journal article·2012-01

Financial Assessment of Logging Residue Collection in the Southeast United States

Mathew F. Smidt, Yaoqi Zhang, Bin Zheng

Forest Products Journal· Volume 62· Issue 1
Publisher page

Abstract

Abstract Logging residue and nonmerchantable stems are an important component of present and future bioenergy resources. Integrated harvesting systems that chip or grind logging residues and nonmerchantable stems with the harvest of roundwood may be the most feasible technology and most likely to produce material at a competitive cost. We conducted simulated harvests on a wide range of southeastern US pine forests using a sample of Forest Inventory Analysis (FIA) inventory plots and Forest Vegetation Simulator (FVS) to model silvicultural treatments and intensities of pine management. In the simulation break-even marginal costs for biomass were typically present when residue volume exceeded 100 m3 ha−1 or ratios of roundwood to biomass were less than 4:1. Increased roundwood harvesting productivity also increased the rate at which residue arrived at the landing for processing, which improved chipper utilization and lowered costs. In integrated systems some roundwood that meets pulpwood specifications may be merchandized as biomass because of the cost savings available from increasing chipper utilization. Cost savings from merchandizing all pulpwood as biomass could support stumpage payments that may be equivalent to pulpwood stumpage in areas with low pulpwood prices and low pulpwood demand.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Forest Biomass Utilization and Management · Forest Management and Policy · Bioenergy crop production and management

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

References (31)

Show source-provided references
1. Baker, S. A., M. D.WestbrookJr., and W. D.Greene. 2010. Evaluation of integrated harvesting systems in pine stands of the southern United States.Biomass Bioenergy34 (5):720–727.
2. Bolding, M. C., L. D.Kellogg, and C. T.Davis. 2009. Productivity and costs of an integrated mechanical forest fuel reduction operation in southwest Oregon.Forest Prod. J59 (3):35–46.
3. Bolding, M. C. and B. L.Lanford. 2005. Wildfire fuel harvesting and resultant biomass utilization using a cut-to-length/small chipper system.Forest Prod. J55 (12):181–189.
4. Brinker, R. W., J.Kinard, R.Rummer, and B.Lanford. 2002. Machine rates for selected forest harvesting machines. Circular 296. Alabama Agricultural Experiment Station. Auburn. 32pp.
5. Caterpillar, Inc. 1996. Caterpillar Performance Handbook. 27th ed. Caterpillar Inc.. Peoria, Illinois.
6. Clark, A. and J. R.Saucier. 1990. Tables for estimating total-tree weights, stem weights, and volumes of planted and natural southern pine in the southeast. Georgia Forest Research Paper GFRP-79. Georgia Forestry Commission. Macon. 23pp.
7. Dixon, G. E. 2008. Essential FVS: A user's guide to the Forest Vegetation Simulator. USDA Forest Service. Fort Collins, Colorado. 219pp.
8. Downing, M., L. M.Eaton, R. L.Graham, M. H.Langholtz, R. D.Perlack, A. F.TurhollowJr., B.Stokes, and C. C.Brandt. 2011. U.S. billion-ton update: Biomass supply for a bioenergy and bioproducts industry. Technical Report ORNL/TM-2011/224. Oak Ridge National Laboratory. Oak Ridge, Tennessee. 194pp.
9. Dykstra, D., B.Hartsough, and B.Stokes. 2009. Updating FRCS, the Fuel Reduction Cost Simulator for national biomass assessments.In:. Annual Meeting of the Council on Forest Engineering, June 15–18, 2009, Kings Beach, California 9pp.
10. Fox, T. R., H. L.Allen, T. J.Albaugh, R.Rubilar, and C. A.Carlson. 2007. Tree nutrition and forest fertilization of pine plantations in the southern United States.South. J. Appl. Forestry31 (1):5–11.
11. Gingras, J. F. 1988. The effect of site and stand factors on feller buncher performance. Technical Report TR-84. Forest Engineering Research Institute of Canada. Pointe-Claire, Quebec. 18pp.
12. Greene, W. D., J. H.Mayo, C. F.deHoop, and A. F.Egan. 2004. Causes and costs of unused logging capacity in the southern United States and Maine.Forest Prod. J54 (5):29–37.
13. Han, H., H. W.Lee, and L. R.Johnson. 2004. Economic feasibility of an integrated harvesting system for small-diameter trees in southwest Idaho.Forest Prod. J54 (2):21–27.
14. Klepac, J. and R. B.Rummer. 2000. Productivity and cost comparison of two different sized skidders. ASAE Paper No. 00-5015. American Society of Agricultural Engineering. St. Joseph, Michigan. 10pp.
15. Kluender, R., D.Lortz, W.McCoy, B.Stokes, and J.Klepac. 1997. Productivity of rubber-tired skidders in southern pine forests.Forest Prod. J47 (11/12):53–58.
16. Lanford, B. L., H.Sobhany, and B. J.Stokes. 1990. Tree-length loading production rates for southern pine.Forest Prod. J40 (10):43–46.
17. Lanford, B. L. and B. J.Stokes. 1996. Comparison of two thinning systems: Part 2. Productivity and costs.Forest Prod. J46 (11/12):47–53.
18. Miller, D. E., T. J.Straka, B. J.Stokes, and W. F.Watson. 1987. Productivity and cost of conventional understory biomass harvesting systems.Forest Prod. J37 (5):39–43.
19. Miller, F. M. and W. D.Greene. 1992. Delimbing southern pines: Gate versus the CTR Model 314 De-Limber.Forest Prod. J42 (6):11–16.
20. Newbold, R. A., V. C.Baldwin, and G.Hill. 2001. Weight and volume determination for planted loblolly pine in north Louisiana. Research Paper SRS-26. USDA Forest Service, Southern Research Station. Asheville, North Carolina. 19pp.
21. Pan, F., H.Han, L. R.Johnson, and W. J.Elliot. 2008. Production and cost of harvesting, processing, and transporting small-diameter (≤5 inches) trees for energy.Forest Prod. J58 (5):47–53.
22. Phillips, D. R. 1980. Total tree weights and volumes for understory hardwoods.TAPPI J60 (6):68–71.
23. Porterfield, R. L. and W. W.von Segen. 1976. Improved utilization: Approaching the goal in Arkansas.J. Forestry74 (6):353–355.
24. Puttock, G. D. 1995. Estimating cost for integrated harvesting and related forest management activities.Biomass Bioenergy8 (2):73–79.
25. Shrestha, S. P. and B. L.Lanford. 2002. Comparison of timber utilization between a tree-length and an in-wood chipping harvesting operation.In:. Annual Meeting of the Council on Forest Engineering, June 16–20, 2002, Auburn, Alabama 5pp.
26. Smidt, M. F., R. A.Tufts, and T. V.Gallagher. 2009. Cost of fiber: Final report. Wood Supply Research Institute. Rockville, Maryland. 28pp.
27. Stokes, B. J., W. F.Watson, and I. W.Savelle. 1984. Alternate biomass harvesting systems using conventional equipment.In:. Southern Forest Biomass Workshop, June 5–7, 1984, Athens, Georgia. USDA Forest Service. Washington, D.C. pp.111–114.
28. Timber Mart-South. 2011. South-wide quarterly summary report, 4th Quarter 2010. Timber Mart-South. Athens, Georgia.
29. Visser, R. and K.Stampfer. 2003. Tree-length system evaluation of second thinning in a loblolly pine stand.South. J. Appl. Forestry27 (2):77–82.
30. Wang, J., C.Long, and J.McNeel. 2004. Production and cost analysis of a feller-buncher and grapple skidder in central Appalachian hardwood forests.Forest Prod. J54 (12):159–167.
31. Westbrook Jr., M. D., W. D.Greene, and R. L.Izlar. 2007. Utilizing forest biomass by adding a small chipper to a tree-length southern pine harvesting operation.South. J. Appl. Forestry31 (4):165–169.