journal article·2026-04-28

Bi-objective optimization of power cycling stress and return loss in stacked BGA solder joints based on NSGA-II algorithm

Xianjia Liu, Long Huang, Chunyue Huang, Yonglin Chen, Ying Liang, Chao Gao, Liye Wu, Zhiqin Cao

Microelectronics International· Volume 43· Issue 3
Publisher page

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to optimize the power cycling stress and return loss of stacked ball grid array (BGA) solder joints using the Non-dominated Sorting Genetic Algorithm II (NSGA-II algorithm). The optimized design is suitable for high-reliability and high-frequency applications such as advanced electronic packaging in computing, communication and consumer electronics. Design/methodology/approach A finite element simulation model for stacked BGA solder joints was developed to analyze the stress–strain distribution under power cycling loads. Experimental samples were fabricated, and a power cycling strain measurement platform was established to carry out strain tests, thereby validating the accuracy of the simulation results. The variation in return loss of the stacked BGA solder joints under different frequency conditions was also investigated. Using solder ball diameter, solder joint height and pad diameter as design variables, a multi-objective optimization of power cycling-induced stress and return loss was conducted for the stacked BGA solder joints based on the response surface methodology and the NSGA-II algorithm. Findings The maximum stress and strain in stacked BGA solder joints occur in the region where the BT substrate connects to the upper solder joint. Prolonged stress concentration in this area can lead to the early initiation of cracks. Under high-frequency conditions, the return loss of stacked BGA solder joints increases with frequency. Excessive return loss can cause signal distortion, leading to circuit malfunction. After the multi-objective optimization, the maximum stress in the stacked BGA solder joints was reduced by 3.5%, while the return loss decreased by 2.78%, achieving simultaneous optimization of power cycling stress and return loss. Originality/value This paper provides a novel, dual-perspective optimization framework for enhancing both reliability and signal transmission in stacked BGA solder joints. The integration of response surface methodology, NSGA-II and entropy-weighted decision analysis offers a practical and accurate method for guiding structural design in complex electronic packaging. The proposed approach is of high value for reliability-critical applications such as aerospace, automotive and high-performance computing systems.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Electronic Packaging and Soldering Technologies · Silicon Carbide Semiconductor Technologies · 3D IC and TSV technologies

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

Affiliations

Guilin University of Electronic Technology School of Mechanical and Electrical Engineering, , Guilin,

Sichuan Beizhi Digital Intelligence Information Engineering Co., Ltd Environmental Protection Business Department, , Chengdu,

Chengdu Aeronautic Vocational and Technical College School of Electronical and Information Engineering, , Chengdu,

Panzhihua University Sichuan Province Engineering Technology Research Center of Vanadium and Titanium Materials, , Panzhihua,

Funding

National Natural Science Foundation of China · the Open Fund Project of Sichuan Province Engineering Technology Research Center of Vanadium and Titanium Materials · the Innovative Program for Postgraduate Education at Guilin University of Electronic Science and Technology

References (21)

Show source-provided references
1. Fatigue reliability analysis of Sn-Ag-Cu solder joints subject to thermal cycling10.1109/TDMR.2012.2195007 ↗
2. Mechanical properties study of Lead-Free solder and determination of ANAND constitutive parameters
3. Global-Local finite element optimization study to minimize BGA damage under thermal cycling
4. Application of improved NSGA-II algorithm in Multi-Objective structural optimization combining ANSYS and MATLAB
5. Optimization of ultrasonic extraction process of acid and B-Acid from hops by Box-Behnken design response surface methodology
6. Stress and strain analysis of BGA solder joints under power cycling loads
7. Signal integrity simulation and analysis of High-Speed interconnect BGA solder joints based on HFSS
8. Signal integrity analysis and optimization of BGA solder joints for complete transmission paths
9. The measurement of optical interconnect module postsoldering alignment offsets and the study of its influence on optical coupling efficiency10.1109/TCPMT.2018.2876330 ↗
10. The FEM analysis of stress and strain in stacked solder bump under power load
11. Encapsulated double-bump WL-CSP: design and reliability
12. Discussion on microelectronic packaging technology
13. Wafer process chip size package consisting of Double-Bump structure for Small-Pin-Count packages
14. A novel approach for RF/microwave modeling and optimization of BGA packages
15. Influence of BGA solder joint morphology and layout on signal integrity
16. Research progress on the new controlled collapse chip connection (C4) technology and the mechanical properties of under-chip materials
17. Thermal stress analysis and optimization of BGA solder joints under power loads based on regression analysis and genetic algorithm
18. Wang · 2006
19. Reliability analysis of Lead-Free solder joints in PBGA stacks under thermal cycling conditions
20. Xia, D. (2020), “Study on rapid thermal fatigue of SAC305 Lead-Free solder and solder bumps”, Master’s thesis, Chongqing University of Technology, Chongqing, China.
21. Decision-Making study on soft foundation treatment schemes for highways based on entropy Weight-TOPSIS method