.1080/13669870802488883 ↗
33. Hybrid causal methodology and software platform for probabilistic risk assessment and safety monitoring of socio-technical systems10.1016/j.ress.2010.06.005 ↗
34. Reliability of sprinkler system in Australian high-rise office buildings
35. Reliability of sprinkler system in Australian shopping centres—A fault tree analysis10.1016/j.firesaf.2019.03.006 ↗
36. Reliability of fire (point) detection system in office buildings in Australia—A fault tree analysis10.1016/j.firesaf.2020.103150 ↗
37. Det Norske Veritas (2015). OREDA-Offshore & Onshore Reliability Data Handbook, Det Norske Veritas. [6th ed.].
38. Swain, A.D., and Guttmann, H.E. (1983). Handbook of Human-Reliability Analysis with Emphasis on Nuclear Power Plant Applications.10.2172/5752058 ↗
39. HSE (1999). The Implementation of CORE-DATA, A Computerised Human Error Probability Database, HSE Books.
40. Zerrouki, H. (2015, January 13–15). Mapping Fault Tree into Bayesian Network in Safety Analysis of Process System. Proceedings of the 2015 4th International Conference on Electrical Engineering (ICEE), Boumerdes, Algeria.
41. System dynamics meta-modelling for reliability considerations in maintenance10.1504/IJPMB.2013.057723 ↗
42. Dulac, N., Leveson, N., Zipkin, D., Friedenthal, S., Cutcher-Gershenfeld, J., Carroll, J., and Barrett, B. (2005, January 4–7). Using System Dynamics for Safety and Risk Management in Complex Engineering Systems. Proceedings of the 2005 Winter Simulation Conference, Orlando, FL, USA.
43. Hurley, M.J. (2016). SFPE Handbook of Fire Protection Engineering, SFPE. [5th ed.].10.1007/978-1-4939-2565-0 ↗
44. An experimental study of fire development in deep enclosures and a new HRR-time-position model for a deep enclosure based on ventilation factor10.1002/fam.986 ↗
45. ABCB (2018). Regulation Impact Statement for Final Decision. Fire Safety in New Class 2 and Class 3 Residential Buildings, ABCB.
46. Garis, L., Singh, A., Clare, J., Hughan, S., and Tyakoff, A. (2018). Sprinkler Systems and Residential Structure Fires—Revisited: Exploring the Impact of Sprinklers for Life Safety and Fire Spread, U. Fraser Valley.
47. Ahrens, M. (2017). U.S. Experience with Sprinklers, NFPA.
48. Ahrens, M. (2019). Smoke Alarms in U. S. Home Fires, NFPA.
49. On a novel method for approximation of FN diagram and setting ALARP borders10.1007/s00773-015-0305-6 ↗