White structure flaking (WSF) in wind turbine gearbox bearings: Effects of ‘butterflies’ and white etching cracks (WECs)
Source abstract
Abstract
The actual service life of wind turbine gearboxes is often well below the desired 20 years. One of the prevalent failure modes in gearbox bearing raceways is white structure flaking (WSF) by the formation of butterflies and white etching cracks with associated microstructural change called white etching areas. Despite these failures having been observed for two decades in various industries, the detailed reasons and mechanisms for their formation are not fully understood. In this review, white etching area formation mechanisms are discussed, specifically grain refinement, and effects of carbon/carbide in a range of bearing steels of widely differing carbon content. The review also highlights the severe transient, cyclic loading and tribochemical operating conditions of gearbox bearings and explains how these may act as drivers to produce WSF. Much previous research has focused on the detrimental effects of hydrogen, but other work suggests that hydrogen is not the only cause for WSF. Possible methods for preventing WSF are discussed, with attention paid to special steels such as high chromium steels, low carbon stainless nitrogen alloy steels and carbonitrided steels. Beneficial compressive residual stresses, surface coatings and enhanced lubrication and additive packages are shown to offer degrees of prevention, although the mechanisms leading to improvements are not fully understood.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline
Research context
OpenAlex topics: Hydrogen embrittlement and corrosion behaviors in metals · Corrosion Behavior and Inhibition · Metal Alloys Wear and Properties
SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.
Affiliations
National Centre for Advanced Tribology (nCATS), University of Southampton, UK
References (100+)
Show source-provided references
1. 10.1098/rsta.2010.019410.1098/rsta.2010.0194 ↗
2. Ihata K Shiga T Umeda A: ‘Rolling bearing assembly having magnet to prevent brittle flaking’ US Patent 7 520 675 B2 2009.
3. Tanaka S Mitamura N Murakami Y: ‘Influence of sliding and chromium content in the steel on the white structural change under rolling contact’ Proc. Global Powertrain Cong. Dearborn MI USA September 2004 Global Powertrain Congress Vol. 32 6–13.
4. Iso K Yokouchi A Takemura H: ‘Research work for clarifying the mechanism of white structure flaking and extending the life of bearings’ SAE World Cong. Detroit MI USA April 2005 SAE International Paper 2005-01-1868.10.4271/2005-01-1868 ↗
5. Luyckx J Broeders W Geertsom J: ‘Method for increasing the fatigue strength of a predominantly steel mechanical part of a wind turbine and/or for reducing the tendency to form what are called ‘white etching cracks’ or ‘brittle flakes’ in such steel mechanical parts’ US Patent 2009/0288742 A1 2009.
6. Northwest Laboratories of Seattle Inc. Seattle WA USA 2007.
7. Wind turbine gearbox reconstruction in Fig. 3 based on model from National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) Gearbox Reliability Collaborative.
8. Barry J, , Byrne G: ‘TEM study on the surface white layer in two turned hardened steels’, Metall. Mater. Trans. A, 2002, 325A, 356–364.
9. 10.1016/j.msea.2004.08.05210.1016/j.msea.2004.08.052 ↗
10. 10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2005.12.00210.1016/j.ijfatigue.2005.12.002 ↗
11. 10.1016/S0965-9773(97)00162-110.1016/S0965-9773(97)00162-1 ↗
12. 10.1016/j.wear.2007.01.00310.1016/j.wear.2007.01.003 ↗
13. 10.1016/j.wear.2008.02.02610.1016/j.wear.2008.02.026 ↗
14. 10.1016/0043-1648(95)06733-710.1016/0043-1648(95)06733-7 ↗
15. Yokoyama H, , Mitao S, , Yamamoto S, , Kataoka Y, , Sugiyama T: ‘High strength bainitic steel rails for heavy haul railways with superior damage resistance’, NKK Tech. Rev., 2001, 84, 44–51.
16. Wright TW: ‘The physics and mathematic of adiabatic shear bands’; 2002 Cambridge Cambridge University Press.
17. 10.1007/s11661-007-9271-x10.1007/s11661-007-9271-x ↗
18. 10.1520/STP26228S10.1520/STP26228S ↗
19. 10.1179/03071698080328667610.1179/030716980803286676 ↗
20. 10.1016/0022-5096(95)00001-Y10.1016/0022-5096(95)00001-Y ↗
21. 10.1007/BF0265659210.1007/BF02656592 ↗
22. Harris TA Kotzalas MN: ‘Rolling bearing analysis – essential concepts of bearing technology’; 2007 Boca Raton FL Taylor & Francis.10.1201/9781420006582 ↗
23. 10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2009.07.00210.1016/j.ijfatigue.2009.07.002 ↗
24. 10.1520/JAI10255910.1520/JAI102559 ↗
25. 10.2355/isijinternational1966.10.9810.2355/isijinternational1966.10.98 ↗
26. Grabulov A: ‘Fundamentals of rolling contact fatigue’ PhD thesis University of Belgrade Serbia 2010.
27. 10.1179/03071698180327541510.1179/030716981803275415 ↗
28. 10.1520/JAI1405910.1520/JAI14059 ↗
29. 10.1016/j.scriptamat.2007.06.02410.1016/j.scriptamat.2007.06.024 ↗
30. 10.2355/isijinternational.45.189710.2355/isijinternational.45.1897 ↗
31. Scott D, , Loy B, , Mills GH: ‘Metallurgical aspects of rolling contact fatigue’, P. I. Mech. Eng., 1966, 181, (315), 94–103.
32. Endo T Dong D Imai Y Yamamoto Y:‘Study on rolling contact fatigue in hydrogen atmosphere – improvement of rolling contact fatigue life by formation of surface film’Proc. 31st Leeds-Lyon Tribology Symp.: ‘Life cycle tribology’ ( Dowson D et al..) 343–350; 2004 Leeds Elsevier.10.1016/S0167-8922(05)80036-7 ↗
33. Vegter RH, , Slycke JT: ‘The role of hydrogen on rolling contact fatigue response of rolling element bearings’, J. ASTM Int., 2009, 7, (2), 1–12.10.1520/JAI102543 ↗
34. 10.1080/1040200100379018610.1080/10402001003790186 ↗
35. Peng XD, , Shimizu Y, , Mitamura N:‘Long life bearing technologies on material aspect’in ‘Advanced tribology’, (, Luo J, , et al..), 932–933; 2010, Berlin, Heidelberg, Springer.
36. Fujita S Mitamura N Murakami Y: ‘Research of new factors affecting rolling contact fatigue life’ Proc. World Tribology Congress III Washington DC USA September 2005 ASME 1–2.10.1115/WTC2005-63400 ↗
37. 10.1520/STP10857S10.1520/STP10857S ↗
38. 10.2474/trol.6.12310.2474/trol.6.123 ↗
39. Hiraoka K, , Fujimatsu T, , Tsunekage N, , Yamamoto A: ‘Generation process observation of micro-structural change in rolling contact fatigue by hydrogen-charged specimens’, Jpn J. Tribol., 2007, 52, (6), 673–683.
40. Österlund R, , Vingsbo O, , Vincent L, , Guiraldenq P: ‘Butterflies in fatigued ball bearings – formation mechanism and structure’, Scand. J. Metall., 1982, 11, 23–32.
41. Davies WJ Day KL: ‘Surface fatigue in ball bearings roller bearings and gears in aircraft engines’ Proc. Symp. on ‘Fatigue in rolling contact’ London UK March 1963 Institution of Mechanical Engineers 23–40.
42. Murakami Y Naka M Iwamoto A Chatell G: ‘Long life bearings for automotive alternator applications’ Proc. Int. Cong. Exposit. Detroit MI USA February–March 1995 SAE International 1–14.10.4271/950944 ↗
43. 10.1016/S0389-4304(03)00035-310.1016/S0389-4304(03)00035-3 ↗
44. 10.1016/0043-1648(96)06990-610.1016/0043-1648(96)06990-6 ↗
45. 10.1115/1.364590210.1115/1.3645902 ↗
46. 10.1115/1.364590710.1115/1.3645907 ↗
47. Buchwald J, , Heckel HW: ‘An analysis of microstructural changes in 52100 steel bearings due to cyclic stressing’, Trans. ASM, 1968, 61, 750–756.
48. McVittie D: ‘Wind turbine gearbox reliability’; 2006. Seattle WA Gear Engineers Inc. Available from: www.sandia.gov/wind/2006reliability/tuesday/14-brianmcniff.pdf.
49. 10.1016/0956-716X(95)00108-810.1016/0956-716X(95)00108-8 ↗
50. Walton HW: ‘The influence of residual stresses on the susceptibility to hydrogen embrittlement in hardened steel components subjected to rolling contact conditions’ Proc. SAE Int. Off-Highway Cong. Las Vegas NV USA March 2002 SAE International 1–6.10.4271/2002-01-1412 ↗
51. NSK: ‘Long life bearings for engine accessories’, Motion Control, Aug. 2004, 1–10.
52. 10.1080/0569819050048632410.1080/05698190500486324 ↗
53. Kawamura T, , Mikami H: ‘Development of NA103A long-life grease for automotive components’, NTN Tech. Rev., 2007, 75, 116–123.
54. Mikami H Kawamura T: ‘Influence of electrical current on bearing flaking life’ SAE Technical Paper 2007-01-0113 SAE International Warrendale PA USA 2007.10.4271/2007-01-0113 ↗
55. Iso K Miyajima H Denpou K Toda Y Yamazaki M Naka M Fujita Y: ‘Rolling bearing rolling bearing for fuel cell compressor for fuel cell system and fuel cell system’ US Patent 7 265 080 B2 2007.
56. Nakashima H: ‘Trends in materials and heat treatments for rolling bearings’, NTN Tech. Rev., 2008, 10–17.
57. Tanaka S Murakami Y: ‘Rolling bearing’ US Patent 7 435 308 B2 2008.
58. Umeda A Shiga T Ihata K: ‘Rolling bearing incorporated in auxiliary device for internal combustion engine’ US Patent 7 618 193 B2 2009.
59. Harada H Ono Y: ‘Toroidal continuously variable transmission and method for producing torque transmitting member thereof’ US Patent 7 488 270 B2 2009.
60. Rosinski J, , Smurthwaite D: ‘Troubleshooting wind gearbox problems’, Gear Solut., 2010, 8, 22–33.
61. Rasmussen F Thomsen K Larsen TJ: ‘The gearbox problem revisited’ Risø Fact-Sheet AED-RB-17(en) Risø National Laboratory Roskilde DenmarK 2004. Available from: http://www.windwin.de/images/pdf/riso.pdf.
62. 10.1002/we.20410.1002/we.204 ↗
63. Hamilton T: ‘A more durable wind turbine’, Technol. Rev., Dec. 2009.
64. Northern Power Systems: ‘The gearbox problem’ Northern Power Systems Barre VT USA July 2009.
65. Broehl J: ‘Gearbox performance probe sparks legal fears’, Windpower Monthly Mag., Mar. 2010.
66. Musial W Butterfield S McNiff B: ‘Improving wind tubine gearbox reliability’ Proc. EWEA 2007 Conf. Milan Italy 2007 US Department of Commerce 1–10.
67. Thor SE: Proc. 57th IEA Topical Expert Meet. Jyväskylä Finland September 2008. http://www.ieawind.org/Task_11/Proceedings/57_Gearboxes.pdf.
68. 10.1098/rsta.2010.019210.1098/rsta.2010.0192 ↗
69. Terrell EJ Needelman WM Kyle JP: ‘Tribological challenges to the system’ ASME/STLE Int. Joint Tribology Conf. Memphis TN USA October 2009 ASME/STLE 26–30.
70. Siebert H: ‘Wind turbines power up with oil’, Lubr. Fluid Power, Sept./Oct. 2006.
71. Heege A, , Radovcic Y, , Betran J: ‘Fatigue load computation of wind turbine gearboxes by coupled structural, mechanism and aerodynamic analysis’, DEWI Mag., Feb. 2006, 61–68.
72. Burton T Sharpe D Jenkins N Bossanyi E: ‘Wind energy handbook’; 2001 New York John Wiley and Sons.10.1002/0470846062 ↗
73. Vries E: ‘Wind turbine gearboxes and the effort to improve their reliability’, Windpower Monthly, Jun. 2010.
74. Olver A: ‘The mechanism of rolling contact fatigue: an update’, P. I. Mech. Eng. J.-J. Eng., 2005, 219, (5), 313–330.
75. 10.1007/s11249-009-9565-910.1007/s11249-009-9565-9 ↗
76. 10.1520/STP12371S10.1520/STP12371S ↗
77. 10.1520/STP12370S10.1520/STP12370S ↗
78. 10.1023/A:100997641855310.1023/A:1009976418553 ↗
79. Tricot R, , Monnot J, , Lluansi M: ‘How microstructural alterations affect fatigue properties of 52100 steel’, Met. Eng. Q., 1972, 12, (2), 39–47.
80. Hyde RS: ‘Microstructural changes from contact fatigue’, in ‘ASM handbook’, Vol. 19, ‘Fatigue and fracture’, 1749–1780; 1996, Materials Park, OH, ASM International.
81. 10.1080/1040200080268789010.1080/10402000802687890 ↗
82. 10.1080/10402004.2010.51242810.1080/10402004.2010.512428 ↗
83. 10.1007/s11249-009-9565-910.1007/s11249-009-9565-9 ↗
84. Tanaka S, , Yamamura K, , Oohori M: ‘Excellent stainless bearing steel (ES1)’, Motion Control, 2000, 8, 23–26.
85. 10.1016/0043-1648(73)90207-X10.1016/0043-1648(73)90207-X ↗
86. 10.1520/STP36149S10.1520/STP36149S ↗
87. 10.1115/1.326107810.1115/1.3261078 ↗
88. 10.1520/STP12126S10.1520/STP12126S ↗
89. Evans RD Hager CH Logsdon RD: ‘Friction and wear performance of candidate surface treatments for wind turbine gearbox bearings in high slip contacts’ Proc. ASME/STLE 2009 Int. Joint Tribology Conf. Memphis TN USA October 2009 491–493.10.1115/IJTC2009-15206 ↗
90. Gebauer R Ruhl S: ‘Rolling bearings in wind turbine gearboxes’ INA Wälzlager Schaeffler oHG 2003. Available from: http://www.schaeffler.com/remotemedien/media/_shared_media/library/downloads/wwg_de_us.pdf.
91. TheEngineer: ‘New coating for cylindrical roller bearings reduces gearbox failures in wind turbine applications’ 2009. Available from: http://www.theengineer.co.uk/news/new-coating-for-cylindrical-roller-bearings-reduces-gearbox-failures-in-wind-turbineapplications/312356.article.
92. Schaeffler: ‘Protective materials and coatings for extreme environments’ 2010. Available from: http://www.ina.de/content.ina.de/de/press/press-releases/press-details.jsp?id=3358849.
93. 10.1115/1.151088110.1115/1.1510881 ↗
94. 10.1179/mst.1997.13.5.43010.1179/mst.1997.13.5.430 ↗
95. Sadeghi F, , Jalalahmadi B, , Slack TS, , Raje N, , Arakere NK: ‘A review of rolling contact fatigue’, J. Tribol.-T. ASME, 2009, 131, (4), 1–15.10.1115/1.3209132 ↗
96. Lundberg G, , Palmgrem A: ‘Dynamic capacity of rolling bearings’, Acta Polytech. Scand. Mech. Eng. Ser., 1947, 3, 5–50.
97. Widner RL: ‘Failures of rolling element bearings: failure analysis and prevention’, in ‘Metals handbook’, 9th edn; 1986, Materials Park, OH, ASM International.
98. Tsushima N: ‘Crack propagation of rolling contact fatigue in ball bearing steel due to tensile strain’, NTN Tech. Rev., 2007, 128–139.
99. Reprinted from A. Petrov Grabulov R., , Zandbergen HW: ‘EBSD investigation of the crack initiation and TEM/FIB analyses of the microstructural changes around the cracks formed under rolling contact fatigue (RCF)’, Int. J. Fatigue, 2010, 32, 576–583 with permission from Elsevier.
100. Furumura K, , Murakami Y, , Abe T: ‘Development of long life bearing steel for full film lubrication and for poor and contaminated lubrication’, Motion Control, 1996, 1, 30–36.