journal article·2023-01-25Open access

A Comparison between Two Statistical Methods for Gear Tooth Root Bending Strength Estimation Starting from Pulsator Data

Luca Bonaiti, Michael Geitner, Thomas Tobie, Carlo Gorla, Karsten Stahl

Applied Sciences· Volume 13· Issue 3

Abstract

Due to their cost-effectiveness, pulsator tests are widely adopted as a testing methodology for the investigation of the effects of material and heat and surface treatment on the gear strength with respect to tooth root fatigue fracture. However, since no meshing contact is present in pulsator tests, there are differences between the test case and the real-world application scenario where gears are rotating under load. Those differences are related to both statistical and fatigue phenomena. Over the years, several methodologies have been developed in order to handle this problem. This article summarizes them and proposes a first comparison. However, no complete comparison between the different estimation methodologies has been conducted so far. This article aims to partially cover this gap, first by presenting and comparing the methodologies proposed in the literature and then via a deeper comparison between two different elaboration methodologies. Those two methodologies, which have been developed by examined to the same test rig configuration, are also discussed in detail. The comparison is performed based on an actual database composed of 1643 data points from case-hardened gears, divided into 76 experimental campaigns. Good agreement between the estimated gear strengths was found. The database is also adopted in order to make further considerations about one methodology, providing additional validation and defining the specimen numerosity required.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Gear and Bearing Dynamics Analysis · Fatigue and fracture mechanics · Advanced machining processes and optimization

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

Affiliations

Politecnico di Milano, Dipartimento di Meccanica, Via La Masa 1, 20156 Milano, Italy

Gear Research Center (FZG), Technical University of Munich, 85748 Garching bei München, Germany

Funding

This research received no direct external funding

References (82)

Show source-provided references
1. Aktiengesellschaft, M. (1963). Maag Gear-Book: Calculation and Manufacture of Gears and Gear Drives for Designers and Works Engineers, Maag Gear-Wheel Co.
2. Dudley, D., and Townsend, D. (1996). Manuale Degli Ingranaggi - Edizione Italiana, Tecniche nuove.
3. Henriot, G. (1993). Manuale Pratico Degli Ingranaggi, Tecniche nuove.
4. Tooth bending fatigue failures in gears10.1016/1350-6307(96)00008-8 ↗
5. Davoli, P., Conrado, E., and Michaelis, K. (2022, January 14). Recognizing gear failures. Mach. Desing. Available online: http://hdl.handle.net/11311/274596.
6. (2019). Standard No. ISO 6336-3:2019. Available online: https://www.iso.org/standard/63822.html.
7. (2004). Standard No. ANSI AGMA 2001-D04. Available online: http://www.agma.org.
8. (2019). Standard No. ISO 6336-6:2019. Available online: https://www.iso.org/standard/63823.html.
9. A rotating gear test methodology for evaluation of high-cycle tooth bending fatigue lives under fully reversed and fully released loading conditions10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2019.105432 ↗
10. Bending fatigue behaviour of 17-4 PH gears produced via selective laser melting10.1016/j.prostr.2020.02.068 ↗
11. Concli, F., Bonaiti, L., Gerosa, R., Cortese, L., Nalli, F., Rosa, F., and Gorla, C. (2021). Bending Fatigue Behavior of 17-4 PH Gears Produced by Additive Manufacturing. Appl. Sci., 11.10.3390/app11073019 ↗
12. Fatigue of gears in the finite life regime—Experiments and probabilistic modelling10.1016/j.engfailanal.2016.01.012 ↗
13. Evaluation of bending fatigue strength in automotive gear steel subjected to shot peening techniques10.1016/j.prostr.2018.12.329 ↗
14. A study on the evaluation of bending fatigue strength for 20CrMoH gear10.1007/s12541-013-0181-0 ↗
15. Bending fatigue strength of aerospace quality gear steels at ambient and elevated temperatures10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2022.107125 ↗
16. Experimental analysis of bending fatigue strength of plain and notched case-hardened gear steels10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2015.04.015 ↗
17. Bending fatigue design of case-hardened gears based on test specimens10.1177/0954406217712278 ↗
18. Fatigue Performance and Residual Stress of Carburized Gear Steels Part I: Residual Stress10.4271/2008-01-1424 ↗
19. Bending Fatigue Behavior of Carburized Gear Steels: Four-Point Bend Test Development and Evaluation
20. Optimized Carburized Steel Fatigue Performance as Assessed with Gear and Modified Brugger Fatigue Tests
21. Mechanical Testing of Gears
22. Ermittlung von Zahnfußfestigkeitskennwerten auf Verspannungsprüfständen und Pulsatoren-Vergleich der Prüfverfahren und der gewonnenen Kennwerte
23. Stahl, K., Michaelis, K., and Höhn, B.-R. (1999). FVA Research Project 304, Final Report No. 580—Life Time Statistics—Statistical Methods for Estimation of the Machine Element Life Time and Reliability, and Exemplary Application on Gears (German: Lebensdauerstatisktik—Statistische Methoden zur Beurteilung von Bauteillebensdauer und Zuverlässigkeit und ihre beispielhafte Anwendung auf Zahnräder), FVA-Forschungsheft.
24. Hein, M., Geitner, M., Tobie, T., Stahl, K., and Pinnekamp, B. (2018, January 24–26). Reliability of gears—Determination of statistically validated material strength numbers. Proceedings of the American Gear Manufacturers Association Fall Technical Meeting 2018, Oak Brook, IL, USA.
25. Tobie, T., and Matt, P. (2012). FVA Guideline 563 I—Recommendations for the Standardization of Load Capacity Tests on Hardened and Tempered Cylindrical Gears, FVA.
26. Hein, M. (2018). Zur Ganzheitlichen Betriebsfesten Auslegung und Prüfung von Getriebezahnrädern. [Ph.D. Dissertation, Tecnhical university of Munich].
27. Estimation of gear SN curve for tooth root bending fatigue by means of maximum likelihood method and statistic of extremes10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2021.106451 ↗
28. Gear root bending strength: Statistical treatment of Single Tooth Bending Fatigue tests results10.1007/s10010-021-00567-7 ↗
29. Results of a Fifteen-Year Program of Flexural Fatigue Testing of Gear Teeth10.1115/1.3670516 ↗
30. Three point load application in single tooth bending fatigue test for evaluation of gear blank manufacturing methods10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2003.11.003 ↗
31. Gear Single Tooth Bending Fatigue Test
32. (2017). Standard No. J1619_201712. Available online: https://www.sae.org/standards/content/j1619_201712/.
33. Bending and contact fatigue strength of innovative steels for large gears10.1177/0954406213519614 ↗
34. Measuring tooth thickness of involute gears
35. (2022, October 21). Test rigs. Available online: https://www.ifa.ruhr-uni-bochum.de/ifa/dienste/pruefstaende.html.en.
36. On the determination of the bending fatigue strength in and above the very high cycle fatigue regime of shot-peened gears10.1007/s10010-021-00499-2 ↗
37. A comparison of gear tooth bending fatigue lives from single tooth bending and rotating gear tests10.1007/s10010-021-00510-w ↗
38. Numerical model for bending fatigue life estimation of carburized spur gears with consideration of the adjacent tooth effect10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2021.106515 ↗
39. Rao, S.B., Schwanger, V., McPherson, D.R., and Rudd, C. (2005, January 24–28). Measurement and Validation of Dynamic Bending Stresses in Spur Gear Teeth. Proceedings of the ASME International Design Engineering Technical Conferences and Computers and Information in Engineering Conference—DETC2005, Long Beach, CA, USA.10.1115/DETC2005-84419 ↗
40. Investigations on the tooth root bending strength and the fatigue fracture characteristics of case-carburized and shot-peened gears of different sizes10.1177/0954406219841650 ↗
41. Fuchs, D., Schurer, S., Tobie, T., and Stahl, K. (2022, July 13). New Consideration of Non-Metallic Inclusions Calculating Local Tooth Root Load Carrying Capacity of High-Strength, High-Quality Steel Gears. Available online: www.geartechnology.com.
42. A model approach for considering nonmetallic inclusions in the calculation of the local tooth root load-carrying capacity of high-strength gears made of high-quality steels10.1177/0954406219840676 ↗
43. Investigations into non-metallic inclusion crack area characteristics relevant for tooth root fracture damages of case carburised and shot-peened high strength gears of different sizes made of high-quality steels10.1007/s10010-019-00324-x ↗
44. Fracture analysis of fisheye failures in the tooth root fillet of high-strength gears made out of ultra-clean gear steels10.1007/s10010-021-00563-x ↗
45. Methodology for translating single-tooth bending fatigue data to be comparable to running gear data
46. Experimental characterization of bending fatigue strength in gear teeth
47. Life Distribution Transformation Model of Planetary Gear System10.1186/s10033-018-0221-x ↗
48. Reliable gear design: Translation of the results of single tooth bending fatigue tests through the combination of numerical simulations and fatigue criteria10.2495/CMEM210101 ↗
49. Concli, F., Fraccaroli, L., and Maccioni, L. (2021). Gear Root Bending Strength: A New Multiaxial Approach to Translate the Results of Single Tooth Bending Fatigue Tests to Meshing Gears. Metals, 11.10.3390/met11060863 ↗
50. Concli, F., Maccioni, L., Fraccaroli, L., and Bonaiti, L. (2021). Early Crack Propagation in Single Tooth Bending Fatigue: Combination of Finite Element Analysis and Critical-Planes Fatigue Criteria. Metals, 11.10.3390/met11111871 ↗
51. Gear Root Bending Strength: A Comparison Between Single Tooth Bending Fatigue Tests and Meshing Gears10.1115/1.4050560 ↗
52. Analysis of Fatigue Data with Runouts Based on a Model with Nonconstant Standard Deviation and a Fatigue Limit Parameter10.1520/JTE11341J ↗
53. Mao, T., Liu, H., Wei, P., Chen, D., Zhang, P., and Liu, G. (2022). An improved estimation method of gear fatigue strength based on sample expansion and standard deviation correction. Int. J. Fatigue, 161.10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2022.106887 ↗
54. A Method for Obtaining and Analyzing Sensitivity Data10.1080/01621459.1948.10483254 ↗
55. Alnahlaui, A., and Tenberge, P. (2022, January 12–14). Improved Method for the Determination of Tooth Root Endurance Strength. Proceedings of the International Conference on Gears 2022, Munich, Germany.10.51202/9783181023891-31 ↗
56. Geitner, M., Tobie, T., and Stahl, K. (2021). FVA research project 610 IV, final report no. 1432—Materials 4.0—Comprehensive statistical data analysis to evaluate the influence of material and heat treatment properties on the load carrying capacity of gears (German: Werkstoffe 4.0-Erweiterte Datenanalyse zur Bewertung des Einflusses von Werkstoff- und Wärmebehandlungseigenschaften auf die Zahnradtragfähigkeit), FVA-Forschungsheft.
57. Ein verbessertes Verfahren für die Auswertung von Treppenstufenversuchen10.1002/mawe.19830141207 ↗
58. Hösel, T., and Joachim, F. (1978). Zahnflankenwälzfestigkeit unter Berücksichtigung der Ausfallwahrscheinlichkeit. Antriebstechnik, 17.
59. Eine einfache Rechenschiebernäherung an die den normal scores entsprechenden Prozentpunkte
60. Spindel, J., and Haibach, E. (1981). Some Considerations in the Statistical Determination of the Shape of S-N Curves, ASTM International.10.1520/STP29330S ↗
61. Beretta, S. (2009). Affidabilità Delle Costruzioni Meccaniche, Springer.10.1007/978-88-470-1079-6 ↗
62. Inclusions Size-based Fatigue Life Prediction Model of NiTi Alloy for Biomedical Applications10.1007/s40830-015-0016-1 ↗
63. Nelson, W. (1982). Applied Life Data Analysis, Wiley.10.1002/0471725234 ↗
64. Nelson, W. (2004). Accelerated Testing: Statistical Models, Test Plans and Data Analyses, John Wiley & Sons.
65. Influence of grinding zones on the tooth root bending strength of case carburized gears10.1007/s10010-021-00518-2 ↗
66. Gasparini, G., Mariani, U., Gorla, C., Filippini, M., and Rosa, F. (2009). Bending fatigue tests of helicopter case carburized gears: Influence of material, design and manufacturing parameters. Gear Technol., 68–76. Available online: www.geartechnology.com.
67. Bending Fatigue Strength of Case Carburized and Nitrided Gear Steels for Aeronautical Applications
68. Estimating the parameters of a fatigue model using Benders’ decomposition10.1007/s10479-011-0891-6 ↗
69. Estimating Fatigue Curves With the Random Fatigue-Limit Model10.1080/00401706.1999.10485925 ↗
70. Estimating fatigue limit distributions under inhomogeneous stress conditions10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2004.03.014 ↗
71. A compatible regression Weibull model for the description of the three-dimensional fatigue σM–N–R field as a basis for cumulative damage approach10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2021.106596 ↗
72. Generalization of the Weibull probabilistic compatible model to assess fatigue data into three domains: LCF, HCF and VHCF10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2022.106771 ↗
73. Physical and Statistical Aspects of Fatigue10.1016/S0065-2156(08)70372-7 ↗
74. The effect of sample size on the confidence of endurance fatigue tests10.1111/j.1460-2695.1995.tb00147.x ↗
75. Fatigue limit estimated using finite lives10.1046/j.1460-2695.2003.00659.x ↗
76. Modelling curved S–N curves10.1111/j.1460-2695.2005.00876.x ↗
77. Theory for Optimal Test Plans for the Random Fatigue-Limit Model10.1198/004017003188618760 ↗
78. Optimum Simple Step-Stress Plans for Accelerated Life Testing10.1109/TR.1983.5221475 ↗
79. Fitting of Fatigue Curves with Nonconstant Standard Deviation to Data with Runouts10.1520/JTE10700J ↗
80. Parameter estimation and uncertainty quantification for systems biology models10.1016/j.coisb.2019.10.006 ↗
81. Meeker, W.Q., and Escobar, L.A. (1995). Teaching about Approximate Confidence Regions Based on Maximum Likelihood Estimation. Am. Stat., 49.10.2307/2684811 ↗
82. Accuracy of approx confidence bounds using censored Weibull regression data from accelerated life tests10.1109/24.103016 ↗