Direct Observations of Ion Densities at Functionalized Interfaces to Test Hypotheses Regarding the Origin of Specific Ion Effects

Interactions of anions with protonatable groups were investigated using X-ray fluorescence near total reflection (XFNTR) on floating monolayers at the surface of water. The number of ions attracted to the interfacial region, which XFNTR measures directly, is ion-specific as well as monolayer-specific. Our observation of the distinctly different behaviors of ClO 4 – and ReO 4 –, two ions with the same tetrahedral structure and almost the same sizes and hydration enthalpies, challenges current theories of ion specificity. Our observations are inconsistent with not only the Gouy–Chapman model (as expected) but also size-modified Poisson–Boltzmann theory and the “law of matching water affinity”. We suggest that factors other than ion size and ion–water interactions, including possibly ion–ion interactions and lateral ordering at the interface, must be considered to account for specific ion effects.