journal article·2010-06

Honeycomb Core and the Myths of Moisture Ingression

John H. Fogarty

Applied Composite Materials· Volume 17· Issue 3
Publisher page

Abstract

While it is true that honeycomb core can trap moisture, it is a myth that widespread moisture ingression is an inevitable outcome when honeycomb sandwich structures are exposed to real world environments. It is also a myth that when moisture ingression occurs, progressive weight gain and strength loss are inevitable outcomes. Using a rebuttal of a 2004 honeycomb-critical paper as the focal point, this paper summarizes multiple sources which indicate both that moisture ingression is preventable and, even if it does occur, that proper material choices can prevent severe consequences. These claims are further supported by results from in-plane compression testing of typical (0.064 g/cm3 aramid-paper/phenolic core with 0.116 cm carbon/epoxy faces) composite honeycomb sandwich specimens after impacting, water submersion, and extensive thermal cycling.
Source: openaire · Quality: candidate unverified · Source record ↗

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Cellular and Composite Structures · Natural Fiber Reinforced Composites · Structural Analysis of Composite Materials

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

References (32)

Show source-provided references
1. Campbell, F: The case against honeycomb core, 49th international society for the advancement of manufacturing and process engineering (SAMPE) symposium, Long Beach, CA (May 2004)
2. Radtke, T., Charon, A.: Vodicka: hot/wet environmental degradation of honeycomb sandwich structure representative of F/A-18: flatwise tension strength, Australian Defense Science and Technology Organization (DSTO) Report DSTO-TR-0908 (September 1999)
3. Whitehead, S., McDonald, M., Bartholomeusz, R.: Loading degradation, and repair of F-111 bonded honeycomb sandwich panels—a preliminary study, Australian Defense Science and Technology Organization (DSTO) Report DSTO-TR-1041 (August 2000)
4. Gintert, L., Singleton, M., Powell, W.: Corrosion control for aluminum honeycomb sandwich structures, 33 rd international society for the advancement of manufacturing and process engineering (SAMPE) Technical Conference, Seattle, WA, November (2001)
5. Shafizadeh, J., Seferis, J.: The cost of water ingression on honeycomb repair and utilization, 45th international society for the advancement of manufacturing and process engineering (SAMPE) Symposium, Long Beach, CA (May 2000)
6. Shafizadeh, J., Seferis, J., Chesmar, E., Geyer, R.: Evaluation of the in-service performance behavior of honeycomb composite sandwich structures. J. Mater. Eng. Perform. 8(6), 661–668 (1999)10.1361/105994999770346422 ↗
7. Shafizadeh, J., Seferis, J.: The effects of long time water exposure on the durability of honeycomb cores, 45th international society for the advancement of manufacturing and process engineering (SAMPE) Symposium, Long Beach, CA (May 2000)
8. Loken, H., Nollen, D., Wardle, D., Zahr, G.: Water ingression resistant thin faced honeycomb cored composite systems with facesheets reinforced with Kevlar Aramid Fiber and Kevlar with Carbon Fibers, Wilmington Campus, DuPont Corporation (1988)
9. Chesmar, E.: From product reliability, in-service experience, and lessons learned. In: Miracle, D.B., Donaldson, S.L. (eds.) ASM handbook, volume 21: composites, pp. 934–945. ASM International, Metals Park (2001)
10. Li, C., Ueno, R., Lefebvre, V.: Investigation of moisture ingress and migration mechanisms of an aircraft rudder composites sandwich structure, 38th international society for the advancement of manufacturing and process engineering (SAMPE) Technical Conference, Dallas (November 2006)
11. Cise, D., Lakes, R.: Moisture ingression in honeycomb core sandwich panels. J. Mater. Eng. Perform. 6(6), 732–736 (1997)10.1007/s11665-997-0074-4 ↗
12. Cise, D., Lakes, R.: Moisture ingression in honeycomb core sandwich panels: directional aspects. J. Compos. Mater. 31(22), 2249–2263 (1997)10.1177/002199839703102202 ↗
13. Timmerman, J., Hayes, B., Seferis, J.: Nanoclay reinforcement effects on the cryogenic microcracking of carbon fiber/epoxy composites. Compos. Sci. Technol. 62, 1249–1258 (2002)10.1016/S0266-3538(02)00063-5 ↗
14. Timmerman, J., Hayes, B., Seferis, J.: Cryogenic microcracking of carbon fiber/epoxy composite: influences of fiber-matrix adhesion. J. Compos. Mater. 37(21), 1939–1950 (2003)10.1177/002199803036281 ↗
15. Ward, S., Gintert, L.: From analysis of sandwich structures. In: Miracle, D.B., Donaldson, S.L. (eds.) ASM handbook, volume 21: composites, pp. 308–320. ASM International, Metals Park (2001)
16. Gerken, N., Thompson, M.: Impact resistant core, the boeing company, US Patent 12/119,561 (filed 13 May 2008)
17. Fell, B.: Continuous process for the preparation of honeycomb structural material and apparatus suitable for use therein, Hexel Corporation, WO 97/16304 International Patent Publication (1997)
18. Ducruy, G.: Method for producing a honeycomb core in thermofusible material and device for implementing same, Sodesa Inc., WO 98/41388 International Patent Publication (1998)
19. Kehl, A.: Self-contained honeycomb structure from flexible film strips and method for its production, Wacotech Inc., WO 01/00397 International Patent Publication (2001)
20. Committee D30 of the American Society for Testing and Materials: Standard test method for measuring the damage resistance of a fiber-reinforced polymer matrix composite to a drop-weight impact event. ASTM D 7136 (November 2007)
21. Chalkley, P., Chester, R.: The influence of tropical exposure on the durability of graphite/epoxy laminates. Theor. Appl. Fract. Mech. 13, 137–144 (1990)10.1016/0167-8442(90)90031-T ↗
22. Komai, K., Shiroshita, S., Kilidjian, G.: Influence of water on mechanical properties and fracture mechanisms of CFRP/aramid honeycomb core sandwich beams. J. Japan. Soc. Mater. Sci. 44(505), 1273–1278 (1995)10.2472/jsms.44.1273 ↗
23. Loken, H.: The effect of moisture conditioning on the mechanical properties of nomex honeycomb core, Trade Literature from Du Pont de Nemours International, (1987)
24. Department of Defense: Composite Materials Handbook, Volume 2: Polymer Matrix Composite Material Properties, MIL-HDBK-17-2F (June 2002)
25. Hexcel corporate brochure: HexWeb honeycomb attributes and properties: a comrehensive guide to standard hexcel honeycomb materials, configurations, and mechanical properties (2009)
26. Hoffman, D.: The 737 graphite composite flight spoiler service evaluation, Report NASA-CR-159362 (April 1980)
27. Crocket, A., Loken, H., Tomblin, J.: Fluid ingression damage mechanism in composite sandwich stuctures, 4th annual joint advanced materials and structures center of excellence (JAMS) Technical Review (July 2008)
28. Committee D30 of the American society for testing and materials: standard test method for compressive residual strength properties of damaged polymer matrix composite plates, ASTM D 7137 (November 2007)
29. Crawley, N.: Non-destructive testing and the link between environmental degradation and mechanical properties of composite honeycomb panels, 62nd annual forum of the American helicopter society, Phoenix (May 2006)
30. Li, C., Ueno, R., Lefebvre, V.: Investigation of an accelerated moisture removal approach of a composite aircraft control surface, 38th international society for the advancement of manufacturing and process engineering (SAMPE) Technical Conference, Dallas (November 2006)
31. Fogarty, J.: Steam pressure induced delamination of honeycomb core sandwich panels, 37th international SAMPE technical conference, Seattle, WA (November 2005)
32. D’Antonio, S.: Getting to the core. Passage Maker 12(1), 150–161 (2007)