Synthesis and Structural Characterization of Cocrystals and Pharmaceutical Cocrystals: Mechanochemistry vs Slow Evaporation from Solution
Source abstract
Abstract
The reliability of solvent drop grinding (SDG), also referred to as liquid assisted grinding, wet cogrinding, or mechanochemistry, to facilitate cocrystal formation is addressed with a series of model cocrystals and pharmaceutical cocrystals. The synthesis and single crystal structures of 17 new cocrystals that are sustained by COOH···N arom and OH···N arom supramolecular heterosynthons are presented. These cocrystals were prepared by both slow evaporation from solution and SDG. We also investigated whether or not SDG could be used to prepare previously reported carbamazepine ( CBZ ) pharmaceutical cocrystals. The following eight cocrystal formers were investigated in this context: 4,4′-bipyridine, 4-aminobenzoic acid/H 2 O, 2,6-pyridinedicarboxylic acid, benzoquinone, terephthalaldehyde, saccharin, nicotinamide, and aspirin. Our results reveal that all of the cocrystals that were grown from solution and characterized by single crystal X-ray crystallography can also be prepared by SDG. SDG therefore appears to be a cost-effective, green, and reliable method for discovery of new cocrystals as well as for preparation of existing cocrystals.
Source: openalex_inverted_index · Quality: baseline
Research context
OpenAlex topics: Crystallography and molecular interactions · Crystallization and Solubility Studies · Crystal structures of chemical compounds
SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.
Affiliations
Department of Chemistry, University of South Florida, CHE205, 4202 E. Fowler Avenue, Tampa, Florida 33620
References (100+)
Show source-provided references
1. Almarsson O. · Chem. Commun. · 2004 · 188910.1039/b402150a ↗
2. Vishweshwar P. · J. Pharm. Sci. · 2006 · 95 · 110.1002/jps.20578 ↗
3. Shan N. · Drug Disc. Today · 2008 · 13 · 44010.1016/j.drudis.2008.03.004 ↗
4. Remenar J. F. · J. Am. Chem. Soc. · 2003 · 125 · 845610.1021/ja035776p ↗
5. Childs S. L. · J. Am. Chem. Soc. · 2004 · 126 · 1333510.1021/ja048114o ↗
6. McNamara D. P. · Pharm. Res. · 2006 · 23 · 188810.1007/s11095-006-9032-3 ↗
7. Walsh R. D. · Chem. Commun. · 2003 · 18610.1039/b208574g ↗
8. Wenger M. · Cryst. Growth Des. · 2008 · 8 · 159510.1021/cg7008732 ↗
9. Vishweshwar P. · Chem. Comm. · 2005 · 460110.1039/b501304f ↗
10. Zuckerman-Schpector J. · Z. Kristalaogr. · 2008 · 223 · 233
11. Desiraju G. R. · Cryst. Eng. Comm. · 2003 · 5 · 46610.1039/b313552g ↗
12. Dunitz J. D. · CrystEngComm · 2003 · 5 · 50610.1039/b315687g ↗
13. Trask A. V. · MolecularPharmaceutics · 2007 · 4 · 301
14. Childs S. L. · MolecularPharmaceutics · 2007 · 4 · 323
15. Aakeroy C. B. · Molecular Pharmaceutics · 2007 · 4 · 31710.1021/mp060126o ↗
16. Brody, M. J.Marvin Samson Center for the History of Pharmacy at the University of the Sciences in Philadelphia, 2004, Mortar and Pestle from Renaissance to Present.
17. Wöhler F. · Annalen · 1844 · 5 · 153
18. Ling A. R. · J. Chem Soc. · 1893 · 63 · 131410.1039/CT8936301314 ↗
19. Etter M. C. · Chem. Mater. · 1989 · 1 · 1010.1021/cm00001a005 ↗
20. Etter M. C. · Tetrahedron Lett. · 1989 · 30 · 361710.1016/S0040-4039(01)80463-9 ↗
21. Etter M. C. · Chem. Commun. · 1990 · 8 · 58910.1039/c39900000589 ↗
22. Etter M. C. · J. Am. Chem. Soc. · 1990 · 112 · 841510.1021/ja00179a028 ↗
23. Etter M. C. · Mol. Cryst. Liq. Cryst. · 1990 · 187 · 25
24. Etter M. C. · J. Phys. Chem. · 1991 · 95 · 460110.1021/j100165a007 ↗
25. Etter M. C. · J. Am. Chem. Soc. · 1991 · 113 · 258610.1021/ja00007a037 ↗
26. Etter M. C. · J. Am. Chem. Soc. · 1993 · 115 · 441110.1021/ja00063a089 ↗
27. Huang K. S. · J. Mater. Chem. · 1997 · 7 · 71310.1039/a604311j ↗
28. Shan N. · Chem. Commun. · 2002 · 20 · 237210.1039/b207369m ↗
29. Trask A. V. · Top. Curr. Chem. · 2005 · 254 · 4110.1007/b100995 ↗
30. Trask A. V. · Chem. Commun. · 2006 · 5110.1039/B512626F ↗
31. Bis J. A. · Molecular Pharmaceutics · 2007 · 4 · 40110.1021/mp070012s ↗
32. Jones W. · MRS Bull. · 2006 · 31 · 87510.1557/mrs2006.206 ↗
33. Cheng W.-T. · Int. J. Pharm. · 2007 · 357 · 16410.1016/j.ijpharm.2008.01.048 ↗
34. Trask A. V. · Chem. Commun. · 2004 · 7 · 89010.1039/b400978a ↗
35. Trask A. V. · Chem. Commun. · 2005 · 88010.1039/b416980h ↗
36. Bis J. A. · Cryst. Growth Des. · 2006 · 6 · 104810.1021/cg0680024 ↗
37. Friscic T. · Cryst. Growth Des. · 2008 · 8 · 160510.1021/cg700929e ↗
38. Friscic T. · Chem. Comm. · 2006 · 500910.1039/B613073A ↗
39. Friscic T. · Faraday Disc. · 2007 · 126 · 16710.1039/b616399h ↗
40. Cincic D. · J. Am. Chem. Soc. · 2008 · 130 · 752410.1021/ja801164v ↗
41. Desiraju G. R. · Angewandte · 1995 · 34 · 2311
42. Shan N. · Cryst. Eng. · 2002 · 5 · 910.1016/S1463-0184(02)00002-3 ↗
43. Childs S. · Cryst. Growth Des. · 2007 · 7 · 129110.1021/cg060742p ↗
44. Leiserowitz L. · Acta Crystallogr. · 1976 · 32 · 77510.1107/S0567740876003968 ↗
45. Bernstein J. · Struct. Correl. · 1994 · 2 · 43110.1002/9783527616091.ch11 ↗
46. Moulton B. · Chem. Rev. · 2001 · 101 · 162910.1021/cr9900432 ↗
47. Aakeroy C. · Molecular Pharmaceutics · 2007 · 4 · 31710.1021/mp060126o ↗
48. Taylor R. · Acta Crystallogr. · 2001 · 57 · 81510.1107/S010876810101360X ↗
49. Allen F. H. · Chem. Des. Automation News · 1993 · 8 · 31
50. Allen F. H. · Acc. Chem. Res. · 1983 · 16 · 14610.1021/ar00089a001 ↗
51. Allen F. H. · Acta Crystallogr. · 2002 · 58 · 38010.1107/S0108768102003890 ↗
52. Allen F. H. · Chem. Soc. Rev. · 2004 · 33 · 46310.1039/b309040j ↗
53. eCSD, November 2007 release with Jan 2008 update. Search parameters: organics only, no ions, 3D coordinates determined,R< 7.5%.
54. Jayaraman A. · Cryst. Growth Des. · 2006 · 6 · 15010.1021/cg050251p ↗
55. Aitipamula S. · Acta Crystallogr. · 2003 · 59 · o48110.1107/S0108767303015381 ↗
56. Thalladi V. R. · CrystEngComm · 2000 · 2 · 9610.1039/b003788p ↗
57. Glidewell C. · Acta Crystallogr. · 1999 · 55 · 2133
58. Lough A. J. · Acta Crystallogr. · 1999 · 55 · 1890
59. Lavender E. S. · Acta Crystallogr. · 1999 · 55 · 430
60. Zeng Q. · Cryst. Growth Des. · 2005 · 5 · 188910.1021/cg0501783 ↗
61. Friscic T. · Chem. Commun. · 2003 · 130610.1039/B301726P ↗
62. Friscic T. · Org. Lett. · 2004 · 6 · 464710.1021/ol0484052 ↗
63. Glidewell C. · Acta Crystallogr. · 1999 · 55 · 2133
64. Ferguson G. · Acta Crystallogr. · 1999 · 55 · 59110.1107/S0108768199002657 ↗
65. Sokolov A. N. · J. Am. Chem. Soc. · 2006 · 128 · 280610.1021/ja057939a ↗
66. Smolka T. · Struct. Chem. · 1999 · 10 · 42910.1023/A:1022427122156 ↗
67. Oswald I. D. H. · Acta Crystallogr. · 2005 · 61 · 4610.1107/S0108768104028605 ↗
68. Benyen A. C. · Acta Crystallogr. · 1998 · 54 · 1515
69. Nguyen T. L. · New J. Chem. · 1998 · 22 · 12910.1039/a707642h ↗
70. Birada K. · J. Am. Chem. Soc. · 1998 · 120 · 643110.1021/ja974105m ↗
71. Wheatley P. S. · Acta Crystallogr. · 1999 · 55 · 1489
72. Ferguson G. · Acta Crystallogr. · 1999 · 55 · 57310.1107/S0108768199002645 ↗
73. Zakaria C. M. · Acta Crystallogr. · 2002 · C58
74. Caira M. R. · J. Mater. Chem. · 1997 · 7 · 214510.1039/a703221h ↗
75. Ferguson G. · J. Mater. Chem. · 1998 · 8 · 233910.1039/a804216k ↗
76. Macgillivray L. R. · CrystEngComm. · 1999 · 110.1039/a907110e ↗
77. Macgillivray L. R. · Chem. Commun.. · 2001 · 103410.1039/b102856c ↗
78. Ma B. q. · Cryst. Growth Des. · 2001 · 1 · 272
79. Ma B. q. · Cryst. Growth Des. · 2002 · 2 · 710.1021/cg0155595 ↗
80. Hoger S. · J. Am. Chem. Soc. · 2002 · 124 · 673410.1021/ja017628+ ↗
81. Haung K, -S. · J. Mater. Chem. · 1997 · 7 · 71310.1039/a604311j ↗
82. MacGillivray L. R. · CrystEngComm · 2002 · 4 · 3710.1039/b200332e ↗
83. Cheney M. L. · Cryst. Growth Des. · 2007 · 7 · 61610.1021/cg0701729 ↗
84. Macgillivray L. R. · J. Am. Chem. Soc. · 2000 · 122 · 781710.1021/ja001239i ↗
85. Krahn F. U. · Pharmaceutica Acta Helvetiae. · 1987 · 62 · 247
86. Kala H. · Acta Pharm. Technol. · 1986 · 32 · 72
87. Brittain H. · 1999
88. Vishweshwar P. · J. Am. Chem. Soc. · 2005 · 127 · 1680210.1021/ja056455b ↗
89. Hickey M. B. · Eur. J. Pharm. Biopharm. · 2007 · 67 · 11210.1016/j.ejpb.2006.12.016 ↗
90. Fleischman S. G. · Cryst. Growth Des. · 2003 · 3 · 90910.1021/cg034035x ↗
91. McMahon J. · Z. Kristallogr. · 2005 · 220 · 34010.1524/zkri.220.4.340.61624 ↗
92. Childs S. · CrystEngComm · 2008 · 10 · 85610.1039/b715396a ↗
93. SADABS[Area-Detector Absorption Correction]. Siemens Industrial Automation, Inc.: Madison, WI, 1996.
94. Sheldrick G. M. · 1997
95. Walsh R. B. D. · Chem Commun. · 2003 · 18610.1039/b208574g ↗
96. Stahl P. H. · 2002
97. Johnson S. L. · J. Phys. Chem. · 1965 · 69 · 7410.1021/j100885a013 ↗
98. Cotterill R. M. J. · J. Cryst. Growth · 1980 · 48 · 58210.1016/0022-0248(80)90269-9 ↗
99. Sim G. A. · Acta Crystallogr. · 1955 · 8 · 15710.1107/S0365110X55000601 ↗
100. Etter M. C. · Acta Crystallogr. B46 · 1990 · 25610.1107/S0108768189012929 ↗