journal article·2025-11

Impact of materials deterioration and corrosion on the readiness of U.S. naval aviation

Sergei A Shipilov

Publisher page

Abstract

The U.S. Navy faces high corrosion costs, surpassing the expenses of most-price ships and weapons systems. Naval aircraft operating in harsh environments are especially susceptible to corrosion, which affects nearly all their components and materials. Corrosion is responsible for over a quarter of the maintenance expenses for naval aviation – every hour of maintenance related to corrosion results in multiple hours of lost availability. Lengthy delays in aircraft maintenance jeopardise the Navy and Marine Corps’ ability to maintain readiness. Corrosion, especially stress corrosion cracking/corrosion fatigue, is one of the primary technical reasons why Admiral William F. Moran, then Vice Chief of Naval Operations, reported to the U.S. House Armed Services Committee in February 2017 that ‘the Navy's overall readiness has reached its lowest level in many years’ and is continuing to decline, as demonstrated in this paper. The consequences of neglecting these issues became tragically evident when a U.S. Marine Corps KC-130T Hercules crashed in Mississippi in July 2017, killing all 16 servicemen on board. The investigation revealed that the growth of a corrosion fatigue crack was ‘ultimately the root cause of this catastrophic mishap’. This crash and dozens of other aircraft accidents could have been prevented if the Department of Defense had made a rule to seek the advice of subject matter experts rather than just talking about corrosion costs and battling cosmetic corrosion relying on the expertise of and mainly, if not exclusively, dealing with barely trained graduates of short corrosion courses. Misunderstanding what corrosion (theoretically and practically) means and how it should be addressed is the leading (and only) cause of the lack of visible success in ‘fighting corrosion’ across all military services, especially in naval aviation.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Fatigue and fracture mechanics · Mechanical Failure Analysis and Simulation · High Temperature Alloys and Creep

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

Affiliations

FIRST-M Consulting Ltd, North York, Ontario, Canada

References (100+)

Show source-provided references
1. Dunmire DJ. DoD corrosion prevention and control (CPC) program [PowerPoint slides]. Washington DC: Department of Defense 19 September 2012.
2. Herzberg E. Impact of corrosion on cost and availability to DoD 2012 Department of Defense Maintenance Symposium held 13–16 November 2012 Grand Rapids Michigan USA.
3. Koch M. Corrosion control in the US Navy: ships and USMC vehicles ASETS Defense Workshop 2014: Sustainable Surface Engineering for Aerospace and Defense held 18–20 November 2014 Fort Myer Virginia USA.
4. Hays R. Impact of corrosion Joint Technology Exchange Group (JTEG) Monthly Teleconference on ‘Corrosion Prevention and Repair’ held 30 March 2015.
5. Koch M. Briefing: interfaces of acquisition and corrosion S&T in DoD Sixth Persh Workshop: Corrosion Policy Guiding Science and Technology held 11–12 February 2016 Alexandria Virginia USA.
6. Hays RA Huynh LH. Challenges and best practices for the implementation of corrosion control technologies for U.S. DoD assets. In: Proc. 2017 DoD-Allied Nations Technical Corrosion Conference paper no. 2017-874410. Washington DC: Department of Defense 2017.
7. Hays R. Implementation of corrosion control technologies within the U.S. Department of Defense 19th Int. Cong. on Marine Corrosion and Fouling held 24–29 June 2018 Melbourne Florida USA.
8. Sedriks J. Personal communication with G.H. Koch July 2000; quoted in [11].
9. Wynne MW. The DoD’s new corrosion policy. AMPTIAC 2003; 7(9): 9–12.
10. Rogoway T. Check out how rusty and battered USS Stout looks after spending a record 215 days at sea. The War Zone 27 November 2020.
11. Koch GH. Cost of corrosion in military equipment. CORROSION 2004 paper no. 04252. Houston TX: NACE International 2004.10.5006/C2004-04252 ↗
12. Shipilov SA. Corrosion and reliability of advanced high-performance alloys in the military services Meeting with U.S. Navy Vice Adm. Kendall L. Card (Ret.) held 9 October 2015 Global Security Directorate Oak Ridge National Laboratory Oak Ridge Tennessee USA.
13. Shipilov SA. Advances and challenges in understanding the influence of environments on the long-term stability and mechanical integrity of materials: a means of avoiding failures in aircraft structures Meeting at the Office of Corrosion Policy and Oversight (CPO) within the Office of the Under Secretary of Defense for Acquisition Technology and Logistics chaired by CPO Director Dan Dunmire held 14 January 2016 Department of Defense Alexandria Virginia USA.
14. Shipilov SA. DoD-focused master’s degree program in corrosion engineering Leadership Team Meeting chaired be Dean Wayne Davis held 3 February 2016 College of Engineering University of Tennessee Knoxville Tennessee USA.
15. Shipilov SA. Corrosion and materials research to meet 21st-century defense needs: Defense Institute for Science and Technology of Corrosion (DISC) at ORNL and master’s degree program in materials science and engineering with a concentration in corrosion engineering at the University of Tennessee Teleconference Meeting of the U.S. Department of Defense Corrosion Policy and Oversight (CPO) Leadership and Military Department Corrosion Control and Prevention Executives chaired by CPO Director Dan Dunmire held 17 February 2016.
16. Shipilov SA. Corrosion fatigue crack propagation in a Stryker combat vehicle. DoD CorrDigest 2018; 1(2): 18–24. Reprint from Proc. 2017 DoD-Allied Nations Technical Corrosion Conference, paper no. 2017-761104. Washington, DC: Department of Defense, 2017.
17. Shipilov SA. An experimental irradiation assembly for the investigation of corrosion fatigue crack growth in the structural components of naval reactors. In: Proc. 2019 DoD-Allied Nations Technical Corrosion Conference, paper no. 2019-0099. Washington, DC: Department of Defense, 2019.
18. Shipilov SA. Impact of corrosion on the United States Navy’s overall readiness. Report to the U.S. National Commission on Military Aviation Safety. North York Ontario Canada: FIRST-M Consulting Ltd. 14 February 2020.
19. Fontana MG. Corrosion engineering. 3rd ed. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill, 1986.
20. What is military readiness? Chapel Hill NC: Institute for Defense and Business 2023.
21. Long-term strategy to reduce corrosion and the effects of corrosion on the military equipment and infrastructure of the Department of Defense. Report to Congress by the Principal Deputy Under Secretary of Defense for Acquisition Technology and Logistics. Washington DC: Office of the Secretary of Defense 2003. Also Ruocco J director of the Air Vehicles Engineering Department at NAVAIR. Keynote at the 2019 DoD-Allied Nations Technical Corrosion Conference held 12–15 August 2019 Oklahoma City Oklahoma USA.
22. Hodge Seck H. Active ships in the US Navy. Military.com 23 June 2021.
23. 2023 world air forces. Sutton UK: FlightGlobal 2022.
24. Defense management: opportunities to reduce corrosion costs and increase readiness. Report to congressional committees GAO-03-753. Washington DC: General Accounting Office 7 July 2003.
25. McGarry B. Admiral: corrosion damage on F/A-18 Hornets ‘caught us by surprise’. Military.com 5 June 2015.
26. Rose A. Corrosion resistant design: using CCM+ to model electrochemical processes and guide material choice in aerospace and automotive systems [PowerPoint slides]. Tyrone GA: Corredesa 2018.
27. Mendoza R. In-service corrosion issues in sustainment of naval aircraft [PowerPoint slides]. NAVAIR public release SPR-2012-982. San Diego CA: NAVAIR (Naval Air Systems Command) North Island Advanced Structures Design Group 28 August 2012.
28. Agarwala VS. Aircraft corrosion control and maintenance. In: Proc. RTO AVT-144 Workshop on ‘Enhanced Aircraft Platform Availability Through Advanced Maintenance Concepts and Technologies’, paper no. 25. Neuilly-sur-Seine Cedex, France: NATO, 2006.
29. Spadafora SJ. NAVAIR perspective on corrosion prevention and control. Report ADA375736. Patuxent River MD: NAWCAD (Naval Air Warfare Center Aircraft Division) January 2000.10.21236/ADA375736 ↗
30. Freedberg SJ. Navy Marine F-18s in ‘death spiral’ as readiness plummets. Breaking Defense 8 February 2017.
31. Greenwood C. The Naval Air Systems Command unveils a breakthrough alternative to chromate-based primers for DoD aircraft. Armed with Science 13 April 2018.
32. Eckstein M. VCNO Moran: Navy will be ‘just flat out out of money’ without supplemental funding; would cancel flight hours ship avails. USNI News 7 February 2017.
33. Cavas CP. Grounded: nearly two-thirds of US Navy’s strike fighters can’t fly. Defense News 6 February 2017.
34. Giangreco L. Top USN admiral warns Congress on aviation fleet. FlightGlobal 9 November 2017.
35. Statement of Lieutenant General Steven R. Rudder Deputy Commandant for Aviation before the Readiness Subcommittee of the U.S. House Armed Services Committee on Aviation Readiness. Washington DC: The Armed Services Committee 9 November 2017.
36. Fiscal year 2009 budget for Air Force and Navy aviation. Summary justification. Washington DC: Department of Defense 4 February 2008.
37. A cooperative strategy for 21st century seapower. Washington, DC: Department of the Navy, 2015.
38. Larter DB. A top US Navy engineer says the fleet needs to get out and bust the rust. Defense News 30 June 2019.
39. Kanable R. How naval aviation is combatting its billion-dollar corrosion problem. Aviation Pros 16 June 2022.10.4324/9781003127406-01 ↗
40. Koch G, Varney J, Thompson N, et al. International measures of prevention, application, and economics of corrosion technologies (IMPACT) study. Houston, TX: NACE International, March 2016.
41. Bennett LH, Kruger J, Parker PL, et al. Economic effects of metallic corrosion in the United States, part 1. A report to the Congress by the National Bureau of Standards. NBS special publication 511-1. Washington, DC: National Bureau of Standards, May 1978.
42. Koch GH, Brongers MPH, Thompson NG, et al. Corrosion costs and preventive strategies in the United States. FHWA report RD-01-156. Washington, DC: Federal Highway Administration, March 2002.
43. Larter DB. The US Navy’s top officer says he’ll trade growing the fleet for readiness. Defense News 15 January 2020.
44. McCurdy C. Navy officials ask for bigger share of Pentagon budget. SpaceDaily.com 16 January 2020.
45. Thomas II ED. Cost of corrosion for ships submarines and naval aviation [PowerPoint slides]. Washington DC: Department of the Navy ca. 2014.
46. Spadafora S Matzdorf C. Impact of corrosion on the naval aviation enterprise brief to NAVAIR Commander. Patuxent River MD: NAVAIR 2005; quoted in [73].
47. Sensor system developed for remote corrosion detection. Mater Perform 1999; 38(4): 16.
48. Agarwala VS. Aircraft corrosion in the military – maintenance and repair issues. CORROSION'98 paper no. 597. Houston TX: NACE International 1998.10.5006/C1998-98597 ↗
49. Agarwala VS. Control of corrosion and service life. CORROSION 2004 paper no. 04257. Houston TX: NACE International 2004.10.5006/C2004-04257 ↗
50. Audit of Navy and Marine Corps actions to address corrosion on F/A-18C-G aircraft. Report no. DODIG-2021-133. Washington DC: Department of Defence Office of Inspector General 1 October 2021.
51. LaGrone S. U.S. aircraft carrier deployments at 25 year low as Navy struggles to reset forces. USNI News 26 September 2018.
52. Mizokami K. The U.S. Navy flies its last F/A-18 Hornet. Popular Mechanics 7 October 2019.
53. Werner B. Navy fighter readiness nearing 80 percent mission capable target. USNI News 5 April 2019.
54. Herzberg EF Acton L Chan TK et al. Estimated impact of corrosion on cost and availability of DoD weapon systems FY2019 update. Tysons VA: LMI March 2019.
55. Copp T. The death toll for rising aviation accidents: 133 troops killed in five years. Military Times 8 April 2018.
56. Copp T. Is military aviation getting any safer? New mishap data shows mixed results. Military Times 8 April 2019.
57. Myers M. This commission wants to hear your uncensored concerns about military aviation safety. Military Times 21 October 2019.
58. Mattis J. Memorandum for secretaries of the military departments Under Secretary of Defense for Acquisition and Sustainment and Under Secretary of Defense for Personnel and Readiness: NDS implementation mission capability of critical aviation platforms of September 17 2018. Washington DC: Department of Defense 2018.
59. Maurer D. Military readiness: improvement in some areas, but sustainment and other challenges persist. Testimony before the Subcommittee on Readiness and Management Support, Committee on Armed Services, U.S. Senate, GAO-23-106673. Washington, DC: Government Accountability Office, 2 May 2023.
60. Weapon system sustainment: aircraft mission capable goals were generally not met and sustainment costs varied by aircraft. Report to congressional committees GAO-23-106217. Washington DC: Government Accountability Office 10 November 2022.
61. Naval aviation achieved SECDEF readiness target shifts focus to readiness sustainment Naval Aviation Enterprise Public Affairs (NAEPA) story no. NNS 190924-06 24 September 2019.
62. Navy's Super Hornet readiness recognized for program leadership excellence. NAVAIR News 21 October 2021.
63. World air forces 2011/2012. Sutton UK: Flightglobal Insight 2011.
64. World air forces 2013. Sutton UK: Flightglobal Insight 2012.
65. World air forces 2014. Sutton UK: Flightglobal Insight 2013.
66. World air forces 2015. Sutton UK: Flightglobal 2014.
67. World air forces 2018. Sutton UK: Flightglobal 2017.
68. World air forces 2020. Sutton UK: Flightglobal 2019.
69. World air forces 2021. Sutton UK: Flightglobal 2020.
70. Gilday MM. Chief of Naval Operations (CNO) navigation plan 2022. Washington, DC: Department of the Navy, January 2021.
71. O’Rourke R. Navy force structure and shipbuilding plans: background and issues for Congress. CRS report RL32665. CRS report RL32665. Washington, DC: Congressional Research Service, 19 April 2023.
72. Maurer DC. Navy maintenance: persistent and substantial ship and submarine maintenance delays hinder efforts to rebuild readiness. Testimony before the Subcommittees on Seapower and Readiness and Management Support, Committee on Armed Services, U.S. Senate, GAO-20-257T. Washington, DC: Government Accountability Office, 4 December 2019.
73. Fischer J. Naval aviation S&T: corrosion resistant alloys [PowerPoint slides]. Patuxent River MD: NAVAIR 8 November 2006.
74. Availability and use of aircraft in the Air Force and Navy. Washington DC: Congressional Budget Office January 2022.
75. Availability and use of the F/A-18E/F Super Hornet fighter aircraft. Washington DC: Congressional Budget Office February 2023.
76. F/A-18E/F Super Hornet. Patuxent River MD: NAVAIR n.d.; retrieved 15 April 2023.
77. Maurer D. F-35 sustainment: DOD faces several uncertainties and has not met key objectives. Testimony before the Subcommittee on Readiness, Committee on Armed Services, U.S. House of Representatives, GAO-22-105995. Washington, DC: Government Accountability Office, 28 April 2022.
78. Newdick T Rogoway T. The F-35C’s radar-absorbent skin is looking pretty rough after months at sea. The War Zone 29 January 2022.
79. F-35C carrier-based fighters quickly rust. Top War 30 January 2022.
80. Rust – not stealth: U.S. Navy’s new F-35C fighters are conspicuously decaying on their carriers. Military Watch Magazine 2 February 2022.
81. F35 was found to be covered in rust can stealth fighters still be invisible if they are rusted? The U.S. Navy is underwhelming iNEWS 2022; retrieved 26 June 2023.
82. Jennings G. USN stands up F-35C West Coast Fleet Replacement Squadron Janes 26 January 2017.
83. Nikolov B. Shocking photos: US F-35C Lightning II jets covered in rust. Bulgarian Military 28 January 2022.
84. Mouritz AP. Introduction to aerospace materials. Cambridge, UK: Woodhead Publishing, 2012.
85. F/A-18E/F aircraft crash rescue: fire fighting information. Seattle, WA: Boeing, January 2006.
86. Axe D. Lockheed’s dubious claim: stealth fighter will get stealthier with age. Wired 6 November 2012.
87. Revealed: top 10 best fighter jets in the world in 2023. AeroTime 14 June 2023.
88. VFA-147 ‘Argonauts ’ U.S. Navy Strike Fighter Squadron 147 (STRKFITRON 147). Seaforces.org (Naval Information) n.d.; retrieved 25 June 2023.
89. Rogoway T. These images of an F-22 Raptor’s crumbling radar absorbent skin are fascinating. The War Zone 1 December 2019.
90. Insinna V Larter DB. Supersonic speeds could cause big problems for the F-35’s stealth coating. Defense News 12 June 2019.
91. Carl Vinson Carrier Strike Group departs on deployment. From Commander U.S. 3rd Fleet Public Affairs. America's Navy 3 August 2021.
92. EA-18G Growler. Patuxent River MD: NAVAIR n.d.; retrieved 15 April 2023.
93. F/A-18E/F Super Hornet. Military.com (Military Advantage) 2003; retrieved 15 April 2023.
94. Venckunas V. Top 10 most expensive fighter jets in 2021. AeroTime 29 March 2021.
95. Finnerty R. US Navy aims for majority of carrier-based aircraft to be pilotless. FlightGlobal 5 April 2023.
96. Sadler B. U.S. Navy. In: An assessment of U.S. military power. Washington, DC: The Heritage Foundation, 2022, pp.361–396.
97. Mizokami K. New report ranks U.S. military branches from strong to weak. The results aren’t great. Popular Mechanics 18 November 2020.
98. You’re a senior leader; get out of your lane. U.S. Naval Institute Blog 19 September 2019.
99. Konrad J. Top Navy admiral wants rust-free ships. gCapitan 28 April 2022.
100. Schogol J. The Navy’s surface fleet is turning into a floating advertisement for rust-oleum. Task & Purpose 2 March 2021.