Removing Friction and Bark Improves Drill Resistance Data for Selection on Wood Density in Pinus taeda Plantations
Source abstract
Abstract
Abstract Wood density is used for genetic selection because of its association with wood quality. Traditional assessments of wood density, such as volumetric measurement and X-ray densitometry, are labor intensive and time consuming. Drill resistance (measured with a Resistograph) is faster and gives an indirect assessment of wood density. The Resistograph generates thousands of data points for each tree that must be summarized. The data include bark and air as the drill enters and exits the bole, as well as friction that builds on the drill shaft. This study evaluated data processing methods for drill resistance to improve correlation with wood density, with a focus on practical implementation by breeding programs. We compared methods that thoroughly removed bark, air, and friction, as well as simple methods based on expected bark thickness and depth to the pith. The most thorough method produced the highest phenotypic correlation with density (rp = 0.81). All methods that excluded data after the drill exits the tree had very strong genetic correlations (rg > 0.92), although avoiding bark gave a noticeable increase in genetic correlation. Unprocessed drill resistance had unacceptably low phenotypic correlations (rp = 0.38) and the lowest genetic correlation observed, although it was still very high (rg = 0.91). For tree breeding programs, we recommend developing reasonable bark and pith depth thresholds and using simple rules to avoid bark and friction.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline
Research context
OpenAlex topics: Forest ecology and management · Forest Biomass Utilization and Management · Tree Root and Stability Studies
SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.
Affiliations
The authors are, respectively, graduate student, North Carolina State Univ. Cooperative Tree Improvement Program (mtracht@ncsu.edu); Associate Professor and Director of Camcore (jjacosta@ncsu.edu); and Assistant Professor and Co-Director of the North Carolina State Univ. Cooperative Tree Improvement Program, Dept. of Forestry and Environ. Resources, College of Natural Resources, North Carolina State Univ., Raleigh (trevor_walker@ncsu.edu [corresponding author])
References (35)
Show source-provided references
1. ASTM. 2022. Standard test methods for specific gravity of wood and wood-based materials. ASTM Standard D2395-17. In: Annual Book of ASTM Standards. ASTM, West Conshohocken, Pennsylvania.
2. Baltunis, B. S.,Gapare W. J., and Wu H. X. 2010. Genetic parameters and genotype by environment interaction in radiata pine for growth and wood quality traits in Australia. Silvae Genet. 59(1–6):113–124.
3. Bouffier, L.,Charlot C.,Raffin A.,Rozenberg P., and Kremer A. 2008. Can wood density be efficiently selected at early stage in maritime pine (Pinus pinaster Ait.). Ann. Forest Sci. 65(1):1–8.
4. Butler, D. G.,Cullis B. R.,Gilmour A. R.,Gogel B. J., and Thompson R. 2017. ASReml-R Reference Manual Version 4. VSN International Ltd, Hemel Hempstead, UK. 188 pp.
5. Camcore. 2015. Camcore annual report 2015. North Carolina State University, Raleigh. p. 26. https://camcore.cnr.ncsu.edu/files/2018/04/AnnReport-2015-WebVersion.pdf. Last accessed February 23, 2024.
6. Camcore. 2016. Camcore annual report 2016. North Carolina State University, Raleigh. p. 35. https://camcore.cnr.ncsu.edu/files/2018/04/AnnReport-2016-Web-Version.pdf. Last accessed February 23, 2024.
7. Camcore. 2017. Camcore annual report 2017. North Carolina State University, Raleigh. p. 22. https://camcore.cnr.ncsu.edu/files/2018/04/AnnReport-2017-WebVersion.pdf. Last accessed February 23, 2024.
8. Camcore. 2018. Camcore annual report 2018. North Carolina State University, Raleigh. p. 36. https://camcore.cnr.ncsu.edu/files/2019/04/AnnReport-2018-Web.pdf. Last accessed February 23, 2024.
9. Camcore. 2019. Camcore annual report 2019. North Carolina State University, Raleigh. p. 32. https://camcore.cnr.ncsu.edu/files/2020/04/AnnReport-2019.pdf. Last accessed February 23, 2024.
10. Camcore. 2021. Camcore annual report 2020 & 2021. North Carolina State University, Raleigh. p. 36. https://camcore.cnr.ncsu.edu/files/2022/05/AnnReport-2020-21.pdf. Last accessed February 23, 2024.
11. Cown, D. J. 1978. Comparison of the Pilodyn and torsiometer methods for the rapid assessment of wood density in living trees. N. Z. J. Forestry Sci. 8(3):384–391.
12. Cown, D. J. and Clement B. C. 1983. A wood densitometer using direct scanning with X-rays. Wood Sci. Technol. 17(2):91–99.
13. Downes, G. M. 2023. User Guide to the FWPA ResiProcessor Web Platform, Forest Quality Pty Ltd. Version 4.3.0.
14. Downes, G. M.,Harrington J. J.,Drew D. M.,Lausberg M.,Muyambo P.,Watt D., and Lee D. J. 2022. A comparison of radial wood property variation on Pinus radiata between an IML PD-400 ‘Resi’ instrument and increment cores analysed by SilviScan. Forests 13(5):751.
15. Downes, G. M.,Lausberg M.,Potts B. M.,Pilbeam D. L.,Bird M., and Bradshaw B. 2018. Application of the IML Resistograph to the infield assessment of basic density in plantation eucalypts. Aust. Forestry 81(3):177–185.
16. Eckard, J. T.,Isik F.,Bullock B.,Li B., and Gumpertz M. 2010. Selection efficiency for solid wood traits in Pinus taeda using time-of-flight acoustic and micro-drill resistance methods. Forest Sci. 56(3):233–241.
17. Forest Products Laboratory (US). 1987. Wood Handbook: Wood as an Engineering Material (No. 72). U.S. Forest Service. Forest Products Laboratory. General Technical Report FPL–GTR–190.
18. Fundova, I.,Funda T., and Wu H. X. 2018. Non-destructive wood density assessment of Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) using Resistograph and Pilodyn. PloS one 13(9):e0204518.
19. Gantz, C. H. 2002. Evaluating the efficiency of the resistograph to estimate genetic parameters for wood density in two softwood and two hardwood species. Master’s thesis. North Carolina State University, Raleigh. 87 pp.
20. Gapare, W. J.,Baltunis B. S.,Ivković M., and Wu H. X. 2009. Genetic correlations among juvenile wood quality and growth traits and implications for selection strategy in Pinus radiata D. Don. Ann. Forest Sci. 66(6):1, 606–609.
21. Gendvilas, V.,Lee D. J.,Kain D. P.,Kumar C.,Downes G. M.,Lausberg M., and Harrington J. J. 2024. Predicting wood density using resistance drilling: The effect of instrument and operator. Forests 15(1):157.
22. Grans, O. A. D. 2012. Effects of genetics and silviculture and their interactions on loblolly pine and Norway spruce growth and wood properties. Master’s thesis. North Carolina State University, Raleigh. 193 pp.
23. Gwaze, D. and Stevenson A. 2008. Genetic variation of wood density and its relationship with drill resistance in shortleaf pine. South. J. Appl. Forestry 32(3):130–133.
24. Icel, B. and Güler G. 2016. Nondestructive determination of spruce lumber wood density using drilling resistance (Resistograph) method. Turk. J. Agric. Forestry 40(6):900–907.
25. Isik, F. and Li B. 2003. Rapid assessment of wood density of live trees using the Resistograph for selection in tree improvement programs. Can. J. Forest Res. 33(12):2426–2435.
26. Jordan, L.,Clark A.,Schimleck L. R.,Hall D. B., and Daniels R. F. 2008. Regional variation in wood specific gravity of planted loblolly pine in the United States. Can. J. Forest Res. 38(4):698–710.
27. Kretschmann, D. E. 2010. Mechanical properties of wood. Environments 5:34.
28. Lauer, E.,Sims A.,McKeand S., and Isik F. 2021. Genetic parameters and genotype-by-environment interactions in regional progeny tests of Pinus taeda L. in the southern USA. Forest Sci. 67(1):60–71.
29. Oliveira, J. T. D. S.,Wang X., and Vidaurre G. B. 2017. Assessing specific gravity of young Eucalyptus plantation trees using a resistance drilling technique. Holzforschung 71(2):137–145.
30. Rinn, F.,Schweingruber F. H., and Schär E. 1996. RESISTOGRAPH and X-ray density charts of wood. Comparative evaluation of drill resistance profiles and X-ray density charts of different wood species. Holzforschung 50:303–311.
31. Ukrainetz, N. K. and O’Neill G. A. 2010. An analysis of sensitivities contributing measurement error to Resistograph values. Can. J. Forest Res. 40(4):806–811.
32. Walker, T. D.,Isik F., and McKeand S. E. 2019. Genetic variation in acoustic time of flight and drill resistance of juvenile wood in a large loblolly pine breeding population. Forest Sci. 65(4):469–482.
33. Williams, C. G. and Megraw R. A. 1994. Juvenile–mature relationships for wood density in Pinus taeda. Can. J. Forest Res. 24(4):714–722.
34. Zobel, B. J. and van Buijtenen J. P. 1989. Wood variation and wood properties. In: Wood Variation: Its Causes and Control. Springer, Berlin. pp. 1–32.
35. Zobel, B. J., and Jett J. B. 1995. Genetics of Wood Production. Springer, Berlin. 351 p.