Determination of material properties of thin films and coatings using indentation tests: a review
Source abstract
Abstract
This paper presents a review of the mechanical characterisation of thin film and coated systems using indentation tests. The potential in assessing mechanical properties of films and coatings using indentation tests has received a great deal of attention since this knowledge is vital for predicting their performance. The relevant theoretical background is discussed. Experimental work, numerical studies and data interpretation techniques for indentation on single bulk materials and thin films are discussed. Surface conditions, indentation depths and indentation size effects for indentation tests on thin films and coated systems are discussed. Data interpretation methods for indentation on films and coated systems are reviewed with a discussion on their limitations. Other studies in this field concerning the substrate effects and critical indentation depth ratios are also discussed. Suggestions for future experimental work and data interpretation are provided.
Source: openaire · Quality: candidate unverified · Source record ↗
Research context
OpenAlex topics: Metal and Thin Film Mechanics · Diamond and Carbon-based Materials Research · Force Microscopy Techniques and Applications
SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.
References (100+)
Show source-provided references
1. Oliver WC, Pharr GM (1992) An improved technique for determining hardness and elastic modulus using load and displacement sensing indentation experiments. J Mater Res 7:1564–158310.1557/JMR.1992.1564 ↗
2. Vaidyanathan R, Dao M, Ravichandran G, Suresh S (2001) Study of mechanical deformation in bulk metallic glass through instrumented indentation. Acta Mater 49:3781–378910.1016/S1359-6454(01)00263-4 ↗
3. Su C, Anand L (2006) Plane strain indentation of a Zr-based metallic glass: experiments and numerical simulation. Acta Mater 54:179–18910.1016/j.actamat.2005.08.040 ↗
4. Zhang J, Niebur GL, Ovaert TC (2008) Mechanical property determination of bone through nano- and micro-indentation testing and finite element simulation. J Biomech 41:267–27510.1016/j.jbiomech.2007.09.019 ↗
5. Misra RDK, Venkatsurya P, Wu KM, Karjalainen LP (2013) Ultrahigh strength martensite-austenite dual-phase steels with ultrafine structure: the response to indentation experiments. Mater Sci Eng A 560:693–69910.1016/j.msea.2012.10.015 ↗
6. Olofinjana AO, Bell JM, Jamting AK (2000) Evaluation of the mechanical properties of sol–gel-deposited titania films using ultra-micro-indentation method. Wear 241:174–17910.1016/S0043-1648(00)00372-0 ↗
7. Stauss S, Schwaller P, Bucaille JL, Rabe R, Rohr L, Michler J, Blank E (2003) Determining the stress-strain behaviour of small devices by nanoindentation in combination with inverse methods. Microelectron Eng 67–68:818–82510.1016/S0167-9317(03)00192-8 ↗
8. Hu Y, Shen L, Yang H, Wang M, Liu T, Liang T, Zhang J (2006) Nanoindentation studies on nylon 11/clay nanocomposites. Polym Testing 25:492–49710.1016/j.polymertesting.2006.02.005 ↗
9. Harsono E, Swaddiwudhipong S, Liu ZS, Shen L (2011) Numerical and experimental indentation tests considering size effects. Int J Solids Struct 48:972–97810.1016/j.ijsolstr.2010.12.002 ↗
10. Karimzadeh A, Ayatollahi MR, Alizadeh M (2014) Finite element simulation of nano-indentation experiment on aluminum 1100. Comput Mater Sci 81:595–60010.1016/j.commatsci.2013.09.019 ↗
11. Kot M, Rakowski W, Lackner JM, Major Ł (2013) Analysis of spherical indentations of coating-substrate systems: experiments and finite element modeling. Mater Des 43:99–11110.1016/j.matdes.2012.06.040 ↗
12. Li W, Huang C, Yu M, Liao H (2013) Investigation on mechanical property of annealed copper particles and cold sprayed copper coating by a micro-indentation testing. Mater Des 46:219–22610.1016/j.matdes.2012.10.029 ↗
13. Piana LA, Pérez REA, Souza RM, Kunrath AO, Strohaecker TR (2005) Numerical and experimental analyses on the indentation of coated systems with substrates with different mechanical properties. Thin Solid Films 491:197–20310.1016/j.tsf.2005.06.025 ↗
14. Venkateswaran P, Xu ZH, Li X, Reynolds AP (2009) Determination of mechanical properties of Al–Mg alloys dissimilar friction stir welded interface by indentation methods. J Mater Sci 44:4140–4147. doi: 10.1007/s10853-009-3607-410.1007/s10853-009-3607-4 ↗
15. Monclus MA, Young TJ, Di Maio D (2010) AFM indentation method used for elastic modulus characterization of interfaces and thin layers. J Mater Sci 45:3190–3197. doi: 10.1007/s10853-010-4326-610.1007/s10853-010-4326-6 ↗
16. Okayasu M, Takasu S, Mizuno M (2012) Relevance of instrumented nano-indentation for the assessment of the mechanical properties of eutectic crystals and α-Al grain in cast aluminum alloys. J Mater Sci 47:241–250. doi: 10.1007/s10853-011-5791-210.1007/s10853-011-5791-2 ↗
17. Zhu LN, Xu BS, Wang HD, Wang CB, Yang DX (2011) Measurement of mechanical properties of 1045 steel with significant pile-up by sharp indentation. J Mater Sci 46:1083–1086. doi: 10.1007/s10853-010-4876-710.1007/s10853-010-4876-7 ↗
18. Cheng W, Wang M, Xu C, Zhang J, Liang W, You B, Nie K (2015) Microstructure characterization and indentation hardness testing behavior of Mg–8Sn–xAl–1Zn alloys. J Mater Sci 30:1043–1048. doi: 10.1007/s11595-015-1270-y10.1007/s11595-015-1270-y ↗
19. Nakayama T, Sakaue K, Ogawa T, Kobayashi Y, Teratani T (2009) Evaluations of mechanical properties of DLC film by indentation method and the effect of substrate. Zairyo J Soc Mater Sci 58:833–84010.2472/jsms.58.833 ↗
20. Bhushan B, Kulkarni AV, Bonin W, Wyrobek JT (1996) Nanoindentation and picoindentation measurements using a capacitive transducer system in atomic force microscopy. Philos Mag A 74:1117–112810.1080/01418619608239712 ↗
21. Newey D, Wilkins MA, Pollock HM (1982) An ultra-low-load penetration hardness tester. J Phys E Sci Instrum 15:119–12210.1088/0022-3735/15/1/023 ↗
22. Bell TJ, Bendeli A, Field JS, Swain MV, Thwaite EG (1992) The determination of surface plastic and elastic properties by ultra micro-indentation. Metrologia 28:463–46910.1088/0026-1394/28/6/004 ↗
23. Randall NX, Consiglio R (2000) Nanoscratch tester for thin film mechanical properties characterization. Rev Sci Instrum 71:2796–279910.1063/1.1150695 ↗
24. Kang JJ, Becker AA, Sun W (2012) determining elastic-plastic properties from indentation data obtained from finite element simulations and experimental results. Int J Mech Sci 62:34–4610.1016/j.ijmecsci.2012.05.011 ↗
25. Kang JJ, Becker AA, Sun W (2013) Determination of elastic and viscoplastic material properties obtained from indentation tests using a combined finite element analysis and optimization approach. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part L: Journal of Materials: Design and Applications 229:1–14
26. Dao M, Chollacoop N, Van Vliet KJ, Venkatesh TA, Suresh S (2001) Computational modeling of the forward and reverse problems in instrumented sharp indentation. Acta Mater 49:3899–391810.1016/S1359-6454(01)00295-6 ↗
27. Zhao M, Ogasawara N, Chiba N, Chen X (2006) A new approach to measure the elastic–plastic properties of bulk materials using spherical indentation. Acta Mater 54:23–3210.1016/j.actamat.2005.08.020 ↗
28. Ogasawara N, Chiba N, Chen X (2006) Measuring the plastic properties of bulk materials by single indentation test. Scripta Mater 54:65–7010.1016/j.scriptamat.2005.09.009 ↗
29. Antunes JM, Menezes LF, Fernandes JV (2006) Three-dimensional numerical simulation of Vickers indentation tests. Int J Solids Struct 43:784–80610.1016/j.ijsolstr.2005.02.048 ↗
30. Luo J, Lin J, Dean TA (2006) A study on the determination of mechanical properties of a power law material by its indentation force–depth curve. Phil Mag 86:2881–290510.1080/14786430600640528 ↗
31. Gamonpilas C, Busso EP (2007) Characterization of elastoplastic properties based on inverse analysis and finite element modeling of two separate indenters. J Eng Mater Technol 129:603–60810.1115/1.2744428 ↗
32. Luo J, Lin J (2007) A Study on the determination of plastic properties of metals by instrumented indentation using two sharp indenters. Int J Solids Struct 44:5803–581710.1016/j.ijsolstr.2007.01.029 ↗
33. Le MQ (2008) A Computational study on the instrumented sharp indentations with dual indenters. Int J Solids Struct 45:2818–283510.1016/j.ijsolstr.2007.12.022 ↗
34. Farrissey LM, McHugh PE (2005) Determination of elastic and plastic material properties using indentation: development of method and application to a thin surface coating. Mater Sci Eng A 399:254–26610.1016/j.msea.2005.03.109 ↗
35. Rico A, Gómez-García J, Múnez CJ, Poza P, Utrilla V (2009) Mechanical properties of thermal barrier coatings after isothermal oxidation. Surf Coat Technol 203:2307–231410.1016/j.surfcoat.2009.02.035 ↗
36. Łatka L, Chicot D, Cattini A, Pawłowski L, Ambroziak A (2013) Modeling of elastic modulus and hardness determination by indentation of porous yttria stabilized zirconia coatings. Surf Coat Technol 220:131–13910.1016/j.surfcoat.2012.07.025 ↗
37. Fischer-Cripps AC (2006) Critical Review of analysis and interpretation of nanoindentation test data. Surf Coat Technol 200:4153–416510.1016/j.surfcoat.2005.03.018 ↗
38. Pharr GM, Oliver WC, Brotzen FR (1992) On the generality of the relationship among contact stiffness, contact area, and elastic-modulus during indentation. J Mater Res 7:613–61710.1557/JMR.1992.0613 ↗
39. Love AEH (1929) The stress produced in a semi-infinite solid by pressure on part of the boundary. Philos Trans R Soc Lond Ser A Contain Pap Math Phys Character 228:377–42010.1098/rsta.1929.0009 ↗
40. Love AEH (1939) Boussinesq’s problem for a rigid cone. Q J Math 10:161–17510.1093/qmath/os-10.1.161 ↗
41. Boussinesq J (1885) Applications des Potentiels a l’etude de equilibre dt du mouvement des solides elastiques. Gauthier-Villars, Paris
42. Harding JW, Sneddon IN (1945) The elastic stresses produced by the indentation of the plane surface of a semi-infinite elastic solid by a rigid punch. Math Proc Cambridge Philos Soc 41:16–2610.1017/S0305004100022325 ↗
43. Sneddon IN (1965) The relation between load and penetration in the axisymmetric Boussinesq problem for a punch of arbitrary profile. Int J Eng Sci 3:47–5710.1016/0020-7225(65)90019-4 ↗
44. Hay JC, Bolshakov A, Pharr GM (1999) A critical examination of the fundamental relations used in the analysis of nanoindentation data. J Mater Res 14:2296–230510.1557/JMR.1999.0306 ↗
45. Malzbender J, de With G, den Toonder J (2000) The P-h2 relationship in indentation. J Mater Res 15:1209–121210.1557/JMR.2000.0171 ↗
46. Malzbender J (2002) Indentation load-displacement curve, plastic deformation, and energy. J Mater Res 17:502–51110.1557/JMR.2002.0070 ↗
47. Sneddon IN (1951) Fourier transforms. McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York, pp 450–467
48. ISO (2015) ISO 14577-1:2015, Metallic materials—instrumented indentation test for hardness and materials parameters—part 1: test method. ISO, Geneva
49. Vanlandingham MR (2003) Review of instrumented indentation. J Res Nat Inst Stand Technol 108:249–26510.6028/jres.108.024 ↗
50. Sakharova NA, Fernandes JV, Antunes JM, Oliveira MC (2009) Comparison between Berkovich, Vickers and conical indentation tests: a three-dimensional numerical simulation study. Int J Solids Struct 46:1095–110410.1016/j.ijsolstr.2008.10.032 ↗
51. Zhang J, Sakai M (2004) Geometrical effect of pyramidal indenters on the elastoplastic contact behaviors of ceramics and metals. Mater Sci Eng A 381:62–7010.1016/j.msea.2004.04.015 ↗
52. Field JS, Swain MV (1993) A simple predictive model for spherical indentation. J Mater Res 8:297–30610.1557/JMR.1993.0297 ↗
53. Francis HA (1976) Phenomenological analysis of plastic spherical indentation. ASME J Eng Mater Technol 98:272–28110.1115/1.3443378 ↗
54. Le MQ (2012) Material characterization by instrumented spherical indentation. Mech Mater 46:42–5610.1016/j.mechmat.2011.10.008 ↗
55. Riester L, Blau PJ, Lara-Curzio E, Breder K (2000) Nanoindentation with a Knoop indenter. Thin Solid Films 377:635–63910.1016/S0040-6090(00)01298-0 ↗
56. Riester L, Bell TJ, Fischer-Cripps AC (2001) Analysis of depth-sensing indentation tests with a Knoop indenter. J Mater Res 16:1660–166710.1557/JMR.2001.0230 ↗
57. Bolshakov A, Pharr GM (1998) Influences of pileup on the measurement of mechanical properties by load and depth sensing indentation techniques. J Mater Res 13:1049–105810.1557/JMR.1998.0146 ↗
58. Begley MR, Evans AG, Hutchinson JW (1999) spherical impression of thin elastic films on elastic–plastic substrates. Int J Solids Struct 36:2773–278810.1016/S0020-7683(98)00128-0 ↗
59. Gamonpilas C, Busso EP (2004) On the effect of substrate properties on the indentation behaviour of coated systems. Mater Sci Eng A 380:52–6110.1016/j.msea.2004.04.038 ↗
60. Schwaiger R, Moser B, Dao M, Chollacoop N, Suresh S (2003) Some critical experiments on the strain-rate sensitivity of nanocrystalline nickel. Acta Mater 51:5159–517210.1016/S1359-6454(03)00365-3 ↗
61. Chen J, Lu L, Lu K (2006) Hardness and strain rate sensitivity of nanocrystalline Cu. Scripta Mater 54:1913–191810.1016/j.scriptamat.2006.02.022 ↗
62. Maier V, Durst K, Mueller J, Backes B, Höppel HW, Göken M (2011) Nanoindentation strain-rate jump tests for determining the local strain-rate sensitivity in nanocrystalline Ni and ultrafine-grained Al. J Mater Res 26:1421–143010.1557/jmr.2011.156 ↗
63. Misra RD, Zhang Z, Jia Z, Venkatsurya PK, Somani MC, Karjalainen LP (2012) Nanoscale deformation experiments on the strain rate sensitivity of phase reversion induced nanograined/ultrafine-grained austenitic stainless steels and comparison with the coarse-grained counterpart. Mater Sci Eng A 548:161–17410.1016/j.msea.2012.04.005 ↗
64. Lorenz D, Zeckzer A, Hilpert U, Grau P, Johansen H, Leipner HS (2003) Pop-in effect as homogeneous nucleation of dislocations during nanoindentation. Physical Rev B 67(172101):1–4
65. Durst K, Backes B, Franke O, Göken M (2006) Indentation size effect in metallic materials: modeling strength from pop-into macroscopic hardness using geometrically necessary dislocations. Acta Mater 54:2547–255510.1016/j.actamat.2006.01.036 ↗
66. Cheng YT, Cheng CM (2004) Scaling, dimensional analysis, and indentation measurements. Mater Sci Eng R Rep 44:91–15010.1016/j.mser.2004.05.001 ↗
67. Cheng CM, Cheng YT (1999) Can stress–strain relationships be obtained from indentation curves using conical and pyramidal indenters”. J Mater Res 14:3467–347310.1557/JMR.1999.0468 ↗
68. Capehart TW, Cheng YT (2003) Determining constitutive models from conical indentation: sensitivity analysis. J Mater Res 18:827–83210.1557/JMR.2003.0113 ↗
69. Ogasawara N, Chiba N, Chen X (2005) Representative strain of indentation analysis. J Mater Res 20:2225–223410.1557/JMR.2005.0280 ↗
70. Huber N, Tsagrakis I, Tsakmakis C (2000) Determination of constitutive properties of thin metallic films on substrates by spherical indentation using neural networks. Int J Solids Struct 37:6499–651610.1016/S0020-7683(99)00270-X ↗
71. Kang JJ, Becker AA, Sun W (2011) A combined dimensional analysis and optimization approach for determining elastic-plastic properties from indentation tests. J Strain Anal Eng Des 46:749–75910.1177/0309324711421723 ↗
72. Atkins AG, Tabor D (1965) Plastic indentation in metals with cones. J Mech Phys Solids 13:149–16410.1016/0022-5096(65)90018-9 ↗
73. Antunes JM, Fernandes JV, Menezes LF, Chaparro BM (2007) A new approach for reverse analyses in depth-sensing indentation using numerical simulation. Acta Mater 55:69–8110.1016/j.actamat.2006.08.019 ↗
74. Tunvisut K, O’Dowd NP, Busso EP (2000) Use of scaling functions to determine mechanical properties of thin coatings from microindentation tests. Int J Solids Struct 38:335–35110.1016/S0020-7683(00)00017-2 ↗
75. ISO (2008) NPR-ISO/TR 29381, Metallic materials—measurement of mechanical properties by an instrumented indentation test—indentation tensile properties. ISO, Geneva
76. Huber N, Tsakmakis C (1999) Determination of constitutive properties from spherical indentation data using neural networks. Part ii: plasticity with nonlinear isotropic and kinematic hardening. J Mech Phys Solids 47:1589–160710.1016/S0022-5096(98)00110-0 ↗
77. Chen X, Ogasawara N, Zhao M, Chiba N (2007) On the uniqueness of measuring elastoplastic properties from indentation: the indistinguishable mystical materials. J Mech Phys Solids 55:1618–166010.1016/j.jmps.2007.01.010 ↗
78. Moussa C, Hernot X, Bartier O, Delattre G, Mauvoisin G (2014) Evaluation of the tensile properties of a material through spherical indentation: definition of an average representative strain and a confidence domain. J Mater Sci 49:592–603. doi: 10.1007/s10853-013-7739-110.1007/s10853-013-7739-1 ↗
79. ISO (2007) ISO 14577-4:2016 Metallic materials—instrumented indentation test for hardness and materials parameters—part 4: test method for metallic and non-metallic coatings. ISO, Geneva
80. Li H, Bradt RC (1993) The microhardness indentation load/size effect in rutile and cassiterite single crystals. J Mater Sci 28:917–926. doi: 10.1007/BF0040087410.1007/BF00400874 ↗
81. Chicot D, Gil L, Silva K, Roudet F, Puchi-Cabrera ES, Staia MH, Teer DG (2010) Thin film hardness determination using indentation loading curve modelling. Thin Solid Films 518:5565–557110.1016/j.tsf.2010.05.063 ↗
82. Sun Y, Bell T, Zheng S (1995) Finite element analysis of the critical ratio of coating thickness to indentation depth for coating property measurements by nanoindentation. Thin Solid Films 258:198–20410.1016/0040-6090(94)06357-5 ↗
83. Knapp JA, Follstaedt DM, Barbour JC, Myers SM (1997) Finite element modeling of nanoindentation for determining the mechanical properties of implanted layers and thin films. Nucl Instrum Methods Phys Res, Sect B 127–128:935–93910.1016/S0168-583X(97)00034-7 ↗
84. Knapp JA, Follstaedt DM, Myers SM, Barbour JC, Friedmann TA, Ager JW, Monteiro OR, Brown IG (1998) Finite element modeling of nanoindentation for evaluating mechanical properties of MEMS materials. Surf Coat Technol 103–104:268–27510.1016/S0257-8972(98)00422-8 ↗
85. Ma DJ, Xu KW, He JW (1998) Numerical simulation for determining the mechanical properties of thin metal films using depth-sensing indentation technique. Thin Solid Films 323:183–18710.1016/S0040-6090(97)01054-7 ↗
86. Lichinchi M, Lenardi C, Haupt J, Vitali R (1998) Simulation of Berkovich nanoindentation experiments on thin films using finite element method. Thin Solid Films 312:240–24810.1016/S0040-6090(97)00739-6 ↗
87. Tang K (1999) Determination of coating mechanical properties using spherical indenters. Thin Solid Films 355–356:263–26910.1016/S0040-6090(99)00444-7 ↗
88. Panich N, Sun Y (2004) Effect of penetration depth on indentation response of soft coatings on hard substrates: a finite element analysis. Surf Coat Technol 182:342–35010.1016/j.surfcoat.2003.07.002 ↗
89. Xu Z, Rowcliffe D (2004) Finite element analysis of substrate effects on indentation behaviour of thin films. Thin Solid Films 447–448:399–40510.1016/S0040-6090(03)01071-X ↗
90. Tunvisut K, Busso EP, O’Dowd NP (2002) Determination of the mechanical properties of metallic thin films and substrates from indentation tests. Philos Mag A 82:2013–202910.1080/01418610208235713 ↗
91. Chudoba T, Schwarzer N, Richter F (1999) New possibilities of mechanical surface characterization with spherical indenters by comparison of experimental and theoretical results. Thin Solid Films 355:284–28910.1016/S0040-6090(99)00445-9 ↗
92. Chudoba T, Schwarzer N, Richter F (2000) Determination of elastic properties of thin films by indentation measurements with a spherical indenter. Surf Coat Technol 127:9–1710.1016/S0257-8972(00)00552-1 ↗
93. Chudoba T, Schwarzer N, Richter F, Beck U (2000) Determination of mechanical film properties of a bilayer system due to elastic indentation measurements with a spherical indenter. Thin Solid Films 377–378:366–37210.1016/S0040-6090(00)01365-1 ↗
94. Schwarzer N, Whittling M, Swain M, Richter F (1995) The analytical solution of the contact problem of spherical indenters on layered materials: application for the investigation of tin films on silicon. Thin Solid Films 270:371–37510.1016/0040-6090(95)06751-5 ↗
95. Schwarzer N, Richter F, Hecht G (1999) The elastic field in a coated half-space under hertzian pressure distribution. Surf Coat Technol 114:292–30310.1016/S0257-8972(99)00057-2 ↗
96. Schwarzer N, Chudoba T, Billep D, Richter F (1999) Investigation of coating substrate compounds using inclined spherical indentation. Surf Coat Technol 116–119:244–25210.1016/S0257-8972(99)00206-6 ↗
97. Li JF, Wang XY, Liao H, Ding CX, Coddet C (2004) Indentation analysis of plasma-sprayed Cr3C2-NiCr coatings. J Mater Sci 39:7111–7114. doi: 10.1023/B:JMSC.0000047561.79036.8210.1023/B:JMSC.0000047561.79036.82 ↗
98. Shiwa M, Weppelmann E, Munz D, Swain MV, Kishi T (1996) Acoustic emission and precision force-displacement observations of pointed and spherical indentation of silicon and TiN film on silicon. J Mater Sci 31:5985–5991. doi: 10.1007/BF0115214910.1007/BF01152149 ↗
99. Bressan JD, Tramontin A, Rosa C (2005) Modeling of nanoindentation of bulk and thin film by finite element method. Wear 258:115–12210.1016/j.wear.2004.05.021 ↗
100. Saha R, Nix WD (2002) Effects of the substrate on the determination of thin film mechanical properties by nanoindentation. Acta Mater 50:23–3810.1016/S1359-6454(01)00328-7 ↗