Discussion of smoke corrosivity test methods: Analysis of existing tests and of their results
Source abstract
Abstract
Abstract Smoke corrosivity was, until recently, associated only with acid, mainly halogenated, gas emission. It has now been shown that all smoke is corrosive, even if it does not contain acid gases. Moreover, acid gas emission from burning materials does not fully correlate with smoke corrosive potential. Many factors govern corrosion, e.g. smoke amount and composition, humidity and temperature. Four small‐scale performance tests for smoke corrosivity have been proposed and are described: CNET, ASTM E‐5.21.70 draft radiant, ASTM D‐9.21.4 draft cone corrosimeter and DIN 53436 draft flow‐through tests. All are undergoing attempts at standardization but none has completed the process. Furthermore, none of them has, as yet, been correlated with full‐scale fires. An analysis was made of the advantages and disadvantages of each of the tests, based on the concepts applied, on the reproducibility and on the results supplied to date. Of particular interest in this respect was a study, by the Society of the Plastics Industry Polyolefins Fire Performance Council, which tested over 20 materials using three of the tests mentioned above. This analysis suggests that the cone corrosimeter is the most promising. The three main reasons for this statement are: (1) it generates a broad range of smoke corrosivity data,(2) the data have good reproducibility and (3) the apparatus is capable of yielding, with an excellent fire model, a whole range of fire properties other than smoke corrosivity. Moreover, this analysis also suggests that the CNET test is the one with the largest number of negative aspects.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline
Research context
OpenAlex topics: Fire dynamics and safety research · Combustion and Detonation Processes · Wind and Air Flow Studies
SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.
References (20)
Show source-provided references
1. 10.1016/0379-7112(89)90048-910.1016/0379-7112(89)90048-9 ↗
2. M. M.Hirschler Update on smoke corrosivity. InProc. 39th Int. Wire & Cable Symp. US Army Communications‐Electronics Command (CECOM) Fort Monmouth NJ Ed. E. F. Godwin Reno NV 13–15 November1990 pp.661–72.
3. 10.1177/07349041920100020610.1177/073490419201000206 ↗
4. J. D.Ryan V.Babrauskas T. J.O'NeillandM. M.Hirschler Performance testing for the corrosivity of smoke. InCharacterization and Toxicity of Smoke ASTM STP 1082 Amer. Soc. Testing and Materials Philadelphia PA Ed.H. J.Hasegawa pp.75–88(1990).10.1520/STP23521S ↗
5. Fire Performance: Determination of the Corrosiveness of Effluents (158 CNET/LAB/SER/ENV). National Centre for Telecommunications Studies (CNET) France (1983).
6. Test to determine acid gas evolution CSA StandardC22.2 No 0.3‐M1985 February1989 p.94 Canadian Standards Association Rexdale Ontario Canada.
7. 10.1002/vnl.73009010610.1002/vnl.730090106 ↗
8. 10.1016/0014-3057(87)90098-X10.1016/0014-3057(87)90098-X ↗
9. 10.1002/fam.81008020610.1002/fam.810080206 ↗
10. 10.1177/07349041920100050410.1177/073490419201000504 ↗
11. 10.1177/07349041910090020410.1177/073490419100900204 ↗
12. International Electrotechnical Commission Test on Gases Evolved During Combustion of Electric Cables Part 1: Determination of the amount of halogen acid evolved during the combustion of polymeric materials taken from cables IEC 754–1 Geneva Switzerland 1982.
13. International Electrotechnical Commission Test on Gases Evolved During Combustion of Electric Cables Part 2 IEC 754–2 Geneva Switzerland 1982.
14. Prüfung an Kabeln und Isolierten Leitungen Korrosivität von Brandgasen Deutsche Elektrotechnische Kommission Germany DIN 57 472‐Pt 813 1983.
15. Central Electricity Generating Board Leatherhead UK Test for Type Approval of Cables E/TSS/EX5/8056 Pt 3 1984.
16. 10.1177/07349041920100020210.1177/073490419201000202 ↗
17. C. E.Rogers S. L.KesselandJ. G.Bennett Corrosivity test methods for polymeric materials. Part 2—CNET test method. InProc. 17th Int. Conf. on Fire Safety Product Safety Corp. San Francisco CA Ed. C. J. Hilado 13–17 January pp.392–403(1992).
18. J. G.Bennett S. L.KesselandC. E.Rogers Corrosivity test methods for polymeric materials. Part 2—Modified DIN test method. InTechnical and Marketing Issues Impacting the Fire Safety of Building and Construction and Home Furnishings Applications Proc. Fire retardant Chemicals Assoc. Spring Tech. Mtg Orlando Fl 29 March–1 April 1992 FRCA Lancaster PA pp.79–97(1992).
19. S. L.Kessel J. G.BennettandC. E.Rogers Corrosivity test methods for polymeric materials. InProc. 40th Int. Wire & Cable Symp. US Army Communications‐Electronics Command (CECOM) Fort Monmouth NJ Ed. E. F. Godwin St Louis MO 18–21 November1991 pp.348–56.
20. J. G.Bennett S. L.KesselandC. E.Rogers Corrosivity test methods for polymeric materials Part 4—Cone corrosimeter test method. InIndustry Speaks Out on Flame Retardancy: Coatings; Polymers & Compounding; Test Method Development; New Products Proc. Fire Retardant Chemicals Assoc. Fall Tech. Mtg Kiawah Island SC 27 30 October 1992; FRCA Lancaster PA pp.1–21(1992).