Fracture mechanics analysis of thin coatings under spherical indentation

Spherical indentation of a thin, hard coating bonded to a thick substrate is investigated. The bending of the coating over the softer substrate induces concentrated tensile stresses on the lower and upper coating surfaces, from which transverse cracks may ensue. This work is primarily concerned with ring cracks originating from the top surface of the coating. In-situ indentation tests are carried out on a model glass/polycarbonate bi-layer, with the coating thickness and the indenter radius being the main test variables. As the coating thickness is decreased, the critical load to initiate ring cracks progressively departs from that associated with a critical surface stress, the effect that increases with increasing the indenter radius. A fracture mechanics approach in conjunction with the FEM technique is used to elucidate the onset of cylindrical ring cracks in thin-film bi-layer structures due to spherical indentation. The analysis, conducted as a function of the coating thickness and the indenter radius, reveals the existence of bending-induced compression stress regions ahead of the crack tip, which tend to shield the crack or increase the fracture resistance. The specific behavior is dictated by a complex interplay between the contact radius,a, the coating thickness,d, and the crack length,c. An interesting manifestation of this shielding mechanism is that when the coating surface contains flaws of various sizes, small flaws in this population may be more detrimental than large ones. Incorporation of this aspect into the analysis led to a good correlation with the experimental results. In the limit case ofpoint-load, a closed-form, approximate solution for the stress intensity factors and the critical loads is obtained. This solution constitutes a lower bound for the critical loads, and is furthermore directly applicable to finite size indenters providedd ≫a. In the limitc/d → 0, a failure stress criterion may be used irrespective of the ball radius,r. The analysis in this case reveals that decreasing eitherd/r or the coating/substrate modulus ratio tend to favor ring cracking over radial type cracking. The transition between these two failure modes is identified explicitly as a function of the system parameters.