Effect of Defect Site Preorganization on Fe(III) Grafting and Stability: A Comparative Study of Delaminated Zeolite vs Amorphous Silica Supports

The stabilization of isolated grafted Fe 3+ sites on siliceous supports is investigated by a comparative study of crystalline versus amorphous materials. Our synthetic approach treats crystalline delaminated zeolite DZ-1 and amorphous silica (SiO 2 ) with an aqueous NaFeEDTA cation precursor complex, to result in grafting of isolated Fe 3+ sites via covalent attachment to support hydroxyl groups. Thermogravimetric analysis and UV–visible spectroscopy demonstrate the complete detachment of chelating EDTA ligand upon Fe 3+ grafting on both supports. Before calcination treatment, both Fe/DZ-1 and Fe/SiO 2 have similar UV–visible spectral features, with absorption bands at 208–225 and 257 nm, characteristic of framework Fe 3+ sites in zeolites. Calcination does not affect the UV–visible spectroscopic characteristics of Fe/DZ-1 but changes the spectrum of Fe/SiO 2 to a single absorption band at 260 nm, indicating better thermal stability of Fe 3+ sites in Fe/DZ-1 as compared to Fe/SiO 2 . This stability persists for Fe/DZ-1 even during alkane oxidation catalysis in the presence of hydrogen peroxide, which causes aggregation of Fe 3+ into oxide oligomers for Fe/SiO 2 . 57 Fe Mössbauer spectroscopy of calcined materials indicates a more uniform distribution of sites in Fe/DZ-1 relative to Fe/SiO 2 . We thus attribute the greater robustness and site uniformity of Fe/DZ-1 to the chelation of Fe 3+ by the rigid crystalline silicate DZ-1 framework, engendered by the spatial preorganization of grafting hydroxyls groups within its uniform defect sites, which are templated by framework B 3+ removal during delamination. Such preorganization enables cooperativity between neighboring hydroxyl groups. This contrasts with more randomly distributed hydroxyl groups on SiO 2, which lack such preorganization, leading to decreased hydrothermal stability and an Fe 3+ grafting density that is ∼7-fold lower for Fe/SiO 2 relative to Fe/DZ-1. These observations reveal how the silicate surface onto which a cation is grafted can act as a relevant ligand, capable of controlling material synthesis and functionality akin to ligands in homogeneous metal complexes, and demonstrate the advantages of support crystallinity in having this ligand be hydrothermally stable and tunable via templating.