journal article·2025-04Open access

In search for a new lead white: Understanding the historical production processes for industrial-age lead white pigments (1740–1940)

Iryn Bijker, Nina Deleu, Yvan Darcis, Koen Janssens, Geert Van der Snickt

Dyes and Pigments· Volume 235

Abstract

In heritage science, lead white pigments are of great significance due to their omnipresence in historical polychrome and finishing layers. However, although lead white dominated the artist's palette from Antiquity until the early 20th century, modern production processes have remained largely unstudied. This paper explores the manufacturing methods from 1740 to 1940, as these differ fundamentally from the traditional ‘Dutch Stack Method’. Moreover, the technological breakthroughs of the industrial-age initiated an intensive search for improved production pathways, as attested by the 185 process descriptions found during this survey of historical textual sources. A thorough understanding of these innovative processes and their ensuing end-products is particularly relevant for the conservation field as recent studies demonstrated that the production method influences the resulting lead white subtype and its painting properties. Drawing on process descriptions in patents, technical manuals and treatises, a classification is proposed based on the underlying chemical methodology; the main categories are methods based on corrosion, precipitation, electrolysis and volatilisation. In addition, the real-life, commercial prevalence of these categories was assessed by studying literature and archival information on large-scale trade and industry. Surprisingly, these findings indicate that, despite the many innovative chemical pathways registered, the lion's share of lead white manufacturers across Europe and North America continued to employ the corrosion methods, which remain the most indebted to the traditional stack method. Nevertheless, a significant number of factories adopted the novel pathways (i.e. precipitation methods), even though the ensuing products were often considered as of lesser quality in contemporary literature. • The pre-industrial age stack method dominated lead white production until WWII. • Lead white patent publications do not necessarily reflect actual industry practices. • Lead white can be made by corrosion, precipitation, electrolysis or volatilisation.
Source: openalex_inverted_index · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: Cultural Heritage Materials Analysis

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

References (100+)

Show source-provided references
1. Eastaugh · 2008
2. The use of lead white in painting
3. 1982
4. Wehlte · 1992
5. 1823
6. 3. Lead white
7. Kraaijpoel · 2007
8. The white of the 20th century: an explorative survey into Dutch modern art collections
9. Selective dating of paint components: radicarbon dating of lead white pigment10.1017/RDC.2018.101 ↗
10. Pb and Sr isotopes and the provenance of the painting materials of Cornelius Krieghoff in 19th-century Canada10.1111/arcm.12189 ↗
11. 'To prepare white excellent...': reconstructions investigating the influence of washing, grinding and decanting of stack-process lead white on pigment composition and particle size
12. Synchrotron-based high angle resolution and high lateral resolution x-ray diffraction: revealing lead white pigment qualities in old masters paintings10.1021/acs.analchem.7b02949 ↗
13. Synthetic hydrocerussite, 2PbCO3.Pb(OH)2, by X-ray powder diffraction
14. X-ray and infrared microanalyses of Mona Lisa's ground layer and significance regarding Leonardo da Vinci's palette10.1021/jacs.3c07000 ↗
15. The basic lead carbonates10.1016/0022-1902(66)80373-1 ↗
16. Plumbonacrite identified by X-ray powder diffraction tomography as a missing link during degradation of red lead in a Van Gogh painting10.1002/anie.201411691 ↗
17. X-Ray diffraction and the composition of lead white
18. Composition and microstructure of the lead white pigment in Masters paintings using HR Synchrotron XRD10.1016/j.microc.2015.11.005 ↗
19. Bleiweiß und seine Verwendung in der Malerei (2)
20. Gonzalez · 2016
21. Macroscopic X-ray powder diffraction scanning, a new method for highly selective chemical imaging of works of art: instrument optimization10.1021/acs.analchem.8b00240 ↗
22. Macroscopic x-ray powder diffraction imaging reveals Vermeer's discriminating use of lead white pigments in Girl with a Pearl Earring10.1126/sciadv.aax1975 ↗
23. A relation on the making of ceruss10.1098/rstl.1677.0036 ↗
24. Synthesizing lead white pigments by lead corrosion: new insights into the ancient manufacturing processes10.1016/j.corsci.2018.10.033 ↗
25. Bradley S.R., inventor. Improvement in the manufacture of white lead. United States patent US 95075. 1869 Sep 2.
26. Rowe · 1983
27. A brief history of patents
28. Technische vernieuwing in een oude trafiek. De Nederlandse loodwitindustrie, 1600-1870
29. Holley · 1909
30. Pulsifer · 1888
31. Vergnaud · 1874
32. Hurst · 1892
33. Espacenet [database on the internet]. European Patent Office. 1998 - [cited 2023 Feb 13]. Available from: https://worldwide.espacenet.com.
34. Patent Public Search [database on the internet]. United States Patent and Trademark Office. 2021 - [cited 2023 Feb 13]. Available from: https://www.uspto.gov/patents/search/patent-public-search.
35. Patentscope [database on the internet]. World Intellectual Property Organization. 2001 - [cited 2023 Feb 12]. Available from: https://patentscope.wipo.int.
36. Google Patents [database on the internet]. Google. 2006 - [cited 2023 Feb 13]. Available from: https://patents.google.com.
37. Loodwitfabriek G. Greve. Inventaris van het archief van de loodwitfabriek G. Greve te Utrecht. 1798-1960. 94 items; 0.24 lineair meters. Located at: Utrechts Archief, Utrecht; Access No. 721. [Dutch].
38. G. Prince & Zonen. Archief van de aardewerk-, loodwit- en garenfabrieken van G. Prince, later firma G. Prince & Zonen te Gouda. 1806-1919. 7 items; 0,5 linear meters. Located at: Streekarchief Midden-Holland, Gouda; Access No. 0105. Shelf Location: GD.0.2.042.05.02. [Dutch].
39. Hondorff Block & Braet and NV De Vrijheid. Archieven van de loodwitfabriek Hondorff Block & Braet en NV De Vrijheid te Schoonhoven. 1800-1964. 37 items; 1,49 linear meters. Located at: Streekarchief Midden-Holland, Gouda; Access No. 1035. Shelf Location: GD.0.3.026.01.04. [Dutch].
40. Leggett · 1874 · 2
41. Woodcroft · 1857 · 1
42. Woodcroft · 1861
43. Woodcroft · 1871
44. Woodcroft · 1869
45. The repertory of patent inventions, and other discoveries and improvements in arts, manufactures and agriculture; being a continuation, on an enlarged plan
46. Zimmer · 1926
47. Bishop · 1868 · vol. 2
48. 25 Centuries of lead white manufacturing processes identified by 13C and 14C carbon isotopes
49. Stols-Witlox · 2014
50. Zerr · 1908
51. Leuchs · 1846
52. Rodgers J.E.D., inventor. Manufacture of white lead. British patent GB 12724. 1849 Aug 1.
53. Bailey E., Cox G.R., Hey W.T., inventors. Process of and apparatus for producing white lead. United States patent US 625918. 1899 May 30.
54. Chap. 54-Psimithium, or ceruse; six remedies
55. 1914
56. Caley · 1956
57. Lambert · 1902
58. Bleiweiß und seine Verwendung in der Malerei
59. Harrison · 1890
60. The manufacture and comparative merits of white lead and zinc white paints
61. Wetherill W.H., inventor. Manufacture of white lead. United States patent US 324200. 1885 Aug 11.
62. Vickerman C.H., inventor. Art of manufaturing white lead. United States patent US 712870. 1902 Nov 4.
63. Talbot W.P., inventor. Manufacture of white lead. United States patent US 374716. 1887 Dec 13.
64. Walton · 1893
65. Creed J., inventor. Manufacture of white lead, and casting sheet lead. British patent GB 651. 1749.
66. Lintsen H.W., editor .Geschiedenis van de techniek in Nederland. De wording van een moderne samenleving 1800-1890. Pt. 4, Delfstoffen, machine- en scheepsbouw. Stoom. Chemie. Telegrafie en telefonie. Zutphen: Walburg Pers; 1993. [Dutch].
67. Rumpf K., editor .Gmelins Handbuch der anorganischen Chemie. Blei Teil A 1. Geschichtliches. eighth ed. Berlin: Springer; 1973. [German].
68. Improvements in the condensation of metallic fumes, and in the manufacture of white lead
69. Mellor · 1927 · vol. 7
70. Improvements in the manufacture of white lead and in the means and apparatus employed therein
71. Improvement in manufacture of white lead
72. Bailey J.W., inventor; The Union Lead and Oil Company, assignee. Method of producing lead carbonate. United States patent US 709955. 1902 Sep 30.
73. Von Justi J.H.G., Beckmann J. Volledige verhandeling der manufaktuuren en fabrieken. Az J.V.M., translator. Utrecht: Wed. van J. v. Schoonhoven; 1782. [Dutch].
74. Specification of a patent for an improvement in the manufacture of white lead, and other metallic salts
75. Lothman C.R., inventor. Manufacture of white lead. British patent GB 11521. 1847 Jan 7.
76. Rowley W.H., inventor. Process of making white lead. United States patent US 713155. 1902 Nov 11.
77. Chemistry applied to arts and manufactures. On a new process for manufacturing white lead or carbonate of lead, invented by M. Gannal
78. Bersch · 1901
79. Specification of a patent for an Improvement in manufacturing white lead
80. Brumlen L., inventor. Apparatus for manufacturing white lead. United States patent US 182160. 1876 Sep. 12.
81. Thompson G.W., Stewart A., inventors; National Lead Company, assignee. White lead. United States patent US 2218940. 1940 Oct 22.
82. Improvement in the manufacture of white lead
83. On the theory of the formation of white lead10.1016/S0016-0032(40)91083-3 ↗
84. Specification of a patent for manufacturing white lead, and other salts of lead
85. inventor. Improvement in the manufacture of white lead
86. Amatore · 2010
87. Phillips P., inventor. Making white lead. United States Patent US 160. 1837 Apr 17.
88. Milner E., inventor. Improvement in the manufacture of white lead for pigments. United States patent US 140721. 1873 Jul 8.
89. Falk L., inventor. A Process for the manufacture of white lead. British patent GB 29962. 1909 Jun 16.
90. Hof H., Rinck B., inventors. Verfahren zur Herstellung von basischem Bleikarbonat. German patent DE 226245. 1910 Jan 1.
91. Bischof G., inventor. Manufacture of white lead. United States patent US 442943. 1890 Dec 16.
92. Waller E., Sniffin C.A., inventors. Method of manufacturing white lead. Canadian patent CA 43265. 1893 Jun 17.
93. J Franklin Inst · 1843 · 6 · 212
94. Crystal growth of lead carbonates: influence of the medium and relationship between structure and habit10.1016/j.jcrysgro.2013.04.007 ↗
95. Hunt · 1867 · vol. 3
96. Bronner P., inventor. Making white lead. United States patent US 431505. 1890 Jul 1.
97. Specification of the patent granted to Hugh Lee Pattinson, of Bensham Grove, near Gateshead, in the county of Durham, manufacturing chemist, for improvements in the manufacture of white lead. Sealed September 10, 1840
98. Terry · 1893
99. 'The heaviest and the whitest': lead white quality in north western European documentary sources, 1400-1900
100. The manufacture of white lead, considered with a view to its improvement