On the use of effective limit strains to evaluate the forming severity of sheet metal parts after nonlinear loading

The conventional forming limit curve (FLC) is significantly strain path-dependent and therefore is not valid for formability evaluation of sheet metal parts that undergo nonlinear loading paths during the forming process. The stress-based forming limit curve (SFLC) is path-independent for all but very large prestrains and is a promising tool for formability evaluation. The SFLC is an ideal failure criterion for virtual forming simulations but it cannot be easily used on the shop floor as there is no straightforward experimental method to measure stresses in stamped parts. This paper presents a theoretical basis for predicting the effective limit strain curve (ELSC) using the Marciniak and Kuczynski (MK) analysis (Int J Mech Sci 9:609–620, 1967, Int J Mech Sci 15:789–805, 1973). Since the in-plane strain components are sufficient to calculate the effective strain, the ELSC can easily be determined from strains measured in the stamping plant, and therefore it is a better alternative to the SFLC for formability evaluation. This model was validated using experimental data for AISI-1012 steel (Molaei 1999) and AA-2008-T4 aluminum alloys Graf and Hosford (Metall Trans 24A:2503–2512, 1993). Predicted results showed that, similar to SFLC, the ELSC remains practically unchanged for a significant range of prestrain values under various bilinear loading paths, but some strain-path dependence can be observed for significant magnitudes of the effective prestrain (ee ≥ 0.37 for AISI-1012 steel and ee ≥ 0.25 for AA-2008-T4 aluminum).