journal article·2009-10-01

Dipolar Control of Monolayer Morphology on Graphite: Self-Assembly of Anthracenes with Odd Length Diether Side Chains

Wenjun Tong, Xiaoliang Wei, Matthew B. Zimmt

The Journal of Physical Chemistry C· Volume 113· Issue 39
Publisher page

Abstract

The monolayers self-assembled at the solution−graphite interface by 18 1,5-bis(2,X-dioxaalkyl) anthracene derivatives bearing odd length side chains are studied using scanning tunneling microscopy and molecular mechanics (MM) simulations. 1-D molecular tapes are the key and common building block of the many morphologies self-assembled by these compounds. The dominant monolayer morphology and the extent of monolayer polymorphism depend critically on the position of the X-ether group and side chain length. MM simulations of the compounds’ different morphologies are useful tools with which to dissect, explain, and predict morphological variation and polymorphism as a function of side chain structure. The simulations reveal that the dependence on X-ether group position arises from dipolar repulsions between ether groups in adjacent tapes, dipolar attractions between ether and anthracene C−H groups in adjacent tapes, and geometric distortions of the side chains.
Source: openalex_inverted_index · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Molecular Junctions and Nanostructures · Advanced biosensing and bioanalysis techniques · Surface Chemistry and Catalysis

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

Affiliations

Department of Chemistry, Brown University, Providence, Rhode Island 02912

References (47)

Show source-provided references
1. Rothemund P. W. K. · Nature · 2006 · 440 · 29710.1038/nature04586 ↗
2. Förster S. · Macromolecules · 1994 · 27 · 692210.1021/ma00101a033 ↗
3. Jenekhe S. A. · Science · 1999 · 283 · 37210.1126/science.283.5400.372 ↗
4. Chaudhury M. K. · Science · 1992 · 256 · 153910.1126/science.256.5063.1539 ↗
5. Le J. D. · Nano Lett. · 2004 · 4 · 234310.1021/nl048635+ ↗
6. Yan H. · Science · 2003 · 301 · 188210.1126/science.1089389 ↗
7. Tong W. · Langmuir · 2009 · 25 · 291310.1021/la803811w ↗
8. Pokrifchak M. · J. Phys. Chem. C · 2007 · 111 · 773510.1021/jp0704968 ↗
9. Stabel A. · J. Phys. Chem. · 1995 · 99 · 869010.1021/j100021a039 ↗
10. Kaneda Y. · Langmuir · 2001 · 17 · 618510.1021/la0100587 ↗
11. Kim K. · Langmuir · 2003 · 19 · 714910.1021/la0342621 ↗
12. Lackinger M. · Langmuir · 2005 · 21 · 498410.1021/la0467640 ↗
13. Kampschulte L. · J. Phys. Chem. B · 2006 · 110 · 1082910.1021/jp057553m ↗
14. Wei Y. · J. Am. Chem. Soc. · 2006 · 128 · 1336210.1021/ja065338t ↗
15. Wei Y. · J. Am. Chem. Soc. · 2008 · 130 · 339910.1021/ja075170r ↗
16. Xu X. · Chem. Phys. Lett. · 2000 · 323 · 20910.1016/S0009-2614(00)00501-7 ↗
17. Kannappan K. · J. Phys. Chem. B · 2007 · 111 · 663410.1021/jp0706984 ↗
18. Ilan B. · J. Phys. Chem. C · 2007 · 111 · 1824310.1021/jp075673j ↗
19. Ilan B. · J. Phys. Chem. C · 2009 · 113 · 364110.1021/jp809218r ↗
20. Hentschke R. · J. Chem. Phys. · 1992 · 96 · 621310.1063/1.462612 ↗
21. Peters G. H. · Langmuir · 1996 · 12 · 155710.1021/la950306x ↗
22. Cincotti S. · Phys. Rev. E · 1995 · 51 · 209010.1103/PhysRevE.51.2090 ↗
23. Krishnan M. · Proc. Ind. Acad. Sci. · 2003 · 115 · 66310.1007/BF02708256 ↗
24. Steele W. A. · Surf. Sci. · 1973 · 36 · 31710.1016/0039-6028(73)90264-1 ↗
25. Carbon 1 of the anthracene core is attached to a side chain. Carbon (and hydrogen) atoms along the exterior of the same benzene ring are numbered 2−4. Atoms 5−8 are interchanged with atoms 1−4 by rotation about the 2-fold symmetry axis aligned perpendicular to the anthracene plane.
26. Intermolecular interactions determine the lowest energy morphology provided that molecule−HOPG interactions do not vary significantly with morphology.
27. Burkert U. · 1982
28. Hyperchem 8.0, CyberChem, Inc., 1115 NW 4th Street Suite 2, Gainesville, FL 32601.
29. Dewar M. J. S. · J. Am. Chem. Soc. · 1985 · 107 · 390210.1021/ja00299a024 ↗
30. RMS gradient limit of 10−3kcal/mol·Å was not achieved for any minimization. The minimizations required 5−20 days depending on starting position and side chain length.
31. Shifting an interior anthracene more than 2 nm from the closest section edge eliminates its interactions with all other molecules in the section.
32. The factor of one half is required to partition the “vertical” extraction energy equally between the shifted molecule and its neighbors.
33. “Vertical extraction” of an anthracene disrupts two intratape contacts, two intertape contacts and two anthracene−anthracene contacts. The intratape, intertape, and An-An values listed in Table2areper contact. C-2-C packed tapes: (i) the intratape term arises primarily from interactions of the odd atoms on two ω↔2 packed side chains and between these side chains’ terminal methyl groups and the 8-CH and 9-CH units of the adjacent anthracene in the same tape; (ii) the intertape term includes interaction of the even atoms of two ω↔2 packed side chains from adjacent tapes and interaction of these side chains’ terminal ethyl groups with the 2-CH and 3-CH groups of the adjacent tape anthracenes; (iii) the An-An terms includes interaction of the 3-CH and 4-CH groups of adjacent tape anthracenes. H-2-H packed tapes: (i) the intratape term includes interactions of odd atoms of two ω↔2 packed side chains in the same tape and interactions of these side chains’ terminal methyl groups with the 8-CH and 9-CH units of the adjacent anthracene in the same tape; (ii) the intertape term arises from interaction of the even atoms of two ω↔8 packed side chains from adjacent tapes. The H-2-H intertape term does not include interactions of side chains with anthracenes in an adjacent tape; (iii) the An-An terms includes interactions of the 2-CH and 3-CH groups of adjacent tape anthracenes and interactions of the anthracenes’ 3-CH groups with the 2-O and 4-CH2groups in the adjacent tape.
34. The lower and upper values for the 10 compounds are fromA-[192,8]2andA-[132,12]2, respectively. The energy difference per nm for each morphology is obtained by dividing the difference of calculated SAE per molecule by the unit cellb-axis length: 3.2 nm forA-[192,8]2and 2.35 nm forA-[132,12]2. Theb-axis lengths are nearly identical for C-2-C and H-2-H morphologies.
35. This analysis ignores entropic contributions.
36. The MM calculated SAE per molecule forA-[112,7]2ec-tape HB morphology, is−15.32 kcal/mol (16.07 kcal/mol “vertical” extraction energy). SAE for the C-2-C and H-2-H morphologies are−13.66 and −12.56 kcal/mol. The MM calculated SAE per molecule forA-[132,8]2oc-tape HB morphology is−18.39 kcal/mol (19.11 “vertical” extraction energy). SAE for the C-2-C and H-2-H morphologies are−15.94 and −16.92.
37. A-[152,9]2andA-[212,12]2primarily assemble C-2-C morphology, with oc-tape HB as defects. The MM calculated SAE per molecule for their C-2-C, H-2-H and oc-tape HB morphologies are, respectively,A-[152,9]2{ −19.15, −17.83 −17.27 kcal/mol} andA-[212,12]2{ −28.10, −27.67, −27.65 kcal/mol}. The simulations predict C-2-C as the major morphology of both compounds, in agreement with the experimental results. The simulations do not exhibit a detectable, intrinsic bias in favor of C-2-C, H-2-H, or HB morphology.
38. AM1 calculations(18)assign the ether oxygen a charge of −0.281. The α-H charge is +0.066.
39. Charges and positions of the ether oxygen, α-carbon and α-hydrogen atoms of proximate 2- and 8- position ether groups(27)were used to determine the intertape ether−ether Coulomb repulsion forA-[152,8]2(1.2 kcal/mol) andA-[112,8]2(average of 0.47 ± 0.05 kcal/mol for each of the 2-O - 8′-O, 8-O - 8′-O, and 2′-O - 8-O interactions, where nonprime and prime numbers indicate oxygen side chain positions in adjacent tapes).
40. Compounds with side chain 10 position oxygen atoms (10-O) produce smaller increases of the An-An attraction (C-2-C → H-2-H) than do 8-O compounds but produce larger increases than most other compounds. A 10-O group will also induce a side chain bend and rotation of the attached anthracene. However, the bend forces the same chain’s 8-CH2toward the (ω − 1)-CH2of the adjacent tape. The mean calculated 2-O−3-H(An) separation = 3.27 Å is larger than for the 8-O substituted compounds. Consequently, a 10-O is less effective than an 8-O at increasing the 2-O−3-H(An) Coulomb attraction and the An-An (H-2-H) stabilization.
41. Even chain length anthracene compounds are another potential way to form single morphology monolayers. These compounds spontaneously assemble ω↔2 packed AA* tapes, which then assemble into C-2-C monolayers. As a consequence of these tapes’ highly jagged peripheries, ω↔2 intertape registration is the only AA* tape alignment that generates close packed monolayers.
42. Stabilizing interactions are shared between side chains, so these values are 1/2 those reported in Table2.
43. Desiraju G. R. · Acc. Chem. Res. · 1991 · 24 · 27010.1021/ar00010a002 ↗
44. Steiner T. · Crystallogr. Rev. · 1996 · 6 · 110.1080/08893119608035394 ↗
45. cSteiner, T.Chem. Comm. 1997, 727.10.1039/a603049a ↗
46. dDesiraju, G. R.Chem. Comm. 2005, 2995.10.1039/b504372g ↗
47. Lavoie S. · Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. · 2006 · 45 · 740410.1002/anie.200603103 ↗