journal article·2025-07-20Open access

Surface Protection Technologies for Earthen Sites in the 21st Century: Hotspots, Evolution, and Future Trends in Digitalization, Intelligence, and Sustainability

Yingzhi Xiao, Yi Chen, Yuhao Huang, Yu Yan

Coatings· Volume 15· Issue 7

Abstract

As vital material carriers of human civilization, earthen sites are experiencing continuous surface deterioration under the combined effects of weathering and anthropogenic damage. Traditional surface conservation techniques, due to their poor compatibility and limited reversibility, struggle to address the compound challenges of micro-scale degradation and macro-scale deformation. With the deep integration of digital twin technology, spatial information technologies, intelligent systems, and sustainable concepts, earthen site surface conservation technologies are transitioning from single-point applications to multidimensional integration. However, challenges remain in terms of the insufficient systematization of technology integration and the absence of a comprehensive interdisciplinary theoretical framework. Based on the dual-core databases of Web of Science and Scopus, this study systematically reviews the technological evolution of surface conservation for earthen sites between 2000 and 2025. CiteSpace 6.2 R4 and VOSviewer 1.6 were used for bibliometric visualization analysis, which was innovatively combined with manual close reading of the key literature and GPT-assisted semantic mining (error rate < 5%) to efficiently identify core research themes and infer deeper trends. The results reveal the following: (1) technological evolution follows a three-stage trajectory—from early point-based monitoring technologies, such as remote sensing (RS) and the Global Positioning System (GPS), to spatial modeling technologies, such as light detection and ranging (LiDAR) and geographic information systems (GIS), and, finally, to today’s integrated intelligent monitoring systems based on multi-source fusion; (2) the key surface technology system comprises GIS-based spatial data management, high-precision modeling via LiDAR, 3D reconstruction using oblique photogrammetry, and building information modeling (BIM) for structural protection, while cutting-edge areas focus on digital twin (DT) and the Internet of Things (IoT) for intelligent monitoring, augmented reality (AR) for immersive visualization, and blockchain technologies for digital authentication; (3) future research is expected to integrate big data and cloud computing to enable multidimensional prediction of surface deterioration, while virtual reality (VR) will overcome spatial–temporal limitations and push conservation paradigms toward automation, intelligence, and sustainability. This study, grounded in the technological evolution of surface protection for earthen sites, constructs a triadic framework of “intelligent monitoring–technological integration–collaborative application,” revealing the integration needs between DT and VR for surface technologies. It provides methodological support for addressing current technical bottlenecks and lays the foundation for dynamic surface protection, solution optimization, and interdisciplinary collaboration.
Source: crossref · Quality: baseline

Research context

OpenAlex topics: 3D Surveying and Cultural Heritage · Archaeological Research and Protection · Building materials and conservation

SciVX discovery tags are terminology-based. OpenAlex topics are source-provided classifications.

Affiliations

Faculty of Art, Xi’an University of Architecture and Technology, No. 13, Middle Section of Yanta Road, Beilin District, Xi’an 710055, China

Institute of Urban and Sustainable Development, City University of Macau, Avenida Padre Tomás Pereira, Taipa, Macau 999078, China

Funding

the General Research Project of the Zhejiang Provincial Department of Education: “The Impact of Local Identity on Rural Settlements in the Middle Reaches of the Nanxi River and Optimization Strategies” · the 2024 Zhejiang Provincial Philosophy and Social Science Planning “Provincial-City Cooperation” Project: “The Distribution Characteristics, Spatiotemporal Evolution, and Influencing Factors of Rural Settlements in the Nanxi River Basin from 1990 to 2020”

References (100+)

Show source-provided references
1. Progress toward the sustainable development of world cultural heritage sites facing land-cover changes
2. The context of the Venice Charter (1964)10.1179/135050398793138762 ↗
3. Yao, Y., Wang, X., Lu, L., Liu, C., Wu, Q., Ren, H., Yang, S., Sun, R., Luo, L., and Wu, K. (2021). Proportionated distributions in spatiotemporal structure of the world cultural heritage sites: Analysis and countermeasures. Sustainability, 13.10.3390/su13042148 ↗
4. Laohaviraphap, N., and Waroonkun, T. (2024). Integrating Artificial Intelligence and the Internet of Things in Cultural Heritage Preservation: A Systematic Review of Risk Management and Environmental Monitoring Strategies. Buildings, 14.10.3390/buildings14123979 ↗
5. Li, J., Pei, Y., Zhao, S., Xiao, R., Sang, X., and Zhang, C. (2020). A review of remote sensing for environmental monitoring in China. Remote Sens., 12.10.3390/rs12071130 ↗
6. 3D LiDAR and multi-technology collaboration for preservation of built heritage in China: A review
7. Geoinformatics for the conservation and promotion of cultural heritage in support of the UN Sustainable Development Goals10.1016/j.isprsjprs.2018.01.001 ↗
8. Conservation of Jiaohe ancient earthen site in China10.3724/SP.J.1235.2011.00270 ↗
9. Space technology: A powerful tool for safeguarding world heritage
10. Embracing change: How cultural resilience is increased through cultural heritage10.1080/00438243.2018.1510340 ↗
11. Poulopoulos, V., and Wallace, M. (2022). Digital technologies and the role of data in cultural heritage: The past, the present, and the future. Big Data Cogn. Comput., 6.10.3390/bdcc6030073 ↗
12. Mapping our heritage: Towards a sustainable future for digital spatial information and technologies in European archaeological heritage management
13. Sustainable development and sustainability: Landscape approach as a practical interpretation of principles and implementation concepts10.2478/v10285-012-0040-1 ↗
14. Unique traditional villages on the Loess Plateau of China: Historic evolution and challenges to sustainable development of silo-caves10.1186/s40494-021-00591-4 ↗
15. Preservation of earthen heritage sites on the Silk Road, northwest China from the impact of the environment10.1007/s12665-010-0829-3 ↗
16. Earthen architectural heritage in the international context: Values, threats, conservation principles and strategies10.1108/JCHMSD-06-2021-0115 ↗
17. The Venice charter down under: Its legacy in landscape preservation10.1353/cot.2014.0015 ↗
18. Cultural heritage management: A possible role for charters and principles in Asia10.1080/1352725042000299045 ↗
19. World heritage classification and related issues—A case study of the “convention concerning the protection of the World cultural and natural heritage”10.1016/j.sbspro.2010.05.048 ↗
20. Systematic review: A scientometric analysis of the status, trends and challenges in the application of digital technology to cultural heritage conservation (2019–2024)10.1038/s40494-025-01636-8 ↗
21. Lu, Y., and Ahmad, Y. (2023). Heritage protection perspective of sustainable development of traditional villages in Guangxi, China. Sustainability, 15.10.3390/su15043387 ↗
22. Lian, Y., and Xie, J. (2024). The evolution of digital cultural heritage research: Identifying key trends, hotspots, and challenges through bibliometric analysis. Sustainability, 16.10.3390/su16167125 ↗
23. Preservation, conservation and heritage: Approaches to the past in the present through the built environment
24. Environmental flows: Striking the balance between development and resource protection10.5751/ES-01682-110226 ↗
25. The research and application of spatial information technology in cultural heritage conservation—Case study on Grand Canal of China
26. Satellite remote sensing in archaeology: Past, present and future perspectives10.1016/j.jas.2011.02.002 ↗
27. Yao, Y., Wang, X., Luo, L., Wan, H., and Ren, H. (2023). An overview of GIS-RS applications for archaeological and cultural heritage under the DBAR-heritage mission. Remote Sens., 15.10.3390/rs15245766 ↗
28. Zhang, C., Chen, J., Li, P., Han, S., and Xu, J. (2024). Integrated high-precision real scene 3D modeling of karst cave landscape based on laser scanning and photogrammetry. Sci. Rep., 14.10.1038/s41598-024-71113-y ↗
29. Limongiello, M., Musmeci, D., Radaelli, L., Chiumiento, A., Di Filippo, A., and Limongiello, I. (2025). Parametric GIS and HBIM for Archaeological Site Management and Historic Reconstruction Through 3D Survey Integration. Remote Sens., 17.10.3390/rs17060984 ↗
30. Terrestrial laser scanning in geology: Data acquisition, processing and accuracy considerations10.1144/0016-76492007-100 ↗
31. Review of bridge structural health monitoring aided by big data and artificial intelligence: From condition assessment to damage detection10.1061/(ASCE)ST.1943-541X.0002535 ↗
32. An integrated system for regional environmental monitoring and management based on internet of things10.1109/TII.2014.2302638 ↗
33. Guo, Q., Wang, Y., Chen, W., Pei, Q., Sun, M., Yang, S., Zhang, J., and Du, Y. (2022). Key Issues and Research Progress on the Deterioration Processes and Protection Technology of Earthen Sites under Multi-Field Coupling. Coatings, 12.10.3390/coatings12111677 ↗
34. Sánchez-Calvillo, A., Rincón, L., Hamard, E., and Faria, P. (2024). Bibliometric Analysis on Earthen Building: Approaches from the Scientific Literature and Future Trends. Buildings, 14.10.3390/buildings14123870 ↗
35. Exploring Preventive Conservation Strategies for the Preservation of Rammed Earth Architectural Sites
36. Construction characteristics and reinforcement and maintenance technology of native earth buildings in Liling area
37. Zheng, Y., Liu, S., Zhang, Y., Du, Z., Li, M., Luo, H., and Zhu, J. (2024). Effect of In Situ Polymerization of Super Absorbent Polymers on the Protection of Earthen Heritage Sites in Semi-Arid Regions. Materials, 17.10.3390/ma17194839 ↗
38. States of conservation: Protection, politics, and pacting within UNESCO’s World Heritage Committee10.1353/anq.2014.0009 ↗
39. Gao, Y., Lin, R., and Lu, Y. (2022). A visualized analysis of the research current hotspots and trends on innovation chain based on the knowledge map. Sustainability, 14.10.3390/su14031708 ↗
40. Bibliometric analysis of GIS applications in heritage studies based on Web of Science from 1994 to 202310.1186/s40494-024-01163-y ↗
41. Burnham, J.F. (2006). Scopus database: A review. Biomed. Digit. Libr., 3.10.1186/1742-5581-3-1 ↗
42. Mapping the literature on academic publishing: A bibliometric analysis on WOS10.1177/21582440231158562 ↗
43. Usability Testing: A Bibliometric Analysis Based on WoS Data10.5530/jscires.13.1.2 ↗
44. A tale of two databases: The use of Web of Science and Scopus in academic papers10.1007/s11192-020-03387-8 ↗
45. Huang, Y., Xia, J., Chen, Y., and Hong, J. (2024). Global research progress on rural settlement spatial patterns from 2000–2024: A comprehensive review of hotspots, frontiers, and emerging trends. Front. Earth Sci., 12.10.3389/feart.2024.1505570 ↗
46. Bibliometrics: Its theoretical foundations, methods and applications10.1515/libr.1981.31.1.294 ↗
47. Some bibliometric procedures for analyzing and evaluating research fields
48. From open data to open science10.1029/2020EA001562 ↗
49. Fang, Q., Inoue, T., Li, D., Liu, Q., and Ma, J. (2023). Transit-Oriented Development and Sustainable Cities: A Visual Analysis of the Literature Based on CiteSpace and VOSviewer. Sustainability, 15.10.3390/su15108223 ↗
50. Visual analytics of co-occurrences to discover subspaces in structured data10.1145/3579031 ↗
51. Meng, L., Wen, K.-H., Brewin, R., and Wu, Q. (2020). Knowledge atlas on the relationship between urban street space and residents’ health—A bibliometric analysis based on VOSviewer and CiteSpace. Sustainability, 12.10.3390/su12062384 ↗
52. Emerging trends in GIS application on cultural heritage conservation: A review10.1186/s40494-024-01265-7 ↗
53. Deterioration mechanisms of building materials of Jiaohe ruins in China10.1016/j.culher.2012.03.006 ↗
54. Mapping and monitoring of the impact of gully erosion in Southeastern Nigeria with satellite remote sensing and Geographic Information System
55. Spatial analysis and heritage conservation: Leveraging 3-D data and GIS for monitoring earthen architecture10.1016/j.culher.2019.02.011 ↗
56. Liu, Z., and Wang, J. (2024). Protection and Utilization of Historical Sites Using Digital Twins. Buildings, 14.10.3390/buildings14041019 ↗
57. Puertas, E., Ávila, F., García-Macías, E., and Gallego, R. (2024). Preventive Preservation of Rammed Earth Historical Heritage Through Continuous Monitoring, Architectural Inspections, and Data Fusion. Buildings, 14.10.3390/buildings14103294 ↗
58. Cultural landscapes in Asia and the Pacific: Implications of the World Heritage Convention10.1080/13527250701853408 ↗
59. Zhang, R., and Zhang, C. (2022). Classification and application of digital technologies in landscape heritage protection. Land, 11.10.3390/land11101699 ↗
60. Fan, J., Chen, Y., and Zheng, L. (2024). Artificial Intelligence for Routine Heritage Monitoring and Sustainable Planning of the Conservation of Historic Districts: A Case Study on Fujian Earthen Houses (Tulou). Buildings, 14.10.3390/buildings14071915 ↗
61. Guo, Y., Geng, X., Chen, D., and Chen, Y. (2022). Sustainable building design development knowledge map: A visual analysis using CiteSpace. Buildings, 12.10.3390/buildings12070969 ↗
62. Mapping a discipline: A guide to using VOSviewer for bibliometric and visual analysis10.1080/0194262X.2021.1991547 ↗
63. The importance of wind as a driver of earthen heritage deterioration in dryland environments10.1016/j.geomorph.2020.107363 ↗
64. A controlled field experiment to investigate the deterioration of earthen heritage by wind and rain10.1186/s40494-019-0293-7 ↗
65. A model characterizing deterioration at earthen sites of the Ming Great Wall in Qinghai Province, China10.1007/s11204-017-9423-y ↗
66. Li, L., Feng, R., and Xi, J. (2021). Ecological risk assessment and protection zone identification for linear cultural heritage: A case study of the Ming Great Wall. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health, 18.10.3390/ijerph182111605 ↗
67. Tsakiridis, N.L., Samarinas, N., Kalopesa, E., and Zalidis, G.C. (2023). Cognitive soil digital twin for monitoring the soil ecosystem: A conceptual framework. Soil Syst., 7.10.3390/soilsystems7040088 ↗
69. Assessment of vulnerability and site adaptive capacity to the risk of climate change: The case of Tchogha Zanbil World Heritage earthen site in Iran10.1108/JCHMSD-06-2021-0108 ↗
70. Research progress on in-situ protection status and technology of earthen sites in moisty environment10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2020.119219 ↗
71. Weathering the storm: A framework to assess the resistance of earthen structures to water damage10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2020.118098 ↗
72. Climate change and cultural heritage: Methods and approaches for damage and risk assessment addressed to a practical application10.3390/heritage6040190 ↗
73. He, D., Hu, J., and Zhang, J. (2023). Assessment of sustainable development suitability in linear cultural heritage—A case of Beijing great wall cultural belt. Land, 12.10.3390/land12091761 ↗
74. A quantitative safety risk assessment model for construction site layout planning10.1016/j.ssci.2018.01.016 ↗
75. On technological solutions for repair and rehabilitation of heritage sites: A review
76. Conservation and in situ enhancement of Earthen Architecture in Archaeological sites: Social and anthropic risks in the Case studies of the Iberian Peninsula10.3390/heritage7050106 ↗
77. Cultural heritage and risk assessments: Gaps, challenges, and future research directions for the inclusion of heritage within climate change adaptation and disaster management
78. Qin, R.J., and Leung, H.H. (2021). Becoming a traditional village: Heritage protection and livelihood transformation of a Chinese village. Sustainability, 13.10.3390/su13042331 ↗
79. Exploration on the Win-win Cooperation between Cultural Heritage and Natural Environment Protection Based on the Theory of Cooperation and Competition
80. Mendoza, M.A.D., De La Hoz Franco, E., and Gómez, J.E.G. (2023). Technologies for the preservation of cultural heritage—A systematic review of the literature. Sustainability, 15.10.3390/su15021059 ↗
81. City information modelling: A conceptual framework for research and practice in digital urban planning10.2148/benv.46.4.501 ↗
82. Cultural preservation and digital heritage: Challenges and opportunities
83. Scientometric review and visualisation of City Information Modeling (CIM) trends and future directions10.1007/s44327-025-00072-4 ↗
84. Guidelines for interpreting the results of bibliometric analysis: A sensemaking approach10.1002/joe.22229 ↗
85. The role of GPT chat in writing scientific articles: A systematic literature review
86. Space technology facilitates the preventive monitoring and preservation of the Great Wall of the Ming dynasty: A comparative study of the Qingtongxia and Zhangjiakou sections in China10.1109/JSTARS.2020.3023297 ↗
87. 3D Digital protection and representation of burial ruins based on LiDAR and UAV survey10.1177/00202940221110949 ↗
88. Conserving geodiversity sites in a changing climate: Management challenges and responses10.1007/s12371-010-0016-7 ↗
89. Internet of things for disaster management: State-of-the-art and prospects10.1109/ACCESS.2017.2752174 ↗
90. A disaster management framework using Internet of Things-based interconnected devices10.1155/2021/9916440 ↗
91. Using artificial intelligence to visualize the impacts of climate change10.1109/MCG.2020.3025425 ↗
92. Tsatsaris, A., Kalogeropoulos, K., Stathopoulos, N., Louka, P., Tsanakas, K., Tsesmelis, D.E., Krassanakis, V., Petropoulos, G.P., Pappas, V., and Chalkias, C. (2021). Geoinformation technologies in support of environmental hazards monitoring under climate change: An extensive review. ISPRS Int. J. Geo-Inf., 10.10.3390/ijgi10020094 ↗
93. Virtualization of digitalized cultural heritage and use case scenario modeling for sustainability promotion of national identity10.1016/j.procs.2015.12.384 ↗
94. Shabani, A., Kioumarsi, M., Plevris, V., and Stamatopoulos, H. (2020). Structural vulnerability assessment of heritage timber buildings: A methodological proposal. Forests, 11.10.3390/f11080881 ↗
95. Seismic vulnerability assessment of concrete shear wall buildings through fragility analysis10.1016/j.jobe.2017.06.006 ↗
96. A new scientific framework for quantitative risk assessments10.1504/IJBCRM.2009.028951 ↗
97. Assessing the performance of earth building materials: A review of recent developments10.21809/rilemtechlett.2018.71 ↗
98. Authenticity: Principles and notions10.1353/cot.2014.0014 ↗
99. The impacts of world cultural heritage site designation and heritage tourism on community livelihoods: A Chinese case study
100. Determining minimum intervention in the preservation of heritage buildings10.1080/15583058.2019.1645237 ↗