Surface Topography of PVD Hard Coatings

The primary objective of this study was to investigate and compare the surface topography of hard coatings deposited by three different physical vapor deposition methods (PVD): low-voltage electron beam evaporation, unbalanced magnetron sputtering and cathodic arc evaporation. In these deposition systems, various ion etching techniques were applied for substrate cleaning. The paper summarizes our experience and the expertise gained during many years of development of PVD hard coatings for the protection of tools and machine components. Surface topography was investigated using scanning electron microscopy (SEM), atomic force microscopy (AFM), scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) and 3D stylus profilometry. Observed similarities and differences among samples deposited by various deposition methods are discussed and correlated with substrate material selection, substrate pretreatment and deposition conditions. Large variations in the surface topography were observed between selected deposition techniques, both after ion etching and deposition processes. The main features and implications of surface cleaning by ion etching are discussed and the physical phenomena involved in this process are reviewed. During a given deposition run as well as from one run to another, a large spatial variation of etching rates was observed due to the difference in substrate geometry and batching configurations. Variations related to the specific substrate rotation (i.e., temporal variations in the etching and deposition) were also observed. The etching efficiency can be explained by the influence of different process parameters, such as substrate-to-source orientation and distance, shadowing and electric field effects. The surface roughness of PVD coatings mainly originates from growth defects (droplets, nodular defects, pinholes, craters, etc.). We briefly describe the causes of their formation.