journal article·2022-05-01Open access

Charge and field driven integrated optical modulators: comparative analysis: opinion

Jacob B. Khurgin, Volker J. Sorger, Rubab Amin

Optical Materials Express· Volume 12· Issue 5

Abstract

Electro optic modulators being key for many signal processing systems must adhere to requirements given by both electrical and optical constraints. Distinguishing between charge driven (CD) and field driven (FD) designs, we answer the question of whether fundamental performance benefits can be claimed of modulators based on emerging electro-optic materials. Following primary metrics, we compare the performance of emerging electro-optic and electro-absorption modulators such as graphene, transparent conductive oxides, and Si, based on charge injection with that of the ‘legacy’ FD modulators, such as those based on lithium niobate and quantum confined Stark effect. We show that for rather fundamental reasons and when considering energy and speed only, FD modulators always outperform CD ones in the conventional wavelength scale photonic waveguides. However, for waveguides featuring a sub-wavelength optical mode, such as those assisted by plasmonics, the emerging CD devices are indeed highly competitive especially for applications where component-density on-chip is a factor.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Photonic and Optical Devices · Optical Network Technologies · Advanced Fiber Laser Technologies

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

Affiliations

Johns Hopkins University

George Washington University

Funding

Air Force Office of Scientific Research · Directorate for Engineering · Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency

References (33)

Show source-provided references
1. Kaminow · Appl. Phys. Lett. · 1974 · 24 · 62210.1063/1.1655079 ↗
2. Wooten · IEEE J. Sel. Top. Quantum Electron. · 2000 · 6 · 6910.1109/2944.826874 ↗
3. Bar-JosephKlingshirn · Appl. Phys. Lett. · 1987 · 50 · 101010.1063/1.97991 ↗
4. Kuo · IEEE J. Sel. Top. Quantum Electron. · 2006 · 12 · 150310.1109/JSTQE.2006.883146 ↗
5. Knupfer · IEEE Photonics Technol. Lett. · 1993 · 5 · 138610.1109/68.262549 ↗
6. Sysak · Opt. Express · 2008 · 16 · 1247810.1364/OE.16.012478 ↗
7. Zhang · Optica · 2021 · 8 · 65210.1364/OPTICA.415762 ↗
8. Xu · Nat. Commun. · 2020 · 11 · 391110.1038/s41467-020-17806-0 ↗
9. Miller · IEEE J. Sel. Top. Quantum Electron. · 2000 · 6 · 131210.1109/2944.902184 ↗
10. Miller · Opt. Express · 2012 · 20 · A29310.1364/OE.20.00A293 ↗
11. Xu · Nature · 2005 · 435 · 32510.1038/nature03569 ↗
12. Dainesi · IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett. · 2000 · 12 · 66010.1109/68.849076 ↗
13. Amin · APL Photonics · 2018 · 3 · 12610410.1063/1.5052635 ↗
14. Ma · Nanophotonics-Berlin · 2015 · 4 · 19810.1515/nanoph-2015-0006 ↗
15. Shi · Opt. Lett. · 2014 · 39 · 497810.1364/OL.39.004978 ↗
16. Amin · Optica · 2020 · 7 · 33310.1364/OPTICA.389437 ↗
17. You · Laser Photonics Rev · 2020 · 14 · 200023910.1002/lpor.202000239 ↗
18. Sun · Nat Photonics · 2016 · 10 · 22710.1038/nphoton.2016.15 ↗
19. Liu · Nature · 2011 · 474 · 6410.1038/nature10067 ↗
20. Amin · Appl. Opt. · 2018 · 57 · D13010.1364/AO.57.00D130 ↗
21. Phare · Nat Photonics · 2015 · 9 · 51110.1038/nphoton.2015.122 ↗
22. Kravets · npj 2D Mater. Appl. · 2019 · 3 · 3610.1038/s41699-019-0119-1 ↗
23. Datta · Nat Photonics · 2020 · 14 · 25610.1038/s41566-020-0590-4 ↗
24. Liu · Laser Photonics Rev · 2015 · 9 · 17210.1002/lpor.201400219 ↗
25. Miller · J. Lightwave Technol. · 2017 · 35 · 34610.1109/JLT.2017.2647779 ↗
26. Chen · 2012
27. Wakita · 1998
28. Amin · Opt. Express · 2018 · 26 · 1544510.1364/OE.26.015445 ↗
29. Amin · IEEE J. Sel. Top. Quantum Electron. · 2021 · 27 · 110.1109/JSTQE.2020.3041835 ↗
30. Nedeljkovic · IEEE Photonics J. · 2011 · 3 · 117110.1109/JPHOT.2011.2171930 ↗
31. Physics of photonic devices
32. Aoki · IEEE J. Quantum Electron. · 1993 · 29 · 208810.1109/3.234473 ↗
33. Veithen · Phys. Rev. B · 2002 · 65 · 21430210.1103/PhysRevB.65.214302 ↗